oliverstoned wrote:
Dean wrote:
Frankly I'm surprised that the sub needed such drastic (and brutal) treatment |
I don't listen to theories and formulas but to sound. You'd be surprised by the gap between your theories and experience.
My hifi guru (the guy who learned me all i know thanks to his 40 years of experience)is himself an engineer from the famous Poytechnique school and from the first day he told me that engineers were
painful because they think they know everything whereas this knowledge is only theorical.
|
I'm sorry Oliver, but I cannot believe that you truly believe this.
I mean, don't get me wrong - I can see where you're coming from and I believe that (to a degree) you are correct that science is not always the full explanation.
But I think you also need to remember where it is that your equipment - including all your audiophone wires, speakers, etc. - are coming from. That is, engineers.
If engineers are so inadequate, how is it that they are able to make speakers/etc. that sound better? They don't just come from thin air. Somewhere, problems must be being identified - solutions sought after and discovered - experiments being run to see if their guesses as to how to improve the sound really worked. This is in essence a scientific process.
Whether or not they publish their findings or followed the suggested scientific process for measuring their results is irrelevant - perhaps some of these companies are making discoveries in the realm of sound reproducing and keeping it proprietary to keep their competitive edge - hey, this is a capitalist society - but in the end, to disregard the word of engineers is a bit ridiculous.
Especially considering that what engineers do is not just "theoretical" - they apply it in their day to day work. It's what they do.
Furthermore, I wouldn't disregard Dean's word either, even if I didn't trust engineers, he has indicated several times that he has sound systems that he has tried various things with and observed results, and that those results have lined up with what he has known to be true based on these "theories".
Edited by TheGazzardian - September 20 2011 at 10:27