CITADEL

Ne Obliviscaris

Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Rowsol

I've listened to this maybe 20 times over and Portal Of I probably 50 times. I feel I have enough experience to write my experience with this.

If I had to rate my top songs from them it would be: (in this order)

Forget Not Xenoflux Painters of the Tempest Tapestry of the Abstract

Citadel is a much shorter album than the previous and not as good. I see people on the internet saying Citadel is better than Portal Of I, and I have to disagree. That's not to say it's not good, it's still a 4 to me. "Portal" was just that damn good.

Citadel has only a few stand out parts in my opinion. The last 5 minutes of Painters, and 4:00 and 9:00 of "Devour Me, Colossus".

Portal had the middle of Tapestry, the last half of Xenoflux, and the entirety of Forget Not that was excellent.

I saw someone compliment their choice to make this new album shorter than Portal. Why? Portal was 70 minutes and great the entire time. Why would they want to shorten it?

I guess that's all I have to say.

Report this review (#1299361)
Posted Saturday, November 1, 2014 | Review Permalink

NE OBLIVISCARIS Citadel ratings only

chronological order | showing rating only

rrkk
Imperial Zeppelin (Nasir)
SirFunchalot
katatonia (Aziz)
Mjolner
crosekrantz (Cornelius Rosenkrantz)
miab
CassandraLeo (Aaron)
hugoboss (Hugo Ferreira)
sauromat (alexander)
Spitf1r3
Pieromcdo (Pierre McDonald)
Nacho220 (Allen Thompson)
Hexalion (Jim)
Floyd Steely
assasinan (Sinan Dogan)
Sophocles (Sophocles Papavasileiou)
Maximuss (Massimo)
Hrvat (Karlo Jelincic)
MrEdu3 (Eduardo Santos)
SymptomaticFiend (Valtteri)
Ayrton_2112 (Andrea Tringali)
cgibbs
AJMA
uzebsbys
CorcoranW (Matt Corcoran)
agencement
rjknutsen (Ryan Knutsen)
jeromeT. (thomas)
marsalzinho (Marçal Schmitt Junior)
negipan (KH)
Lebmetalcom (Rami)
rdavis1992 (Robert Davis)
Hugh (Ugo)
D.sciortino (davide Sciortino)
MediaDownstream
dorubraslasu
MoonlapseSerenity (Dan)
Kozlotur The Twisted (A)
M3g52 (Miguel Ceraglioli)
ed14 (ILDAR)
Revolution666 (Arik Manley)
erikbelphegor (Erik)
frahm (DHK)
R.Diaz (Luis)
frantic
HillTopMan (Ian Merchant)
Elixen (Brian)
Pablo Scheglione (Pavel)
bhuelga (Brandon Huelga)
Brini max (Max)
cecco (andrea)
Torecan (Andrea)
RuntimeError (Boris Musha)
j.cope (jesse)
DTprog (andrea)
E.noor (Eckart)
mfoucault (KRL)
Crynus
Haxprocess (Barış)
thepurplepiper (Colm)
Puppies On Acid (Chris)
abg05 (Anaël Bérubé Gaudreau)
bwood637 (Brandon)
Ehlirt (Gavin)
Stasis (Edu)
AugustoR (Augusto Rudzinski)
daniellob (daniel)
MrPoisson (Hiram Silva)
Birdland (.)
Returnity (Yalcin Inel)
LesPaul59 (Matej Lovrenovic)
felipeterry (Felipe Massuia)
Paondragon (Paon Dragon)
HarryAngel746 (Maciej) COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
Rickyntik (Riccardo Capocci)
ziltoid101 (Andy)
icaro9293 (icaro)
Delayzy (Diogo Cunha)
LMTR14
Mae7Mae (****** *******)
karolcia (Piotr Lachowicz)
ElliotYork (Elliot Cameron)
Throwness (Ioannis Ch.)
Exivious_Erik (Erik)
burak (Burak Aktay)
okas123 (markos)
pepezitos (Pedro Langer)
TonyAMO (Tony)
profburp (Fourmont)
Isaac Peretz (Isaac Peretzz)
dannyb
IgnosAn (Ignacio)
tupan (Bruno Rios Evangelista)
Soul2Create (David Romera)
rivierkaas (Kay van den Berg)
Line K.N. (Iam Notgivingit)
Guccitore (Salvatore)
Hakosuka (Eejmar)
M7amad666 (Mhamad kareem)
Griseus (Dan)
alexanderxes (Alexander)
Evissergorp
Mehdi Taba (Mehdi Tabatabaei)
Aggprog (Alvaro)
carbonbazed (b.)
nicko1991 (Nikolai)
Bombalak (Cinar K)
luminol (ivan)
Yrgal (Jan Oscar)
WillFerreira (Willian Ferreira)
-Cactus92- (Francesco)
amongusrtx30080 (Xavier)
Herr_Raul (Antoni)
sasuke-014 (Mohamed Jbira)
Trivial_Theater2995 (Michael)
Alanyyz (Alan Cefali)
RagelordCheato (Prefer not to say)

Post a review of NE OBLIVISCARIS Citadel

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).