Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
David Bowie - David Bowie CD (album) cover

DAVID BOWIE

David Bowie

Prog Related


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
2 stars Talk about a shaky start. This album, if you are used to Bowie's classic material, will seem very dated and quaint. The relatively simplistic pop songs are not very sophisticated. That said, there are a few surprises that make this worth buying, even if just for interest in Bowie's roots. Another thing worth noting is the story telling is very clever, even at this early stage.

'Uncle Arthur' is an average pop song, nothing special. 'Sell Me a Coat' isn't very special either, and there is a better remix on 'The Deram Years' anthology. 'Rubber Band' is slightly more intense, with very surreal lyrics. 'Love You Till Tuesday' is another simple pop song... but I like it. The lyrics never fail to make me laugh, and the tune is uplifting. 'There is a Happy Land' is probably the first serious song on the album, but it still has silliness included. There would later be a sequel to this song on 'The Man Who Sold the World' called 'After All'. If Bowie's lyrics are to be taken seriously on 'We Are Hungry Men', he is more deranged than I assumed, otherwise it is a darkly humourous song about a future society, that hints towards Boie's later albums. 'When I Live My Dream' is a very weak track that is just too romantic, without Bowie's usual wit and satire added. 'Little Bombadier' is simply a story telling pop song. 'Silly Boy Blue' is slower and sounds almost like a cautionary tale. 'Come and Buy my Toys' is pretty worthless here, as is 'Join My Gang', and 'She's Got Medals' is only slightly better. There's nothing special about 'Maid of Bond Street' either, to be honest. So all we have left is 'Please Mr. Gravedigger', a song that could qualify as experimental, and unlike anything Bowie has recorded since. It is a half sung/half moaned dialogue adressed to a gravedigger (which may or may not be himself), with no instrumental backgrounds, just the sound of wind and rain, and other noises you would expect to find in a grave yar. Weird!

So, there it is. A one of a kind album, form a one of a kind artist. Not essential by any stretch of the imagination, and even the word good is pushing it a little. Bowie fans may be interested, as I was, jsut to see what it is like, but it holds very few musical merits. This should not be of any interest to an average prog fan.

Cantebury addicts may appreciate the humour, but there's nothing near the complexity of that subgenre here. Two stars for being not totally terrible.

Report this review (#174969)
Posted Monday, June 23, 2008 | Review Permalink
ZowieZiggy
PROG REVIEWER
1 stars FROM DAVID JONES TO DAVID BOWIE

David Robert Jones was thirteen years old while he got his first instrument : a saxophone. At fifteen, he will play at a Christmas ball with a band called "George & The Dragons". After a fight with his bandmate Georges Underwood, he will have serious problems with one of his eye which will never been solved. He will have to live with one green eye and a blue one. At this time, he had no clue how much this detail will have an influence on his later image.

In 1963 (while he was sixteen), he was working in the centre of London and often went to the Marquee club to listen to the Stones or the Yardbirds and couldn't wait to get a band. He sung as a solo artist for a few months and formed a couple of bands which will have a very short life ("The Buzz", "David Jones & The King Bees"). A single will be recorded with the latter in 1964 but with absolutely no commercial success.

A couple of bands later, a new single was released with "The Manish Boys" with the same results.In the late 65, a TV programme is underway in the US. "The Monkees" were born. Their singer's name is Davy Jones. To avoid confusion, our David will change from name. He thought of David.Bowie.

1965 ends as it had started: a complete disaster and no recognition at all. But, he met someone very important for his later career. His new manager Ken Pitt. He was the one whom had him signed a contract at Deram in the late 66 (Marc Bolan and Cat Stevens were already signed artists there). So while Cat was releasing a huge success ("Matthew &Son"), David was releasing "Rubber Band". A complete and deserved flop.

In the midst of the psychedelic revolution, David remained totally resistant to it and was sticking to a more folkish approach. His debut album is a collection of naďve songs with a very thin skeleton.

It is difficult to mention the worst one. Maybe "Uncle Arthur", or "Rubber Band".Highlights are non existent but I guess that "Love You Till Tuesday" is the more decent one. The lyrics of "We Are Hungry Men" are also interesting. It features a politician who wants to fight against the over-population imposing "infertility". But the crowd doesn't pay attention and say: "We are hungry men. We don't give a damn for what you're saying, We're here to eat you".

The closing number shows some good dose of humour. "Please Mr. Gravedigger" is a theatric piece of music in which David is more acting than singing.

His debut album was well received amongst some critics but is another commercial failure. David is rather desperate and decided to spend some time learning more about Buddhism. He already wrote a song about it ("Silly Boy Blue"). Another interesting song thanks to the lyrics.

If it weren't for his later career, no one would talk about this album which is not good at all. Only early days fans and completionists can be interested by this "document". If you are not amongst them, just pass your way for better things to come.

Report this review (#175003)
Posted Monday, June 23, 2008 | Review Permalink
Dobermensch
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars Yeah, so what - the cover is diabolical. But you know, I think this is a great record, far better than 'Space Oddity' which was released two years later. I've got the cd version of this which runs for almost 80 mins! and it includes 'The Laughing Gnome' and singles from that era of Bowie's that everyone seems to hate- Hooray! It's Bowie being Un-Bowie. A one off, scatty, light hearted masterpiece. It's got nothing on 'Ziggy' or 'Scary Monsters'. Take it for what it is - funny, goofy and cheery. It's not often you can say that about Bowie. The way in which the songs are structured always reminds me of Syd Barrett's Floyd - and no-one gave them a hard time about 'Piper at the Gates of Dawn' afterwards, did they? Fair enough, 'Sell me a Coat' and 'Silly Boy Blue' are a bit pants. Bowie even gets his sitar out on 'Come and Buy my Toys'. And on 'Please Mr Gravedigger' he's coughing and hacking away like Wilfrid Brambell's 'Albert Steptoe' while digging a grave for a ten year old girl that he's just killed! So cheer up misery guts and stop being so po-faced about this album. Bowie's biggest mistake with this record was the hideous front cover, not the music within!
Report this review (#215347)
Posted Wednesday, May 13, 2009 | Review Permalink
tarkus1980
PROG REVIEWER
2 stars The first thing that jumps out at me regarding this album is just how hard Bowie is trying to look like contemporary (Between the Buttons-era) Mick Jagger on this album cover. The hair, the sweater, the slight sneer, it's basically dead on. Were they hoping somebody would look at this album cover and think for a second Jagger had released a solo album? Seems like an odd thing given that the "David Bowie" name was right next to the picture.

Bowie's "debut," of course, wasn't really his debut; he'd been trying to make his mark since 1964, jumping from style to style with one failed single after another, but this was the first time he'd recorded enough tracks in a single general style to have enough for an album. There's an expanded re-release floating around, extensively covering all of his mid-to-late-60's attempts at music-making, but I'm content to have my single-CD 12-track release. As for the music, this is Bowie trying to make a Something Else/Between the Buttons-style musichall/Brit-pop collection, but not really succeeding. His singing needed a lot of work at this point; the opening "la la"'s in "Sell Me a Coat" are the worst example, but there are more than a couple of moments on the album that make it obvious that Bowie wasn't going to have any success along the path of croon-balladeering. The music is full of "cute" (read: stupid) sound effects like the British announcer at the beginning of "We Are Hungry Men," the lyrics are extremely childish in an unimpressive way (he's clearly gunning for a Ray Davies or Syd Barrett approach, but failing), and the music has pretty much no grounding in rock music whatsoever.

Still, while I don't like this album much, I can't really hate it either. "Love You Till Tuesday" is a fun orchestrated pop song, and his "da-da-da-dum" singing is a terrific touch. Other songs are all afflicted by an excessive amount of twee or by silly lyrics or by silly sound effects, but it's hard to point to any one particular song and go "Man, this is horrible." Taken in other contexts, the songs on here could have made cute diversions; put together, the effect is a little underwhelming. If you're a major Bowie historian, you'll want this or one of the expanded releases of this, but regular Bowie fans could probably do fine just to find "Love You Till Tuesday" on a compilation or something.

Report this review (#287900)
Posted Tuesday, June 22, 2010 | Review Permalink
2 stars Well, we all had to start somewhere. In the case of one of the biggest icons in the pop/rock world, the start was a naive, charming album.

I had expected a worse album than this, due to it's reputation. This album is also regarded as David Bowie's false start. His Space Oddity album is regarded as the real debut of this cultural icon. So, what we have here is an earthbound oddity of an album. You got this joke, huh ?

The opener Uncle Arthur kind of sums up this album. A folk hall inspired song which Morecambe & Wise could implement in one of their comic routines if they wanted. This is folk music and cabaret into one. This despite of some quite serious lyrics. Short, sweet and pretty good. The music on this album is pretty basic and based around David Bowie's already excellent voice. Actually, while writing this review, it dawns on me that the music on this album is pretty similar to what The Beatles did on some of their more simple songs after Rubber Soul. The difference is David Bowie's vocals and some pretty naive lyrics.

The quality of this album is actually pretty good. Not good, but pretty good. It is impossible to overlook the fact that the songs are substandard, only kept alive by David Bowie's excellent vocals. But songs like Uncle Arthur, Silly Boy Blue and Rubber Band is actually good songs. The rest is best forgotten. In any case, I very much prefer the naive David Bowie on this album to the one cynical David Bowie on the likes of Let's Dance and Tonight. But this album still fails by some country miles.

2 stars

Report this review (#294385)
Posted Friday, August 13, 2010 | Review Permalink
3 stars "David Bowie" may be mostly suitable for fans but it's a fun, lighthearted album. It's not up there with anything at his creative peak in the 70's, but what is? We are talking, not only classics here, but influential records, important in music history.

"David Bowie" is probably, well ceratainly not 'important', generally speaking but I like it. The music here is actually good after several listens. For all David's musical directions, this is the only 'tongue in cheek', humourous album he (at least so far) has managed to come up with. And therefore unique in its own way.

I don't think it's any less cohesive in style, than the diverse "Hunky Dory" for instance (my favorite Bowie album). It's a young artist and his debut. A good humoured David Bowie. Bowie has humour of course, but only usually in inteviews, rarely in his music after this period.

Personal favourites are "Uncle Arthur", "Rubber Band" and "When I Live My Dream". His voice is wonderful throughout. As the last reviewer said, the CD version has many bonus tracks, so worth looking out for

Overall, it is dated, whimsical and not the least bit progressive but still entertaining, listenable stuff not to be taken seriously. 3 stars.

Report this review (#430685)
Posted Monday, April 11, 2011 | Review Permalink
Warthur
PROG REVIEWER
2 stars Not exactly where you should start with Bowie, his debut album catches him with one foot in the past and one with the future. On the one hand, you have songs in an old-fashioned easy listening style with interesting, off-beat lyrics such as The Little Bombardier (a ballad about a lonely ex-soldier accused of pedophilia) and Love You Till Tuesday (the cheeky song of a creepy stalker whose infatuation doesn't last the week), and on the other you have songs tied in with the trends of the day - whether it's the mild psych of Join the Gang or the orchestal-trippy Silly Boy Blue or the folky Come and Buy Me Toys - with stilted, cliched lyrics.

Occasionally Bowie manages to be musically modern and lyrically adept, as on We Are Hungry Men or She's Got Medals; other times he manages to be lyrically stilted and musically out of date - the worst possible combination in this case (When I Live My Dream is unbelievably sappy). Either way, he's all over the place. His old-fashioned tracks try out tricks that have already been performed better by others, and his more modern tracks have only a hazy contact with modern trends. Some kudos should be given for his efforts to bring more classical instrumentation into 60s pop, but let's face it - the Moody Blues did it better.

It's a pleasant enough listen, don't get me wrong; my favourite songs are probably the cross- dressing rock story She's Got Medals or the nostalgia-inducing There Is a Happy Land (though the latter's a guilty pleasure, considering how sappy it is), though the gloomy poetry of Please Mr Gravedigger is also striking. It's just that, well, Bowie's still trying to work out who he is and what he wants to do here. His next album isn't a classic either, but at it least had some kind of direction and focus.

Report this review (#446718)
Posted Thursday, May 12, 2011 | Review Permalink
UMUR
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
3 stars "David Bowie" is the self-titled debut full-length studio album by UK artist David Bowie. The album was released through Deram Records in June 1967.

Most listenerns are probably familiar with early "David Bowie", because of his breakthrough album "Space Oddity (1969)", but the music on this album is a far cry from the music style on "Space Oddity (1969)". While the music may not be as interesting or adventurous as the music on it's successor, "David Bowie" is still a pretty fascinating psychadelic tinged rock album. Especially the storytelling type lyrics which feature both humourous, odd and at times quite dark themes, are greatly enjoyable. How about "Uncle Arthur", which tells the story about a guy who after a short fling with a girl, who can't cook a decent meal, moves back in with his mother or the rather bizarre "Please Mr. Gravedigger".

The instrumentation is probably where the album could have been a bit more interesting. David Bowie does toy with both waltz time, citar, tuba, and some sound effects too, but most tracks are still clearly singer/songwriter styled with an acoustic guitar and vocals as the foundation. Not that it's necessarily an issue when the tracks are as charming as these generally are, but some of these tracks almost beg for more elaborate arrangements. When the tracks feature more elaborate arrangements, it´s often because of excessive use of strings and the string arrangements are often so dominant that they seldom do the tracks any favours.

While "David Bowie" is overall a promising debut album, it´s still a bit of an oddity in his discography (although there are plenty of those), and he would go on to release more interesting material only a few years down the line. However if you enjoy early Pink Floyd psychadelia (the least distorted tracks) or 1966 - 1967 The Beatles, this could easily be an album you'd be able to appreciate. A 3 - 3.5 star (65%) rating is warranted.

Report this review (#709754)
Posted Thursday, April 5, 2012 | Review Permalink
Necrotica
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Colaborator
2 stars Chapter I: Trends of the Times

David Bowie. The man, the myth, the legend. A trendsetter. An accomplished multi-instrumentalist. An innovator. A legend of musical and visual reinvention. It seems the world has become a darker place since Bowie's death on January 10, and emotional recollections and tributes regarding his work surfaced all over the world in the wake of his passing. And why not? Of his 25-album career, at least a quarter of that work can safely be considered ground- breaking and legendary in the world of popular music. The Rise of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars was a seminal piece of glam rock that gave birth to the iconic titular alter ego, Low and 'Heroes' saw Bowie bringing krautrock and ambient music to the masses, and now we've got his final effort Blackstar combining art rock with jazz in unique and fascinating ways. Why do I bring all of this up? Because it's interesting to think that such a trendsetter had such humble and derivative beginnings.

David Bowie's self-titled debut (not to be confused with his 1969 self-titled effort) is pretty much baroque pop with elements of folk rock and music hall. Right from the first track 'Uncle Arthur,' you can tell that Bowie was heavily influenced by artists such as The Beatles and Pet Sounds-era Beach Boys both musically and vocally around this time. The music hall influences are a lot more prominent here, however, and quite a few songs (most notably 'Rubber Band,' 'Little Bombardier,' and 'Maid of Bond Street') and have brass-based orchestration of some sort. There's an oddly bubbly and whimsical tone to the whole record, even during some of the darkest and most morbid subject matter; most songs sound quite innocent, like the sweetly upbeat and somewhat tongue-in-cheek 'Love You till Tuesday' or the tale of a land children inhabit apart from their elders in 'There Is a Happy Land,' but then there's a song like 'We Are Hungry Men' which talks about infanticide and abortion! Either way, the quirky tone of the album doesn't always mesh well in situations like these. Another problem is that the record sounds so inoffensive and boring during other parts that the songs run together after a while. There's not much variety; when you pick a song from this album, you usually get either of these: a quirky music hall song, a more subdued folk rock number, or a Beatles-influenced baroque pop tune. There's not much beyond that.

However, a few things stand out. First of all, the acoustic guitar playing tends to be fantastic on this album. 'Come and Buy My Toys' is a big highlight in this regard, frequently switching between whimsy and subdued melancholy with the very same instrument (the acoustic guitar is also the only instrument on this song other than the bass). There's also a fair amount of experimentation in a few songs, which would ultimately hint at Bowie's more innovative work. 'Join the Gang' combines a vintage piano sound with a sitar while its tempo creates a generally frantic and energetic atmosphere, and the closer 'Please Mr. Gravedigger' is an oddly somber and minimalistic a cappella number sung over the backdrop of a thunderstorm. If we had more of these songs to break up the general monotony of the cheerier pop/rock numbers, I think this would have been a more interesting and notable release in David Bowie's discography. However, aside from a larger emphasis on music hall elements, this is basically an average baroque pop record that does little beyond what many of Bowie's 60s peers were doing at the time. It's not really a bad record, just not the most interesting album compared to what Bowie could do in the future. Luckily, his next piece of work showcases a huge leap forward in both creativity and distinctiveness as an artist.

(Originally published on Sputnikmusic)

Report this review (#1515752)
Posted Wednesday, January 20, 2016 | Review Permalink
2 stars This album, if I remember correctly, was released on the same day as the Beatles' Sgt. Pepper album, but it was completely ignored. Musically, it is a far cry from Bowies early rhythm and blues singles, being mostly in the style of easy listening and cabaret, sometimes with a feel of 1966/67 "Swinging London". The music is generally not very engaging. The melodies are for most part unmemorably and clumsy, and it often sounds like he is unsure of where the melody should actually go. Consequently they are often difficult to remember. A good example is "Sell Me a Coat" where the melody is very repetetive in the chorus. The most memorable element of that song is probably the "la la la" part before the verses. His chords are usually stronger though, and they sometimes take you to unexpected places. I suspect he may have made the chorus first and then the melody.

Instrumentally, the playing sounds uninspired and very, very decent, and there's practically no energy. There are a few sound gimmicks now and then, like for instance in "Join the Gang", which spice the music up a bit, but only a bit. More outstanding is David Bowie's characteristic singing voice which adds a lot of personality to an otherwise very sterile sounding album.

Perhaps as a result of this, a lot of emphasis is on the lyrics which are often a bit "out there". Listen for instance to "Love You Till Tuesday": "Beautiful baby, my sweet desire started on Sunday, give me your heart and I'll love you till Tuesday... well I might stretch it till Wednesday". The most striking lyrics appear in "We Are Hungry Men" which is about overpopulation and how someone tries to reduce the number of people on earth by drastic means. It's a downright scary song, but it is sadly marked by the same musical weakness as most of the other numbers (uncertain melody and mediocre playing once again) - and then thre's a very annoying "Achtung! Achtung!" speaking voice that mostly sounds like a British idea of a German trying to speak English (á la Peter Sellers in Dr. Strangelove or several Monty Python sketches), rather than actual German accent.

"When I Live My Dream" is an example of a more cohesive song where music and lyrics fit each other. It is probably the album's best song, but it sounds more like a Frank Sinatra hit than something by the David Bowie we came to know from "Space Oddity" and onwards. Another remarkable track is the closer, "Please Mr. Gravedigger" where Bowie's singing is only accompanied by the sound of rain and thunder. There's some sneezing too, in what is essentially a novelty song. Quite a charming one though.

All in all not a very convincing album, and it is easy to hear why it made little impact at the time. However, you can sense some of the more quirky ideas from Bowie's later work.

Personal favourite song: "When I Live My Dream"

Report this review (#2496574)
Posted Saturday, January 23, 2021 | Review Permalink
DangHeck
PROG REVIEWER
2 stars David Bowie's debut and first self-titled album (1967) is a Baroque Pop effort, released just in time for this. As one reviewer put it aptly, when comparing this album to his 1970s output, first-time listeners in the least will find this album "quaint". To reiterate, do agree. [See my highlights below.]

The appropriate thing to do, I think, in the case of a lesser, early album by a beloved and respected artist such as Bowie is to compare and contrast to what was going on at the time and what was inspiring Bowie as musician and songwriter. To me, as another noted coyly, likely most similar to The MONKEES' "Psych-Pop Lite" brand, if anything (I love the Monkees, to make this clear). Just 5 months before this, they released their second, More of the Monkees.

In this same vein of 1967 Psychedelic Pop [Rock] (whether it's Sunshine or Baroque or something slightly heavier), in order of their release we have the following albums (just a fun exercise, but please take note, if you don't know them): Between the Buttons (The ROLLING STONES), Headquarters (The Monkees), Absolutely Free (FRANK ZAPPA & the MOTHERS OF INVENTION) and released the same day on May 26 Sgt. Pepper's... (The BEATLES), From the Beginning (SMALL FACES), We Are Paintermen (The CREATION), Bee Gees' 1st (BEE GEES) [seriously if you don't know this album, I highly recommend it--some of the best Psych Pop out there], Piper at the Gates of Dawn (PINK FLOYD), Something Else (The KINKS), Gorilla (BONZO DOG DOO-DAH BAND)[!!!!!!!], Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn & Jones Ltd. (The Monkees), Days of Future Passed (The MOODY BLUES), Magical Mystery Tour (The Beatles), and The Who Sell Out (The WHO).

Check out the songs below, but really, you'd be benefited greater, in my humble (lol) opinion to look above and elsewhere.

Personal Highlights: "Love You Till Tuesday", "We Are Hungry Men", "She's Got Medals"

Report this review (#2636054)
Posted Monday, November 22, 2021 | Review Permalink
1 stars Review #15: David Bowie

David Bowie has been one of the most indispensable figures in the entire rock scene, and I was expecting something at least decent when listening to the first album, but I was a bit disappointed.

Not to throw out hate for the sake of it, and gratuitously so. I just felt like I was listening to any commercial album typical of these "60s beach bands" (this is not a reference to The Beach Boys, I like them a lot).

Obviously, we can't compare this early Bowie work with his later projects in the 70s. Finding such a pop sound and so "cliché", to use an adequate term, it is logical that it doesn't sound like "Ziggy Stardust".

Personally, I wouldn't recommend this album for any prog lover, but in itself, it's a good listen, this and others, to get a hint of the beginnings of these rock stars.

2/10, 1 star. What can I say? a little disappointed.

Report this review (#2656631)
Posted Thursday, December 30, 2021 | Review Permalink

DAVID BOWIE David Bowie ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of DAVID BOWIE David Bowie


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.