Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
The Residents - Arkansas CD (album) cover

ARKANSAS

The Residents

RIO/Avant-Prog


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
2 stars The Bunny Boy project poses an interesting dilemma for the reviewer, even more so than most of the Residents' work. The problem here is that this particular project involves a multi-episode internet drama series, an album of music based around the series, an album of music used in the series, an album of unused pieces, and a DVD consisting of a newly edited version of the original series, all of which act as parts for a larger (but deliberately holey) whole. What, then, is the work one is actually reviewing?

The entire project revolves around a man, seemingly named Roger, who is using the internet to try and find his lost brother Harvey. Roger was victim of some kind of accident while in Greece (the details of this, though, are vague), and the appeals he makes over the web become increasingly disturbed. We eventually see him donning a full body bunny costume, as if this will somehow help him in his plea. When the series originally ran online, viewers could contact Roger by email to help him find Harvey, and Roger would respond back to you (giving you a chance, perhaps, to actually communicate with a central Resident?). Along the way, Roger starting selling objects from the room he was broadcasting from so that he could get money to go to Arkansas to find Harvey. One could actually go to ebay and buy cheap little knickknacks to "help" Roger. He also went on tour with the Residents to help make his case and earn money. So, ebay and the Residents' tour were also part of the larger narrative (that is, the tour wasn't strictly in support of the album but yet another part of the big story). So what is the work one is actually reviewing?

The block you have just read (and the one you are reading now) will reappear in each review I am offering of each element of the Bunny Boy project. This boilerplate, meant to help connect everything, will be followed by a segment that focuses on what the separate element adds. Overall, what should be recognized is that with the Bunny Boy series, the Residents have pushed the idea of the concept album into a radical new direction in a way that was truly multimedia but that also tripped the lines between art and reality, artist and audience.

"Arkansas" consists of unused tracks or variations of tracks used on The Bunny Boy album. The title refers to Roger's ambition to get to Patmos, Arkansas to find his missing brother. Is that the real Harvey on the cover? Nah, probably just some Louisianian mockery of those on the other side of the border. "Nobody is Listening," "Sad Saint John," "Memories for Sale," "Two Clown Paintings," "My Brother's Skin" and "Circe" were intended for the original album but then left off. "The Bunny Boy," "The Butcher Shop" and "The Black Behind" are alternative arrangements of tracks from the album. "Save the World" is a variation of a song used on the tour.

The inner sleeve also tells us that "The Bunny Boy Comic," by the Residents and Adam Weller, is forthcoming. So, the saga continues?

The ranking of two stars has nothing to do with the quality of the music, as there are some great moments here ("Save the World" is a strong instrumental and I like "Circe"'s channelling of Lee Hazlewood). Rather the rating has everything to do with being consistent with the system here at ProgArchives: this is not an essential album. Its value can be found entirely in the ears and wallets of the already converted, the fans and collectors. At 33:35, it's also a pretty short deal. Is that an Arkansas thing?

Overall project: 4; this album: 2.

Also see: The Bunny Boy, Postcards from Patmos and Is Anybody Out There? (DVD).

Report this review (#263332)
Posted Friday, January 29, 2010 | Review Permalink
TCat
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin
3 stars This is probably considered an EP since the run time is around 34 minutes. But it is more than just that. It is a collection of outtakes and alternate versions of songs recorded during "The Bunny Boy" sessions. I won't go into the story of "The Bunny Boy" other than to say it is a strange story based on a person looking for his brother that got lost on the island of Patmos or something like that. The entire thing is based upon an internet adventure that The Residents produced, and the music on this album and The Bunny Boy album are from those serialized internet adventure.

The music on it's own does little to explain the story. But it is still interesting music as far as The Residents go. Thankfully, there is more to it than just the strange electronic instrumentation of earlier Resident's albums, though there is still quite a bit of it here, at least it's not as cheesy as some of the earlier albums. There is a lot of strange singing, and a lot of it has to do with characterization. Simply purchasing this EP and the album that is based on will only confuse the listener and make them wonder what it is all about.

Those of you that have heard The Bunny Boy album will realize that the songs on here are in the same style as the regular album, and depending on whether you like that album or not will determine whether you like this collection of rarities. The outtakes are good enough to have been included on the album and are actually used in the show that was performed when touring was done for the entire multimedia experience and the alternative versions are pretty much as interesting as the original versions.

This series of work by The Residents, which also includes a video and another album based on the series, is a very good collection of music and it makes a lot more sense when you know where it is coming from. It is also one of the better Residents projects. However, it is good to go into it knowing that each part of the work comes from a greater whole and is not an end in of itself. I suppose if you like avant prog enough, you might enjoy the weirdness of it all anyway. I have to say I really enjoy this album and the other things connected to it all. It is not as annoying as say "God in 3 Persons" or some of the work put out around that period. The instrumentation is much better. The sound of cheap synths and bad electronic work is mostly gone.

The music is strange, mostly electronic, but with real instruments added in from time to time. The music is far from ordinary, even strange and very dark at times, at others it is satirical and light hearted. And another nice thing about it all is The Residents actually seem to take the project seriously, even if the story is kind of kooky.

However, I am afraid this one will probably only be attractive to fans. I can boost this up from 2 to 3 stars, because even taken out of context, I still find the music enjoyable and interesting. But, if you are interested in this project, I would suggest you get "The Bunny Boy" before you get this one. This EP is just more of the same, and if you like the companion album, then you will like this too.

Report this review (#2009747)
Posted Saturday, August 25, 2018 | Review Permalink

THE RESIDENTS Arkansas ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of THE RESIDENTS Arkansas


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.