Outlaw posts entirely in bold/uppercase letters? - Progressive Rock Music Forum

I haven't seen a single argument here as to why we should ban large font and bold....just people stating a preference.

On most forums members "police" this themselves by explaining to the "offender(s)" that it is poor forum etiquette, or posting "why are you shouting at me?"

Something could be added to the "Site Rules and Guidelines" about forum etiquette, however to make a rule about this seems both excessive and pedantic.

I too think that very large signatures exhibit bad manners on the part of the forum member.

Tony R wrote:

I haven't seen a single argument here as to why we should ban large font and bold....just people stating a preference. >> as mentioned before writing it in major/enlarged upper case bold characters is assimilated to screaming and yelling >> this is like a code that everyone cayches fairly quickly. Those making constant uses of it actually go against the grain (intentionally or not) or have an inferiority complex, wanting their words to come across as the utmost and complete truth.

I personally choose to bold (and color) my replies in a quote, but normally nobody takes that as a shout, because I do not upper case it. More than the bolding, it is the constant uppercase that is tiresome to me.

This being said, I rarely read El Bothy's posts because of his choice of character policy, as I rarely read also Yukorin's italic and centered posts. Not because I do not like them or do not care for what they say, but I find it troublesome and not worth the effort.

Something could be added to the "Site Rules and Guidelines" about forum etiquette, however to make a rule about this seems both excessive and pedantic. Not really, as the simple fact that the sentence is there can be used to prevent abuse and even serve as grounds to excusion if necessary (in terms of trolls a.o.)

I too think that very large signatures exhibit bad manners on the part of the forum member.

let's just stay above the moral melee
prefer the sink to the gutter
keep our sand-castle virtues
content to be a doer
as well as a thinker,
prefer lifting our pen
rather than un-sheath our sword

Ricochet wrote:

but now Mikey, except two or three we know or we can point out, who else uses CAPS/bold all the time?

Very few users do, fortunately. Big smile

Recently listened to:

Tony R wrote:

I too think that very large signatures exhibit bad manners on the part of the forum member.

Agreed.

Recently listened to:

^ for me the width of a signature doesn't matter ... the new forum software adds scrollbars automatically. But I don't like signatures that are too high ... if the signature takes up more than half of my screen, for example.

Recently listened to:

MikeEnRegalia wrote:

Ricochet wrote:

but now Mikey, except two or three we know or we can point out, who else uses CAPS/bold all the time?

Very few users do, fortunately.

then why to disturb the peace of some who like to do it once in a while

yes, but won't we all be affected?

there's a difference between

"we're sorry, you can't post in bold letters"

and

"we're sorry, you can't post in bold letters because of El Bothy (and, respectively, Mike)

How about

"please use standard font size and weight for your posts unless there is a specific situation where you want to highlight something. Using large and/or bold fonts for no apparent reason is offensive for some users - as are large and/or obtrusive signature images."

Smile

Recently listened to:

maybe we should all write like this for a while, until more people admit that it's annoying.

Edited by MikeEnRegalia - December 28 2006 at 11:06

Recently listened to:

no it pwns! Wink

Interested in my reviews?
You can find them HERE

"...He will search until He's found a Way to take the Days..."

Poll Question: Outlaw posts entirely in bold/uppercase letters?
Poll Choice	Votes	Poll Statistics
Yes	17	[54.84%]
No	14	[45.16%]
This topic is closed, no new votes accepted