![]() |
OIL ON CANVASJapanProg Related |
From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website



However, music should be mainly judged by listening, not by associations, or questions of appearance. Though the band's dandified, decadent image seemed a million miles removed from any traditional prog iconography, it came straight from artists who had more than a fleeting connection with progressive rock - namely, David Bowie and Roxy Music. The same could be said about their sound, definitely darker and more complex than that of the 'pretty boy' bands with whom they were unfairly associated. David Sylvian's languid baritone takes Bryan Ferry's crooner-on-acid style to another, more sophisticated level, and Mick Karn's distinctive bass playing gives the band's music both depth and an edge.
All those elements are very much in evidence in this live album, released in 1983 after the band had split up the previous year. As it is to be expected, it features most of the tracks of Japan's last studio effort, the excellent "Tin Drum", as well as some highlights from two of their previous albums, "Quiet Life" and "Gentlemen Take Polaroids". The stylistic difference between the latter songs and those taken from "Tin Drum" is often rather evident. It could be said that the band's earlier compositions are more 'new-waveish' in sound, being somewhat 'colder' and lacking the Oriental inspiration that characterises their last album. The most interesting is definitely the eerie, keyboard-based Nightporter, quite reminiscent of Eno-era Roxy Music's darker offerings. On the other hand, some of the tracks from Tin Drum possess a jagged, funky rhythm driven by Karn's skillful use of the fretless bass - notably "Still Life in Mobile Homes" and The Art of Parties, the latter featuring a vaguely martial, Oriental-style chorus. The album's highlight is, however, the haunting, rarefied "Ghosts", iits mysterious synths and evocative percussion patterns forming a perfect background for Sylvian's inspired crooning.
In spite of some people's scepticism, Japan's relation to prog is undeniable, both as regards the band members' subsequent career (keyboardist Richard Barbieri joined Porcupine Tree, and Sylvian has since become a very respected progressive artist, working among others with Robert Fripp) and their musical approach, which blends typically Western elements like electronica with ethnic influences. Though their music may not be everyone's cup of tea, they deserve to be listened to without prejudice. "Oil on Canvas", which was ironically their most successful release, is an excellent starting point for those who are interested in learning more about this intriguing band. Approach with an open mind, and enjoy.

This was recorded after their final, and best studio album, Tin Drum, and primarily covers that release. And that's a good thing. It happens to have two of my favorite songs from this band Sons Of Pioneers and Visions Of China, both powered by Mick Karn's unique bass lines.
Structurally, the songs are based upon simple compositions. But it is in the performance that they shine. Led by Karn and drummer Steve Jansen's rhythms, the songs are lively and highly entertaining.
If they could only have added depth to the songwriting, this could have rated four stars.

It´s not like it´s something you notice though as the live tracks are rather sterile and more or less sound like they were recorded in a studio too. Audience noise is very sparse and low in the mix, which doesn´t exactly enhance the feeling that you´re listening to a live recording. When that is said the live versions of the tracks are different from the original studio versions and "Oil on Canvas" is still a good quality release even though a more "live" sound, to my ears, would have boosted the listening experience. Most tracks are from "Tin Drum (1981)", which is natural enough as it was the latest studio album at the time and they toured in support of that album, when recording "Oil on Canvas", but there are tracks from other albums too.
Not surprisingly the musicianship is on a high level. David Sylvian delivers sensitive and melancholic vocals and the keyboards by Richard Barbieri are adventurous and well played. It´s the rythm section of bassist Mick Karn and drummer Steve Jansen that take the prize though. Especially Mick Karn plays some incredible bass lines. This might be some sort of artsy pop music upon initial listens, but dig a little deeper and you´ll learn how sophisticated it actually is underneath. Session guitarist/keyboardist Masami Tsuchiya helps the soundscape to be more full and layered.
Overall "Oil on Canvas" is an enjoyable release by Japan. In terms of being a vibrant live album it fails a bit, but somehow it´s still an interesting and engaging listen. The detailed and clear sound production might have something to do with it, but the high level musicianship and of course the generally high quality of the compositions are great assets too. A 3.5 star (70%) rating is warranted.
JAPAN Oil on Canvas ratings only
chronological order | showing rating only
-
Yukorin
-
valravennz (Penny)
-
synesthetize (Adrian)
-
frankbostick
-
Badabing666 (David Pierre Turner)
-
brig64 (Igor)
-
corrierecosmico
-
chrijom (Chris)
-
plinius (Achille)
-
Jean-Louis (Jean-Louis Marechal)
-
Ennio
-
Harold-The-Barrel (Mark Mc Cormac)
-
Lynx33 (Balázs Markó)
-
Jonda Thorn (Steve Donaldson)
-
Rumspringa (Babkov Alex)
-
al b
-
Matt-T (Matthew E Thomas)
-
milanoclaudio (Claudio Milano)
-
danielfortin (Daniel Fortin)
-
duclos
-
Vano
-
ZBDMiller
-
Wanorak (Jeff Nichols)
-
Hazy7868
-
krotik111 (Bill)
-
Einwahn (257)
-
Themis (Piotr)
-
dalho (Tom Dalhoy)
-
szmataarmata (Bartosz)
-
APartOfTheUniverse (Matthew)
-
kostas0918
-
HarryAngel746 (Maciej) COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
-
ARWSYES (Ludvig Arvid)
-
Caught (Artur)
-
statice-pro (Daniel)
-
THX1138
-
Gentle and Giant (Chris W)
-
dannyb
-
Alle Royale (Alessandro)
-
Kaplan (Stéphane Laquerrière)
-
copperlynx (Phil)
-
ray_man700 (Ray Manuel)
-
alainPP (mass-art)
-
mellotronwave (Mailo)
-
Dr. Whatnick (Vano Mouradeli)
-
fugazi68 (Dave Harvey)
-
stefanbedna (STEFAN)
Post a review of JAPAN Oil on Canvas
You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.
MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).