Duplicated entries

Someone added the super-duper deluxe 40th anniversary edition of KC's In The Court Of The Crimson King as a compilation

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=26891

Note: They must've spent forever typing this out:

CD1 (in mini-lp sleeve of UK Island 2nd Pressing)
1.     "21st Century Schizoid Man"
2.     "I Talk to the Wind"
3.     "Epitaph"
4.     "Moonchild"
5.     "The Court of the Crimson King"
6.     "Moonchild" [full version]
7.     "I Talk to the Wind" [Fripp and McDonald duo version]
8.     "I Talk to the Wind" [alternate take]
9.     "Epitaph" [backing track]
10.     "Wind session" [extracts from the session that produced the intro to "21st Century Schizoid Man"]
.     tracks 1-5: 2009 Robert Fripp & Steven Wilson re-mix from the original multi-track master tapes.
.     tracks 7-10: Alternative takes from the original studio session. Mixed & produced by Steven Wilson.

CD2 (in mini-lp sleeve of Canadian Release with artist's name sticker on the front cover)
1.     "21st Century Schizoid Man"
2.     "I Talk to the Wind"
3.     "Epitaph"
4.     "Moonchild"
5.     "The Court of the Crimson King"
6.     "21st Century Schizoid Man" [early instrumental recording]
7.     "I Talk to the Wind" [BBC session, from bootleg source]
8.     "21st Century Schizoid Man" [BBC session, from a BBC transcription disc]
9.     "The Court of the Crimson King (Part 1)"
10.     "The Court of the Crimson King (Part 2)"
.     tracks 1-5: 2004 re-master, transferred of the original 1969 vinyl mix
.     tracks 7-8: BBC Radio 1 session
.     tracks 9-10: A-side and B-side from the original vinyl single

CD3 (in mini-lp sleeve of original UK 1st release in original paper stock)
1.     "21st Century Schizoid Man" [trio version - instrumental]
2.     "I Talk to the Wind" [studio run-through]
3.     "Epitaph" [alternate version]
4.     "Moonchild" [take 1]
5.     "The Court of the Crimson King" [take 3]
6.     "21st Century Schizoid Man"
7.     "I Talk to the Wind"
8.     "Epitaph"
9.     "Moonchild"
10.     "The Court of the Crimson King"
.     tracks 1-5: Alternative takes from the original studio session. Mixed & produced by Steven Wilson.
.     tracks 6-10: De-clicked vinyl transfer of the first Island Records stereo UK pressing run.

CD4 (in mini-lp sleeve of Argentina release [name of album printed on the front cover] in original paper stock)
1.     "21st Century Schizoid Man"
2.     "The Court of the Crimson King"
3.     "Get Thy Bearings"
4.     "Epitaph"
5.     "Mantra"
6.     "Travel Weary Capricorn"
7.     "Mars"
8.     "The Court of the Crimson King"
9.     "A Man A City"
10.     "Epitaph"
11.     "21st Century Schizoid Man"
.     tracks 1-7: restored bootleg, recorded live at Hyde Park, London, 5 July 1969
.     tracks 8-11: restored bootleg, recorded Live at Fillmore East, New York, November 1969

CD5 (in mini-lp sleeve of US promotional release [with artist's name sticker] in original paper stock, plus three stickers in the sleeve [two, one red and one yellow stating ) "Promotional d/j copy monaural Not For Sale" and the third, orange, stating "Promotional Copy Not For Sale")
1.     "21st Century Schizoid Man"
2.     "I Talk to the Wind"
3.     "Epitaph"
4.     "Moonchild"
5.     "The Court of the Crimson King"
6.     "The Court of the Crimson King"
.     tracks 1-5: mono album mix used for radio promotion only in the USA
.     track 6: edited, mono single mix used for radio promotion only in the USA

DVD (in mini-lp sleeve of original Japan release with Rock Age obi strip and original paper stock)
1.     5.1 Surround Sound mixes available in DTS 5.1. Mixed & produced by Steven Wilson.
2.     24/48 High Resolution Stereo mixes of CD1.
3.     24/48 High Resolution Stereo mixes of alternative takes from the original studio session (CD3 tracks 1-5).
4.     24/48 High Resolution Stereo mixes of 2004 re-master, transferred of the original 1969 vinyl mix (CD2 tracks 1-5).
5.     "21st Century Schizoid Man" - film from Hyde Park concert 5 July 1969.

It's tricky, because besides the various remixes of the same material or various alternate takes of the same material, there are also two live recordings. It could have been a compilation, indeed, but I'd say that we should take into account the publisher's intentions, too. This is definitely not regarded as a compilation by the publisher, but as a very rich, "expanded" reissue of the same album. I'd say we should only update the release information of the original release and delete this new entry. We must remember that the new material is 99% not original material, only variations of the same (remixes, alternate takes, live recordings). This always goes to "bonus", according to PA policy.

Easy Money wrote: ^ thanks joel, but it looks like there is enough new material to justify it having it's own entry seperate from the original.

Ah, okay. No problem

Thanks for looking after the site Alex, but after taking the time to check out what's on this CD, I'd say the hardcore KC fan like myself would find at least 2 Cds worth of new and interesting material on here. It's not a compilation at all, but until we have a better category, that's it's best fit.

Here are some for deletion

Frasse wrote: In the Jan Hammer artist section, the album Drive from 1994 is listed twice. Delete the entry without ratings maybe? http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=26193   Osibisa has their Live at the Marquee album listed twice. Delete the one listed as a studio album instead of a live album: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=11377

Edited by Snow Dog - January 19 2010 at 09:27

Double click error, could you delete, please? Thanks!

Snow Dog wrote: Frasse wrote: In the Jan Hammer artist section, the album Drive from 1994 is listed twice. Delete the entry without ratings maybe? http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=26193   Osibisa has their Live at the Marquee album listed twice. Delete the one listed as a studio album instead of a live album: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=11377  I agree with both these deletions, but make it this album from Osibisa http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=25563 the other has a better cover.

done

There is the same album ( the first one is original release, the second one is just re-release, track list is the same, cover picture is the same, just all text is translated in English, whenever it is Musea Records 2001 CD re-release). First one (with Russian text) is original, the second one should be deleted.

The same situation as above is with another John Zorn's Masada series album: