![]() |
THE SECRET LANGUAGE OF BIRDSIan AndersonProg Folk |
From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website










I've known the album for quite a few years, and I just played it again in order to write this review. At first my heart sank. Having listened to quite a lot of classic Tull in recent months, it depressed me that Ian's voice has now lost so much force. Many of the tunes here will remind you of the acoustic stuff on MINSTREL IN THE GALLERY and SONGS FROM THE WOOD; Ian's guitar playing is in the same familiar style and so are his lyrics - but I felt sad so much of his voice has gone; you can tell he's straining, even when he tries to sing softly.
Strangely enough, by the third or fourth song (and there are quite a lot of tracks) the problem stopped bothering me. The music was getting livelier all the time, the melodies got more inspired, the arrangements sounded warm and witty... I simply loved "Postcard Day", and after that I stopped worrying and simply enjoyed the colourful tunes. There was one piece accompanied by violin which I found beautiful and deeply moving: most probably "Better Moon" or "Sanctuary" - I'm not sure, I don't have the CD at home, I was playing an old-fashioned tape and there's no violin listed in the credits. "Habanero Reel" is superb as well: great fun the way it's accompanied on accordion and marimba! Throughout the album, Ian uses his mandolin quite a bit (which I always appreciate), and if grumbled about his voice, well, let me add this: by the year 2000 Ian's flute playing had gotten much better than in the classic 1970s... You can just tell he now has a much fuller and more sensuous tone, so whenever there's a flute solo you don't feel exasperated - you actually look forward to the next one!
True Tull freaks may feel there's something missing... If THE SECRET LANGUAGE had been arranged by the old band (circa 1977), it would have been enriched with all kinds of variations that got played on pipe organs, synths, electric guitars, glockenspiel etc. But the 1970s are gone forever, and meanwhile, THE SECRET LANGUAGE OF BIRDS is well worth hearing.

Normally, Ian Anderson is the leader of Jethro Tull, one of my favourite bands of all time. Here he is on his own. Some people seem to think that his solo albums sound just like Jethro Tull albums. These people cannot have heard many Jethro Tull albums! If this music is to be compared with Jethro Tull it must be pointed out that this is a very naked and strongly acoustic Jethro Tull. But this is not enough to put them apart. The Secret Language Of Birds is more towards Folk Pop than Prog Rock. It is certainly not mainstream anyway, and also hardly progressive.
The songs of The Secret Language Of Birds are well written, melodic, flawlessly performed, perfectly recorded, mixed and produced. Indeed, everything about this album is perfect to the point of verging towards being too perfect, almost glossy. Ian always has a strong attention to detail and this is a high quality product. But I would certainly not call it progressive rock nor compare it in any way with the music of Jethro Tull. An Ian Anderson solo album can, as far as I am concerned, never be compared with a Jethro Tull album. The only similarities is the flute sound and the vocals.
I enjoy the heavily flute and vocal based musings of The Secret Language Of Birds to some degree, and it is a good album overall. But I would certainly not put it up there with Jethro Tull's music. But this is a decent Folk Pop album in it's own right. But certainly no more than that!

The songs are all short, the longest being just over 5 minutes, and any of them would fit quite well on most Tull albums. Martin Barre even makes an appearance on a couple of songs (wouldn't that make them Tull songs anyway?).
As I mentioned previously, the arrangements are spectacular, and the recording quality is crystal clear, with instruments dancing across the stereo spectrum. I highly recommend this one to any Tull fan, prog- folk fan, or good music fan in general.

Whenever very acoustic, this album in it sound returns you back to early years of JT. A bit softer, less rock, a bit more folk, but generally very similar to early JT sound. Intelligent songs, nice sound and bright and light atmosphere. Not too much original ,however. Often you will have the feeling you heard these songs before.
For sure, nice album for JT and Jan Anderson fans. For others possibly better just to listen more characteristic albums .

Ian Anderson really seems to enjoy himself with these mainly acoustic and folksy ditties. Despite the short format, the songwriting is very clever and Anderson covers lots of moods and different alterations within each song. His vocals are relaxed, dynamic and perfectly at easy. Of course, you can't teach this old geezer much new tricks and almost everything will have a very familiar ring to it. But it is well written and executed.
While not raising any musical bars, it is a pleasant album that will please most fans of Tull. Anderson has sure put his heart into this album, which always much appreciated. Especially if you are into the folksier side of Tull, you can't go wrong with this album.


Folky in nature, each song has different world music motifs, be they Celtic, Indian, Russian folk, Spanish or even neo classical. There's certainly no rockers here. which results in a relaxing close listen to some of Anderson's best lyrics as a solo artist. Standout tracks are "The Secret Language of Birds", "The Little Flower Girl", "Postcard Day", "The Water Carrier", "A Better Moon" and "Sanctuary". But in truth, all are worth a listen in this very consistent solo effort from old Ian. 3.5 stars rounded up to 4.
IAN ANDERSON The Secret Language of Birds ratings only
chronological order | showing rating only
-
uelen@inwind.
-
DaviesHippych
-
nitramessahc
-
kyrandia
-
Gentle King (Alejandro Sozzi)
-
sauromat (alexander)
-
JJ (Jorma J)
-
valravennz (Penny)
-
Barbu (M.)
-
fifek (Rafal Bigda)
-
Mirsset (Miroslav Krajnik)
-
mdelval (Manuel del Val Latorre)
-
GabrielGenesis
-
CJSrans (Jose)
-
Menestrel (Diego Bezerra)
-
gelud
-
MIEDZIAK64 (JAREK)
-
knorkator (Andrew)
-
BarryGlibb (B)
-
rpaez (Rafael)
-
stefanbedna (STEFAN)
-
Lynx33 (Balázs Markó)
-
Anster (Anton Ermakov)
-
check7 (Jan Dolezel)
-
R. Hugo (R.Hugo Villanueva J.)
-
Squire348
-
gegece (gustavo garate de Nacional)
-
magoatem (Fabio Poggi)
-
cloudynow
-
brig64 (Igor)
-
Lemmings (Naji Chmayssani)
-
king Of karate (Alex)
-
al b
-
Dr. Yes (Artem)
-
Retropolis (A Blaze)
-
milosshomi80 (milos)
-
tmay102436 (Thomas May)
-
hawkzen (Kenneth Borody)
-
SergeUnseen (Serge Filimonov)
-
Jihnik1958 (Evgeniy)
-
Wanorak (Jeff Nichols)
-
snowman1980
-
pars (Valeriy)
-
fluiddruid (Antal Molnár)
-
progstreaming (Markwin Meeuws)
-
Pintos (Sasha)
-
Harkonnen (Alex Ramos)
-
MediaDownstream
-
Rendref (Ilia)
-
Psychomodo (Mike)
-
Tasartir (Alex)
-
diegoth (Diego Thierry)
-
milanoclaudio (Claudio Milano)
-
nickel (Jon)
-
progressouno
-
faroutsider (Craig Farham)
-
Sabbather (Temo)
-
Progosopher (Robert Fox)
-
BORA
-
sylphida (Valentayn)
-
barp
-
GKR (Gustavo)
-
mwood (Marshall Wood)
-
deckard33 (Leullier)
-
sorcerer kermes (arvin)
-
Proglandish
-
teermin8r (Christopher Teer)
-
plam
-
Serg (Sergey)
-
fisuras
-
Kingsnake (Kingsnake)
-
Ackspice
-
mfinato (Marco Finato)
-
sergeyluk (sergey)
-
JAK
-
Antony (Antony)
-
Jeth (Vadim)
-
proghaven (Nicolas N. Sorokin)
-
Guran7004 (Lars-Göran Rosén)
-
Tull Tales (Bruce O)
-
Xonty (Tom Burgess)
-
Kogaion (Dragos MASALA)
-
SayYes
-
GaryD
-
Silenus (Tom)
-
thoughtships (Nick Lee)
-
Sina_81 (Sina HM)
-
Gongo
-
freewheeler (Sergei Komarov)
-
Gopo (Popescu Radu)
-
charles_ryder (Alexandr)
-
NoSonOfVine (Thomas)
-
proggrog80
-
plinius (Achille)
-
lightoftheworld (Francis)
-
improove
-
The Engineer
-
Matt-T (Matthew E Thomas)
-
delu
-
Ennio
-
Progear (Progear)
-
madcap68
-
Pieromcdo (Pierre McDonald)
-
pepecastello (jose castello)
-
zuzuwelsh (Bob Welsh)
-
atomemo (Marco)
-
Dima_Phoenix (Dmitrij)
-
occido
-
Edwin333 (Ed Lohrer)
-
rocknrolldoctor (Uwe Schwarz)
-
Mind_Drive (Constantin)
-
vasad70 (Vas András)
-
Leverkuehn (Peter Rempel)
-
kaktus63 (pavel m)
-
manga
-
postprog (U. Schwarz)
-
bessiegilsson (Bessi)
-
Liam Walrus (Waldemar Corner)
-
ed14 (ILDAR)
-
negipan (KH)
-
cunico (Wilson)
-
Watchmaker (George)
-
pelham (roberto poggetti)
-
fant0mas
-
dimonichlv
-
karolcia (Piotr Lachowicz)
-
jacobaeus (Alberto Nucci)
-
pink_prog80 (milos)
-
APartOfTheUniverse (Matthew)
-
puzart (Artur)
-
Phrank (Frank)
-
kostas0918
-
luminol (ivan)
-
hockeyhabs00 (perry)
-
Maggese (Kürşat)
-
freewheeleer1962 (Sergei Komarov)
-
HarryAngel746 (Maciej) COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
-
JHAP
-
daland75 (Brian King)
-
Q_ukko (Tuukka Jussila)
-
Fischman (John Fisch)
-
crimsogenes
-
gershnev (Jere)
-
Trinity S (Mark)
-
Soul2Create (David Romera)
-
Kalacho (Carlos Mendoza)
-
Man from Mandrake (Karel Boggens)
-
dyyigor1958 (Igor)
-
mhernand3 (Martin Hernandez Valdez)
-
AdolfoC1971 (Adolfo Camargo)
-
marus (Alexey)
-
Tipper112 (Sam)
-
SkynyrdLynyrd175 (Ivan Zemlyakov)
-
Psychedelic Paul (Paul)
-
lemarquisat (Arda Kaynak)
-
Fernandi (Fernandi Gunawan)
-
popolvuh (Ari)
-
Kaplan (Stéphane Laquerrière)
-
lexus (Serg)
-
ekang otse (p.S.)
-
justaguy
-
jordiyes
-
Snafje
-
Philchem8 (Phil C)
-
zeb1981 (Tom-Erik Løe)
-
TinoPP (Martin Lačný)
-
g.bostock (Chris)
-
LevySpearmen (Brian)
-
mejuta (Jukka Tarvonen)
-
Dr. Whatnick (Vano Mouradeli)
-
Criswell (Jerry Payonk)
-
edinho (Eduardo)
-
Art for Rock (Alexandr)
-
PintosMob (Olek)
-
progresssaurus (Jara)
-
Andy B Hardy (Andy Hardy)
-
dion
Post a review of IAN ANDERSON The Secret Language of Birds
You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.
MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).