Forum Home Forum Home > Progressive Music Lounges > Prog Polls
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Gentle Giant: with or without Phil Shulman?
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

Topic ClosedGentle Giant: with or without Phil Shulman?
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  123>
Poll Question: Which Gentle Giant era do you rather prefer?
Poll Choice Votes Poll Statistics
32 [55.17%]
26 [44.83%]
This topic is closed, no new votes accepted

Author
Message
  Topic Search Topic Search  Topic Options Topic Options
Gandalff View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 07 2007
Location: Middle-Earth
Status: Offline
Points: 4214 		Direct Link To This Post Topic: Gentle Giant: with or without Phil Shulman?
    Posted: February 25 2012 at 10:58

Gentle Giant albums with Phil Shulman:
  • Acquiring the Taste (1971)
  • Three Friends (1972)
  • Octopus (1972)

    - without him:

  • In a Glass House (1973)
  • The Power and the Glory (1974)
  • Free Hand (1975)
  • Interview (1976)
  • The Missing Piece (1977)
  • Giant for a Day (1978)
  • Civilian (1980)

    First era has an average PA rating 4,09 (rounded). Second era has 3,52 (rounded).

    Nevertheless, these numbers may not be decisive.


    • Edited by Gandalff - February 25 2012 at 14:12
    A Elbereth Gilthoniel
    silivren penna míriel
    o menel aglar elenath!
    Na-chaered palan-díriel
    o galadhremmin ennorath,
    Fanuilos, le linnathon
    nef aear, sí nef aearon!
    Back to Top
    PabstRibbon View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: November 26 2009
    Location: Québec
    Status: Offline
    Points: 925     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 11:23
    Three Friends that's it
    Back to Top
    Horizons View Drop Down
    Collaborator
    Collaborator
    Avatar
    Honorary Collaborator

    Joined: January 20 2011
    Location: Somewhere Else
    Status: Offline
    Points: 16952     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 11:33
    The only album i like without him is Free Hand. 
    Crushed like a rose in the riverflow.
    Back to Top
    Fox On The Rocks View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: February 10 2011
    Location: Toronto, Canada
    Status: Offline
    Points: 5012     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 11:52
    My favourite GG albums are without Phil - In A Glass House, The Power And The Glory and Free Hand. He sure was a great loss, but those three albums are light years ahead from the earlier albums.
    Back to Top
    friso View Drop Down
    Prog Reviewer
    Prog Reviewer
    Avatar

    Joined: October 24 2007
    Location: Netherlands
    Status: Offline
    Points: 2506     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 12:16
    The first four albums are more diverse, I voted for that.
    Back to Top
    DisgruntledPorcupine View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: January 16 2010
    Location: Thunder Bay CAN
    Status: Offline
    Points: 4395     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 12:17
    Originally posted by Fox On The Rocks Fox On The Rocks wrote:

    My favourite GG albums are without Phil - In A Glass House, The Power And The Glory and Free Hand. He sure was a great loss, but those three albums are light years ahead from the earlier albums.

    This. Not to say their earlier ones aren't great, but all three of the albums that came after are masterpieces for me.
    Back to Top
    Gandalff View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: September 07 2007
    Location: Middle-Earth
    Status: Offline
    Points: 4214     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 12:33
    Originally posted by Fox On The Rocks Fox On The Rocks wrote:

    My favourite GG albums are without Phil - In A Glass House, The Power And The Glory and Free Hand. He sure was a great loss, but those three albums are light years ahead from the earlier albums.
    Well, it is indeed nice, but then they ruin it with trashes like Giant For A Day or Civilian. Therefore, I prefer their first four records, since they are more consistent and we can see that Phil was really an equivalent part of the band, including his considerable author contribution. Without him, it's somehow not the same. I accept without reservation from this period actually Free Hand only.
    A Elbereth Gilthoniel
    silivren penna míriel
    o menel aglar elenath!
    Na-chaered palan-díriel
    o galadhremmin ennorath,
    Fanuilos, le linnathon
    nef aear, sí nef aearon!
    Back to Top
    Capt Fongsby View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member


    Joined: February 07 2012
    Location: Norway
    Status: Offline
    Points: 403     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 13:46


    Woohoo! Post #40, and voting rights!


    I vote With Phil Shulman. Purely subjective; I just enjoy the earlier period more    .



    Edited by Capt Fongsby - February 25 2012 at 13:47
    Back to Top
    Wanorak View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: December 09 2006
    Location: Canada
    Status: Offline
    Points: 4574     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 14:04
    Same as Fox on the Rocks, without Shulman.
    A GREAT YEAR FOR PROG!!!
    Back to Top
    Man With Hat View Drop Down
    Collaborator
    Collaborator
    Avatar
    Jazz-Rock/Fusion/Canterbury Team

    Joined: March 12 2005
    Location: Neurotica
    Status: Offline
    Points: 166183     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 15:47
    With Phil.
    Dig me...But don't...Bury me
    I'm running still, I shall until, one day, I hope that I'll arrive
    Warning: Listening to jazz excessively can cause a laxative effect.
    Back to Top
    Hober Mallow View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: July 26 2011
    Location: Everywhere
    Status: Offline
    Points: 178     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 17:46
    Originally posted by Fox On The Rocks Fox On The Rocks wrote:

    My favourite GG albums are without Phil - In A Glass House, The Power And The Glory and Free Hand. He sure was a great loss, but those three albums are light years ahead from the earlier albums.
    “When Fortuna spins you downward, go out to a movie and get more out of life.” John Kennedy Toole
    Back to Top
    Zombywoof View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member


    Joined: November 26 2009
    Status: Offline
    Points: 1217     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 21:51
    The albums without the elder Shulman seemed a lot less proggy and with a gradual drift towards going entirely mainstream. Sure, "Glass House", "Power and the Glory" and "Free Hand" are great records, but they don't spark my imagination like those first four, particularly "Acquiring the Taste". My vote goes for 'with Shulman', as the latter albums don't impress me as much as the first four.
    Continue the prog discussion here: http://zombyprog.proboards.com/index.cgi ...
    Back to Top
    rupert View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: February 18 2006
    Location: Germany
    Status: Offline
    Points: 610     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 25 2012 at 21:55
    Originally posted by PabstRibbon PabstRibbon wrote:

    Three Friends that's it


    Quite agree here, it's my favourite as well.
    ...I'm a musician/singer/songwriter, visit me on www.reverbnation.com/rupertlenz and there you can choose from 125 recordings you can listen to ( for free ) if you're not limited to prog-rock !
    Back to Top
    richardh View Drop Down
    Prog Reviewer
    Prog Reviewer
    Avatar

    Joined: February 18 2004
    Location: United Kingdom
    Status: Offline
    Points: 29474     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 26 2012 at 02:54
    Octopus and Power And The Glory are my favourites so this is quite difficult! I think I marginally prefer the heavier version of GG which actually started with Octopus.
    Back to Top
    Slartibartfast View Drop Down
    Collaborator
    Collaborator
    Avatar
    Honorary Collaborator / In Memoriam

    Joined: April 29 2006
    Location: Atlantais
    Status: Offline
    Points: 29630     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 26 2012 at 09:04
    GG fan that I am I wasn't really aware of when Phil left.  Despite the Giant For A Day turkey, I went for post Phil.  
    Released date are often when it it impacted you but recorded dates are when it really happened...
    Back to Top
    MonsterMagnet View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: July 31 2010
    Location: Liège, Belgium
    Status: Offline
    Points: 561     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 26 2012 at 14:35
    With, I managed to choose just because the Phil era has 4 excellents albums, whereas the period without him has only 3 albums of this quality (Interview is only half-good and the last three don't do much for me) 
    Back to Top
    Slaughternalia View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: February 17 2011
    Status: Offline
    Points: 901     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 26 2012 at 14:51
    I think their best albums are just before AND just after his departure. I guess if I had to choose, after
    I'm so mad that you enjoy a certain combination of noises that I don't
    Back to Top
    Slartibartfast View Drop Down
    Collaborator
    Collaborator
    Avatar
    Honorary Collaborator / In Memoriam

    Joined: April 29 2006
    Location: Atlantais
    Status: Offline
    Points: 29630     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 27 2012 at 07:27
    I'll always have a soft spot for Civilian because they came to Atlanta on what I think was the last of five more appearances live before they hung it up. Big smile

    More importantly, I got into a venue I was too young to be in to see them and they broadcast the show on radio.



    Edited by Slartibartfast - February 27 2012 at 07:30
    Released date are often when it it impacted you but recorded dates are when it really happened...
    Back to Top
    spknoevl View Drop Down
    Forum Senior Member
    Forum Senior Member
    Avatar

    Joined: December 14 2011
    Location: Dallas, TX
    Status: Offline
    Points: 296     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 27 2012 at 07:50
    I think Phil's leaving helped the band focus a little more on the arrangements and a little less on multi-instrumentation.  In a Glass House, Free Hand and Power and the Glory are more streamlined efforts instrumently with, arguably, better songs yet the arrangements are still as interesting as the earlier releases.
    http://martinwebb.bandcamp.com

    The notes are just an interesting way to get from one silence to the next - Mick Gooderick
    Back to Top
    Moogtron III View Drop Down
    Prog Reviewer
    Prog Reviewer
    Avatar

    Joined: April 26 2005
    Location: Belgium
    Status: Offline
    Points: 10616     		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 27 2012 at 08:02
    With Phil, no doubt.
    I prefer the older albums much more, even though they have done some fine things post-Phil.
    Back to Top
     Post Reply Post Reply Page  123>

    Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



    This page was generated in 0.469 seconds.
    Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.