Weirdest albums

siLLy puPPy wrote: ... https://rateyourmusic.com/list/siLLy_puPPy/crazy-dog-magazines-60-weirdest-albums/1/

Edited by moshkito - February 05 2021 at 09:17

moshkito wrote: siLLy puPPy wrote: ... https://rateyourmusic.com/list/siLLy_puPPy/crazy-dog-magazines-60-weirdest-albums/1/ Hi, Sorry ... but that list is the biggest pile of trash I have ever seen ... the person putting it together obviously is upset that the "songs" are not formatted properly and are not a hit. That list, actually, would fare better as a "progressive music" listing ... even if the idiot had never heard any of it, which I can not say he/she did at all ... "Dance of the Lemmings" is not weird, and the inside picture tells you all and the music stands out ... because it is not "based" on the "known" effects and formats used in radio and top of the pops ... and on top of it ... it makes fun at our own look at things ... opens a door, and all we can say is that it is weird ... and it isn't ... we intentionally STOPPED and closed the ability to learn and find out what it was all about. .... even more so, when "you" are not the pilot of the trip ... which is shown in the flaring out of the double LP inside cover. It gets really sad when people think things are weird just because someone said so, not because they heard the albums! I have heard and appreciated all the albums listed, and in fact, I have to look but I think I have 6 of them, maybe 7!

Mike (Silly Puppy) clearly came out with that list himself -- the one you should be directly addressing -- talking to rather than about. Calling him an idiot and making claims (the kinds of generalisations you often pull out) that I bet you cannot adequately support is not okay. I have issues with the list, partially because I think it would be better termed, 50 Albums I find Weird (rather than weirdest), but that doesn't mean that I would resort to name-calling or making unverified claims about the person. We have rules against insulting people and if that not being his list is not obvious to you, then you are not paying attention as he even said "Check out my 60 Weirdest albums list on RYM", which you edited out purposefully.

This is an official warning.

Edited by Logan - February 05 2021 at 09:38

From the list, Comus. A little disappointed to not see any Residents (any of their albums would fit on this list and I would have included Not Available). White Noise was another I thought of, but it is not my list - just mentioning these titles for those who are looking for weird and don't know them. 

moshkito wrote: siLLy puPPy wrote: ... https://rateyourmusic.com/list/siLLy_puPPy/crazy-dog-magazines-60-weirdest-albums/1/ Hi, Sorry ... but that list is the biggest pile of trash I have ever seen ... the person putting it together obviously is upset that the "songs" are not formatted properly and are not a hit. That list, actually, would fare better as a "progressive music" listing ... even if the idiot had never heard any of it, which I can not say he/she did at all ... "Dance of the Lemmings" is not weird, and the inside picture tells you all and the music stands out ... because it is not "based" on the "known" effects and formats used in radio and top of the pops ... and on top of it ... it makes fun at our own look at things ... opens a door, and all we can say is that it is weird ... and it isn't ... we intentionally STOPPED and closed the ability to learn and find out what it was all about. .... even more so, when "you" are not the pilot of the trip ... which is shown in the flaring out of the double LP inside cover. It gets really sad when people think things are weird just because someone said so, not because they heard the albums! I have heard and appreciated all the albums listed, and in fact, I have to look but I think I have 6 of them, maybe 7!

Logan wrote: moshkito wrote: siLLy puPPy wrote: ... https://rateyourmusic.com/list/siLLy_puPPy/crazy-dog-magazines-60-weirdest-albums/1/ Hi, Sorry ... but that list is the biggest pile of trash I have ever seen ... the person putting it together obviously is upset that the "songs" are not formatted properly and are not a hit. That list, actually, would fare better as a "progressive music" listing ... even if the idiot had never heard any of it, which I can not say he/she did at all ... "Dance of the Lemmings" is not weird, and the inside picture tells you all and the music stands out ... because it is not "based" on the "known" effects and formats used in radio and top of the pops ... and on top of it ... it makes fun at our own look at things ... opens a door, and all we can say is that it is weird ... and it isn't ... we intentionally STOPPED and closed the ability to learn and find out what it was all about. .... even more so, when "you" are not the pilot of the trip ... which is shown in the flaring out of the double LP inside cover. It gets really sad when people think things are weird just because someone said so, not because they heard the albums! I have heard and appreciated all the albums listed, and in fact, I have to look but I think I have 6 of them, maybe 7! Mike (Silly Puppy) clearly came out with that list himself -- the one you should be directly addressing -- talking to rather than about. Calling him an idiot and making claims (the kinds of generalisations you often pull out) that I bet you cannot adequately support is not okay. I have issues with the list, partially because I think it would be better termed, 50 Albums I find Weird (rather than weirdest), but that doesn't mean that I would resort to name-calling or making unverified claims about the person. We have rules against insulting people and if that not being his list is not obvious to you, then you are not paying attention as he even said "Check out my 60 Weirdest albums list on RYM", which you edited out purposefully. This is an official warning.

^ It doesn't get any weirder than The Residents! They pretty much outweirded EVERYONE

Guldbamsen wrote: Oh Captain my Captain! That was easy Funny how some albums start out completely impenetrable...and then after a good day of listening on repeat...small melodies appear and I started out peaking through ‘the looking glass’. That’s not to say that it’s for everyone..not even slightly. It will always remain an album most folks detest and like to cut down. That can however also be the mark of true genius. Another wonderfully strange album I thought of whilst reading this poll is Geinoh Yamashirogumi’s Osorezan: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=D5iLT7qalJc