Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Magma - 1001° Centigrades [Aka: 2] CD (album) cover

1001° CENTIGRADES [AKA: 2]

Magma

Zeuhl


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
Sean Trane
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Prog Folk
4 stars I've known this one with a different and much better cover but I think it was an italian edition. A classic Magma ,where Vander confirms that the previous albums were no accident. On some editions of this album comes some quite deep and somber poetry first written in french and tranlatted to their invented Kobaian language. One of my best buddies actually studied it and wrote them a letter in Kobaian and got an answer again in Kobaian, so this is no joke.

As for the music on here it is just as great as Mekanik or Kohntarkosz having this unique blend of influences of Stravinsky, John Coltrane for the music and Carl Orff for the vocals that come mainly as choirs. Very impressive..... MAGMA alone invented a style of music that will be called Zheul music.

Report this review (#22300)
Posted Tuesday, February 3, 2004 | Review Permalink
lor68
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars A classic one by this famous French experimental progressive music,when such " Zeuhl Music" did not completely take its shape!!

Well despite of such Zeuhl Music being often difficult to assimilate, this work was their first step ahead and their music was quite accessible to the lovers of normal experimental fusion progressive... afterwards, thanks to their contribution to the complex and very dissonant Zeuhl School. They became more difficult to take and their dissonant parts were too much "brainstoming" to take them easily. Anyway albums such as the following "Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh" or "Udu Wudu" represent an important reference still today, for bands such as UNIVERS ZERO, ART ZOYD and so on.

Recommended!!

Report this review (#22301)
Posted Saturday, April 3, 2004 | Review Permalink
5 stars What an inferior cover pictured here compared to the beautiful colourful original of the vinyl issue. But now to the music: First a fierce bass-line accompanied by Vander's drumming kicks in, then making it's musical appearance is the electric piano, then the woodwinds and finally Blasquiz' fascinating and almost unbelievable vocal work in a foreign self-invented language, and by then "Rïah Sahïltaahk" is blasting through the speakers in all it's musical splendour, very energetic and extremely well-played epic piece of music, it never bores me, it's constantly evolving throughout the 21 minutes, full of constant changes in rhythm and melody, but succeeds in never actually losing it cohesiveness, there are even plenty of occasionally catchy jazz-like textures. I see "Rïah Sahïltaahk" as a very well accomplished bridge between the first more "jazzy" LP, and their future signature Zeuhl sound, albeit "Rïah Sahïltaahk" is more closer to the sound of their first LP. The second side is consisting of two compositions not composed by Vander, they are much closer in spirit to what you hear on Magma's first LP. All though not quite the absolute splendour and mesmerizing energy of "Rïah Sahïltaahk", Lasry's "Iss" Lanseï Doïa" and Cahen's "Ki ïahl ö lïahk" are nothing short of brilliant, very solid jazzy compositions. Overall I rate this splendid record approximately about 4.75 stars.
Report this review (#46034)
Posted Thursday, September 8, 2005 | Review Permalink
Progbear
PROG REVIEWER
3 stars An awkward transitional LP. "Rïah Sahïltaahk" is probably the great Magma "epic", a feature-length composition that builds estimably on the concepts first delved into on the debut Magma double-platter. As before, the vocal attack of Blasquiz and Vander can be hard to swallow if you're used to "easier" music, but their vocals are also perfectly in tune with the tone of the music. Which, as before, is darker than dark. One can only expect such from a conceptual oratorio about the End of the Earth.

What keeps me from listing this album among the Magma greats is the B-side. Here, we find rather more conventional jazz-oriented compositions; well-played but somewhat lacking in inspiration. They weren't composed by Vander and don't fit in with his conceptual vision of Magma in any way, shape or form. Later, the band would acquire members who could compose music that did (notably, irreplaceable bassist Jannick Top), but this is something of an early aberration. After this album, Seffer and Cahen would form the slightly Magma-esque Zao, while Moze defected to Gong.

This is really one of the less essential of the "classic" Magma albums. Not bad, but not something to run out and buy either. Wait until you have some of their other albums first.

Report this review (#46575)
Posted Wednesday, September 14, 2005 | Review Permalink
5 stars The second work "1001℃ entigrades" released in 1971. It is music that develops the first work further. Style that performs enchantment, dashes about angry waves, and repeats eerie stagnation extremely. It is a work that multiuses the melody of the orient style again. The wind instrument section was strengthened by Jeff SEFFER of the new joining though the guitarist seceded. The latter half of the album is electric jazz-rock that approaches SOFT MACHINE. The advancement power of the drum and music for wind instruments is overwhelming. The sound of bass is near the following Jannick TOP and Bernard PAGANOTTI peculiar.

This album is not a poor work at all. I recommend it with confidence in the MAGMA fan who has not listened to this album. 「Riah Sahiltaahk」 is one of the masterpiece of MAGMA.

Report this review (#80345)
Posted Monday, June 5, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars Despite the atrociously boring cover (some issues of the vinyl version came with a much more colourful cover at the insistence of the record company), "1001° Centigrades" is an excellent album. This was the album where Magma had to show that they hadn't just blown it all off on the debut. And they sure hadn't!

The opening track, "Rïah Sahïltaahk" composed by Christian Vander himself, shows by itself just how much Magma have grown since the first album, even though there is only one year between the two. The sound of this epic is generally much closer to later-day Zeuhl - all of the elements from the first album are still there: driving basslines, ever-changing rhythms, jazzy woodwind arrangements and of course, the crazy vocals, but the crucial difference is that the melodies seem more refined, due to Vander drawing from his classical inspirations as well this time. It's still not "real" Zeuhl, but "Rïah Sahïltaahk" sounds like a logical prologue of MDK.

Teddy Lasry's "'Iss' Lanseï Doïa" is more in the vein of the first album, but also a highly experimental venture. A deep bassline (backed up by a Fender Rhodes) kicks off this piece while the brass section signals the arrival of the Kobaïan cavalry (there's really no other way of describing this!) and Blasquiz moans something in the invented language. The rest of the track is a tour-de-force of Zeuhl-Blues (believe it or not), atonal and yet melodic brass interludes and eerie deep vocals by Blasquiz. A compelling Kobaïan nightmare and one of my own absolute favourites.

The last track, "Kï Ïahl Ö Lïahk" composed by François Cahen (who left to form Zao shortly after), wraps it all up and concludes the story. Compared to the two other tracks, this is probably the lesser one, but it is by no means bad. There are some very nice motifs to be found in this Cahen-composition - oppressive marches, complete with Kobaïan shouting, as well as brief up-tempo jazz melodies that relieve the tension. The song generally sticks closer to "Rïah Sahïltaahk" and also reprises the lead-off track in it's final minutes.

All in all, "1001° Centigrades" is Magma's first real masterpiece. A much more mature and well-balanced album than "Magma" and also the one where the Zeuhl-genre got its real baptism.

Report this review (#95309)
Posted Saturday, October 21, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars Every (three) song in this album is a masterpiece. Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk is maybe a little monotonic (can it be?) and too short track, and Iss' Lanseï Doïa is maybe little bit boring at the start, maybe even four-star song, but eventually there''s nothing else to say about this great Zeuhl, it is so good, and it is what makes Zeuhl so precious. Rïah Sahïltaahk is just orgasmic and best songs on the Earth or Zeuhl-world ;) ! This is in my top 10 list of prog.
Report this review (#109208)
Posted Sunday, January 28, 2007 | Review Permalink
laplace
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars About half a year ago, I wrote a three star review of this album, which just goes to show a) how much of an idiot I am, and b) how long it takes to come to appreciate these formative Zeuhl albums; I've long considered myself a confirmed Magma fan and yet only recently have I come to terms with their pre-M.D.K. vision.

"Rïah Sahïltaahk", the opening story here - and a track I had previously described only as "proto-Zeuhl" - has all the central Kobaian elements and musically conveys the loose plot of a chapter from an epic space opera, skipping past your likely rudimentary grasp of the celestial language and manifesting directly in your creative centres, and in a more melodic sense, is a voyage from upbeat beginnings akin to brass-rock through incidental filmic moments, the required electric piano motifs and mournful prayers of an uprooted galactic community, descending into volatile, jazzified marching dirges replete with shrieking Vanderisms, spluttering trumpet stab-rows and the grim determination of Master Blasquiz - there is an amazing amount of viciousness throughout "1001 Centigrades" and here is the first knockout dose. In my first draft I mourned that this song came before the arrival of Jannick Top but in truth, the Zeuhl bassoblueprint is equally strong here and in some places, the grooves make so much sense, so much cosmic correctness that it makes me think that the Magma bass chair is sentient in and of itself, and each player to don the Kobaian garb channels its wisdom.

Side B is actually JUST AS ESSENTIAL - something I wish I had realized initially. If "Rïah Sahïltaahk" was momentarily vicious then "Iss Lanseï Doïa" is full-on psychotic, and squalls throughout. "Ki Ïahl ö Lïahk" starts with a Kobaian hymn, moogs out and then resolves towards brilliantly grooving jazz-funk-space-rock. I can admit that the chord progressions here are a mite too relaxing, but this would make the most ridiculous elevator muzak possible, space elevators excepted. Shades of Coltrane, Davis AND Hancock all in the same song? Buy.

I can't be sure whether my adjustment to this album came thanks to Stockholm syndrome, brainwashing or a legitimate fruition in understanding, and I hope it's not just the result of my desperation to justify a purchase, since I have plenty of derision for the Genesis and Rush die-hards who brave cognitive dissonance to do the same. All I can remember is that it wasn't easy. What I'm trying to say is this: if, like me, you're none too fond of jazz qua jazz, don't start here - it's "Mekanik Destructiw Kommandoh" you need. Then, if you received it favourably, come back and dare to grok this much wilder album.

Report this review (#109774)
Posted Tuesday, January 30, 2007 | Review Permalink
4 stars Birth of a musical type: Zheul music

" Rïah Sahïltaahk ", piece of 20 minutes written, composed and arranged by Christian Vander constitutes the birth of a true musical style in full measure. Very different from symphonic rock, school of Canterbury or Italian prog, Zheul music has been founded first and foremost on rhythm. The melody and harmony are not away but they always remain second behind this tremendous heartbeat.

Zheul don't express feelings but energy. The incredible energy of life.This music is made for the body more than for mind.

The two other pieces, not composed by Vander, are very good but less original. They return in a jazz mood, music the zheul found his source (the druming of elvin jones, the universal spirituality of Coltrane).

A disc of transition. Very accessible (more than MDK for a debut) and very recommended to every people who want to discover a new ground in music.

Report this review (#140128)
Posted Sunday, September 23, 2007 | Review Permalink
Mellotron Storm
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars As much as I enjoyed their debut I think this one's better. Claude Engel's leaving is the most significant lineup change for this record, although the guitarist would return for their next one under the band name UNIVERIA ZEKT. Perhaps Jeff Seffer's arrival is even more significant, what a talent ! Ted Lasry stays but the other two horn players left allowing Seffer and Louis Toesca to join. Their style has changed from their debut. And it's the vocals that are the most significant change and they clearly are Zeuhl now. This is heard on the first and third tracks here.That vocal Zeuhl style would come on even stronger on "MDK". So I think it would be fair to call this album MAGMA's first real Zeuhl record. The next one under the name UNIVERIA ZEKT is a little different for the first half of the album, but the second half returns to the MAGMA sound of the first two records. Interesting that on the back of this album it says "Magma 2", and then near the bottom, under the song titles and band members' list it says "Univeria Zekt".

"Riah Sahiltaahk" is a side long suite composed by Vander. Vocals, bass, percussion, sax? and drums start us off with piano joining the melody 2 minutes in. This is a great uptempo section. The song changes before 3 minutes as it slows right down and then theatrical vocals arrive. A sax melody 5 minutes in with fast paced vocals reminds me of Zappa for some reason. The drumming is prominant 6 minutes in and a great section follows a minute later as the tempo picks up the pace. The song slows down briefly with theatrical vocals and the speeds up again as we are cooking now. The tempo shifts often and themes keep returning. Some screaming sax after 11 minutes as flute,vocal melodies, a great horn section, and then heavy drums follow as the song continues to change so quickly and often. Drums, vocals, horns and throbbing bass dominate to almost the end of the song before it ends with gentle piano. The trip is over and I can breathe now.

"Iss Lansei Doia" is a Teddy Lasry composition. These last two songs are more Jazz influenced and less experimental than the first track. This one opens with a nice sound of vocal melodies, bass, percussion and horns. Some dissonant horns 3 minutes in as drums and bass continue. A good pastoral sound follows. The electric piano and bass is to die for people ! Check out the sound 6 minutes in ! Strange vocals come and go. There is an amazing 4 minutes of music until the song calms down 10 minutes in with piano and vocals. The clock is ticking to end it. Time is up. "Ki Iahl O Liahk" is a Cahen composition and my favourite. I can't wait to review ZAO, a band Cahen and Seffer started after the UNIVERIA ZEKT album. This song flows so well, and it's just a cool tune. Bass, horns, cymbals to open with piano then vocals joining in this relaxing soundscape. The song speeds up briefly 4 minutes in with liquid sounding keys coming in right after this as drums pound away.The horns are fantastic with piano, drums and bass filling out the melody. It's almost haunting and experimental before 12 minutes then the electric piano, a beat and sax come in tastefully joined by vocals as it builds. Amazing stuff !

A top three MAGMA album for me. And don't let the ("duct tape" grey) cover put you off, it's what's inside that counts.

Report this review (#140238)
Posted Sunday, September 23, 2007 | Review Permalink
5 stars I wasn't sure if anyone had done symphonic jazz before. I also wondered if Math Jazz had ever been done. Here, Magma has done both, and done it extremely well. Each song captures the rising and falling tumult of an epic with the complex detail and sound of math jazz, creating a very unique and exquisite sound. This album was only four bucks on iTunes, but it gives more satisfaction than any album I bought for more than twice that. No reason not to get this album.
Report this review (#151399)
Posted Saturday, November 17, 2007 | Review Permalink
4 stars Halfway between avant-jazz and Zeuhl, we find 1001° Centigrades. Very much like its predecessor, Kobaïa, it moves with slick rapidity, weaving through complex compositions, wild arrangements, and stark splashes of beauty. Comprised of three monster tracks: all outstanding, but none standing out, this second attempt at Zeuhl lands much, much closer to the mark, but pales in comparison to the bullseye which is Mekanïk Destruktïw Kommandöh. The Zeuhl hallmarks begin to appear, though are still overpowered by the Jazz and Avant-Garde leanings (the former much more than the latter this time). Again, the concept or story is not a silly murder mystery, nor an irrelevant ode or complaint, like too many concept albums are, but instead is a relevant and complex tale emphasizing mankind's need to progress, and highlighting our faults.

The story of this release directly continues that of the previous release. Our Kobaïan protagonists were just leaving with the newly acquainted Earthlings back for the ancient realm of their forefathers. The Earthlings had asked them to return to Earth with them to share their wisdom, teach their methods, and, in a certain sense, preach their way of life. As it now stands, Earth had fallen to depths never before reached, and Kobaïa's population was infinitely advanced to Earth's: on political, social, spiritual, and technological grounds. The story of this chapter begins with the trip to Earth, and the bright welcome they are met with. The Kobaïans tell the tale of their ancestors' leave-taking, explain the progress they've made since, share their philosophies on the betterment of mankind, and how purity and spiritual enlightenment are the best, if not the only, means to growth, peace, and a perfect civilization.

At first, it sounds as if the Earthlings are sincerely considering these words, but within moments of sharing their speech with the world during a meeting with government, or some other form of high-ranking authority, they are arrested, imprisoned, and their spacecraft is immediately apprehended. Our protagonists, now prisoners, somehow manage to communicate with the Kobaïans back home, who quickly organize a retrieval effort. Now, at a civil meeting between the Earthling and Kobaïan authorities, the Kobaïa demand their kinsmen be released, or if not, the Kobaïans will unleash their ultimate weapon and destroy them. The details of this ultimate weapon are unclear. We don't know if it's some sort of Death Star, or another really advanced arm that will destroy the planet or wipe out its inhabitants, or something simpler and harder to conceptualize as a weapon.

At any rate, the Earthlings buy this story of an Ultimate Weapon, and release the Kobaïans immediately. The only condition the Earthlings demanded was that their entire people vow to never return to Earth. Thus ends this tale, but where it ends, another begins. The trilogy of Theusz Hamtaahk, which will be released in reverse chronological order (the first installment being never released apart from live recordings) pick up the threads this story ended with. The next release, Mekanïk Destruktïw Kommandöh, is the last installment in this trilogy, yet was recorded and released first.

Many people feel that concepts are irrelevant if the music doesn't support them. Who cares if the worst band in the world's new album has the best story ever: it's the worst band in the world! Rest assured that every moment of music here (and, truly every second of music ever released by Magma - apart from Merci) is brilliant. Unlike Kobaïa, which was mainly an Avant-Jazz, this one is more of a Jazz/Zeuhl hybrid, with the avant-garde patches toned down. Horns still playing a very important role, along with a slightly more prominent bass, and a larger reliance on keys, this release is a step above (or perhaps just a step away) from the last. Drumming is still top-notch from Vander, as is all playing from all musicians.

1001° Centigrades is an addictive, rhythmically strong, jazzy release. The sound quality is very good for its time, the production and packaging is brilliant (the booklet and its contents look great), and the music is probably a bit more accessible (especially to Jazz fans) than the preceding and proceeding releases. Know, however, that accessibility does not equal music prowess.

Report this review (#152870)
Posted Monday, November 26, 2007 | Review Permalink
obiter
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars A rip roaring expedition into the eclectic world of zeuhl.

Not as approachable but more challenging than Hhai/Live, 1001 is definitely a love it or hate album.

Riah Sahïltaahk is characteristic of the album as a whole. There are passages of weirdness interspersed with smooth jazz interludes. During the jazzy bits, the listening becomes a lot easier. And yet, there is no doubt that having listened again and again to the album it is the weirdness that grabs you: it's that original strangeness that offers more.

Iss has a trippy groovy bass intro that would not be out of place as a backing track to some of the darker corners of the internet. Dripping with groove and a salacious undertone. It enters a land of trippy weirdness before finding an altogether more spaced out jazz feel.

Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk has a very jazzy feel. At times it almost sounds mainstream late 60s/early 70s.

Maybe it's still a bit rough round the edges still, the ideas are there, but this is not the finished article. wait for MDK and Live.

The complex arrangements and accomplished musicianship are obvious. The bizarre vision is also slowly crystallizing.

It's a good album, certainly a decent addition to a prog music collection. Between 3 and 4 for me: on balance a 4. I'd recommend MDK or Hhai/Live for the non-initiated.

Report this review (#162277)
Posted Wednesday, February 20, 2008 | Review Permalink
4 stars 1001˚ Centigrades is Magma's second album. Whilst their first was a somewhat aimless double LP, with an air of rootlessness which saw the band wandering from one type of music to the next, not just over the double album as a whole, but even within the confines of each separate piece, this second effort begins to show a deal more backbone, a heap more discipline, a lot more coherence, and tantalisingly offers us a kind of "proto-Zeuhl", with a more confident, masterful tone. The first track ('Rïah Sahïltaahk', penned by Christian Vander) is really excellent - the pounding repetition, layers of dark texture, interlocking units of complex rhythm and passionately sincere Kobaïan vocals are a taste of Magma-to-be. No vaguely jazzy doodling here! It's got a marvellous sense of urgency and structure, instead of being all over the shop like some of the music on their début.

Track 2 ('"Iss" Lanseï Doïa', by Teddy Lasry) starts off with some eerie mumbling, percussion and gentle wind instruments which give off a slightly tribal aroma, but it soon takes on a more conventional, jazz-inflected mood, somewhat reminiscent of an outtake from Zappa's 'Hot Rats'. It's a good catchy piece with occasional bursts of atonal tootling to liven things up. Then some choral vocals chime in, reminding us that this is Magma after all! Some deep, squelchy-sounding spoken Kobaïan adds to the tense air. (Sounds a bit like as if Zappa had given Captain Beefheart the afternoon off and hauled in an Inuit shaman to add some vocals to 'Hot Rats'.) This is a piece in which the combination of straightforward jazz rock and extra-terrestrial otherness sits rather well together, integrating nicely, rather than grating or constantly flipping from one style to the next. The driving piano figures (soon matched by the wind/brass) and effervescent drumming again offer hints at Zeuhl-to-come. It ends with a 'tick-tock' rhythm as if some infernal countdown to doomsday has begun.

The third and final track ('Ki Ïahl Ö Ïlahk', by François Cahen) continues the theme of brisk, urgent, disciplined jazz with added Kobaïan flourishes - notably some impassioned screeches from Vander (doing his enraged Zeuhl prophet voice!) and Klaus Blasquiz's sonorous invocations of the phrase 'Wurdah Itah'. Then after a few surprising swirly, phasey, psych-style effects (do you get the feeling the producer was a little nonplussed by Magma?! "Uh, they're weird, right? Okey-dokey, standard 'weird' sound effects coming right up."), it degenerates into what I can only describe as 'If Magma was a lounge band' - with some out-of-place cheery keyboard tinkling and jolly tunefulness all round! That's probably the weirdest thing on the whole album! Eventually, it just fades away as if 'lounge band Magma' have boarded the nearest spacecraft and are drifting off into the night, earning their passage by entertaining the first class passengers.

Overall, I think this album is perfect proof of why the early formations of Magma had to be superseded. Here and there are fleeting glimpses of the magisterial might of fully-fledged Zeuhl (which would get its triumphant coming-out party courtesy of 'MDK'), but ultimately, such idiosyncratic music was bound to want to struggle free of the rather more polite (although very well executed) jazz excursions on the album. Yes, it works much better and is far tighter and more ordered than the endearing muddle of Magma's first album, but set it in its timeline alongside later gems. well, I think this is a four star deal we have here! Great stuff, but even better yet to come!

Report this review (#165961)
Posted Monday, April 7, 2008 | Review Permalink
UMUR
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars 1001° Centigrades is the second studio album from French avant garde rock/ zeuhl band Magma. I was very impressed by Magma´s debut album which I found to be an excellent album and an eye opener as I hadn´t listened to music like that before. 1001° Centigrades continues the style which was initiated on the debut.

The music is dominated by lots of brass arrangements and there are lots of influences from both avant garde rock and jazz. The jazz influences are really great and never sounds like regular jazz which is such a relief for someone like me who´s generally not very fond of jazz. The semi-operatic vocal style is an aquired taste for sure and I have to be in a certain mood to enjoy it. The song structures are really complex and with song lengths that are 21:45, 11:46 and 8:23 minutes respectively ( there are only three tracks on the album)this qualifies for a very challenging listen.

Rïah Sahïltaahk which is dominated by the weird vocals is the hardest song to get into IMO but it definitely wins on repeated listens. Iss Lanseï Doïa is pretty avant garde and reminds me a bit of Henry Cow at their most out there. My favorite here is Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk. It´s certainly the easiest song to get into IMO.

The musicianship is outstanding. Christian Vander´s drums are innovative and challenging and is the driving force in Magma´s music but as I said above the brass section is very dominant. There are actually three brass players on the album. There are also some really great bass and piano playing.

The production is excellent. Great organic mix.

I prefer the debut to 1001° Centigrades and it´s probably because I still have a hard time with the weird vocals which are much more dominant on 1001° Centigrades compared to the debut. This is still an excellent album though. Magma has a very unique musical approach and 1001° Centigrades fully deserves 4 stars even though I think it´s a hard album to get into. I can feel it growing on me though.

Report this review (#185603)
Posted Tuesday, October 14, 2008 | Review Permalink
Dobermensch
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars Magma were bonkers weren't they? They always sounded so confident in what they did. Unfazed by critics and doing exactly what they wanted to do. Who else would have had the bottle to release a double LP as their first record? They even had the cheek to release a single from it too - 'Kobaïï' - which unsurprisingly sank without trace. This one's a bit wilder sounding than the more popular 'MDK' and 'Könterkösz' which are darker and more brooding in sound. 1001˚ is big, boisterous and in your face. The last track 'Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk' has a great little catchy tune towards the end, and is basically the only part you can whistle to yourself after the album is finished. This album from 1971 and its predecessor are considerably 'jazzier' than what was to follow. Both are real growers after a couple of listens. 1001˚ certainly won't be everyone's cup of tea though. It's true what they say about Magma - there's no grey area - you either love 'em or hate 'em.
Report this review (#215332)
Posted Wednesday, May 13, 2009 | Review Permalink
Ivan_Melgar_M
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Before I proceed to review "1001º Centigrades" need to be honest and say that I evaded Zeuhl until this point of my life mainly because I consider he use of Kobaian as absurd as Klingon Opera or Elvish music, and one of the reasons why people catalogues Prog as unreal and excessively fantastic, but still worth to give a try.

Before I got this album, started to investigate what exactly Zeuhl is (Before my research Zeuhl was only a hollow term), and the idea of blending Neo Classical, Jazz Fusion, Symphonic and even tribal elements sounded interesting, so bought a couple albums and likes what I heard.

So where better to start my adventure in Zeuhl than with MAGMA

"Rïah Sahïltaahk" is a 21 minutes epic that I enjoyed from start to end, and summarizes what I read about the genre, the rack begins with a Funk - Jazz intro and the peculiar vocals of Christian Vander (Not my cup of tea, a bit self indulgent IMHO), the wind instruments by Teddy Lasry and Jeff Seffer are simply delightful while the harsh and almost tribal chants of Vander blend perfectly.

What impressed me more about MAGMA is the speed in which they move from one sound, mood or atmosphere to another radically different, in some points I believe they sacrifice coherence for spectacularly, but the result is delightful and intriguing, forcing me to listen more.

The piano performances by "François Cahen" deserve special mention, because the radical changes from almost violent Operatic sections he jumps to fluid jazz in the vein of MAHAVISHNU. By the way, the frenetic finale is simply fantastic. Still the Kobaian language is hard to assimilate, but the music is outstanding.

"Iss Lanseï Doïa" is simply one of the weirdest musical experiences I had in my life, after an experimental intro of incoherent sounds comes an extremely coherent Fusion passage, and despite the obvious dissonances, they never loose the sense of melody and musicality. But this is only the beginning, the real weird stuff comes after that, chant sections, experimental stuff, hallucinating vocals, frenetic music, interrupted by coherent Jazzy sections, almost impossible to assimilate by a newbie.....Despite this fact, I loved it, the mystery and pomp is fantastic.

"Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk" is the shortest track and my favorite, the bass , winds intro that lead to an absolutely dissonant passage where the piano enters as in Avant garde and then sections of fantastic melody and contradictory changes, but overall the amazing chants and the fluid fusion sections, all blended in a coherent mixture, is something you love or hate from the first listen...I like it

Before I finish this review I want to apologize if the review sounds amateurish, but this is my first experience with Zeuhl, even when I'm sure not the last, the only thing I can say in my defense is that is really honest, being that I am basing my opinion in what I hear and for that reason judging MAGMA exclusively for their merits

Now, if I try a weird genre for the first time and like it, I believe here must be something, if you add the versatility and skills of the musicians you are before a great album that deserves no less than 4 stars.

Report this review (#223101)
Posted Thursday, June 25, 2009 | Review Permalink
Gooner
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars Carl Orff forms a rock band and runs into a humourless Frank Zappa? Next door, they hear Ian Carr's Nucleus playing electric modal jazz. Across the hall from Ian Carr's Nucleus is Osibisa. Both Carl & Frank invite the groups over and they record Magma's 1.001 Centigrades. That's about it. Of note, however, is the Zeuhl sound fully realized on the opener _Riah Sahiltaahk_ which they develop to the fullest on subsequent albums. Still a little too jazzy for most prog.rock listeners and not rock enough for fusion fans. The bass guitar is much higher in the mix than on the previous debut. Still not a great place to start for the Zeuhl sound. A solid 4 stars. The best Magma album from their early period(first 3).
Report this review (#225702)
Posted Friday, July 10, 2009 | Review Permalink
Sinusoid
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars Kind of a wonder of the prog rock world. I still wonder what genre this encompasses other than Zeuhl, and it's probably better just to leave it at Zeuhl.

Those unfamiliar to Magma might be very turned away from their works unless they have open minds or of the adventurous sort. Think meaty fusion type compositions with brass and opera backdrops all done in pretentious, fixated language system. Many a prog fan might get a fancy tickled in them because of how 1001 CENTIGRADES is set up; very CLOSE TO THE EDGE style with the massive epic kicking it off followed by two shorter pieces and that's it. But, I can't stress enough, APPROACH AT YOUR OWN RISK!!! This album/group might be something that you just won't like.

Let's take the monster ''Riah Sahiltaahk''; there are so many themes going on that it's just crazy. It seems that every one to two minutes, the theme has to all of a sudden change into something different. Any typical progster will enjoy the constant inflow/outflow of themes, but it happens too often for me to really enjoy it. The piece contains several different dynamic levels, multiple odd metres and prominent clarinet/bass clarinet in the first half in style that I've already described.

The two things on the second side have more focus to them; both take themes and lay them out for a few minutes at a time while constantly expanding them. The only low point of the second half is the very bland fusion at the end of ''Ki Iahl O Liahk''. The vocals here are sparse as opposed to ''Riah Sahiltaahk'', and the sparseness helps the enjoyability factor. The electric pianos here are absolutely mesmerising and layered over fantastic bass grooves by Francis Moze (not surprising considering what he'd do for Gong on FLYING TEAPOT).

If the name Magma ever strikes an interest, try this album first as it has things that many typical progsters and fusion-ites will enjoy. Be mindful of the vocals as they are an acquired taste and the general bizarreness of everything presented. I made my Magma start here and I am very proud of doing so.

Report this review (#229284)
Posted Friday, July 31, 2009 | Review Permalink
5 stars 1001 Centigrades was my first exposure to Magma, and it actually remains my favorite. This captures them in their early stages, and has a lot of jazzy elements still very prominent. To me, this has the most memorable moments of the 5 or so albums I'm familiar with. It's the kind of album that after 3 or 4 listens, you can recall a ton of the changes before they happen. All the riffs and rhythms are very intentional, and thus, easily memorable. Of course, it's not nearly as dark and strange as their later material, but that may be why I still like it so much--it fits a variety of moods. It's very hard to describe if you've never heard it before: imagine strong riff- based music, without guitars, and a very believable mixture of jazz and modern classical music. I recommend this, especially if it's your first exposure to zheul, or if you haven't liked the bit of zheul you have heard.
Report this review (#230814)
Posted Monday, August 10, 2009 | Review Permalink
3 stars My travels in Magma land continues with this, their second album.

This album, a socalled Zeuhl album, is basically a jazz album with some added neo- classical, chanting and tribal rhythms. The first song is a twenty minutes long epic called Rïah Sahïltaahk which winds itself through some good jazz passages with some added tribal rhythms and chanting. "Iss" Lanseï Doïa is the second song and jazz pretty much influenced by neo-classical music. The chants are still there. The third track called Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk is a much more pastoral song than the two other songs. Listen well and you pick up some Genesis vibes from it. The same can be said about Soft Machine vibes although they are far more evident here.

The quality is good throughout. For me, Magma is bordering to being too weird for my tastes and I guess it will take me many years to get through their albums and to develop an appreciation for Zeuhl. But this album is one of the more accessible Zeuhl and Magma albums out there and I pretty much likes it. But there is no really good tracks on this album and I having problems with the genre in general so it is only a three star album in my view.

3 stars

Report this review (#265852)
Posted Saturday, February 13, 2010 | Review Permalink
Bonnek
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
3 stars The second Magma is a lot stronger then I anticipated after being slightly disappointed with the debut. It's still very much rooted in jazz-rock, but over the course of the album it gradually develops into a full blown Zeuhl attack, featuring heavy war-like rhythms, unconventional vocals and crazed theatricals.

The first piece is the most traditionally jazzy, mainly due to the jazz drumming, the keyboard chords and extensive horn section. The singing is very unusual though and originally it made me think of recitative parts from operas. Now I'd rather say it sits somewhere between jazzy, operatic and avant-garde. While I'm usually very fond of Magma's non-conventional approach to vocals, they do not entirely satisfy me here. Also the music is not Magma's best yet, it's swinging, original and adventurous but it doesn't convince me as much as the following two tracks on the album. It seems to lack the coherence, power and purpose of later Magma works.

Also Iss is a dominantly jazzy piece, but this time with a dreamy lounge atmosphere. The mood is occasionally broken by a threatening section with low rough vocals, sounding as if Captain Beefheart poked his nose into the recordings. The second half of the track is dominated by a repeated loop on piano, a typical Zeuhl feature that Magma has further explored ever since: the art of making a repetitive phrase into an entrancing one. I think Iss is one of Magma's best studio pieces, certainly when looking at their first few years.

The closing Ki adds a few more Zeuhl elements, especially the solemn main theme and the more warlike rock drumming brings it closer to the sound Magma achieved on MDK and Köntarkösz. But the jazz presence is still very strong as well, after the threatening and cacophonous bits in the opening section, the track mainly operates in soft dreamy jazz textures.

Based on the excellent second side of the album, 3 stars feel rather short. But this is Magma and I need to establish some margin to be able to distinguish between the many masterpieces they would continue to create. Had this been from any other band I would certainly have given 4.

Report this review (#273081)
Posted Saturday, March 20, 2010 | Review Permalink
4 stars First step was creating of the Kobaïn language. Second step in Zeuhl evolution was this. Already acquired strong jazz and classical influences, 1001° Centigrades features more conventional for Zeuhl and less conventional in general vocals ('tribal' chanting). This is where Zeuhl began. The cover claims to be one the most boring covers ever, but I don't think the alternative one would fit either. If jazz and avant-garde are your territory, then 1001° Centigrades is a warm welcome to Zeuhl rather than shock (as it was with qualitatively new musical concept of MDK). Side one is Vander's Rïah Sahïltaahk, featured far more complex time signatures than the debut ever had, a lot of completely different non-repeating parts varying from rhythmic jazz in 'tribal' form (that reminds of UduWudu's self-titled track) through almost catchy melodies to debut-like insanity. The result gives an idea of Math-Symphonic-Jazz-Avant-Garde Zeuhl. Rïah Sahïltaahk is one of the Magma's 'epic' brilliants and gets 5/5 (it's a masterpiece itself plus 0.5 for being a huge step in Zeuhl evolution), although ... somewhat rough 'brilliant' though. It does seem very noncohesive due to the huge amount of radical changes, but since you've listened to it more than 4 times, you discover all the brilliancy in its fickleness and true complexity. Also, the impression of Side A being noncohesive and chaotic depends solely on the fact that there're no repeated parts at all(!), which feels somewhat confusing if you remember the famous Magma's repetitions, intriguing and never boring. Still, the music consisting of constant changes here is simply terrific and full of genius. Vander knows how to put 'soul' in ultimate experimentation and Side A proves it. Now, for side B, featured two non-Vander's pieces. Given all the reviews, currently side A is underrated and Side B is sligthly overrated. I think there's an analog in symphonic rock world, first half of Tarkus was brilliant, the other half was good, just not that good. Happily enough, the difference between 1001° Centigrades' parts is far less considerable, but the 'problem' is these tracks being slightly more conventional jazz compositions, although they do have outstanding and completely unexpected subtle avant-garde moments and Zeuhl elements still go far beyond the characteristic singing. They're less complex in terms of musical content, nevertheless Side B is an outstanding effort as well, and at the very least never gets below the level of non-Vander's compositions of the debut.

Now, let's face the fact that nearly every album in discography of Magma, a band of King Crimson's caliber (if not more)(even if not everyone knows it), Is Essential Masterpiece. Of course, 4.5 would be perfect rating for both first albums, just to point out the difference between MDK-and-Kohntarkosz and the rest. But somehow, if I had to choose, I'd prefer the debut to this, and the reason is extremely banal: 1001° Centigrades is easier to get into and less 'weird' and it's still not pure Zeuhl at the same time. I give 4.5 stars for both first albums really, but if there's no the needful option, then... personal taste. But this IS essential as long as you're into Zeuhl/Jazz/Avant-garde and 93% masterpiece. If it was another band, I'd give 5/5. Magma has its own independent standards. Honestly... if only there was that female chanting, I'd give up and go with 5.

Report this review (#278378)
Posted Sunday, April 18, 2010 | Review Permalink
friso
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Magma - 1001° Centigrades (1971)

Climbing in their discography, the second offering of Magma is 1001° Centigrades. First of all. This cd-cover (also shown here on PA) is inferior to the original vinyl cover, which was also used for my vinyl reissue. The burning lava path to the Magma logo with it's warm red colors stands out as perhaps Magma's best cover and fans of the band should try to find this original artwork.

The second Magma album is a recognizable follow-up for their innovative debut. The sound of the band became a bit more professional and precise, but the real difference is the great recording of 1001° Centigrades. This makes it less hard to get into the music. Another big difference from the debut is the fact this isn't a double lp, but a single one. Side one has one big Zeuhl epic, side two has two compositions with more jazz moments albeit very atmospheric jazz.

On 1001° Centigrades there are still no female choirs, but male (double) vocals. For those who aren't knowledgeable of the Magma-experience it is important to know this is the truly Progressive side of prog with innovation being the basis of the music. Magma plays dark music with diverse influences such as classical music, jazz-rock, minimal music, war rhythms and avant-garde. The emphasis is on the rhythmic department led by founder and main composer Christian Vander. The brass section plays the intelligent rhythmical melodies that often have a dark impact. There are few recognizable emotions in Magma music, therefore it has been called Zeuhl or celestial music. The vocals are sung in an own language.

The storyline continues on 1001° Centigrades. The Kobaians are asked to teach about their magnificent culture on earth. This becomes a problem for the local authorities on earth and it is decided the Kobaians are imprisoned. The great planet of Kobaia reacts by threatening the Earthlings with Kobaia's main weapon (which I think feels very hot). Enough storyline to make dark music.

It is apparent to me this record is far better digestible if one first listens to side two and then ends with the big epic on side one. Emotionally this sound way more logical though I know this disrupts the continuation of the storyline.

Conclusion. This record might not be as innovative as the debut, but I think the quality is high throughout the record and there are no forgettable moments. The recording is very good, the compositions are great, the band amazing. I will give it four stars for now, but I just might change it to five stars someday. I really like this record and I think it's essential for fans of Magma and proggies interested in Zeuhl, psychedelic, jazz-rock and the heavy side of eclectic prog.

* Eddited *

I have listened to this album some more and it turned out to be a perfect masterpiece that fully deserves the five star rating. The technical aspect combined with it's un-earthly atmospheres and out-of-the-box thinking is unique. The sound of the album has a special transitional sound, coming from the male-vocals debut - going to the choirs of MDK. The jazzy aspect of side two is very strong: they made the best jazz I know of!

Report this review (#280691)
Posted Thursday, May 6, 2010 | Review Permalink
Flucktrot
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars For 1001, it appears that planet Kobaia has received some visitors!

For the opening track, the 22-minute Riah, it sounds as if perhaps the band Chicago has come to join the sessions...but without their guitarist...and with a clarinet and bass clarinet...and probably on acid...OK, it's probably not Chicago, but the horns really are quite reminiscent of Chicago, even if the vocals and rapid time changes are not. Overall, this track really does not hang together well for me. It opens well, with some nice energy and uniquely Magma vibe, but the middle sections are so hit and miss that I lose interest. Fortunately, there are some classic Magma moments toward the end, with a couple good freakouts--most notably the final syncopated crescendo with some nice monkey-like vocals just to remind you that you are indeed listening to Magma, and not Barry Manilow, for example. You know, because sometimes I get the two confused.

For the B side, it sounds as if perhaps Area, and maybe the ghost of Fusion Zappa, has stopped in for some dinner on Kobaia, with some very nice jazzy chords (cleverly revisiting some themes in the opener along the way) and horn work. These final two tracks are better pieces, both in terms of hanging together as well as being more enjoyable. They certainly are more musical, and they spend just a bit more time to explore these ideas than elsewhere.

Great arrangements, mostly interesting melodies, lots of controlled experimentation and plenty of Magma weirdness, but not so much that it distracts from the music (i.e., half an album's worth of Vander screeching). Although I'm a long way from being a fan of their first album, I'm on board with their second release.

Report this review (#285580)
Posted Tuesday, June 8, 2010 | Review Permalink
4 stars Magma, after the big debut still maintaining the level of your music with their sound influenced by KC, delving into jazz. The album mentioned is more a question of keeping or not the five stars (which does not dare to do). Besides a unique style, the fact of abusing woodwinds less common in progressive music is what attracted our attention beyond the heavy pianos, voices and dark psychedelia. I believe that the presence of Christian Vander on drums is crucial because of its unique style of play, another thing that contributes to the MAGMA throughout this album is the synchrony between the various instruments and also the voices, one follows the other while creates a freedom to improvise, the song "Iss" Lanseï Doïa ached and a most obvious example of this: it seems that an instrument responds to another in an epic jazz-rock. As I have said it is a question between giving 4 or 5 stars I justify saying that many often these wind instruments remind me a lot KC, but what is nevertheless an album of very high level.
Report this review (#287906)
Posted Tuesday, June 22, 2010 | Review Permalink
snobb
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Second Magma's album is somewhere in the middle between their jazz-rock debut and real zeuhl of later albums. It's still not the classic Magma's sound, but I really like it (as I like their debut as well). Some musicians were changed for this albums, and album's sound generally made one more step towards their dark Orffian neoclassic tribal hymns.

This album is still strongly jazz fusion based, even if there are plenty of neo-classical elements added. Just three long compositions, vocals singing on Kobayan, some screams and operatic bombastic brass.

Not a masterpiece, but really interesting album for whose interested in unusual genre combinations. Zeuhl purists should search on next few albums though...

Report this review (#291627)
Posted Friday, July 23, 2010 | Review Permalink
JJLehto
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars Zeuhl. The first time I saw this genre I thought that has to be a made up word, (back to that in a bit!). I am still not sure quite what defines this genre. Maybe I have an inferior mind, but all my metal is condensed into six genres and all my prog into two. Anyway, I must say I really enjoyed this album upon first listen, and it only grew on me over time.

This is largely a jazz based album, but with elements of classical in there as well as symphonic. This album is a nice blend of it all and moves between all the genres seamlessly. Free jazz, minimalism, classical, atmospheric and symphonic, militaristic and tribal. You will hear it all, and this is just in the first song! While the transitions are pretty smooth, (often it just kind of happens and you dont really realize it) the changes can be quite abrupt.

Indeed there are pretty wild changes in tempo, time signature, rhythm, and timbre through out this album. This is good as the first song as an almost 22 minute epic. These are either glorious or a disaster, and it usually depends on how well my attention is kept and how well the song is actually composed. How often are these long songs either boring are terrible, sounding like a bunch of junk sewn together. I digress. The first song does hold my attention, and quite well. Each section lasts the right amount of time. Not an equal amount of time of course, just write. The song never drags, each section is long enough to be enjoyed but not too long to slow or monotonous. Anyone can make equally timed sections though, and that could get boring over the span off 22 minutes. No the emotional roller coaster has the perfect height in its dips and lifts. Truly awesome song, both musically and in composition.

"Iss" Lanseï Doïa. Almost entirely a jazzy song, it ranges from smooth to free jazz, of course with sections of minimalism. The middle section is quite mellow before giving way to a slowly increasingly frantic section, the pace being kept by some sweet drumming. As a drummer, and one who loves jazz drumming, I was quite struck with Vander's drumming. It is spectacular. Any drummer or jazz fan must enjoy it! The frantic climax is halted with a very minimal and kind of creepy outro. A moaning over a disturbingly simple piano riff, ending with a shivering sound and a growing clock ticking. Enough to drive a sane person to the brink of madness! I loved it.

Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk. Starts off very jazzy. Like the other two songs this is the foundation throughout, but of course there is variation. This song has some the best piano and bass playing on the album. The bass is really cool, but the piano is awesome and has a really wild jazz solo at one point. There are solos all over the place, with lots of different instruments of course. My favorite part of the song may be the middle part, which is a mellow jazz section with what sounds frighteningly close to nazi rally chants over it. The tempo quickly picks up and gives way to an ominous piano and then an upbeat folk dance! Which would not be complete without off tempo piano!

The music on this album, now onto the vocals. On my first listen I thought this was in a strange German dialect, or maybe some obscure or archaic European language. Something folk maybe? No. Turns out it was a language made up by Christian Vander. The language is Kobaïan, the language spoken by the people of Kobaïa. Though made up and is a gut reaction to the music, the language has the feel of German, and looks Nordic.

Anyway, I really like it. Sure, to many it may sound silly, but doesn't scat singing? That is what the vocals remind me of. Scat singing is not about a message, (obviously) but using the voice as another instrument. A way to truly improvise the vocals, and a way to match the music on a primal level. That is what Kobaïan is like. Though there is a story, the lyrics are less about conveying the message and more about matching the music. Just like scat singing it is not really "thought" out and constructed but comes from the soul, in a way its more meaningful than the words I am typing.

The vocals themselves vary greatly. Everything from regular singing to tribal chanting, and even militaristic sounding marches. Sometimes they are melodic, sometimes they make you want to dance around a communal fire, sometimes they are abrupt, staccato barks, and often dramatic. Multiple vocalists are used, sometimes in a back and forth manner, sometimes weaving around each other. Sometimes they are in unison like a choir.

This is an excellent album. Sure, this made up language is a bit pretentious. I won't deny that, but I like to look at it another way. Unique. With a common gripe about music being that nothing is new or original, no one can say that about this album. This is not a story about another universe, this is a story IN another universe, in their native language and not English, whatever that crazy language is! More importantly, it really does blend well with the music and compliment it.

This is a brilliant and unique album. Highly recommended.

FOUR STARS

Report this review (#292372)
Posted Thursday, July 29, 2010 | Review Permalink
SaltyJon
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Here we are again for another Magma review tonight. This one, as I mentioned in my review of their debut, is another anomaly in the band's discography. The jazz aspects of the debut are brought out in full force here. A saxophone/bass clarinet player by the name Yochk'o Seffer (here, he was called Jeff) joined the band for this album, and boy did he add a lot. He is a true master of his instrument in my opinion. The guitar of the debut is now absent, as well. As far as length goes, the track lengths are generally on the "epic" scale, but the album is a mere single vinyl this time around. Quality of the tracks hasn't dropped here, though. Again, we get a bit of an otherworldly feeling here in places, but not as often (or as strong) as on the debut. As I said earlier, the focus on this album is the band's jazzy side. The jazzy side would take a back seat for a while starting with the band's next album MDK.

Just like the debut, this is a one-of-a-kind album in the band's discography, and it's another gem. Not quite good enough for the full 5 stars, but it's definitely at least a 4.5. I'll give it four here.

Report this review (#299328)
Posted Wednesday, September 15, 2010 | Review Permalink
octopus-4
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
RIO/Avant/Zeuhl,Neo & Post/Math Teams
4 stars I've just finished reviewing (and relistening to) Merci so I felt the need to go back to some original Magma.

Their second album is not yet totally into Zeuhl, but is somewhere in the middle between the debut and Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh. It contains three tracks, one 20 minutes epic which occupied the whole side A of the vinyl, and two other tracks which filled the B side for the remaining 20 minutes.

Track 1 (I don't write track titles in kobaian) starts in a jazzy mood but after some sudden changes goes totally into zeuhl. This is a clue of what we'll later find on MDK and Kohntarkhosz This epic is very complex but it's not a challenging listen. Some parts are easy enough, other a bit more difficult but in the end you don't need to be born on Kobaia to enjoy it. Even the most chaotic and rhythmated parts are not very hard to follow. There's an excellent brass section, supported by a great bass. Sudden changes in the signature, and in the melody, too are very frequent. It can be described, just enjoy it.

Moving to side B, we start with a dark athmosphere, but the music moves quickly into the orchestral jazz realm. A twelveth of bass notes are the base for brasses, then they are left alone in playing what sounds like classic contemporary, then the bass introduced the sung part. It cant be defined "melodic", but it's not dissonant as when I think Klaus Blasquiz speaks with a bass voice. It's an unusual (out of Zeuhl) kind of chorus. The piano introduces a different section, still jazzy but darker and compulsive. The rhythm is not fast, but there is tension created more by brasses and piano than by drums and bass. It "relaxes" close to the end.

Track 3 starts with bass playing on an odd signature. This is true Magma. Not much dissimilar from the previous track in the athmosphere. Similarities are hard to be found between parts of the same song, so I can't even compare this track to the others. What is remarkable on all the three is the great work made by bass in supporting the brasses.

This is one of the most accessible albums from Magma. I suggest it to those are not familiar with this band and its genre to start with.

4 stars not only for the quality but also because it can be appreciated by any progger. Well, maybe not neo-prog fans, but who knows....

Report this review (#299480)
Posted Friday, September 17, 2010 | Review Permalink
zravkapt
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Originally, the cover for this second Magma album was much more interresting. Compared to the debut album this is slightly less weird and innovative, but also more consistent. This is still much more jazzy than Magma will later become. In fact, this is not as "Zeuhl" sounding as MDK is. Drummer/vocalist Christian Vander is not completely in control of the group yet, although his Kobaian language and mythology leads the way. The songwriting is more democratic than on later albums. The line-up has changed a bit from the first album. After this keyboardist Francois Cahen and saxophonist Jeff Seffer form Zao, while bassist Francis Moze will join Gong.

Things kick off with the almost 22 minute "Riah Sahiltaahk." This starts out with some groovin' jazz-rock with vocals. Later goes into a more typical Zeuhl sound. Parts of this epic definately forshadows later Magma. Constantly changes but nothing ever sounds forced, the different sections melt into each other. Goes almost proto-chamber-prog in the middle; you can hear the sound of later Art Zoyd and Univers Zero in this part. Gets more chaotic and avant for awhile. Music stops at one point and then some beautiful yet eerie Rhodes and flute come in. More typical Zeuhl sounding later on, some vocal freak-outs towards the end. The piece ends with a big bang, then the piano melody from "Klaus Kombalad" (which can be heard on the compilation Simples) finishes it.

You can listen to ""Iss" Lansei Doia" here on PA. I like the bass sound at the beginning, it sounds acoustic. Other than the bass it starts off with everything else just making random noises until a Rhodes leads the bass towards some jazz-rock that sounds like Zao. Later gets more dissonant and noisy with the bass and Rhodes still going steady. Nothing but brass for awhile. Bass and hi-hat come in and harmony vocals follow. Then Klaus Blasquiz (I think) does some some weird low creepy vocals as Vander does drum fills. A long instrumental section later on before the music stops. Some Rhodes and vocals appear again. Clock and bell sounds to finish it.

"Ki Iahl O Liahk" is a rather funky song at times for this early in Magma's career. This is probably the most traditionally melodic song on the album. Love the militant chants you hear once in awhile. I like how the tempo picks up and it goes into a more energenic section before getting more funky. Nice Rhodes playing during this part along with some great trumpet work. This continues until the end of the song. The sound and production is better here than on the following MDK, which was always better live anyway. As usual for Magma, a great mix of vocals, drums and piano; the Zeuhl bass sound had yet to be invented. There is only hints of later Zeuhl here, but also hints of later avant-prog as well. Great album but not their best. 4 stars.

Report this review (#422882)
Posted Saturday, March 26, 2011 | Review Permalink
3 stars 1001 Centigrades ? 1971 (3.4/5) 11 ? Best Song: ?????????????????

While I may understand very little of what could draw a troubled individual to choose this sort of art for their own sense of personal self-expression, I have come to the distinct conclusion that this incarnation of the band were the most inherently embedded within their respective decade (the wonderful 1970's as they were). To be quite frank (as opposed to being quite Linda or William), the debut album wasn't exactly the Magma that history has come to know and revere (or flee from in disgust). It was a more structurally chaotic, jazz-fusion album than anything else, which if you study up on the etymology of the group, that is a stretch from the defining merits of 'Zeuhl', which is what this transitional album is residing within.

Yes, the jazz fusion element is there, and so is the burgeoning, psychotic space opera, but what you get now is a more prominent vocalization. This is what could possibly turn people off from the group. It's akin to frantic, incomprehensible German military chanting, which happens to be flowing and blowing all over the sidelong epic 'Riah Sahilataahk'. Oh, I predict these titles will give me some form of terminal cancer.

I call 1001 Centigrades a transitional album for a few quite pertinent reasons. I wouldn't just spout nonsense for the sake of padding a review, would I? Never! So yes, this is an album that suffers due to the set of changes which altered the form of the original cast of members. The album is much darker, more sludge-oriented, and less diverse. Its half as long, too, so that might explain things. Strangely enough, the new alterations leave the songs to be rather boring. The melodies aren't half as energetic or complex, tending t lend themselves to the likes of a drug- addled jam session that just so happened to accidentally be recorded in the studio. The issue is alleviated after side one, at least minimally. 'Iss Lansei Doia' is more of a focused, cool jazz assault than it is anything else. The bass guitarist gets a deal of frontline time, which is just one more reason to appreciate the group. The vocals, though, are too off-putting for me to rate Centigrades on the same level as the debut.

Report this review (#443194)
Posted Thursday, May 5, 2011 | Review Permalink
Warthur
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars This transitional album from the fusion sound of the debut to the fully developed Zeuhl monstrosity of Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh is unique in the Magma discography for its blending of the two musical styles. Leaning somewhat more towards fusion than Zeuhl, the album brings to the fore the driving, hypnotic rhythms and the pained, roaring lyrics which would be a centrepiece of Christian Vander's Zeuhl vision, but the airy fusion stylings make the album a bit more approachable to jazz fans than the rest of the band's catalogue. Particularly worthy of mention, aside from Vander's always exceptional drum work, is the clarinet work of Lasry and Seffer, which add a compelling accent to the music which makes it a special treat for anyone interested in fusion or proto-Zeuhl.
Report this review (#480268)
Posted Monday, July 11, 2011 | Review Permalink
AtomicCrimsonRush
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Magma's second offering is a transitional album leading to the masterpiece. '1001 Centigrades' is Magma at their revolutionary best with 3 songs of powerful chanting and mantras in Kobaian alienese. It is the album that was released after a knockout debut and before "Mekanik Destructiw Kommandoh" which became the ultimate Magma experience, gaining a massive cult status over the years. Although the second album is not up to that standard there are still some extraordinary passages of music.

Christian Vander is psychotic on drums and vocals that range from operatic low vibrato tones to high pitched screeching. The album is the typical sound of Magma with avant-garde vocals and atonal jazz blasted out with irregular sax and asymmetrical orchestrations. As usual the band are a large cast of musicians that improvise and extemporise musical patterns to evoke dark alien atmospheres. The repetitive chanting is synonymous with Magma and it is a consistent feature on this early album. 'Rïah Sahïltaahk' is a side long epic with characteristic Magma murmurings and chants along with very strong tribal rhythms. At one point there is an outro with a clock ticking, heaving gasps, and moans exuding a rather creepy atmosphere.

'Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahki' features sensuous sax jazz tones, an off beat piano, and a pulsating bassline all in a different time signature. The dissonance and weighty denseness of the music is a specific trait to Magma and works well as the celestial operatic chanting begins.

The irregular percussion and high degree of hyper-jazz musicianship makes for a compelling experience. I would have liked more variation similar to the amazing debut, but this is still a ground breaking album foreshadowing the masterful music to come.

Report this review (#605463)
Posted Sunday, January 8, 2012 | Review Permalink
5 stars 4.5 stars really

Magma did it again!

This one is amazing, and it's different to its predecessor. I found it more jazz-rock and more aggressive than Kobaia. There's too a better production, and the drums sound really clear and very heavy, with an inmense groove (reminds me of Miles Davis' drummer in the Agharta period)

The album begins with Rïah Sahïltaahk. This song is the first long track by Magma (i mean, the first song that goes on the 20 minutes). The first 5 minutes are really happy and even you can dance it, with the always amazing drum ejecution by Vander. From then to the end, it's an intrincated piece whose feelings and emotions change constantly. Close to the end (and not the "edge", je), Vander screams insanely (19.30). 9.50/10

The next song is the more jazz-rock oriented track: Iss Lansei Doia. This one is more focused on music and rhythms. There's a section in the middle of the song that is incredible. The piano and the drums are syncronizated amazingly. It's a good track. (9/10)

Finally, we arrive to the last song Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk. This song made me love Magma. We can divide this track in two parts: the first one in the first 4 minutes, and the second one, from then to the end. The first part is a bizarre demostration of zeuhl (the intro sounds like a joke, and it's great!). The second part begins with a rhythm by Vander (4.30), followed by the piano and the sax, becoming the absurd into immortality: this part reminds me Weather Report and some jazz fusion/rock bands at the time. (10/10)

I want to make a mention of Klaus Bazquiz, whose voice is close to the perfection. That's all

Report this review (#807022)
Posted Saturday, August 18, 2012 | Review Permalink
BrufordFreak
COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Magma "2" following some of the patterns established by the band's first album in that the three long songs contained here are each credited to different composers: the opener (and by far longest) to Christian Vander, the second to Ted Lasry, and the third to François Cahen. In an unusual move, the band decided to record without a guitarist after the departure of Claude Engel. Also, tensions within the group were mounting with regard to which direction the music was to go. This resulted in the splintering off of members Yochk'o "Jeff" Seffer and François Cahen to form their own group (which would be called Shekina).

1. "Rïah Sahïltaahk" (21:45) constructed in a big band fashion with lots of staccato motion with lead vocalist Klaus Blasquiz doing most of the story telling throughout (and a complete absence of female vocalists!). The opening passage is segued to the mid-section by a two minute passage of theatric orchestral effects while the cinematic mid-section sounds and feels quite like a Burt Bacharach film soundtrack passage, though a little more dramatic due to the Blasquiz effect. Still, the "Do You Know the Way to San Jose" and "South American Getaway" motifs and feel are quite noticeable--though there is also quite a few moments that remind me of Leonard Bernstein sounds and motifs. Powerful but less engaging, less hypnotic, than many future compositions. (32/40)

2. "Iss Lanseï Doïa" (11:46) as is common with Ted Lasry compositions, there is much more of a familiar jazz foundation--here modern and very much in line with other contemporary film soundtracks--and the softer, more nocturnal side of humanity seems to be expressed more in Lasry pieces. There are still multiple voices being explored, but here it is done through a cacophonous horn section, each spouting its own voice and pace. Mid-song there is a break down in which only the horns play their plaintive discordant weave, but then bass and male choir enter to prep us for the cohesive horn and keyboard support of a section of deep-gutteral alien-sounding narration. The horns and piano are actually being used as two separate voices of this civilized intergalactic "conversation." Cool! (17/20)

3. "Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk" (8:23) less jazzy, less staccato, but still founded in what were current principles of cinematic soundtrack music, this piece feels to me closer to the music that Eumir Deodato and Herbie Hancock were exploring at the same time. A nice, unobtrusive piece of lounge jazz. (12/15)

The music of "2" or "1.001* Centigrades" is definitely a step forward in the progression of the establishment of Zeuhl as its own musical form, but not quite there yet. Also, for the sake of Zuehl, I think it a good and necessary thing that Christian Vander step forward to take full control of the band's musical direction; only then do you get a more comprehensive feel for that which defines the musical sub-genre.

3.5 stars; a collection of nice cinematic jazz pieces that are more interesting for their place in the history and development of the musical form that would soon be called "Zeuhl."

Report this review (#843821)
Posted Tuesday, October 23, 2012 | Review Permalink
siLLy puPPy
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
PSIKE, JRF/Canterbury, P Metal, Eclectic
5 stars The Kobaian zeuhl rhythms that came bursting forth on the debut album seem to have wrested control from the other jazz-fusion tendencies of Christian Vander and his strange new musical entity MAGMA. On their second album 1001 DEGREES CENTIGRADES, that zeuhl bursts onto the scene right away indicating that a transition was taking place from the all encompassing type of a fusion to a more focused one that was quickly establishing itself as an entirely separate subgenre within the progressive rock world. However despite the ongoing battle between the newly formed zeuhl sound and jazz, it is the jazz-fusion aspect of the music that ultimately dominates the soundscape as it still retains a horn dominated arrangement. The operatic Orff inspired female vocals haven't come to be yet and the band began the continued decline in band members due to disagreement in musical direction. On this album Claude Engel took off leaving one less guitarist two other band members left and were replaced.

I love this album a lot. It takes a lot of the zaniness of the debut but it is clearly more refined and focused. The zeuhl developments seem to add a stabilizing effect to the whole thing. The midway point between the full-on frenzy of anything goes jazz-fusion to the total loss of it is a successful formula that finds zeuhl rhythms accompanied by beautiful jazz tinged melodies that have beautiful horn passages, lovely flute and clarinet parts and of course, frantic and frenzied Kobaian language skills finding itself shouted, screeched, screamed and uttered in startling ways. This album like the debut is one of my favorite MAGMA albums and although I love their entire output it is these first two that I find the most exotic and adventurous and unpredictable. As Christian Vander kept pushing the band towards the fully fledged zeuhl that would come to be on "MDK" it caused a rift in the band and ultimately saxophonist Jeff Seffer and keyboardist Francois Cahen would leave to form Zao which would continue the musical style of the first two MAGMA releases.

Report this review (#1282819)
Posted Tuesday, September 23, 2014 | Review Permalink
Neu!mann
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars The second chapter in the Gospel according to Christian Vander expands the mythology of planet Kobaïa even farther into the uncharted musical cosmos of Vander's imagination. The interplanetary narrative remains totally inscrutable, sung in an alien language to equally obscure (but exhilarating) music, more refined and sophisticated in the band's second outing but no less outrageous in its pinpoint, polyrhythmic weirdness.

The immediate surprise in this Magma album is how upbeat the music is, more so than anything else in their still expanding catalogue. Despite a few suitably bizarre digressions (look no deeper than the guttural Munchkin voices interrupting "Iss Lanseï Doïa"), this could almost be Zeuhl party music: a far cry from the hypnotic, sepulchral mantras of "M.D.K." or "Köhntarkösz".

Ditching their electric guitarist after the debut album only emphasized the jazzy horn work. But it still wasn't Jazz Rock, no matter what anyone might still be saying. The sequel stressed the more operatic elements in the music, strained as always through a unique sieve of jazz-like spontaneity and precise mathematic notation, all performed with eldritch Avant-Rock intensity.

The album's three long tracks might be too fractured at times, each one organized in an episodic medley of seemingly unrelated fragments and repetitive phrases (when it was revisited in 2014, the 22-minute "Rïah Sahïltaahk" was indexed into eight separate tracks). And the whole thing ends on a surprisingly anti-climactic note, with an unresolved fade-out in the middle of another groovy Zeuhl jam, this one shouldering the unwieldy title "Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk"...grammatically normal in the universe of Magma, but still a tongue-twister worthy of Mr. Fox (in Socks, of Dr. Seuss fame, of course).

The element of surprise is missing too, after the outer-limit innovations of the first Magma LP. But the second album is illuminated by its own mysterious light, strong enough in retrospect to withstand the long shadow cast two years later by the band's magnum opus, "Mëkanïk Dëstruktïw Kömmandöh".

Report this review (#1505718)
Posted Saturday, January 2, 2016 | Review Permalink
4 stars At the end of Magma's first album, a group of Kobaians agree to travel to Earth to pass on their wisdom and help save the planet. The plot states that the party arrive on Earth, receive a friendly welcome, and tell various stories of the growth of civilisation on Kobaia, and their philosophy on purification and spiritual enlightenment. This is likely the plot of the first half of the 21 minute opening track which is relatively upbeat and curious in parts. However, after telling the story, the Kobaian ship is impounded and the party imprisoned, as the title track takes a more ominous sounding tone, but they are able to communicate with their home planet and a message for rescue is sent, signified by the appearance of the shrieking vocals that ended the previous album as the travellers left Kobaia.

A rescue party is scrambled and travels to Earth. They offer an ultimatum to Earth, release the imprisoned Kobaians or face destruction at the hands of Kobaia and the ultimate weapon. This track is obviously a lot darker, with some quite minimalist sections as the tension builds. The second track ends in suspense with a ticking clock, signalling this dark ultimatum.

The release happens, and the angered Kobaians vow never to return in the opening to the final track. However those on Earth that they came in contact with and were not responsible for their imprisonment, are inspired by their visit, living by Kobaian ideology and preserving it for future generations.

Compared to the debut album, Magma's follow up sounds a fair bit more Zeuhl-y, although in upbeat sections still very much a Coltrane tribute. There are some elements of the authoritarian marching rhythm and repeating chanting vocals, but still without the operatic female vocals of Mrs Vander. This is one of my favourite Magma albums, particularly for its position as the transitional album from their mostly pure jazz debut, and the major leap into Zeuhl style in the next album MDK.

Report this review (#2456172)
Posted Wednesday, October 14, 2020 | Review Permalink
3 stars 1001° Centigrades, also called 2, was released about a year after Magma. By ditching the guitar, Magma continued to refine their sound and move away from traditional rock structures. This album is still not quite 100% zeuhl, but it's getting there. The jazz influences on 1001° Centigrades remain obvious and salient among the rock elements.

This album's story starts with the Kobaïans arriving on Earth to tell their story. The Earthlings are seemingly receptive, but their leaders imprison the Kobaïans and impound their spaceship.The Kobaïans back on Kobaïa give Earth an ultimatum to release the prisoners, or else they will unleash their ultimate weapon and destroy Earth. The Earthlings agree, and the Kobaïans are released, but stories about them continue to circulate on Earth.

1001° Centigrades opens with the side-long epic "Rïah Sahïltaahk". Bouncy piano and warm clarinet push it along, and this opening passage is some of the most accessible music Magma has ever recorded. (Check out this live rendition, where it was reworked to prominently feature guitar. It's vastly different from the studio version, and superior, I would argue.) After this energetic opening, the song enters a slower, more plodding movement, though that soon transitions to something lighter and jazzy. 

The Zappa comparison I made for Magma is every bit as apt here. It's weird, jazz-filled, and technical, though it lacks any of Zappa's guitar theatrics or overt humor.

"Rïah Sahïltaahk" is an impressive composition, but it suffers from some of the structural ills of songs on Magma. At times, it feels disjointed, and for all its strong moments, it lacks cohesion.

Side two features just two long songs. The first is "'Iss' Lanseï Doïa", and it's one of my least-favorite songs in Magma's catalog. The first third is an odd, slinking jazz piece that sounds more like something I would hear from Charles Mingus than Magma. The second third feels more like Magma however, and I like a lot of the warmer moments, though it is admittedly inconsistent. The last third of the piece is a return to the structure of the first third.

The album ends on "Ki Ïahl Ö Lïahk". After opening with a strange, ascending bassline, circling reed passages, and sharp piano, it develops an insistent marching beat. The song's midsection interpolates between straightforward jazz fusion, à la Return to Forever, and Magma's typical strangeness.

Review originally posted here: theeliteextremophile.com/2022/04/18/deep-dive-magma/

Report this review (#2904546)
Posted Tuesday, April 4, 2023 | Review Permalink

MAGMA 1001° Centigrades [Aka: 2] ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of MAGMA 1001° Centigrades [Aka: 2]


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.