ARCHIVE CARDIACS 1977-1979

Cardiacs

RIO/Avant-Prog

From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Cardiacs are usually not considered as a real prog band, but this compilation of some of their earliest recordings proves that they once were very much prog. The influence of Yes, Zappa and Genesis cannot be overheard. Most songs are from the tapes Toy World and The Obvious Identity which, unfortunately are not represented here in their entirity and were never re-released either. Added were the two Piffols, demos from a project by Tim Smith and Dominic Luckman that have not been released earlier. There are a few more or less "punky" songs that prog die-hards might possibly not like, even though all of those show more inventiveness than you'd usually find in punk.

Report this review (#76402)
Posted Thursday, April 27, 2006 | Review Permalink

sabbacc108

I have been a Cardiacs fan for a few years, and was excited to pick up some of the recent CD reissues. However, I was a bit on the fence about Archive, simply because little has been written about it (the sparse notes in the album itself likely don't help in this regard), and some opinions online seemed to regard it as an inessential compilation for completists only. How wrong they were! Archive is a spectacular compilation that showcases some of the best of what Cardiacs have to offer.

Anyone going in expecting the prologue to A Little Man and a House, or Sing to God, will need to temper their expectations slightly---these are early recordings, done on very low budgets, and showcase an embryonic version of the band. On the once hand, this is Cardiacs as the most straight-ahead "punk" band that they would ever be, with some songs that might not sound out of place on an early Buzzcocks B-side (albeit with Tim Smith's trademark wonky lyrics). On the other hand, this is where Tim Smith's prog-era influences are truly laid bare, with the spectacular "Piffol" songs showcasing King Crimsonesque guitar lines, and "T.V.T.V" sounding like a Gentle Giant tribute. On the third hand (of course there's a third hand!), this also showcases Cardiacs' earliest epics, with the wonderful "As Cold as Can Be in an English Sea" and "A Game for Bertie's Party" giving small previews of what the band would accomplish on future songs like "R.E.S."

Some fans may end up skipping the punkier tracks on future listens (fair enough), but for me, the songs come together as a whole that exceeds the sum of its (admittedly marvelous) parts.

Report this review (#3108839)
Posted Sunday, October 20, 2024 | Review Permalink

CARDIACS Archive Cardiacs 1977-1979 ratings only

chronological order | showing rating only

The Reverend
zoidbergfrench
Tullfan (Simon)
purplewolfhounds
Morda
Smurph (Greg)
sashsash
Progmind (Rodrigo)
historian9 (George) SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Retired Admin
jon.nein (Jon)
belch1889 (Adrian Bell)
Tabazan
raggleman (CHRIS ALEXANDER)
dodur
doesnotcompute (Mark Harvey)
JimC (Jim Conyers)
dion
Soul2Create (David Romera)
thegrandjawaka (Jon)
IckyQualms (Graham)
dyyigor1958 (Igor)

Post a review of CARDIACS Archive Cardiacs 1977-1979

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).