DOMINION

British NeoProg band IQ is back with their 16th studio album release since they formed in the early 1980s. It is amazing to me that four of the band's original quintet of membership return/remain . . . after 43+ years!

1. "The Unknown Door" (22:33) herald-like horns open this one before static-treated television (or radio) clips from old WW II British broadcasts float across the background. Then Peter Nicholls enters using the same voice to perform another lyric using the exact same melodic formula he's used for 40 years. The heraldry horns continue with Neil Durant's typical synth strings chord washes for a bit before other computer-generated (or -enhanced) instruments start to come out of their enclaves. This feels like an opening scene to a Disney film--like Beauty and the Beast or The Lion King--where the villagers or jungle animals all start to appear and congregate while the protagonist introduces the audience to the feel and look (new innovative wonders of animation) of the film. Finally, at 4:40 we have full introduction and, by the middle of the sixth minute, full display of all of the personnel and tricks that the producers/artists have. The thick bass and bass pedals are cool, the Hammond and drums nice (though, of course, quite stereotypic in their "requisite" presence) and the bouncing synth chords are nice while a slightly different, slightly more engaged Peter Nicholls continues his storytelling (of the British bravery and tragedy in the Second World War). At 8:38 the band launches into a protracted heavy prog power section (action and passion, Lads!) intended, I think, to represent the courageous, unbridled energy and resolve of the oppressed Brits in the face of Hitler's war machine. The changes in instrumental sounds are effective--and would be moreso had they thought to change the sound effects on Paul Cook's drums, but, alas! they remain the same as they were throughout the first half of the song. At the end of the thirteenth minute the action/onslaught ends, leaving a quiet patch in which to look over the post-battle wreckage through the morning mist. There are those distant herald horns again (or fox hunt horns). At the 15-minute mark, enter a nice strumming, two-chord David Gilmour "Dogs"-duplicate acoustic guitar motif to create the next passage for the band to build around--and for Peter to continue his narrative--which leads up to a majestic church organ breakout that definitely conjures up the royal monarchy and all that represents. This only serves as a bridge to the next section of impassioned performances from all five of the quintet. And here we here Mike Holmes' lead guitar for what feels like the first time but then, one phrase "spoken" and it's gone: receded back into the maelstrom of thick sound. But this, too, soon ends as the simple keyboard synth "grass" supports Peter's introduction to his summation--before the "I think it's gonna work out fine" GENESIS "Supper's Ready"-like dénouement of the moralistic conclusion of his story in the final two and a half minutes. Of course the song ends with the Regina Britannia church organ, but the effect of nationalistic pride chest-puffing is somewhat diminished by the pastoral guitar, synth strings chord wash, and statement of the song's title in Peter's last pronunciations. (I'm quite surprised that the heraldic horns failed to make a final appearance!) (40.333/45) 2. "One of Us" (3:10) nice Paul McCartney-like acoustic guitar play opens this, setting down the balnket over which Peter Nicholls will sing his "Blackbird" like vocal. Too bad for the entry of the synth wash chords at the one-minute mark: the guitar and voice duet was fully sufficient. Nice work Mike and Peter! More of this! (8.875/10)

3. "No Dominion" (6:25) bombast and the familiar instrumental sound palette we all know and, supposedly, love from 1976-77 GENESIS albums, A Trick of the Tail and Wind and Wuthering. while Peter Nicholls sings about something in the same monotone and ploddingly-pace vocal delivery as . . . always! The ending of the song is quite odd as instead of a buildup to a long instrumental passage with its crescendo and (more) bombast--as it definitely feels as if its going--it just fades out. Mid-phrase. As if the engineer, producer, or band said, "No! No! Enough of this!" and then slid down the volume paddles on the console of the soundboard! Since I don't hear lyrics (they're just another instrument in a song's weave), I can't comment or critique the song based on message, but in terms of exciting, refreshing, or innovative music? There is none here. (8.6667/10)

4. "Far from Here" (12:44) a construct that very quickly lost my attention--receded into the background as "another one of those." The sonic landscape is too thick and murky, the drumming too proscribed and rote, the main chord progressions too homogenous, and the few solos or individual performance breakouts too mashed up within the confines of the wall of sounds' overall murk. And Peter Nicholls melody choices are too borrowed (I hear so much of Jon Anderson's Yes vocal melodies in this song). Even the plaintive piano-based finale is just . . . dull. There is nothing I can store or retrieve from this song for future recalll--nothing that even remotely draws to want to try to do so. Before I can even ruminate if I could do this better--what changes I might make--I have to back up and realize that I would never even deign to give my time such a project. (21/25)

5. "Never Land" (8:16) I like the simplicity and near-spaciousness of the opening four minutes of this. Then the shit flies: watered down post-Hackett Genesis, gnarled and scuffed by distortion, overly-thick synth walls, and unnecessary bombast. At the same time, I do find myself, for some as-yet undetermined reason, inexplicably sympathetic to this one: the overall effect of the simplistic, straightforward "pop" chord progressions has an endearing emotional effect on me--one that is quite reminiscent of the way PREFAB SPROUT's "Desire As" has always held me under its spell. Thus, despite my inclination to negate this as a standout representative of progressive rock music, I like it! It makes me feel good! (18/20)

Total Time 53:08

Several reviewers have been commenting on the "new" sound or "reinvention" of IQ for this album, but I hear none of this; Dominion is nothing but more of the same solid, well-engineered NeoProg that the band have been turning out over the last fifteen years. I am so glad the band chose to not publish a two album release--with their now-usual "Bonus Disc" of unfinished, unpolished, second-rate cast-offs. 53 minutes of my time spent with this stuff is quite enough; in the past (and with many of today's NeoProg, RetroProg, and "Symphonic" bands [I'm referring to bands like The Flower Kings, Glass Hammer, Antony Kalugin, and Transatlantic here--not to mention all the "all-star" albums coming from Italian artists]), I've dreaded having to wade through the muck and dross of 70 to 140 minutes of music--especially when it never really presents anything new or exciting, so, thank you, IQ, for that small mercy. Despite its merciful length of 53 minutes, I had to spend some time with this album in order to accurately and record my sincere reactions and form my opinions. The problem with me reviewing any IQ release is the fact that I am disenchanted with the repetitious to the brink of monotony presentation of the same limited sound palette over the band's 43 years and, worse, the total and invariable predictability of Peter Nicholls' singing. The lyrics may change but the melodies and presentation is the same, nearly exactly the same, in every single song he's ever participated on. In the end, I do not hear any deviation from the band's formulae. (And I admit: Why should they? It has worked for a long time; the band has a very loyal and enthusiastic following. I am just not one of them.)

B/four stars; another solid and fairly consistent display of NeoProg mastery from one of the sub-genres' oldest and most consistent artists.

Social review comments

Review related links

• Send comments to BrufordFreak
• Report this review (#3167952)
• Buy IQ music online with PA partners
• Show all IQ MP3/Stream
• Go to IQ page for videos, full discography with ratings, reviews and much more
• Go to Dominion page for more details, where to buy and ratings/reviews
• Search the Forum for IQ related discussions