Kid A sucks

Exactly. The prog umbrella seems pretty big (at least on this site). There
are bound to be differences of opinion, but one man's trash is another
man's treasure. Try to understand and tolerate that other man! I don't
personally like prog-metal (still stuck on Maiden!), so I don't comment on
it- why should I? To denigrate someone else's tastes? What kind of person
am I if I enjoy doing that?

That's not directed at anyone in particular...

And yarstruly, given your tastes, I'm not sure Radiohead's for you,
although OK Computer is very cinematic in scope and atmospheric, and
has some good melodies on it. You could try that one.

Oh yeah and there is NO best band ever...that's subjective. All great
bands put out a crap album or two if they're around long enough.

Edited by Heptade

Heptade--From a prog-metal fan, that's a good attitude and I respect it. I'd be glad if there were many more of you on this site.

There are genres of prog that I don't like, but I hold back my comments because I know the fans of those genres wouldn't appreciate it if I ripped into them. In fact, I've actually tried to keep quiet which genres those are.

Pain Of Salvation suffers from the same thing that DT does. The excess of "Genesis-esque" and "Yes-esque" passages. Not that cheesy at all. Worth checkin if you're in Prog Metal. 

Instead, I would recommend Kaada and Patton album, if you like beautiful songs. Fantastic!

Radiohead sucks.  There, I said it.

Pain of Salvation sucks.  There, I said it.

Kaada/Patton was an interesting project and had more variation than anything I have ever heard from the other two bands that I said suck. 

I agree with Cert...there isnt even an attempt at humour.

Edited by Tony R

I like  humour, I often don't get it, but it's the attempt that matters

Edited by tuxon