Sea of Tranquility Album Rankings

Psychedelic Paul wrote: A Crimson Mellotron wrote: Paul, have you considered making a show of your own given that you already maintain a prog channel on youtube? I think two YouTube Prog Britannia channels is enough to be going on with, but thanks for the suggestion.  As several others have said, Pete Pardo's album rankings make a lot more sense than mine, so I couldn't possibly compete with his Sea of Tranquility show.

Psychedelic Paul wrote: A Crimson Mellotron wrote: Psychedelic Paul wrote: A Crimson Mellotron wrote: Paul, have you considered making a show of your own given that you already maintain a prog channel on youtube? I think two YouTube Prog Britannia channels is enough to be going on with, but thanks for the suggestion.  As several others have said, Pete Pardo's album rankings make a lot more sense than mine, so I couldn't possibly compete with his Sea of Tranquility show.  Hahaha, well, there are no right and wrong answers, as he says. So, what sense? I'll have Pete Pardo's sensible rankings for Blue Oyster Cult's albums coming up next, alongside my album listings, which may or may not be quite so "sensible".

He'd better put their first three albums on top or they will be hell to pay!

^ Ok, Don Pardo got the first three right. Imaginos should have been in the top 5, but what the heck. This as close as he'll ever get to perfection.

I'll always stand by the top 3 being Secret Treaties, Debut and Fire of Unknown Origin. None of the others quite reach those heights for me, new one was surprisingly decent

Psychedelic Paul wrote: SteveG wrote: ^ Ok, Don Pardo got the first three right. Imaginos should have been in the top 5, but what the heck.   The Blue Oyster Cult album rankings are where Pete Pardo & I disagree most of all, especially on the ranking of the Imaginos album, but Heaven Forbid that I give Imaginos any less than a full 5-star rating.

 

I'll have Pete Pardo's rankings for ELP's albums coming up next, just as soon as I've finished listening to all of their albums. I have a feeling the Love Beach album is going to rank pretty highly on my list, having heard it for the first  time today and discovered it's a surprisingly good album.  

lazland wrote: Psychedelic Paul wrote: I'll have Pete Pardo's rankings for ELP's albums coming up next, just as soon as I've finished listening to all of their albums. I have a feeling the Love Beach album is going to rank pretty highly on my list, having heard it for the first  time today and discovered it's a surprisingly good album.   No, it’s not, Paul. It’s an abomination. Shockingly bad. Goodness

 

Psychedelic Paul wrote: ^ Black Moon (1992) is a very good album too. I'm listening to it for the first time right now.

 

geekfreak wrote: oh Paul are you planning a ranking list for Jethro Tull i think it well throw a few surprises like. How people would rate,  Roots To Branches  J-Tull Dot  Crest Of Knave  Catfish Rising  Rock Island

Edited by Psychedelic Paul - November 28 2020 at 01:54

Well, at least you kept Love Beach out of your top 5.