|
FOXTROTGenesisSymphonic Prog4.62 | 4182 ratings |
From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website
|
OpethGuitarist
like
Prog Reviewer |
I'll preface this review by saying that I am generally not in awe of GENESIS's work.
Most of their early work(aka before the pop sound) is good, but it doesn't hold
interest for me for the most part. I'll call Supper's Ready the most overrated song
in prog, 2nd only to Another Brick in the Wall. Creative for its time? Most definitely. There are many sections here that are very entertaining, and my favorites here are the often ignored songs like Get em out and Can Utility. Can Utility is prog excellence through 4 minutes, especially at around the 3 minute mark with wonderful chord layers backed by soft guitars. However, the end is well, overblown and doesn't fit. A major drawback throughout most of the album is the overuse of the mellotron. Similar to the way DREAM THEATER will often wear out songs with extended solo sections, Foxtrot wears out the intrigue of the mellotron in many sections. Supper's Ready is more or less not that good. Many will like it because of its overall scope and mission, however, what we have is a hodge podge of sounds. I'm usually not a lyircs person, but I can't stand the lyrics here, as it sounds much too overblown and mainstream, as if they are trying to prove something. Similar to when a band like Green Day would discuss political affairs, you feel like calling them idiots. It isn't GENESIS's best work, although their are many sections that are really great. I'd say this is a bad song(in overall), however it has many many parts that make it worthwhile and fun. Most of the interludes and "transitions" as I would call them, are really amazing and well done. This album has hits and misses, so take what you can from it, and move on, maybe to an album like VDGG's Pawn Hearts.
OpethGuitarist |
2/5 |
MEMBERS LOGIN ZONEAs a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums. You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials). Social review commentsReview related links |
|