Calling all reviewers

spacecraft wrote: My point is, reveiwers shouldn't reveiw their own reveiws...smacks of smugness.....a disease we can all do without.

In case you didn't notice...quite a few posters criticized their own reviews too.

moonlapse wrote: Whoops sorry Val I didn't see your post when I wrote that!

spacecraft wrote: My god, if you lot were chocolate you'd eat yourselves.   I have never, nor will ever, buy or get my mitts on album, that has been reveiwed on here. Too much personal taste, and nonsense written for my liking. I like go else where for my music, where conceited prats aren't welcome.   What a stupid topic, this is my best? For gods sake, only people reading your reveiws can state such a veiw, and not the reveiwers themselves.

How very nice... And yes, I'd very gladly eat myself, so conceited, arrogant, big-headed and what not as I am! As my dear friend Stonie said,  I don't see why you have to be falsely humble when you know what your work is worth. I'm very proud of my reviews, and I have no problems in stating that loud and clear - sorry if somebody takes exception to that.

If you dislike this site and its members so much, I don't really see what you're still doing here - unless you get a kick out of insulting people who've done nothing wrong to you. As to our being "conceited prats", I'm sure you have nothing to learn from us here...

So, rudely criticizing people for their work is about being an independant individual while you haven't done anything, while actually doing some work yourself makes you a conceited sheep? That sounds like disrespect to me. I suggest you stay away from this thread until you recover from your Premenstrual stress syndrome, spacecraft.

Certif1ed wrote: spacecraft wrote: (...)I have never, nor will ever, buy or get my mitts on album, that has been reveiwed on here. err... You don't like Prog then? What are you doing here if you go elsewhere for your music? How can you possibly join in any of the discussions if you've never heard any of the bands in the archives? I'm not calling you a liar, but here's a line from a thread you started; "I have/had (i can't remember which) the first 2 Marrilion albums" ...both of which have been reviewed on this very site - Not least by me - this would seem to contradict your statement somewhat. Can you write a review that doesn't include personal taste and nonsense? I'd like to see that! Can you spell review?

Cert, he was talking about downloading.
    

My latest review isn't bad, I think...

Vibrationbaby wrote: Melomaniac wrote: My latest review isn't bad, I think...   http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=88413   Feel free to comment. Nice review I`ll try and check these guys out. I`llbe in the music store tomorrow and will PM you back with my take.

Edited by Melomaniac - August 29 2006 at 15:41

bhikkhu wrote: Certif1ed wrote: spacecraft wrote: (...)I have never, nor will ever, buy or get my mitts on album, that has been reveiwed on here. I'm not calling you a liar, but here's a line from a thread you started; "I have/had (i can't remember which) the first 2 Marrilion albums" (...)      Cert, he was talking about downloading.

    

You mean, as in never own a physical copy or pay for a digital one?

Thieves make me sick.


    

Edited by Certif1ed - August 29 2006 at 16:29

I think my latest Allan Holdsworth review is pretty good. Short'n'sweet

Two points boys and girls, one what i meant basically was that i have never bought an album or downloaded one, on the basis of the reviews in here, as i don't generally read them anyway.