MENU
Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography

A SILVER MT. ZION

Post Rock/Math rock • Canada


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

A Silver Mt. Zion picture
A Silver Mt. Zion biography
Originally formed by GODSPEED YOU BLACK EMPEROR guitarist Efrim Menuck, bassist Thierry Amar and violinist Sophie Trudeau, A SILVER MT. ZION was formed as a vehicle for Efrim to explore his own musical ideas. The group has since expanded to a seven-piece, and play a slow, brooding style very simmilar in feel to the band from which they were spawned. At the same time however, their sound contains more of an experimental edge and less of the ear-splitting climaxing that has defined GYBE. They also feature vocals from Efrim, a characteristic not usually seen in bands of this style.

Their name varies slightly on each album, releasing their sophmore effort "Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upward" under the name THE SILVER MT. ZION MEMORIAL ORCHESTRA AND TRA-LA-LA BAND, adding "WITH CHOIR" to that name for their third album "This Is Our Punk Rock", releasing "The "Pretty Little Lightning Paw" E.P." under the name THEE SILVER MOUNTAIN REVERIES, and reverting to THEE SILVER MT. ZION MEMORIAL ORCHESTRA & TRA-LA-LA BAND for 2005's "Horses in the Sky".

Their best album is generally considered to be their debut, 2000's "He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts of Light Sometimes Grace the Corner of Our Rooms".

See also:
- Fly Pan Am
- Godspeed You Black Emperor!
- Set Fire To Flames
- Valley Of The Giants




Why this band must be listed in www.progarchives.com :
They present simmilar ideas as Godspeed You Black Emperor in a different (and sometimes more conventionally progressive) form, and are generally regarded as one of the major post-rock bands.



Discography:
He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts of Light Sometimes Grace the Corner of Our Rooms, studio album (2000)
Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upward, studio album (2001)
"This is Our Punk-Rock," Thee Rusted Satellites Gather + Sing (2003)
The "Pretty Little Lightning Paw" E.P. (2004)
Horses In the Sky (2005)

A Silver Mt. Zion official website

A SILVER MT. ZION MP3, Free Download (music stream)


Open extended player in a new pop-up window | Random Playlist (50) | How to submit new MP3s
No MP3/Stream available for this artist.
Collaborate with Progarchives.com, learn how to submit new MP3s.

A SILVER MT. ZION forum topics / tours, shows & news


A SILVER MT. ZION forum topics
No topics found for : "a silver mt. zion"
Create a topic now
A SILVER MT. ZION tours, shows & news Post an entries now

A SILVER MT. ZION Videos (YouTube and more)


Showing only random 3 | Show all A SILVER MT. ZION videos (1) | Search and add more videos to A SILVER MT. ZION

Buy A SILVER MT. ZION Music


He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts of Light SometimesHe Has Left Us Alone But Shafts of Light Sometimes
Constellation 2000
Audio CD$8.99
$5.98 (used)
Right Now on Ebay (logo)
FLY PAN AM N'Écoutez Pas LP '04 Do Make Say Think A Silver Mt. Zion Mogwai Re: USD $9.98 Buy It Now 2 days
Horses in the Sky by A Silver Mt. Zion (CD, Mar-2005, Constellation) USD $12.21 Buy It Now 4 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - Kollaps Tradixionales [New CD] USD $13.99 Buy It Now 5 days
A Silver Mt. Zion, S - Born Into Trouble As the Sparks Fly Upward [New Vinyl] USD $28.09 Buy It Now 5 days
A Silver Mt. Zion, S - 13 Blues for Thirteen Moons [New CD] USD $14.16 Buy It Now 6 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - Horses in the Sky [New CD] USD $18.51 Buy It Now 6 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - He Has Left Us Alone But - CD ** Very Good Condition ** USD $7.75 Buy It Now 11 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - 13 BLUES FOR THIRTEEN MOONS [SLIPCASE] NEW CD USD $17.65 Buy It Now 11 days
"13 Blues for Thirteen Moons" New CD by A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock Drone Prog USD $13.13 Buy It Now 12 days
A SILVER MT. ZION/THEE SILVER MT. ZION MEMORIAL ORCHESTRA - KOLLAPS TRADIXIONALE USD $18.12 Buy It Now 14 days
Born into Trouble as the Sparks Fly Upward by A Silver Mt. Zion. USD $17.87 Buy It Now 15 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts of Light Sometimes Grace... USD $13.54 Buy It Now 16 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - 13 Blues for Thirteen Moons (2008) USD $13.54 Buy It Now 16 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - Kollaps Tradixionales (2010) USD $13.54 Buy It Now 16 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - Horses in the Sky (2005) USD $13.54 Buy It Now 16 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - F*** Off Get Free We Pour Light on Everything (2014) USD $13.54 Buy It Now 16 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - PRETTY LITTLE LIGHTNING PAW [EP] NEW CD USD $21.97 Buy It Now 17 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - THIS IS OUR PUNK-ROCK, THEE RUSTED SATELLITES GATHER + SING USD $17.73 Buy It Now 17 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - HORSES IN THE SKY NEW CD USD $17.85 Buy It Now 17 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - THIS IS OUR PUNK-ROCK, THEE RUSTED SATELLITES GATHER + SING USD $15.49 Buy It Now 17 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - PRETTY LITTLE LIGHTNING PAW [EP] USED - VERY GOOD CD USD $13.74 Buy It Now 17 days
A Silver Mt. Zion - This Is Our Punk-Rock Thee Rusted Satellites Sing [New CD] USD $19.82 Buy It Now 17 days
A Silver Mt. Zion, S - Pretty Little Lightning Paw [New CD] USD $17.81 Buy It Now 17 days
A Silver Mt Zion - He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts of Light (CD) CST009 - Rare USD $15.79 Buy It Now 17 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - HORSES IN THE SKY USED - VERY GOOD CD USD $15.49 Buy It Now 21 days
A Silver Mt Zion Born Into Trouble 2x 10" vinyl LP Record godspeed you black NEW USD $26.99 Buy It Now 22 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - 13 Blues for Thirteen Moons - CD ** Like New - Mint ** USD $14.95 Buy It Now 22 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - BORN INTO TROUBLE AS THE SPARKS FLY UPWARD NEW CD USD $17.86 Buy It Now 22 days
A Silver Mt. Zion- He has left us alone...LP, 2000, Constellation, Godspeed, NM USD $15.00 Buy It Now 22 days
Born into Trouble as the Sparks Fly Upward [LP] by A Silver Mt. Zion (Vinyl,... USD $24.52 Buy It Now 23 days
13 Blues for Thirteen Moons [Slipcase] by A Silver Mt. Zion (CD, Mar-2008,... USD $12.19 Buy It Now 23 days
A Silver Mt. Zion, S - He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts of Light Sometimes [New C USD $20.02 Buy It Now 24 days
A SILVER MT. ZION - HE HAS LEFT US ALONE BUT SHAFTS OF LIGHT SOMETIMES GRACE THE USD $15.35 Buy It Now 24 days

More places to buy A SILVER MT. ZION music online Buy A SILVER MT. ZION & Prog Rock Digital Music online:
A SILVER MT. ZION has no upcoming shows, according to LAST.FM syndicated events and shows feed

A SILVER MT. ZION discography


Ordered by release date | Showing ratings (top albums) | Help Progarchives.com to complete the discography and add albums

A SILVER MT. ZION top albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.96 | 95 ratings
He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts Of Light Sometimes Grace The Corner Of Our Rooms
2000
3.53 | 65 ratings
Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upwards
2001
3.10 | 40 ratings
This Is Our Punk-Rock, Thee Rusted Satellites Gather + Sing
2003
3.90 | 73 ratings
Horses In The Sky
2005
3.71 | 61 ratings
13 Blues for Thirteen Moons
2008
3.62 | 32 ratings
Kollaps Tradixionales
2010
4.01 | 34 ratings
Fuck Off Get Free We Pour Light On Everything
2014

A SILVER MT. ZION Live Albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

A SILVER MT. ZION Videos (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS etc)

A SILVER MT. ZION Boxset & Compilations (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

A SILVER MT. ZION Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, EP/LP, MC, Digital Media Download)

3.26 | 21 ratings
The Pretty Little Lightning Paw E.P.
2004

A SILVER MT. ZION Reviews


Showing last 10 reviews only
 Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upwards by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2001
3.53 | 65 ratings

BUY
Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upwards
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by siLLy puPPy
Collaborator PSIKE & JR/F/Canterbury Teams

4 stars Efrim Menuck meant for his first release as A SILVER MT ZION to be a one-off tribute to his beloved dog Wanda who passed away while touring as a band member of Godspeed! You Black Emperor, but since it was met with such such positive enthusiasm, he decided to keep releasing new albums as a side project and therefore since this was indeed a new band instead of merely a solo tribute project he expanded the three full time members on the first release and doubled it to six (adding contrabass, cello and extra violins). There also remain three additional session musicians as on the debut with the addition of trumpet and trombone. Menuck also followed the changing-up-the-name game inspired by the great Sun Ra who would change his backing band name every few albums. So on this second release, BORN INTO TROUBLE AS THE SPARKS FLY UPWARD is credited to THEE SILVER MT ZION MEMORIAL ORCHESTRA & TRA-LA-LA BAND. Now isn't that a mouthful? Sometimes it begins with THE SILVER etc so i assume the THEE came about as a database issue.

Musically speaking BORN INTO TROUBLE etc continues the same kind of apocalyptic and mournful classical chamber music mixed with post-rock that suited the tribute to Wanda so well. The album contains eight sprawling tracks but none overly long that utilize the typical post-rock playbook and create riffs that build loops which are then accompanied by other instruments joining in until reaching a climax of some sort. For the most part the "rock" part of the equation doesn't play much of a part in the second album like the first as it is primarily built upon slow brooding violins accompanied by the other instruments merely adding disheartening atmospheric moods but on some tracks like "Take These Hands And Throw Them In The RIver," the pace picks up after the lugubrious intro and unlike most of the album has sung vocals (there are some spoken word parts as well). The heavier passages are very similar to the softer ones except that they have a much more frenetic delivery of the repetitive loops of violin riffs with a cacophonous din of accompanying sounds that make it sound more like the Godspeed! project. "C'monCOMEON" is probably the most rock oriented track as it has heavily distorted guitar and the most energetic percussive elements on the entire album.

Overall the music on BORN INTO TROUBLE AS THE SPARKS FLY UPWARD is much more diverse with all the different instrumental parts sounding more like the first Godspeed! album than the first SILVER MT ZION one but still retains a significant amount of the funeral march anthemic styles of the debut. The subject matter is supposedly inspired by the Book Of Job from the Bible with the title also purportedly taken from the scriptures. Menuck successfully found new ways to expand the debut's sound and even though many of these new ideas came directly from his Godspeed! You Black Emperor style, the album sounds completely distinct as it less hypnotic than Godspeed! releases and creates more of a classical chamber rock type of feel with more melodies that at times sound a tad Floydian in a space rock sort of way accompanied with lots of echo guitars. Add the heavy outbursts although sparse and the weird electronic atmospherics and voila! a satisfying near hour experience of musical bliss. No sophomore slump on this one. In fact i actually prefer listening to this second offering for it has a grander scope of moods and emotional explorations than the extremely misery focused vibe of the first.

 Kollaps Tradixionales by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2010
3.62 | 32 ratings

BUY
Kollaps Tradixionales
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Walkscore

4 stars Takes Longer but Grows on You.

I just submitted my review of their most recent album when I noticed this album gets weaker reviews than most of their other albums. In a way I can understand - this one takes longer for its merits to become clear and it is less likely to grab reviewers on first listen. However, after having listened to this album for six years now, I think this is up there with their best albums. Probably the reason for the lower scores is Efrim's singing is a bit more tortured than usual on this one, and his singing is right up from on the long opening piece "There is a Light". I have to admit not being as keen on this song when I first heard it, but it has really grown on me, and is today one of my favourite songs of theirs. There is a very similar feel to the long closer, "Piphany Rambler", which has Efrim singing (rambling indeed) all over this, with much of the same feel as "There is a Light". This one probably takes even longer to warm up to, but again, after first being a bit turned off by it, I (now) really like it. In the middle are some more great pieces. "I Built Myself a Metal Bird" is distorted hard-driving progressive punk (in fact, the tune is in 7/8 time!), but what I find particularly great about the middle part of this album is that the band is here improvising at length. "I Fed my Metal Bird the Wings of Other Metal Birds" is the improvised extension of the first Metal Bird track. Similarly the two Kollaps Tradixionales pieces include improvisation, and so while these are (for me) the weaker tracks on the album, they are still quite good and indeed essential to the listening experience of the album. I like this album a lot more than 13 Blues for Thirteen Moons, which is less well put together and less musical over all. I also like it better than Horses in the Sky, which has some great songs but for me is uneven. Similar to their most recent album (which I just reviewed), I find Kollaps to be consistently good all the way through.

Some albums are easy to 'get' on first or second listen. Some albums rise quickly at first, but then fall just as quickly after a few listens. This one started lower but kept rising, and only started to plateau after around 20 listens. Even though it is fairly long, I now always listen to this one all the way through - once it is on, I am drawn to hear it out. While most listeners will probably prefer their most recent album over this one on first listen (so, you should get that one first), I actually rate this one a tiny bit higher (after many years). How much you eventually like the album will depend on how much the opening and closing tracks grow on you. But I think it is well worth the time-effort. I give this 8.7 out of 10 on my 10-point scale, which also translates to high 4 PA stars.

 Fuck Off Get Free We Pour Light On Everything by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2014
4.01 | 34 ratings

BUY
Fuck Off Get Free We Pour Light On Everything
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Walkscore

4 stars Real, Heartfelt Music.

The most recent full album (2014) from A Silver Mt. Zion is excellent through-and-through. I love this band (and their cousins/alter-ego but larger Godspeed You Black Emperor-GYBE) for the integrity they bring to the act of making music. They make music they want to play, and say what they want to say, for its own sake damn the consequences. They also write out of passion and gut feeling, rather than (say) logic or aspiration, so the music is full of raw emotion and is personal. As a result, their music comes across as heartfelt, feeling, and authentic. When I listen to this, I am always reminded of a Roger Waters quip (from the Pompeii video) where he says that the only thing that matters in music (or any art) is whether it moves you. SMZ is moving and thought-provoking. While a number of commentators don't like Efrim's singing, I think it fits perfectly, and just adds to authenticity of their statement. The singing would in fact be considered poor judged against the criteria set out by vocal coaches and music schools - it is frequently out of tune, he can't reach some of the high notes he is trying to reach, his voice often cracks, etc - but to me this is beside the point. The point of this band is to be real, warts and all, and thus implicitly to challenge paradigms and stereotypes of what the experts might say music should be. But even disregarding this, I actually think the singing is very musical. Few would ever say Bob Dylan or Jimi Hendrix are good singers, but their vocals are perfect for the songs they sing, with a lot of unique character and instant recognizability, and they add to the music they accompany rather than take away from it. The same applies to Efrim's vocals, which add a personal element to the music that raises it even higher and makes me want to listen to it.

This album continues in the same mode as their previous album (Kollaps Tradixionales), in mixing a harder rockingier approach with progressive acoustic and ethereal soundscapes, generally in the service of longer but well-structured vocal-based tunes. The album begins with a hard-guitar driving punky piece that shifts part-way through into a longer statement which sets the musical and political tone for the album. There is a great shorter tune ("Take Away These Early Grave Blues") as well as two innovative and evocative short pieces ("Little Ones Run" and and "Rains Thru the Rooft"). However, the real gems here are the two longest pieces. The 14-minute "Austerity Blues" is a fantastic piece that begins on acoustic with Efrim's unique voice up high, then morphs into a truly original and musical political statement about the idea of (government, economic) austerity. It's counterpart is "What We Loved Was Not Enough", a beautiful dirty lament from the heart. Both of these are among SMZ's best compositions, and are the primary reason I keep wanting to put on this album. They have entered my list of essential music. But in fact the entire set flows very well and there is not a bad tune on the album. Silver Mt Zion is making exciting and original music that deserves to be listened to. They are my favourite still-touring Canadian band. On balance, I give this album 8.6 out of 10 on my 10-point scale, which is at the high end of 4 PA stars.

 The Pretty Little Lightning Paw  E.P. by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2004
3.26 | 21 ratings

BUY
The Pretty Little Lightning Paw E.P.
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Walkscore

3 stars Microphones in the Trees!

An excellent release from Silver Mt Zion, this EP contains four great tracks that do a good job at encapsulating their sound in the mid-2000s. Like their first album, this one contains no drummer, but instead uses repeated percussion sounds and quiet drum machines selectively in their place on some of the tracks. The title track is one of the more notable pieces, both here and of their repertoire in general. But it is "Microphones in the Trees" that is the real stand-out track. Built around a 5/4 bass/cello line that modulates between four chords in repeated pattern, it starts quiet and builds to a climax backed by pointed political lyrics and eery rising/sawing violins. The melody is highly memorable and the song will stick with you. Check out this EP version, and then check out the amazing 2008 live version from Lees Palace in Toronto (available on youtube). Just amazing. The other two tunes on this release are good, but not quite essential, making the overall rating of this one 7.7 out of 10, which is just shy of 4 PA stars. So, high 3 PA stars.

 This Is Our Punk-Rock, Thee Rusted Satellites Gather + Sing by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2003
3.10 | 40 ratings

BUY
This Is Our Punk-Rock, Thee Rusted Satellites Gather + Sing
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Walkscore

5 stars The Best SMZ Album!

This is not only their most progressive, but most musical and most emotional album. I am shocked by the lower scores for this here. This sees the band writing extended epics - one on each side of the double vinyl album - and in turn developing their musical ideas over longer overlapping themes with quieter, sensitive violin and guitar compositions, while still remaining true to their post-apocalyptic post-punk ethos. Each of the four pieces on this album is unique and distinct - not only from each other, but from the rest of their catalogue. Side 1 ("So Some Lonesome Corners So Many Flowers Bloom") features a rag-tag improvised choir and a slow-building crescendo that is very musical despite representing an almost free experiment. The song is very hypnotic and beautiful, almost in a Floydian way (indeed, sections of this piece actually remind me of (though very different from) Atom Heart Mother). Side 2 ("Babylon Was Built On Fire/Starsnostars") is to my mind SMZ's most musical song (not only on this album, but their entire catalogue). It begins with some amazing soundscapes, slowly introducing the main themes. The vocals are here are very effective, slowly building until each of the song's different themes are all being sung at once by different singers, bouncing off each other in a beautiful rag-tag counterpoint of overlapping melodies. Awesome music! Side 3 ("American Motor Over Smoldered Field") is another of SMZ's most musical songs ever. Containing some rare but beautiful (in a post-apocalyptic way!) vocal harmonies, the song remains subdued for the first 4.5 minutes, but then the drums and bass/cello/guitar pulses kick in. Check out the section that begins just before the 9 min mark which then continues to the end with the 'choir' singing the lyrical theme. So innovative yet deeply musical and emotional music. Side 4 ("Goodbye Desolate Railyard"), characterized by acoustic guitar finger-picking in a major key overlaid with piano and sunrise-violin lines, has a very American feel to it. Very happy-sad melancholy, shifting into musique concrette with thunderstorm and railway soundscapes, and then back to the main theme on acoustic guitar with the key lyric then repeated by the band. While I find the other three sides to be even stronger, this is a great closer for this great, original album. Of course, you have to like Efrim's/the bands' tortured, out of key singing, and this one will take a few listens before the underlying musicality emerges (you are probably not likely to get it on first listen). But this is definitely worth the effort. For me, this is the second-best album out of the entire GYBE/SMZ catalogue, after "Lift Yer Skinny Fists like Antennas to Heaven". I give this 9.0 out of 10 on my 10-point scale, which translates to 5 PA stars. One of the most original, authentic, innovative, musical and moving albums.

 Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upwards by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2001
3.53 | 65 ratings

BUY
Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upwards
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Walkscore

2 stars The Weakest SMZ album.

This album breaks with the very quiet and sombre mood of the first Silver Mt Zion (SMZ) album, and instead adds drums and electric guitars/distortion. It is the weakest SMZ album in my opinion. It actually seems rushed, and the last few tracks are quite poorly recorded (to the point of the whole track distorting), which may have been purposeful but it is not musical. The quite sections here are also not on the same level of musicality as the first album. The slow sections do not hang there, dripping with emotion, like the slower tunes on the first (and later) albums, but instead they drag. And while I really love the SMZ lyrics most of the time, this is the one album where I find them a bit wanting. Not sure what happened. But thankfully, this was only a temporary set-back, and their next album ("This is Our Punk Rock") is really fabulous. I give this album 4.2 out of 10 on my 10-point scale, which translates to 2 PA stars.

 He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts Of Light Sometimes Grace The Corner Of Our Rooms by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2000
3.96 | 95 ratings

BUY
He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts Of Light Sometimes Grace The Corner Of Our Rooms
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Walkscore

4 stars Lovely, Sombre, Quiet.

This is the Silver Mt Zion album that sounds closest to Godspeed, even though here there are only three players most of the time. The pieces are slow, long, and melancholy. This is the album where Efrim decides to sing, although in reality he only sings a small minority of the time. His vocals, as noted by many, are an acquired taste and not everyone will be able to listen to them, but I really like them. They come across as totally authentic and heart felt. Much of this music is quite beautiful, if still sad and post-apocalyptic (ala Godspeed). My favourite track on this album, and a completely unique track in the history of music, is "13 Angels Standing Guard 'Round The Side Of Your Bed". It is so beautiful and magical, despite being musique-concrete of sorts. I am always amazed they could get such a wondrous sound whenever I listen to this piece. I give this album 8.0 out of 10 on my 10-point scale, which is just enough for 4 PA stars.

 Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upwards by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2001
3.53 | 65 ratings

BUY
Born Into Trouble As The Sparks Fly Upwards
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Prog Leviathan
Prog Reviewer

2 stars Born into Trouble as the Sparks Fly Upwards is overall a good post-rock release that fits within many conventions of the genre: slow, melancholic music that features a diverse instrumentation that builds and builds to noisy, abstract, and challenging crescendos. As a casual fan of the genre, there's a handful of interesting songs to enjoy, but not enough to make it memorable. It's highlights are when the players create a gentle rise and fall of lush strings that give the impression of one gently bobbing on ocean swells or walking amid fields of grain. At its best the album is relaxing and subtle. It's the more experimental parts that don't resonate with me. Some tracks have voice overs or singing that sounds frail and incomplete; others use shrill tones to induce tension or a sense of confusion, which aren't supported enough emotionally by the quite parts that precede. The songs don't strike me as being especially interesting or complex; however, the group's playing is solid and subtle. I especially enjoyed the acoustic bass work and warm, rich guitar vibrato heard on some songs.

That's not to say that these criticisms make Born into Trouble as the Sparks Fly Upwards a bad album, just not one that resonates with me. It may appeal to fans more interested in this minimalist and moody genre, but not for casual fans.

Songwriting: 2 - Instrumental Performances: 3 - Lyrics/Vocals: 2 - Style/Emotion/Replay: 2

 He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts Of Light Sometimes Grace The Corner Of Our Rooms by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2000
3.96 | 95 ratings

BUY
He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts Of Light Sometimes Grace The Corner Of Our Rooms
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by siLLy puPPy
Collaborator PSIKE & JR/F/Canterbury Teams

4 stars What we have here is a funeral album although it sounds more like a holocaust soundtrack not just dripping but flooded with melancholy and lucid lugubrious lament. A SILVER MT ZION is a side project of the masters of apocalyptic soundtrack skills Godspeed! You Black Emperor and believe it or not was created solely as a one album project by Efrim Menuck who was morning the death of his beloved dog Wanda. While the Godspeed! main project had a sort of continuity in their releases, Efrim wanted to branch out a bit and what better way than to construct a musical eulogy for your best friend. Yep, the universe's cruel joke is that your beloved pets become as close as your own children but have the lifespan of the average $100 American bill.

The irony was that through the death of a precious departed one, new life sprung from the ashes. This one shot project has become a wise career move that has far surpassed the original Godspeed! project's number of releases. While this debut album is credited to A SILVER MT ZION, Efrim followed the Sun Ra approach when he renamed his notorious Arkestra every album or two just to keep things interesting ie The Sun Ra Arkestra, Sun Ra and His Astro-Infinity Arkestra, Sun Ra and His Myth-Science Arkestra, Sun Ra and His Intergalactic Research Arkestra. Thus a new band was born after the popularity of this tribute to Wanda was released and the A Silver Mt Zion would evolve into The SILVER MT ZION Memorial Orchestra & Tra-La-La Band, The SILVER MT ZION Memorial Orchestra & Tra-La- La Band With Choir and so on and so forth.

While this release is lumped into the general post-rock category this is much more a percussionless parade of chamber music that is simply vocals, guitar, bass, piano and violin. The music is haunting and chilling and the closest thing that comes to mind when i hear this is the soundtrack to "Schindler's List." There is absolutely nothing uplifting and warm and fuzzy going on here. These notes flow together in a way that stabs you in the heart and twists the knife until you simply break down in utter agony and despair. Only the pain of losing a loved one could allow a composer to achieve this effect with such minimal instrumentation. This is one of those albums that i love but choose not to listen to on a regular basis because of the heart wrenching effects of violin tremolos, vibratos, arpeggios and sonic appoggiatura.

I, like many, prefer the albums that follow as they become more artistic and put the rock back in the post-rock, but this album serves a purpose and that purpose is magnificently achieved. The emotional flow of this album is haunting and evokes poignance and bereavement like few other musical works can. I can feel the extreme sense of pain and loss of love in every note on this one as it musters up some incredible dregs of dejection and execution of exuberance. It also makes me want to hug every loved one in my life and hold on dearly for i know the insufferable fate of separation will inevitably touch us all eventually. Sigh. Great album. Difficult subject matter.

 Horses In The Sky by SILVER MT. ZION, A album cover Studio Album, 2005
3.90 | 73 ratings

BUY
Horses In The Sky
A Silver Mt. Zion Post Rock/Math rock

Review by TCat
Prog Reviewer

5 stars This is the first SMZ album that has singing on every track. It is also, for the most part, the most subdued of the albums. It seems that it might have been a tough one for the fans to get at first, but it is a grower, and a lot of that has to do with the vocals. That is the biggest issue for the band, but in my opinion, the vocals match the music perfectly. SMZ's biggest attraction for me is their vulnerability that not only exists in the shaky vocals, but also in the orchestration of the instruments. There is always a slight hesitation in the delivery, or so it always seems, especially noticeable on this album because it is softer. Don't get me wrong though, there are bursts of dynamics throughout. You still get the builds on some of the songs. But other tracks don't build much at all, as in the title track.

"God Bless Our Dead Marines" is the opener and a great highlight in the band's career. It is a multi movement epic track with several melodies that vary in dynamics and tone. This is a beauty of a song and it ebbs and flows and eventually the vocals interweave around each other into a round of sorts. Next is another excellent track called "Mountains Made of Steam" which is based around a more focused theme, but still caries a lot of variation in it. This eventually builds to a harsh climax that utilizes dynamics and dissonance quite beautifully. "Horses in the Sky" is a more acoustic endeavor and remains quiet and thoughtful throughout, but is no less powerful. Eventually, some ambient texturing joins in, but never really takes over the intimacy of the track.

"Teddy Roosevelt's Guns" is follows a typical post rock formula and builds slowly to a final climax and a repeated line. "Hang on to Each Other" was actually recorded by the band around a campfire. You can hear the flames crackling in the background. Talk about a feeling of intimate music. You can close your eyes and picture yourself there listening to the band. The song starts out soft and the vocals build as other vocal lines are added, some wordless vocals and the repeating of the title while Effrim sings the verses. All the while, strings are played in the background to a structured tune. This eventually even drops out leaving the band singing their parts a cappella. The last track is another epic of beauty and dynamics, again with changing melodies and rhythms.

The vinyl is a piece of art, as is the case with most of SMZ's (and Godspeed You! Black Emperor's vinyl) and this is why I prefer to get their recordings in vinyl. On this one, there are only 3 recorded sides which contain all of the tracks. Instead of leaving the 4th side blank however, they commissioned an artist to do an etching into the vinyl. It is artwork of a bird and some branches. This is another way of expressing their artistry and intimacy with their listeners. It really gives the record a personal feeling between the listener and the band. Even though I know the band doesn't know me over any of their other listeners, but these things make me feel like they do, and the unique things they add to their albums make me feel a personal closeness to their music like no other band can do.

Many complain about Effrim's vocals being hard to listen to, but they have always been one of the things about the band that attracts me to them. He sounds like he is singing right to you, in your living room as you listen. He is a very passionate singer too, and the limitations of his voice can show through when he is the most passionate. These things make me love the music even more.

It's true that this band isn't for everyone, but everyone should at least give them a fair chance before deciding whether they like the music or not. The best music always takes time to grow on you, and I find my favorite albums are usually the ones I didn't understand at first, or they took time to grow on me. This is one of those albums. I think it's a masterpiece, not only of music, but of art in general. The lyrics are poetry, the music is original and dynamic, and the medium is taken to it's furthest to portray other forms of artistry, the album covers, the inserts, the little surprises that are included. It all works as a whole on this album, a those things make it the masterpiece that it is. 5 stars.

Thanks to useful_idiot for the artist addition. and to T.Rox for the last updates

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives