Least Prog Album

stonebeard wrote: fender101 wrote: eduardossc wrote: Going for the one = PROG-POP Dark side of the moon = Easy listening prog Aqualung = .....prog The Lamb = pure prog I dont like you mate I have never seen a more bias person in my whole life. I understand you like genesis but for gods sake work it out the lamb is not PURE PROG thats the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Look at the results to the poll and you'll see that Im not the only one that thinks so. F*ck, man! He was just giving his opinion! Reread your post, and you'll find that you come off as a dismissive dick.

And I was just giving my opinion, except I didnt have to resort to petty name calling! You see it's people who can't admit that something they love has a fault that cause me stress (not that not really being prog is a bad thing). My favourite band is pink floyd but believe me I dont think that dark side is prog at all just like I dont think many of those other albums are.

If eduardossc can admit that the lamb is not "pure prog" then I'll be happy!

Dissmissive??? Maybe

fender101 wrote: stonebeard wrote: fender101 wrote: eduardossc wrote: Going for the one = PROG-POP Dark side of the moon = Easy listening prog Aqualung = .....prog The Lamb = pure prog I dont like you mate I have never seen a more bias person in my whole life. I understand you like genesis but for gods sake work it out the lamb is not PURE PROG thats the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Look at the results to the poll and you'll see that Im not the only one that thinks so. F*ck, man! He was just giving his opinion! Reread your post, and you'll find that you come off as a dismissive dick. And I was just giving my opinion, except I didnt have to resort to petty name calling! You see it's people who can't admit that something they love has a fault that cause me stress (not that not really being prog is a bad thing). My favourite band is pink floyd but believe me I dont think that dark side is prog at all just like I dont think many of those other albums are. If eduardossc can admit that the lamb is not "pure prog" then I'll be happy! Dissmissive??? Maybe

 Be happy. I admit "The lamb" is not "pure prog" since it has some simple songs, probably even pop song. which I mention next: "Counting out time", "Cuckoo cocoon", "In the rapids", and  "the carpet crawlers". Any other songs apart of these are definitely not pop, nor plain classic rock, nor anything from the mainstream. ....I dare you to mention one that doesn´t have one or more than one detail that places the song apart from ordinary music.

 Now, about "Dark side", mention one single song that could be considered "pure prog" ¡¡. Or better, mention more than 7 songs from "The wall" that has any rock. Not to mention Prog.

 "Atom Heart mother" and "meddle" are filled with pop and simplistic songs...these albums are some of the least prog albums, still, those simplistic songs don´t make of these albums "less prog" do they?. At least not to the general opinion eyes.

The only one that I dont consider prog is Aqualung!!!

And Going for the one is completly prog!!! Come on...Awake!!!

eduardossc wrote: fender101 wrote: stonebeard wrote: fender101 wrote: eduardossc wrote: Going for the one = PROG-POP Dark side of the moon = Easy listening prog Aqualung = .....prog The Lamb = pure prog I dont like you mate I have never seen a more bias person in my whole life. I understand you like genesis but for gods sake work it out the lamb is not PURE PROG thats the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Look at the results to the poll and you'll see that Im not the only one that thinks so. F*ck, man! He was just giving his opinion! Reread your post, and you'll find that you come off as a dismissive dick. And I was just giving my opinion, except I didnt have to resort to petty name calling! You see it's people who can't admit that something they love has a fault that cause me stress (not that not really being prog is a bad thing). My favourite band is pink floyd but believe me I dont think that dark side is prog at all just like I dont think many of those other albums are. If eduardossc can admit that the lamb is not "pure prog" then I'll be happy! Dissmissive??? Maybe    Be happy. I admit "The lamb" is not "pure prog" since it has some simple songs, probably even pop song. which I mention next: "Counting out time", "Cuckoo cocoon", "In the rapids", and  "the carpet crawlers". Any other songs apart of these are definitely not pop, nor plain classic rock, nor anything from the mainstream. ....I dare you to mention one that doesn´t have one or more than one detail that places the song apart from ordinary music.  Now, about "Dark side", mention one single song that could be considered "pure prog" ¡¡. Or better, mention more than 7 songs from "The wall" that has any rock. Not to mention Prog.  "Atom Heart mother" and "meddle" are filled with pop and simplistic songs...these albums are some of the least prog albums, still, those simplistic songs don´t make of these albums "less prog" do they?. At least not to the general opinion eyes.

Thanks mate now we can get on with our beautiful friendship!

Pink Floyd are really just a rock band who had a dab in progressive music Piper and Animals are the only 2 Prog albums they made. The rest are really rock albums with some prog tracks (AHM, Meddle, ASOS, The Wall, DSOTM)

Cheers mate