NO EARTHLY CONNECTION

Chances are this album will sound as turgid to you as Wakeman's later solo effort OUT THERE did to me, when I bought the latter on the strength of some of the recommendations on this site. (Wakeman has recorded a lot of turkeys, but OUT THERE was to-tal-ly unbearable.)

Much depends on what you make of Ashley Holt's sturdy tenor. On KING ARTHUR, Holt shared duties with another lead vocalist whose voice sounded fragile and somewhat effeminate, but here it's JUST HIM, and if you don't like his blustering style you may be in trouble. An additional problem is that he's been given such lines as: 'Feel and touch the music sense. / Hear the cycle man should have. / Feel and touch the music sense. / To fight emotion, man's defence.' No comment.

To tell you the truth, when NO EARTHLY CONNECTION was first released, I felt happy there was a new album from Rick Wakeman, and I remembered Ashley Holt from previous albums, so I simply accepted him. The idea of Wakeman using a stripped down English Rock Ensemble (i.e. without symphony orchestras blasting away in the background) seemed an attractive one, and in fact the presence of a two-man horn section is one of this album's great strengths. The horns lend a lot of warmth to "Music Reincarnate", the suite that occupies all of Side One as well as the first track of Side Two. They also blend well with Rick's grand piano, synths and occasional mellotron.

The first ever rock concert I attended was the Brussels gig by the band that appears on this album, and I remember Rick and his ensemble managed to reproduce the best bits from ARTHUR so well you didn't even miss a full orchestra. I also remember Holt throwing his tambourine high in the air during "The Prisoner", probably the strongest composition on this album. "The Prisoner" contains several exciting harpsichord solos (Rick's best since "Siberian Khatru") strongly reminiscent of J.S. Bach's keyboard suites; these actually encouraged me to start exploring Bach himself.

Because of that Brussels concert I now find it impossible to review such tunes as "The Maker" and "The Spaceman" objectively. They'll always sound lovely to me (no matter how strange anyone else may find them) because they were so wonderful that night. And let's face it, in spite of its pedestrian lyrics (and in spite of Holt's use of falsetto) "The Maker" IS a touching paean to music, starting as it does with the same sensitive grand piano you can hear on "Life on Mars" or "Morning has Broken".

NO EARTHLY CONNECTION does contain weak moments. Towards the end of "The Warning", Rick plays an unexciting solo on what sounds like a Dutch barrel organ - a foretaste of even cheesier things to come on future albums. On "The Realisation" Ashley Holt sounds so incredibly melodramatic even my concert memories will never save him. The final part of "Music Incarnate" is a dud: what's the use of rehashing all of the suite's themes, in vastly inferior sound? And the album's final track is simply terrible: horrible lyrics, no melody worth speaking of, uninspired solos.

I guess this is strictly one for the fans, although I'd advise everyone else to try and hear it at least once. I bought a Japanese paper sleeve CD of the album a few years ago. It neatly reproduces the inner sleeve with all those incomparable lyrics, and it even includes a square of aluminium foil which, when rolled up, should show you a reflection of the flattened keyboard wizard depicted on the outer sleeve - a trick I've never managed to perform.

Two and a half stars!

Social review comments

Review related links

• Send comments to fuxi
• Report this review (#127518)
• Buy RICK WAKEMAN music online with PA partners
• Show all RICK WAKEMAN MP3/Stream
• Go to RICK WAKEMAN page for videos, full discography with ratings, reviews and much more
• Go to No Earthly Connection page for more details, where to buy and ratings/reviews
• Search the Forum for RICK WAKEMAN related discussions