Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Prog Related • Germany

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

City picture
City biography
The East German rock band City was raised to cult status in their native GDR in 1977 when they released a song called "Am Fenster," which hit the charts for weeks in both German states (in fact, in 2000 it was declared "the best German rock song of the 20th century" by a survey of German radio stations). This was an exceptional occurrence as during the times of German separation bands from the eastern part of Germany were usually ignored in the West. Founded in 1971 in East Berlin with Fritz Puppel (guitar, born November 2, 1944), Klaus Selmke (drums, born 1950), Ingo Döring (bass guitar), Frank Pfeiffer (vocals), Klaus Witte (keyboards), and Andreas Pieper (flute), City initially did what most bands do at the beginning of their career: they played rock standards, among others songs of the Rolling Stones, Santana, and Jimi Hendrix, and nothing distinguished them from a dozen other bands active at that time.

After the departure of keyboarder Klaus Witte in 1973 the real turning point came in 1974 when two Bulgarian musicians joined the band and infused them with fresh musical input: Emil Bogdanow (guitar, vocals) was added to the lineup and Georgi Gogow (bass, violin, born July 12, 1948) replaced Ingo Döring. Andreas Pieper left the band, and after a short episode with a female vocalist (Gudrun Bartels) the core lineup was perfect. It was in these days that Bogdanow conceived the idea for "Am Fenster," originally a poem by Hildegard Maria Rauchfuß (born 1918) and a song which has preserved its haunting musical qualities through the decades. In 1975, Emil Bogdanow left the band and was replaced by vocalist Toni Krahl (born October 3, 1949), who - together with Fritz Puppel - was to become the main player of the City lineups in the next years. Due to the restrictions in record production in the GDR, it took the band a while to release "Am Fenster." The single, released in 1977, immediately became a hit in both German states, so did the accompanying debut album City (1978) which contained an extended 16 minute version of the song. Having such a smash hit at the beginning of a band's recording career is not always a blessing, and in the case of City, it surely was not. Emil Bogdanow, the brainchild of "Am Fenster," had left the band, and it was suspected the band could not deliver equally strong material. Their second release, Der Tätowierte (1979), however was a good record although there was nothing on it which possibly could match the impact of their ...
read more

CITY forum topics / tours, shows & news

CITY forum topics Create a topic now
CITY tours, shows & news Post an entries now

CITY Videos (YouTube and more)

Showing only random 3 | Show all CITY videos (1) | Search and add more videos to CITY

Buy CITY Music

Right Now on Ebay (logo)
Heaven & Hell 3-disc CD/DVD Set Live From Radio City Music Hall USA R2 277564 USD $174.39 Buy It Now 1h 32m
Pyromania by Def Leppard LP mercury city label Rock of Ages Photograph NM origi USD $9.99 [1 bids]
1h 34m
'Bye Bye Baby' - Bay City Rollers - 7 Inch Vinyl Single Record / 45 RPM - 1975 USD $7.25 Buy It Now 1h 37m
Rev. Gary Davis - Live at Gerdes Folk City 1962 [New CD] Boxed Set USD $24.85 Buy It Now 1h 38m
Pat McGlynn You've Got Live in Japan Promo White Label Vinyl LP Bay City Rollers USD $39.99 Buy It Now 1h 38m
New Live At Radio City Music Hall - Bonamassa, Joe - Blues Vinyl USD $44.28 Buy It Now 1h 40m
Motor City Is Burning 45rpm with /sleeve USD $5.50 [0 bids]
1h 41m
David Essex City Lights UK 7" vinyl single record SCBS4050 CBS 1976 USD $12.70 Buy It Now 1h 42m
City of Angels - Music From The Motion Picture - Audio CD USD $18.00 Buy It Now 1h 42m
TIME LIFE Sound of the City NEW YORK DOO WOP 1956-1966 Varioius 3CD Box 50s 60s USD $44.97 Buy It Now 1h 43m
Splash ORIG OZ Yellow Vinyl PS 45 Don't look up EX '91 Phantom PH45 Drop City USD $13.08 Buy It Now 1h 45m
Don Byas~Self Title~Jazz Legacy Inner City IC 7018 (NM-) USD $28.99 Buy It Now 1h 45m
RECORDBREAKER - CITY HEAT - EP CD, 2005 USD $10.13 Buy It Now 1h 46m
John Miles Stranger In The City UK vinyl LP album record TXS118 DECCA 1976 USD $17.82 Buy It Now 1h 49m
Kinsey Report ORIG OZ LP Edge of the city EX '87 Alligator AL4758 Chicago Blues USD $13.80 Buy It Now 1h 49m
Latino Velvet "Velvet City" USD $10.00 Buy It Now 1h 49m
Greatest Hits  by Bay City Rollers (CD, Oct-1991, Arista) USD $30.00 Buy It Now 1h 50m
Lew Tabackin ORIG US LP Dual Nature EX '78 Inner City IC1028 Jazz Hard Bop USD $13.08 Buy It Now 1h 50m
Paul Roberts ORIG OZ LP City without walls EX '86 Sniff N the tears Possum USD $13.08 Buy It Now 1h 51m
Yung Joc : New Joc City [explicit] [us Import] CD (2006) USD $3.98 Buy It Now 1h 51m
Bay City Rollers- It's a Game -1977-Arista Records LP-Gatefold USD $4.99 Buy It Now 1h 52m
RIVER CITY PEOPLE 7" VINYL P/S WHEN I WAS YOUNG EM 176 1991 EX " USD $3.77 Buy It Now 1h 54m
LOVIN' SPOONFUL - SUMMER IN THE CITY - GERMAN 7" P/S ONLY ---------- K @@ L USD $7.99 Buy It Now 1h 54m
Start A Fire Radio 4 UK 12" vinyl single record (Maxi) 202246 CITY SLANG 2003 USD $13.98 Buy It Now 1h 54m
Cleveland City Crookz - Gang Warz Cassette Single Rare RAP Brand New USD $9.59 Buy It Now 1h 56m
CD Lot of 7 ROCK and ALTERNATIVE CD's Fiore FIX MY HEAD Lost City Boys STILL DRE USD $8.16 Buy It Now 1h 56m
Crack Rock City A Compilation CD Michigan Punk Rock VG Condition RARE USD $8.32 Buy It Now 1h 56m
City of Gz Part 2 CD Rare RAP Freeze AMPICHINO Young Bossi USD $7.99 Buy It Now 1h 56m
Diplomats CAM'RON Jr Writer 3 CD Lot - Purple City CRIME PAYS History in the Mak USD $6.78 Buy It Now 1h 57m
BAY CITY ROLLERS - DEDICATION Mega Rare 12" Picture Disc Single Promo LP NM USD $267.00 Buy It Now 1h 57m
False City - Vacancy CD BRAND NEW Rare USD $7.68 Buy It Now 1h 58m
The Modernettes/ Teen City EP/ Quintessence/ 1980/ Canada/ Vancouver Punk KBD USD $137.31 Buy It Now 1h 58m
Chae - Chocolate City CD single Rare R&B Brand New USD $7.16 Buy It Now 1h 59m
Electronic CD single (CD5 / 5") Forbidden City UK CDR6436 PARLOPHONE 1996 USD $12.76 Buy It Now 2h
Self Against City / An Angle - PROMO CD Sampler USD $4.80 Buy It Now 2h
Donald Lawrence - Hello Christmas CD Rare Featuring the Tri-City Singers USD $3.99 Buy It Now 2h 2m
Ray Charles - Living For the City 7" Single STEVIE WONDER Crossover 981 USD $3.99 Buy It Now 2h 2m
Capitol K City (Zongamin Remix) 12" vinyl single record (Maxi) UK CAPKXL001R USD $15.27 Buy It Now 2h 3m
River City People [What's Wrong With] Dreaming? UK 7" vinyl single record EM95 USD $12.70 Buy It Now 2h 3m
Circuit City Listen & Learn Cd NEW Soul Asylum LORD TARIQ & PETER GUNZ Dag FORTE USD $1.84 Buy It Now 2h 5m
B-Def - Prince of the City CD VG Condition DETROIT RAP USD $1.10 Buy It Now 2h 6m
SLOW NEW YORK -charming vignettes about life in the city (CD/BMG) RICHARD JULIAN USD $1.50 Buy It Now 2h 8m
Anberlin - Cities: Live In New York City USD $8.08 Buy It Now 2h 9m
RAY BOHR - radio city music hall organ - ORIGINAL VINYL LP USD $5.36 Buy It Now 2h 10m
REALITY JONEZ Just Say Yes 7" NEW VINYL Crown City XL Middleton lowrider soul USD $13.99 Buy It Now 2h 13m
Eurogliders - The City of Soul (Extended Mix): When the Stars Come Out 12" 45rpm USD $8.95 Buy It Now 2h 14m
Cell China Latina 7" vinyl single record USA EFA0492145 CITY SLANG 1993 USD $13.34 Buy It Now 2h 16m
Marty Robbins El Paso City Kc 34303 1976 Lp Record Ex USD $7.99 Buy It Now 2h 18m
Simple Minds - Live In The City Of Light Audio Cd (1987-Remastered) Very Good USD $9.99 Buy It Now 2h 20m
WLLZ FM LP Motor City Rocks 1982 Starstream records USD $14.95 Buy It Now 2h 21m
Elton John 45 rpm Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me & Sick City 1974 MCA records USD $9.95 Buy It Now 2h 21m
R. Kelly 45 rpm Gotham City 1997 Jive Records USD $9.95 Buy It Now 2h 21m
Stampeders 45 rpm Gator Road & Sweet City Woman Bell records USD $9.95 Buy It Now 2h 21m
Rick James Stone City Band LP Come Get It 1979 Motown records USD $14.95 Buy It Now 2h 21m
NEW CITY JAM BAND Our Love Is Getting Better 45 RCA PROMO 1978 USD $10.50 Buy It Now 2h 22m
sound city limited edition cd foo fighters paul mccartney trent reznor nirvana USD $54.99 Buy It Now 2h 22m
Mill City Grinders : No Corn in the Crib CD USD $4.31 Buy It Now 2h 22m
GHOST - Lama Rabi Rabi CD 1996 Drag City Excellent Condition! USD $10.19 Buy It Now 2h 25m
Elevator Bay City Rollers vinyl LP album record Japanese 25RS-25 ARISTA 1979 USD $44.65 Buy It Now 2h 27m
Parliament - Chocolate City LP - 1975 > ORIG NBLP 7014 < USD $29.99 Buy It Now 2h 27m
Rare MASTODON Leviathan AVENGED SEVENFOLD City Of Evil CD PROMO ADVANCE 2005 EA USD $34.95 Buy It Now 2h 39m
Black Sabbath-Steel City Schizophrenia Vinyl LP NEW Ozzy Osbourne M/M 76/78 TMOQ USD $19.69 Buy It Now 2h 43m
Jon Anderson CD In The City Of Angels ? Hold On To Love ? 1988 CBS CK40910 USD $8.00 Buy It Now 2h 47m
Bright Lights, Big City (explicit) USD $29.82 Buy It Now 2h 47m
Ross Bon and the Mighty Blu...-Alive In The City CD NEW USD $6.70 Buy It Now 2h 48m
Love On The Run Lindisfarne UK 7" vinyl single record LIND2 RIVER CITY RECORDS USD $12.70 Buy It Now 2h 49m
Shine On Lindisfarne 7" vinyl single record UK LIND1 RIVER CITY RECORDS 1986 USD $12.70 Buy It Now 2h 49m
American Tradition: Christmas in the City, Christmas in the Heartland, Winter Su USD $6.52 Buy It Now 2h 50m
The Numbers Band, 15-60-75 - Inward City [New CD] USD $15.35 Buy It Now 2h 51m
John Miles LP STRANGER IN THE CITY w/Obi japan NM !! USD $19.99 Buy It Now 2h 51m
Living In The City (F... Disco Rock Machine 12" record (Maxi) UK USD $17.81 Buy It Now 2h 52m
Werewolves In The City Viking Moses 7" vinyl single record UK MC5123S POPTONES USD $13.99 Buy It Now 2h 52m
I'm A UFO In This City 2013 by LostAlone - Ex-library USD $4.94 Buy It Now 2h 52m
Scorpions Big City Nights UK 12" vinyl picture disc record 12HARP5231 HARVEST USD $31.88 Buy It Now 2h 53m
Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea [PA] by PJ Harvey (CD, Oct-2000,... USD $1.99 Buy It Now 2h 53m
New York City Armoury Show UK 7" vinyl single record R6153 PARLOPHONE 1987 USD $13.99 Buy It Now 2h 53m
Doop Doop! UK CD single (CD5 / 5") CBE774CD CITY BEAT 1993 USD $12.12 Buy It Now 2h 53m
Benny Carter Central City Sketches USA CD album (CDLP) CIJD60126 MUSIC MASTERS USD $16.98 Buy It Now 2h 53m
Resurrection EP Vice Squad UK 7" vinyl single record RIOT2 RIOT CITY 1981 USD $16.54 Buy It Now 2h 53m
Arti Tisi - New York City (CD Used Like New) USD $12.34 Buy It Now 2h 54m
FALL-Pearl City-CD-Brand New-Still Sealed USD $13.04 Buy It Now 2h 55m
Artists United Against Aparthe vinyl LP album record Sun City UK MTL1001 USD $20.38 Buy It Now 2h 56m
Say Yes Blood Arm UK 7" vinyl single record ROCKERS29R CITY ROCKERS 2005 USD $10.14 Buy It Now 2h 57m
Various-Punk & New Wave Second City Statik UK vinyl LP album record STATIK01 USD $31.88 Buy It Now 2h 57m
Mega City 3 Spizz 7" vinyl single record UK RTSO6 ROUGH TRADE 1982 USD $12.70 Buy It Now 2h 57m
Various-Dance Powerhouse Vol.1 vinyl LP album record UK SITYLP4 SOUL CITY 1987 USD $24.21 Buy It Now 2h 57m
Dan Siegel The Hot Shot USA vinyl LP album record IC1111 INNER CITY 1980 USD $24.21 Buy It Now 2h 57m
New York City Happiness Is UK 7" vinyl single record 2005008 CHELSEA 1974 USD $12.70 Buy It Now 2h 57m
Gotham City Dexter Gordon vinyl LP album record UK 84825 CBS 1981 USD $17.82 Buy It Now 2h 57m

More places to buy CITY music online Buy CITY & Prog Rock Digital Music online:

CITY discography

Ordered by release date | Showing ratings (top albums) | Help to complete the discography and add albums

CITY top albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.04 | 11 ratings
3.60 | 5 ratings
Der Tätowierte
3.00 | 2 ratings
3.00 | 3 ratings
Unter der Haut
3.00 | 1 ratings
Feuer im Eis
2.05 | 2 ratings
2.00 | 2 ratings
Keine Angst

CITY Live Albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

CITY Videos (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS etc)

CITY Boxset & Compilations (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

2.33 | 3 ratings
The Best Of City
2.13 | 5 ratings
Am Fenster (Platin Edition)

CITY Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, EP/LP, MC, Digital Media Download)

CITY Reviews

Showing last 10 reviews only
 City by CITY album cover Studio Album, 1978
3.04 | 11 ratings

City Prog Related

Review by Seyo
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars CITY's debut LP record is an important work largely due to the inclusion of their best known song "Am Fenster", which is here present in its lengthy side-long version. The song, also issued in a single format, was a huge hit in both parts of then divided Germany, as well as - believe it or not - a minor hit among musical "hipster" and art-rock oriented circles in Sarajevo, Bosnia, then SFR Yugoslavia, in early 1980s!

Here it is stretched to over 17 minutes, including several sections or parts, a format typical for progressive rock of the 1970s. No doubt, electric violin solo sections played by Georgi Gogow are what distinguishes this composition from many other similar improvisational attempts. The main theme starting around 6:30' is quite remarkable, although it simply continues in almost unaltered form until the very end, which may sound a little too long. A "mid-version" truncated to about 7 minutes can be found on the compilation "Best of City", preserving the core of the song but deleting less interesting, introductory acoustic parts.

Another good track is a bluesy rock ballad "Meister aller Klassen", which ends the side one of the vinyl. Unfortunately the first four tracks are nowhere near the quality of Side B. Unremarkable, lame and mediocre hard rock, although decently performed, cannot justify its inclusion beside the prog epic of the flip side. In this way the whole album suffers from the lack of concept or ideas about what the band had actually meant by releasing this record. Side A ** / Side B ****


P.A. RATING: 3/5

 Am Fenster (Platin Edition) by CITY album cover Boxset/Compilation, 1997
2.13 | 5 ratings

Am Fenster (Platin Edition)
City Prog Related

Review by Rivertree
Special Collaborator PSIKE Team & Band Submissions

2 stars 1997 was the band's 25th anniversary and when they reached the mark of 500.000 sold copies this Platin Edition was released as a compilation. Including their one-hit-wonder 'Am Fenster (Window)' of course - the guarantee for a commercial success in Germany and Greece first and foremost. CITY always remembers me at those turbulent times around 1989/90 with the german reunification as the final result. I'm quite sure I was aware of the band before that. But becoming aquainted with much more people changing over from East Germany my attention grew from now on.

There was no party missing 'Am Fenster' furthermore - and it was conspicious that this CITY song is something special and magical for many of the former GDR citizens. It can be treated as cult even though music from GDR bands generally was misliked by the people - because often dictated from the authorities. Discoteques for example were committed to play GDR music with a pre-defined percentage. Two sides of the story are playing a role - the common experiences with pressure and belief in solidarity on one side and the musical brilliance of this song apart from that. This reflects a special melancholy or disire coupled with joy of life and therefore could become one of the rare highlights.

So CITY is mostly associated with 'Am Fenster' and this Platin Edition confirms that. A complilation which contains three different versions of the song. The Dostoyevskys Single Edit is remoddeled to a mainstream/pop mix with english vocals and the Eyeless Dreams Remix with a house/techno beat should be considered as ... uaaaahhh! Just something to ignore - in the same way as most of the other tracks which are only mediocre folk and pop ballads - not really appealing to prog fans. Der King vom Prenzlauer Berg in opposite - another one from the debut album - appears as a nice heavy rock song with some substance reflecting the situation of young people living in an East Berlin district.

The album highlight is saved for the finale. Am Fenster arose from a jam session in the studio when Georgi Gogow, who had a Bulgarian origin, just began to play on his violin. Nearly 18 impressing minutes indeed - devided in three parts. First we have an acoustic guitar lift-off and later Gogow's violin is interfering - very very melancholic. An immediate break with some clock sounds in the background follows and then the band is indicating the main melody for the first time.

And now it's time to get on your feet. Based on traditional folk this song is fairly dancable when you're on a party. The song is rising and decreasing in waves - provided with psychedelic, folksy guitars and violin echoes, coupled with a catchy melody/refrain. They use mystic, cryptic lyrics - nothing more could be awaited in the light of the political situation. And this was the only chance for them to reach for gigs behind the wall as for example in 1978 for a tour in West Germany where they gave a performance for the famous 'Rockpalast' series in Dortmund.

2.5 stars only because of one real gem which confirms the band's relation to prog music. But this special piece however is recommended to be checked out by everyone who is coming in here.

 Keine Angst  by CITY album cover Studio Album, 1990
2.00 | 2 ratings

Keine Angst
City Prog Related

Review by Easy Livin
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

2 stars And then there were three. and then there were two

Three years after the release of their "Casablanca" album, City returned in 1990 with "Keine Angst" (No fear). Just prior to the start of recording, drummer Klaus Selmke left the band, although he would return some years later. This would also be keyboard player Manfred Hennig's last album with City. Hennig had been instrumental in the change of direction the band had made around 1983, his dominant keyboard work giving the band an at the time contemporary, but overtly pop, feel.

"Keine Angst" continues in the accessible pop field of its immediate predecessors, although the guitar work of Fritz Puppel is starting to push back against the dominance of Hennig. The opening "Morgenmond" (Morning moon) sets the mood for the album with a mid-paced piece of melodic pop. Toni Krahl is in fine vocal form from the outset, his powerful style adding substance to the otherwise rather ordinary compositions.

Unusually (for City) a couple of cover versions are included. The first of these is a German language version of Randy Newman's "Baltimore", here called "Rüdersdorf". The best known cover of this song is probably by Nina Simone, this version being somewhat more rock orientated. The second is a version of Hendrix's "Hey Joe", the title here being the more wordy "Der alte Klempner". This rendition of the standard offers an enjoyable heavy acoustic interpretation.

Elsewhere, songs such as "Steinzeit" revert to the 80's euro-pop of bands such as ABC, M and perhaps even Falco. While "Marie Marie" remains devoid of anything prog as such, it does have a superior arrangement, the synth brass punches being particularly effective.

In all, an album which will probably be of little interest to those who participate in this site. The euro pop style of the music is delivered professionally and competently, but it offers little in the way of originality.

 Casablanca by CITY album cover Studio Album, 1987
2.05 | 2 ratings

City Prog Related

Review by Easy Livin
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

2 stars Play something else Sam

City's 1980's output is somewhat less interesting and innovative than their 1970's releases, which are the prime reason for their inclusion on this site. The 1983 album "Unter der Haut" marked a fundamental change in their direction with keyboards becoming the basis for their sound in place of violin and lead guitar.

This 1987 release continues the move towards shorter accessible pop rock numbers, the longest track here running to a mere 5 minutes. Thankfully though, the electro-pop of ""Unter der Haut" is less in evidence now, the overall feel of the album being decidedly more rock orientated. The opening "Cinema hall" paints an enjoyable picture (in German) against an upbeat guitar driven rhythm. There is little to distinguish the track, and indeed the album, from the many other bands who offer a similar style of melodic rock. Magnum, Styx, Kansas and host of other top names all record music in a similar vein, City offering little if anything which sets their music apart from the rest.

The title track is a reflective rock anthem which mixes German and English lyrics, the instrumental passage being a typical melodic rock lead guitar affair. " Nachts in meinen Träumen" (Nights in my dreams) sees synth taking a more dominant role in the backing, the song being an atmospheric slice of Ultravox like 80's pop. "Pfefferminzhimmel" includes some wandering spoken word passages, here the mood is initially a bit like Dire Strait's "Private investigation". The chorus section though has a rather gooey soft pop flavour.

The upbeat "Noch´n Bier" is a blatant attempt to secure chart success, but the song is as instantly forgettable as it is prosaic. "z.B. Susann" appears to take part of its melody from the Boomtown Rats "I don't like Mondays" although the choruses differ. This is the nearest the entire album comes to anything prog, the song having a slightly more intricate arrangement to support a decent vocal performance. The album closes with a trio of shorter songs, each of which is a fairly enjoyable but quickly forgettable piece of light pop rock.

In all, while the performances here are highly competent, "Casablanca" has the feel of a band playing too far within themselves. The music is generally unambitious pop rock with nothing to distinguish it from the mob.

 Unter der Haut by CITY album cover Studio Album, 1983
3.00 | 3 ratings

Unter der Haut
City Prog Related

Review by Easy Livin
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

3 stars Where have all the flowers gone?

Having found fame and fortune virtually overnight in their native East Germany in the late 1970's, City have gone on released a string of albums over the subsequent years. It is generally agreed though that despite sterling efforts, they have never managed to rediscover the magic which resulted in their best known song "Am fenster". This 1983 release (in English "Under the skin") marks a fundamental shift in style for the band, brought about by a significant line up change. Bassist/violinist Georgi Gogow, whose violin playing was central to the phenomenal success of "Am fenster", left the band. He was replaced by keyboard player Manfred Hennig who immediately became the focus of City's sound.

As a result of these changes, City suddenly took on a Krautrock-lite identity, the opening title track sounding more than a little like a Kraftwerk outtake. The repetitive keyboard motifs and emotionless vocals also have all the hallmarks of 80's electronic music. While lead guitar is still very much in evidence, its impact is far more muted as the familiar synth sounds dominate track after track. The harsh Germanic vocals on "Zuckersüß" are reminiscent of bands such as Devo, the coldness of the singing being emphasised by the strong electronic bass lines and floating synths.

"Unser Schuldirektor" ("Our headmaster") opens with some welcome acoustic guitar which in turn introduces a softer synth style. The song has a noticeable warmth compared to its peers, the vocals being much more intimate. The pop rock sound returns though for "Sisyphus" and "Nur Rock´n Roll", a couple of fairly nondescript affairs. In a surprise turn, we suddenly come across a German language cover of the American folk standard "Where have all the flowers gone" written by Pete Seeger and Joe Hickerson. This superb guitar driven version transforms the track into a rock ballad, and justifies the price of admission for this album single handed. The adaptation is reminiscent of Frigid Pink's take on "House of the rising sun".

"Kontra" takes us back to the ubiquitous electro-pop and 80's synths, while "Was mich trägt" assumes a slightly heavier style with the first real guitar solo and some fine lead synth. The closing "Glastraum" appears to be the longest track on the album at just over 6 minutes, although the final minute or so is silent. The song is similar to "Unser Schuldirektor", featuring a more pleasing, almost passionate style with atmospheric keyboards and an emotional vocal performance by Toni Krahl.

In all, a much different album to the band's early works. Here they are attempting to achieve commercial success by adopting the sounds of the period without actually distinguishing themselves from the many other bands ploughing the same furrow. There are some good moments here, but overall the album is too pop focused and too anonymous to stand out from its peers.

The version I have includes 2 additional tracks. The first of these, "Sonnabendmittag" ("Midday, Saturday") sounds at first like it might be an interesting improvisation, but a prosaic piece of synth pop once again burst forward snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. The distorted Rundgren like guitar solo is worth catching though. "Schalt die Glotze aus" is no less ordinary.

 City by CITY album cover Studio Album, 1978
3.04 | 11 ratings

City Prog Related

Review by Easy Livin
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

3 stars A window in the wall

Originating from what was at the time East Germany, City are virtually unknown to this day outside their native country. The band are rightly listed on this site as Prog related, that relationship being largely down to their one prog epic and best known song "Am Fenster". That song appears on this the band's first album released in 1978, supported by a further 5 songs. "Am fenster" (at the window) was originally released as a highly successful single, the album version being an expended version in 3 parts.

The five songs which make up the first side of the original LP are well crafted but rather undistinguished blues/guitar rock. The lyrics are all in German although the sound is rather British; those looking for Krautrock need to look elsewhere. There are hints of bands such as Wishbone Ash (especially in "Nachts um halb eins") and Golden Earring ("Traudl" is more than a little like "Radar Love").

"Meister aller Klassen" (Master of all classes) is a slower guitar driven power ballad which tells the tale of an over ambitious motorcyclist. The appearance of Flock (the band) like violin played by Georgi Gogow on "Der King vom Prenzlauer Berg" offers a pleasing additional dimension to the song.

It is though to "Am Fenster" that we look for the band's piece de resistance. This 17+ minute suite is made up in three contiguous parts, opening with the acoustic "Traum". Here, violin and acoustic guitar combine in a slightly folk influenced melody, the violin gradually swelling the sound in a manner similar to the middle section of Curved Air's "Vivaldi". The section ends abruptly as ticking clocks and chimes introduce the brief "Tagtraum". This simply acts as link to the main part of the suite, which is also titled "Am fenster". Here we find the first vocals of the track, but violin continues to dominate instrumentally. The track now finds a rhythm and a hook, the relentless violin acting as the catalyst for the development of the song into a hypnotic daydream (Tagtraum). While the song did find significant success in East and West Germany, and indeed in some other parts of Europe, it failed to find an audience in the lucrative markets of the English speaking countries. Such an injustice has befallen many bands who record in their native language, examples such as this merely emphasising how fine music is ignored simply because of the language used.

In all, this is something of a "Tarkus" with one superb side long number, and a collection of good but unremarkable supporting songs. Highly recommended simply for "Am fenster" though.

Thanks to seyo for the artist addition.

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives