The worst prog epic ever written

iguana wrote: diga.stef wrote: I say "Ghostship" by SHADOW GALLERY. i heard that one and i think it's not too shabby – "the queen of the city of ice" from their debut is FAR more atrocious, even the title is awful worst epic? i'd say GRENDEL. it tries to be "supper's ready" so much that it hurts. oh, well, it's nice to hear that even marillion, who i otherwise adore, had to start somewhere...

The only thing the 2 somgs have in commen is that they are both about 20 minutes

sleeper wrote: Drew wrote: Marc Baum wrote: Drew wrote: CTTE seriously- way too  over-hyped. Popular because its popular. Medi-ocre musicianship- messy at times- repetitive lyrics- annoying vocals Im sure there are worse but I cant stand CTTE    Where is the musicianship mediocre and messy? It's the pure excellence...if it's not your taste ok, but that doesn't mean at all it's "medi-ocre" or "messy at times", that's an stupid argument. Simply say "I can't stand it", that would be enough. Otherwise you'll deserve such reactions. ok- saying the song is pure excellence is the same damn thing- explain why! Actually Drew I thought that the song was mainly filler with absolutely no point, would have made a great 10 minute song though

Wether the song is filler or not is not the point. A good song is one that makes you feel good, and with so many people including myself, I have felt emotions that few songs can make me feel, much less for 18 mins entirely. This song sometimes makes me want to cry for the absolute beauty and brilliance it has, I could care less if it means anything or not. Even if the song doesn't make me cry I am still in total bliss while listening because there is so much detail in it I can't help but feel euphoria from this song.

I'm not saying why you are wrong about it, I'm saying why I  like it, if you don't that is your fault and I'm not going to blame you or say that your wrong.

All of the "Overrated" threads are a disaster because you cannot tell someone their wrong if they don't feel what you feel so don't think my point of view is trying to tell you that you are wrong,

I know what you mean when everyone else loves a song, album or band and you don't. Genesis and the album Red are not as good to me as they are for many on this site.

Epic eh? Hmmm....epic, epic, epic....it depends what one would CALL an epic!

Meh...I'm not that fussed. In every epic there's always something good happening. Probably it's a mix between Aphrodite's Child 'All the seats were occupied' and some random one byt Ozric Tentacles called 'Feng Shui' or sommat...I dunno. but even THESE have their moments.

Starette wrote: Epic eh? Hmmm....epic, epic, epic....it depends what one would CALL an epic! Meh...I'm not that fussed. In every epic there's always something good happening. Probably it's a mix between Aphrodite's Child 'All the seats were occupied' and some random one byt Ozric Tentacles called 'Feng Shui' or sommat...I dunno. but even THESE have their moments.

how come you don't like feng shui?? it is a perfect techno-ambient track!

Greetings from Spain!

Just to keep our loved Inquisition away from you all, I'll attract their attention:

"A plague ... " by VDGG, although I admit they can have done even worse, although I couldn't listem to them awake...

greenback wrote: Starette wrote: Epic eh? Hmmm....epic, epic, epic....it depends what one would CALL an epic! Meh...I'm not that fussed. In every epic there's always something good happening. Probably it's a mix between Aphrodite's Child 'All the seats were occupied' and some random one byt Ozric Tentacles called 'Feng Shui' or sommat...I dunno. but even THESE have their moments. how come you don't like feng shui?? it is a perfect techno-ambient track!

Well its a matter of opinion isnt it. As i said- it DOES have its moments. btw- its not like I don't hold YOUR opinion in high regerd Greenback! You were the first person to reccommend Marillion for me and, surprisingly, you wre absolutely right!