YES? I think not

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

  Though they were recorded before I was
  born, I've great admiration for the musical inventiveness that Yes displayed
  in their first five records. For that reason, I've investigated the band's
  history and have learnt about the remarkable drive, determination, and sheer
  musical genius of the band's chief architect and founder, Jon Anderson.

  So it is very sad to learn how, as the band approached its 40th anniversary (and
  Jon developed health problems that prevented him from touring to celebrate
  that anniversary), Messrs. Howe, Squire and White   made the
  decision not to wait for Jon to recover from his illness, but replaced him,
  instead, with a karaoke-singing-croissant - all
  without so much as bothering to inquire  about  Jon's  health,  much  less 
  consult  with  him  about their  plans to tour without
  him!

  Interestingly, in recent interviews, Howe and Squire have shed considerable
  light as to how they undertook the decision to tour without Jon. In one
  interview, for example, Squire has commented as to why Jon was not consulted
  on that decision by saying: "I
  didn't tell him personally…Our manager to
   a  degree  was  dealing  with the politics of it, which, at the time,
  seemed the most  appropriate
  thing.”

  In other interviews, Howe has explained, variously, that they chose to
  replace Jon with Benoit David, a singer with a Canadian Yes cover band,
  simply because  "we felt that he was so
  like Jon", and "we
  were certainly looking for a singer who had a similar sort of sound and
  approach as Jon, and that's what happened with Benoit, we had someone who was
  remarkably similar in tone and texture.”

  In yet another interview, Howe slams
  as “nonsense” a statement that appeared on Jon’s website, in which Jon indicated
  that he felt "disappointed and disrespected" that his band mates
  had not so much as had a personal conversation with him about their plans to
  tour without him. However, Howe's assertion that Jon's statement is "nonsense" is flatly discredited by Squire’s statement above, in which he categorically confirms
  that Jon’s statement is absolutely
  accurate. 

  Thus, the sheer disrespect that they have shown towards the man whose
  creative energy and vision has been the guiding light behind the band's
  entire history, simply reflects the extent to which Squire and Howe, in
  particular,  put their  own  monetary  interests  ahead   of   the   band's musical  and  personal integrity.

  Simply put, it is very clear that Squire and Howe's decision to  tour
  without Jon is motivated by nothing more than sheer greed, monstrous  unkindness, and utter stupidity!

  Yuuuuuuuuuuuck!!!!