MINSTREL IN THE GALLERY

Try as I might, I could not quite get into "Minstrel in the Gallery". It's a fair album for me, but nothing compared to "TAAB" or "A Passion Play", at that. It requires a number of listens to appreciate the few great moments present. The lyrics somewhat lack the "power" that was featured on their previous albums (perhaps due to Anderson's separation with his wife at the time the record was being made). The music is somewhat stagnant, leaving me wanting more risks and creativity. The strongest track for me is the 16 minute "Baker St. Muse", reminding me of previous, glorious moments earlier in their discography. I included in my ratings the bonus tracks, as it does not affect my overall rating. These tracks do not really offer much, but they're somewhat pleasing to my ears at times. Overall, I say this is a must for Tull fans, but seeing as I am a casual fan, it does not really do it for me. Not essential, but it's a nice, little addition once you have the aforementioned classics.

1. "Minstrel in the Gallery" - 8/10

2. "Cold Wind to Valhalla" - 8/10

3. "Black Satin Dancer" - 8/10

4. "Requiem" - 7/10

5. "One White Duck / 0^10 = Nothing At All" - 7.5/10

6. "Baker St. Muse" - 8.5/10

7. "Grace" - 7.5/10

8. "Summerday Sands" - 8/10

9. "March the Mad Scientist" - 7/10

10. "Pan Dance" - 7.5/10

77/10 = 77% = 3 stars