ACHILLES AND THE DIFFERENCE ENGINE

Today I am featuring an album that includes one of my Facebook friends, David Knowles (he does not know I am reviewing this). The band is called "The Swan Chorus," and the album is their second release "Achilles and the Difference Engine," released in 2023. The band is based out of Liverpool. Even though their first self-titled album wasn't released until 2018, they actually have a history that goes back to 1979 when David Knowles and Colin McKay began working together in a band called Achilles. They played all original prog-rock, composed by Knowles (keyboards) and McKay (guitar and vocals) While they gigged heavily, they did not release any music that I am aware of. After Achilles split-up in 1981, Knowles and McKay continued to work together. Next up for the duo was the band Here's Johnny formed in 1984. They released 4 singles on RCA, including "Idlewild" with the BBC's "Syd Lawrence Dance Orchestra." Here's Johnny broke up in 1984. By 1989, David had formed a band called Life that played "a blend of progressive rock with a commercial pop feel." Life only lasted until 1991 without releasing any material as record companies in the UK were not signing prog bands at the time, in favor of dance music. (I'd be interested in hearing it, however, if any recordings were made.) Evidently during this period McKay had left the UK, for a while, but it is not clear as to where he went or how long he was away. When he did return several years later, he contacted Knowles about working together again. Knowles had already been working with original Achilles drummer Peter Dover. The three recruited singer John Wilkinson and The Swan Chorus was born. As mentioned earlier, they released their first album in 2018, but this follow up was delayed due to the pandemic. Interestingly the first album does not include McKay in the credits. On this album, McKay and Knowles essentially played all of the instruments themselves, with Wilkinson singing, with "additional drums" from Dover and bass from Dave Jones. Perhaps David Knowles will help to clarify when he sees this.

So now that you know the background info, let's check out the tunes!

Track 1 - The Waffle House Index

This title refers to the fact that Waffle House Restaurants (in the USA, particularly in the Southeast) only close when the weather is extremely bad. It has become an informal yet useful measure of the severity of a storm. This 9- minute opener begins with a shimmering keyboard tone and other layers gradually emerge. At just before one minute, the band kicks in with some power chords. Excellent keyboard work from Knowles with a synth solo. There is a short guitar solo from McKay and then the vocals begin at around 1:45. The first verse is accompanied by acoustic guitar. Other instruments join in at around 2:15. Wilkinson's voice has been compared to Phil Collins, but he sounds closer to Peter Gabriel to my ears. Either way, it is perfectly suited to express the songs, which I assume are all written by Knowles and McKay. The groove changes at around 2:35. There are many layers of guitars and keyboards, while the bass & drums are a bit further back in the mix that I might prefer. There is a nice transition riff at around 4:05, then I believe I hear the holy grail of classic prog sounds, a mellotron. At 4:15 there is a cool solo bass riff then other instruments start joining back in. This is shaping up to be a nice proggy middle instrumental bit. Nice fingerstyle acoustic at around 6:30. I like the organ that enters around 7:00. Around 8:10 there is a Steve Howe style guitar fill. This section is very Yes-like to me. I like the lyrics here:

Now the Orange Messiah's immune to scandal Breitbart and Bannon and Ayn Rand's vandals Leading the song With inflammatory headlines and big, bright pictures Playing to paranoid curtain-twitchers What could go wrong?

But in the People's Republic of Cafe Nero Somebody's snowflake is someone's hero Proudly surveying the scene Now that the transgender bathrooms are clean . . .

Wonder who they are singing about?? LOL.

Excellent track!!

Track 2 - After Dark

A bit of reggae groovin' here. I like the full sounds of the keyboards, like a horn section and organ all at once. It's a very strong arrangement. Nice guitar solo at around 3 minutes. This one is more pop oriented than the opener, but in the best possible way. I don't detect any auto-tune or cut and paste sections. Think more like something Steve Winwood might have done in the 80s, around the "Back in the High Life Again" era. Good track.

Track 3 - Being There

Wondering if this is a reference to the classic Peter Sellers movie. This 7 minute cut begins with a beautiful piano part from Knowles in a ballad style. He starts playing a riff at around 40 seconds. At about 1-minute the keyboard part reminds me of Tony Banks from Genesis (I believe some of the members also perform in a Genesis tribute band, so that checks). The vocals enter around 1:40. Icy keyboard tones and acoustic guitar create the soundscape here. Yes, this is a tribute to Peter Sellers. There are several references to roles he played. I know some of the songs date back to the early 80s Achilles era of the band, so I'm guessing this is one of them, as I recall that was around the time of his passing. I love the wordplay in the lyrics. The tempo picks up slightly and becomes more rhythmic with about a minute left. After a keyboard lick, there is an excellent guitar solo before the keys take back over to close out the song. I'll put this one in the category of hauntingly beautiful.

Track 4 - Cold Comfort

A 6-8 organ arpeggio pattern starts this one off with accents from the band; it feels a bit Wakeman like to me. I love the drumming when it kicks in. I like the quick 6-8 feel. The guitar chords sustaining behind the 6-8 rhythms remind me of Pete Townshend. But then at 1:20 we shift to a Beatle-esque 4-4. The 6-8 and 4-4 keep alternating. Excellent countermelodies between the guitar and keys just before the 2 minute mark. Just after the 2 minute mark we have a nice proggy synth solo. Then the organ sets the stage for a wonderful guitar solo. Outstanding use of the whammy bar at 2:57 (I'm a guitarist, I pick up things like that ;) ). I like the layering of the guitar parts throughout this section. Another verse follows the instrumental break. Again I wish the bass was more prominent, as it seems to have a Chris Squire flavor to it. I love the ending bit. Great track!

Track 5 - Contender

Solo piano begins this one as well. This one sounds like Knowles had some classical training along his path. Well- done. At 40 seconds, a descending riff accompanies the vocals that simultaneously gives me ELP and Beatles vibes. There are cool fills along the ride. I like the vocal harmonies in the bridge at 2:20. Super-cool keys starting at 2:48! I believe we are in 7 for a moment before returning to 4-4. The story here is about a guy who goes to prison, and eventually gets a "groupie" with whom he has "conjugal visits." Then he goes on a bender after release but by that time he's a celebrity who is too big for jail then he's become a contender. It reminds me in its lyrical absurdity of Genesis' "The Battle of Epping Forest." (That's a compliment, BTW.) Well done with lots to sink my teeth into for a 4:30 track!

Track 6 - My Little Vampire

This begins with a classical guitar part. It is another longer track at 8:30. At around 30 seconds synths accompany an electric guitar part. However, not long after, they get a tone similar to Genesis' "The Cinema Show" going. This seems to be a love song to a female vampire. Excellent chord choice at 2 minutes! I love the mellotron choir that enters just prior to 3 minutes. There is an eerie keyboard part around 3:42. Then at around 4:10, the music pauses. A guitar solo part leads us into a faster tempo section. Nice syncopated drum part here. Excellent musicianship all around. There is a harpsichord sound and even what sounds like a flute before the vocals return. He is singing in great detail about the colors he would use to paint the sky for his vampire lover. A lovely guitar solo follows. The mellotron returns at around 7 minutes. I love the chord progressions they used in this song. Excellent and unique track!

Track 7 - No Idea

A drum fill leads us in. At 12 seconds there is a layered guitar part that reminds me of The Eagles' "Witchy Woman," but it is fleeting, so Don Henley can chill out. The music is very dramatic with some cool synth parts underneath. This one is pretty cinematic, sounding like it would fit in on an 80s movie soundtrack album (again, a compliment). Cool drum fills just before 3 minutes. A wonderful synth solo takes us to the end. Cool tune?very 80s.

Track 8 - English Electric

David Knowles alerted me to this one last year when I posted a review during the #100greatestprogrockchallenge of Big Big Train's phenomenal "English Electric?Full Power" album, as it has a similar name. Not being from the UK, I am not sure, but I am thinking that "English Electric" is the name of the power utility company there. Perhaps someone can confirm or clarify my suspicions. This has a massive intro section. I like the shuffle beat with the keyboards. The song is about the excitement of putting on a live show on the road. The song changes to a completely new groove at 2:30, slowing down and going into a dreamy section with fantastic keyboard playing. Then at around 3:15 the guitar takes over. We are in a floaty 6-8 now. Loving the new section at 4:50 that leads us back to the shuffle. Great prog!

Track 9 - Welcome Home

There are definitely a plethora of keyboard tones that Knowles provides! But after the short intro we go "totally" new-wave! It's somewhere between Devo and The Cars. I wasn't expecting this! I love the walking bass line. This is a bit of upbeat fun. Terrific unison lick at 2:30. I enjoyed it, it even has an old-school fade-out. Does anyone do that anymore? Fun track.

Track 10 - This Great Adventure

Ahh yes, a hallmark of a great prog album is the closing epic, and they give us a 14 minute one here. This one has synths fading in, before the guitar and keys do a bit of call and response. I like the bass back-beat as the music evolves. A big drum fill leads us into a new theme just before 2 minutes. The vocals come in at 2:15 with acoustic guitar accompaniment, and clean electric guitar fills. The band kicks back in at around 2:40. There is a girl mentioned in the lyrics who is bent on the narrator improving himself, and he says "It's all true." A mystical sounding part follows at around 4 minutes, then the groove returns and McKay plays a fusiony guitar solo, influenced by Alan Holdsworth to my ears. At 5:20 a funky-rock riff takes over, and the vocals return. A nice keyboard then guitar solo fills in between verses. At around 7 minutes, the bass keeps the rhythm, then there is a unique sound that almost sounds like electric violin. I like the funky guitar effect at around 8:30. Excellent a cappella harmonies at 9 minutes, joined by instruments. Really cool keys at around 10 minutes. I am enjoying all of the rhythmic shifts. No odd meters, just lots of changes in the syncopation. The main instrumentalists seem very balanced in who is featured at any given time. The song ends on a dreamy note and thus the album ends.

OVERALL IMPRESSIONS:

An excellent album indeed. My least favorite was track 2, "After Dark," but even it wasn't bad. The standout tracks are "The Waffle House Index," "Cold Comfort," "Contender," "My Little Vampire," "English Electric," and "This Great Adventure." I would recommend this to Genesis and Big Big Train fans without reservation. My main quibble is with the mix, it's not bad but I wish the bass and drums were more out front, as I think it would add more depth to the overall sound. Overall, however, it was a very enjoyable listen. I'll give it a 4.25 out of 5 stars.

Clicking 4, but really a bit better at 4.25

Social review comments

Review related links

• Send comments to yarstruly
• Report this review (#3149959)
• Buy THE SWAN CHORUS music online with PA partners
• Show all THE SWAN CHORUS MP3/Stream
• Go to THE SWAN CHORUS page for videos, full discography with ratings, reviews and much more
• Go to Achilles and the Difference Engine page for more details, where to buy and ratings/reviews
• Search the Forum for THE SWAN CHORUS related discussions