THE ROOT, THE LEAF & THE BONE

A very difficult album to review, this one. After no less than 4 masterpieces in a row, I was not that excited when I listened to this new Manning CD. So I decided to wait a little longer and listen some more so I could give it more chances. But, alas, my first impression didn´t change much. Don´t get me wrong: this is a very fine work. As usual you´ll get a lot of 70´s references and sounds, tasteful arrangements, a near perfect modern production, stunning performances and lots of good melodies. It is just that those songs didn´t captivate me with the same power as his previous works.

There are no real lows, but also neither there are anything that stood out as well. Like if a little something is missing, you know? Maybe a more uptempo tune of sorts? Something simpler and more direct? On the other hand, all tracks are of merit and have good moments. Some are excellent like Old School. I really can´t put my finger on it.

Maybe I was expecting too much, specially after the ambitious and more symphonic Margaret´s Children. I still like The Root, The Leaf & The Bone a lot, but clearly this change of musical direction didn´t strike a chord with my tastes as much as Number Ten (2009) for exemple. Maybe next time. However, even if I didn´t appreciated it that much I still do recommend you listen to this CD carefully. Manning is one of those rare cases when an artist so prolific never released a bad album.

Final rating: 3.5 stars.