From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website
Cesar Inca
like
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator
This is the album in which Pink Floyd began to deliver a more focused sound and their
writing skills became more refined, although there are still unmistakable traces of their
early psychedelic era floating in the majestic atmospheres created for 'Echoes',
arguably their most accomplished composition ever. But let's not get ahead of
ourselves. "Meddle" is an album in which Pink Floyd decided to explore their rockier and
bucolic aspects in a clearer frame of mind, giving distinct rooms for each attitude
throughout the fisrt half. The recording kicks off with their anthemic rocker 'One of
These Days', a catchy yet somewhat scary exhibition of minimal textures that gradually
sets a room for emotional darkness until the infamous recitation, from which the band
turns on full swing, with the drums setting a solid pace and the steel guitar exploding
like a diamond in the sky that scatters its splinters across the cosmos. The sound of the
wind connects the opener's end with the beginning and development of 'A Pillow of
Winds', an extremely reflective piece in which the steel guitar reappears, this time as a
painting instrument instead of a summoner of storms. But it is the acoustic guitar
arpeggios that take center stage now, softly displaying their cadences over the dreamy
organ layers. This is classic acoustic Pink Floyd. Portraying a more optimistic mood
although keeping things quite constrained, 'Fearless' gives a candid message of self-
confidence within the confines of a pleasant motif. 'Saint Tropez' and 'Seamus' continue
the acoustic vein with disparate results. The former is a joyful, ironically-absorbed song
in an old jazz mood, while the latter is a failed attempt at easy-going fun on an acoustic
blues set. Perhaps a longer expansion of the 'Saint Tropez' song could have taken more
advantage of the last two minutes of the vinyl's A-side, but well, things are as they
are. And ultimately, it is good that things are as they are, since the second half of the
album is occupied by the monumental suite 'Echoes', which is to many prog fand and PF
heads, the ultimate PF song. And deservedly so. Everything in and about it is a
definitive prog (and art rock) classic, and now comes a list that hopefully will be
extensive enough. The dripping effects played on a distorted piano, the guitar leads
that set the mood for the jams, the best vocal duet performance by Gilmour and Wright
ever, the disturbing interlude played on mellotron overdubs and bizarre guitar effects,
the reflective lyrics that portray the mystery of the ego's encounter with itself in the
others, the ascending climax toward the last sung section, the hypnotic closure of
mellotron choirs going in circles toward the higher notes while the final drips go fading
away. These 23 ½ minutes are pure prog brilliance. "Meddle", while not totally filling
the masterpiece's shoes, it almost does: one of Pink Flyd's absolute gems for the prog
genre.
Cesar Inca |4/5 |
MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).