Who must leave Rush ? (poll)

No! I won't vote too!

Its like a guy without a P***S is not a guy anymore!

NaturalScience wrote: micky wrote: Rushatlantic wrote: micky wrote: [QUOTE=mattuati]Cant replace them!  No way! ahhh... maybe a better question.... what could have made Rush...better.. a true keyboardist a 'better' singer a 2nd guitarist a decent lyricist hmmmm.... Decent lyrics!?!   Neil Perts lyrics are some of the best ever! He is a true poet and intellectual ran across this, this morning... thoughts? {/QUOTE] my thought is this person is an egotistical snob who feels the need to buttress his insufferable rants with ad hominem attacks on Rush fans.  i suggest he start taking two things far less seriously: the music of Rush, and himself.

hahahaha......  I thought about deleting his 'attack' on Rush fans.. and your post shows me I should have. I left it because I thought it was funnier than hell.   You ignored several paragraphs of valid points about Peart's lyrical abilities and focused  only on his 'sucker punch' to Rush fans.  Maybe I should have used the thoughts of another internet album reviewer who's views on Rush and Peart are much the same... just done diplomatically hahahah.

Guests wrote: Fede wrote: TheProgtologist wrote: AngleofRepose wrote: Bonham was replaceable. You must not be a big Zep fan. Zep isn't Zep without Bonzo behind the kit.   I totally agree. Bonzo was a drum master..... Surely one of the strongest and best drummers ever.   I can`t believe we are here talking about Rush (who have one of the best if not the best drummers of all time) and a name like Bonham gets mentioned , I`m a drummer and drum teacher and I have to tell you that I think Bonham was awful , his drum solos were unskilled and sloppy and his drumming in time to the music lacked imagination and was pedestrian

You don't know what you're talking about. Think before speak.............