ProgArchives Mafia: The Merriweather Murder

If there is a baddie role that survives NK attempts and there is another baddie who can make it look someone has that role then yes.... that baddie would try to make a civvie look like a baddie by "making them" survive an NK attempt!!

It has been done before!

And how can you say "It wouldn't make you look like a baddie"? Of course it does! You never brought up my name until I survived an NK attempt!

Being dead is kind of fun at times.

 

Not really, when does Avant Mafia start?

I know that Anderson has a protect ability as well.. i read your post! :o !

What is frustrating ME is that you seem to completely dismiss the idea that the baddie who can protect would protect a civvie, someone other than his teammate, in order to cause suspicion to fall on that civvie.

The possibilities for me surviving are
1. anderson protected me
2. keenan protected me
3. i am akerfelt

only one of those says 100% i am a baddie... the other two I could be either....

Why are you not suspicious of the other players in the game who have survived an NK attempt? Oh I know why.... svs says she thinks you are a civvie... THATS why you don't suspect her. ;)

And what does my hostile attitude now that you are hounding me tell you? Is this a typical response from me when I am falsely accused? Yes, yes it is but of course you (who has never played a game with me before) will just use it as more faulty proof for your case.

Edited by MovingPictures07 - November 04 2010 at 17:58

Sorsha wrote: I know that Anderson has a protect ability as well.. i read your post! :o ! What is frustrating ME is that you seem to completely dismiss the idea that the baddie who can protect would protect a civvie, someone other than his teammate, in order to cause suspicion to fall on that civvie. The possibilities for me surviving are 1. anderson protected me 2. keenan protected me 3. i am akerfelt only one of those says 100% i am a baddie... the other two I could be either.... Why are you not suspicious of the other players in the game who have survived an NK attempt? Oh I know why.... svs says she thinks you are a civvie... THATS why you don't suspect her. ;) And what does my hostile attitude now that you are hounding me tell you? Is this a typical response from me when I am falsely accused? Yes, yes it is but of course you (who has never played a game with me before) will just use it as more faulty proof for your case.

Wait a second...when did I say I don't suspect S~V~S? now you're putting words into my mouth.    Have you seen the huge back and forth she and I had a while back?  Don't think that she's completely out of my suspicions after that.  Lately she hasn't been doing much to make me think "ZOMG SHE'S IN THE MAFIA GUYS".  I'll give it to you straight, here - I suspect everyone who's still alive and who isn't me.  I haven't gotten enough positive signs from ANYONE at this point to completely convince myself that they're civilians.

OK, this confirms my thoughts as well, except I can read TNP fairly well, and i think TNP was civ~

Sorsha wrote: S~V~S wrote: Sorsha wrote: RIPIYWG Lizzy... I don't think she was a baddie :( Interesting that SVS says she has a nice little case on Bea, but now she has mysteriously survived a NK attempt? hmmm... interesting... Would a civvie protector choose her, out of everyone left in the game? I haven't mysteriously survived, i won a Night Protection, like I told Salty Jon. The civvie protector didn;t choose me. Why would they? Interesting that you are jumping on vapors. And my case consists of "I know her really well, and I KNOW she is bad". I will put together a post in the AM when I am sober but it mainly consists of Bea saying.....um, not much~ Which is my whole point. I don't think its vapors... It's easy enough to say you won a prize and no one would be the wiser. But like Jon pointed out there are other options to be considered and more than one of them is a baddie possibility... I'm not making any judgments right now.. Just observations :)

Now Sorsha, here you're making the same observations about S~V~S's night kill survival that I've been making about yours.    I notice that here you didn't point out the possibility that the baddie NK-protector could be setting her up.  Convenient that you neglect to mention that then but make sure to mention it now when you're the one in question...

idk - jon - you may be on to something - but her post did say that there were "more than one" baddie options - to svs surviving the nk.  I'm not sure that her lack of spelling them out the first time around is a sign of her being a baddie. I read that as sorsha implying that we as players should go look at the roles and figure it out for ourselves. 

SaltyJon wrote: Sorsha wrote: S~V~S wrote: Sorsha wrote: RIPIYWG Lizzy... I don't think she was a baddie :( Interesting that SVS says she has a nice little case on Bea, but now she has mysteriously survived a NK attempt? hmmm... interesting... Would a civvie protector choose her, out of everyone left in the game? I haven't mysteriously survived, i won a Night Protection, like I told Salty Jon. The civvie protector didn;t choose me. Why would they? Interesting that you are jumping on vapors. And my case consists of "I know her really well, and I KNOW she is bad". I will put together a post in the AM when I am sober but it mainly consists of Bea saying.....um, not much~ Which is my whole point. I don't think its vapors... It's easy enough to say you won a prize and no one would be the wiser. But like Jon pointed out there are other options to be considered and more than one of them is a baddie possibility... I'm not making any judgments right now.. Just observations :) Now Sorsha, here you're making the same observations about S~V~S's night kill survival that I've been making about yours.    I notice that here you didn't point out the possibility that the baddie NK-protector could be setting her up.  Convenient that you neglect to mention that then but make sure to mention it now when you're the one in question...

Did I go on and on about how SVS must be a baddie because she survived? Did I dance around every explanation for her to be a civvie and only pay attention to the reasons she is a baddie? Nope.

You should pay attention to the players who have played with me before, Bea and SVS. Oh but thats right... everyones a baddie except for you. my bad.

SaltyJon wrote: Oh, I know it's not very great evidence.  I just like how in one case she keeps quiet that it could be a setup by the baddies but in another she keeps repeating that.  I'm holding off on voting for now, though.

lol... you are ridiculous...

I didn't continuously go after SVS for her NK survival because I knew that there WERE civvie and baddie options that could be behind her survival.

And you are comparing apples to oranges. One situation is me accusing another player of something, this one is me defending myself. You can't really think that both situations are the same. The only way your argument makes sense is if we had two situations where other people survived NK attempts and I treated THEM differently. You are grasping at straws to make me a baddie and you are wrong.