Most Overrated Band of the &#039;Big Six&#039;

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 17:08

According to JD, Love Beach would make much better impression with this cover Big smile

Edited by David_D - May 02 2023 at 17:11

quality over quantity, and all kind of PopcoRn almost beyond

Hugh Manatee View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: December 07 2021
Location: The Barricades
Status: Offline
Points: 1587

Post Options

Quote Hugh Manatee

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 10:29

richardh wrote:

Rick1 wrote:

ELP had the courtesy to quit in 79 - King Crimson did so earlier in 74 as well and reincarnated effectively for the 80s. Jethro Tull are not really prog as such so they get my vote.

It seems to me that ELP should have quit after the live triple and their legacy would have been intact. The Works and Love Beach did a massive amount of damage it seems to me. Crimson somehow managed to skirt all the way round the punk movement and maybe that helped retained respect.

Even at the height of their prowess ELP where held up by the music press, who were stumbling over themsleves to promote punk at the time, as representing everything that was wrong with music.

Now it seems according to this poll it has become trendy even within prog circles to pile onto ELP.

There appeaars to be some element of resentment that somehow ELPs later output has made some come to the conclusion that those darn punks might have been right all along.

I should have been a pair of ragged claws
Scuttling across the floors of uncertain seas

essexboyinwales View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 27 2015
Location: Bridgend
Status: Offline
Points: 4951

Post Options

Quote essexboyinwales

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 09:02

Yes

Heaven is waiting but waiting is Hell

David_D

Forum Senior Member

Joined: October 26 2010
Location: Copenhagen
Status: Online
Points: 15113

Post Options

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 08:45

David_D wrote:

ELP is overrated because it's underrated. LOL

It might also be that The Big Six have been reduced to The Big Five. Unhappy

quality over quantity, and all kind of PopcoRn almost beyond

felonafan

Forum Senior Member

Joined: August 08 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 393

Post Options

Quote felonafan

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 08:26

Pink Floyd

siLLy puPPy View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

PSIKE, JRF/Canterbury, P Metal, Eclectic

Joined: October 05 2013
Location: SFcaUsA
Status: Offline
Points: 15243

Post Options

Quote siLLy puPPy

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 08:18

For what it's worth, i used to dislike ELP quite a bit because they were OVERHYPED (the word that should be used instead of overrated).

Last time i did a marathon of their first four albums though i was blown away having matured into them i guess.

Despite that i'd still prefer Yes, Gentle Giant, VDGG, Cardiacs and quite a few other bands over them any day.

https://rateyourmusic.com/~siLLy_puPPy

richardh

Prog Reviewer

Joined: February 18 2004
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Online
Points: 28022

Post Options

Quote richardh

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 07:20

siLLy puPPy wrote:

Hugh Manatee wrote:

The dichotomy here appears to be that despite being voted the most overrated band, ELP don't seem to be very highly rated 'round here.

Perhaps the lowest rated of the Big Six presented but still several albums in the PA top 250

#85 - ELP debut

#179 - Brain Salad Surgery

#203 - Trilogy

if we had a top 500 then Tarkus would surely be on it with a 4.07 score from 2015 ratings

I seem to have the point out many times on this site that the first 6 albums (inc the live triple) actually have decent ratings. As a fan I have no issue whatsoever with these scores. Works Vol One is slight underrated but that is the only one I have a small quibble with. There is a lot of music on this site that is extremely highly valued and albums that are better and more organised than ELP's slightly chaotic approach. ELP were really a live 'festival' band and not ones for hanging about in the studio. They had equally large egos as befitting their massive talent and divided opinion then and now. There are worst things to be!

richardh

Prog Reviewer

Joined: February 18 2004
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Online
Points: 28022

Post Options

Quote richardh

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 07:13

Rick1 wrote:

ELP had the courtesy to quit in 79 - King Crimson did so earlier in 74 as well and reincarnated effectively for the 80s. Jethro Tull are not really prog as such so they get my vote.

Saperlipopette! View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: December 20 2010
Location: Tomorrowland
Status: Offline
Points: 11621

Post Options

Quote Saperlipopette!

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 07:01

^ I agree but

Stressed Cheese wrote:

Not to mention that I'm sure there are as many prog fans who absolutely can't stand VdGG than those who love them.

that's a thing VdGG and ELP have in common.

Stressed Cheese View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: March 16 2022
Location: The Netherlands
Status: Offline
Points: 540

Post Options

Quote Stressed Cheese

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 05:34

To be part of the Big Six, you don't just need acclaimed albums, but you need to be, well, Big. To be successful in the golden age of prog, to still be referenced to this day, to have modern prog bands clearly taking after you, etc. VdGG isn't big in that sense. You'll see the odd ELP or Crimson reference outside of the prog-sphere once in a while, but VdGG is too niche for that. For example, before I started getting into prog, I had already seen the album covers for ITCOTCK and Tarkus many times. I've encountered all of the bands in the Big Six in unexpected places, but not VdGG. Not to mention that I'm sure there are as many prog fans who absolutely can't stand VdGG than those who love them.

I prophesy disaster View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: December 31 2017
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 4779

Post Options

Quote I prophesy disaster

Thanks(1)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 05:02

Saperlipopette! wrote:

VdGG seem to have the most "rabid fanbase" of the two

Yeah, Van der Graaf Generator are the best group EVER!!

No, I know how to behave in the restaurant now, I don't tear at the meat with my hands. If I've become a man of the world somehow, that's not necessarily to say I'm a worldly man.

Saperlipopette! View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: December 20 2010
Location: Tomorrowland
Status: Offline
Points: 11621

Post Options

Quote Saperlipopette!

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 04:40

David_D wrote:

Saperlipopette! wrote:

^ I just mean that they seem more popular or "bigger" on places such as PA and RYM. Not that something is wrong or false. One may get the impression that VdGG has infact "grown more popular than ELP" because we're in a bubble where that appears to be true. But outside of the bubble(s) ELP has almost 20 times more listeners still. But VdGG are more popular among people that are obsessive with music - which of course counts for something.

I presume that is for streaming, and if so, you don't think that the total number of listenings to VdGG when including all media, like vinyl and CD, can be relatively seen much higher and come closer to that of ELP?

Probably some, yes. Seeing how much more online interest the spark, I would guess VdGG are listened to more often by those who own physical copies of their music (but there has to be millions more physical copies of ELP-albums out there). As I said I'm guessing, but VdGG seem to have the most "rabid fanbase" of the two in this millennia. I brought the factual numbers available here to adjust the opposite impression that Jamesbaldwin(?) left us, with his lists from PA. Besides I did write:

Saperlipopette! wrote:

These numbers doesn’t tell the full story. I know.

but that's the numbers I got.

Rick1

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 14 2020
Location: Loughborough UK
Status: Offline
Points: 2792

Post Options

Quote Rick1

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 03:52

ELP had the courtesy to quit in 79 - King Crimson did so earlier in 74 as well and reincarnated effectively for the 80s. Jethro Tull are not really prog as such so they get my vote.

David_D

Forum Senior Member

Joined: October 26 2010
Location: Copenhagen
Status: Online
Points: 15113

Post Options

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 03:15

Sorry Catcher and others, but if Rush were one of The Big Six, I'd return my Prog card. LOL

quality over quantity, and all kind of PopcoRn almost beyond

David_D

Forum Senior Member

Joined: October 26 2010
Location: Copenhagen
Status: Online
Points: 15113

Post Options

Thanks(1)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 02:47

ELP is overrated because it's underrated. LOL

quality over quantity, and all kind of PopcoRn almost beyond

David_D

Forum Senior Member

Joined: October 26 2010
Location: Copenhagen
Status: Online
Points: 15113

Post Options

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 02 2023 at 02:40

Saperlipopette! wrote:

quality over quantity, and all kind of PopcoRn almost beyond

Saperlipopette! View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: December 20 2010
Location: Tomorrowland
Status: Offline
Points: 11621

Post Options

Quote Saperlipopette!

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 01 2023 at 23:00

Hugh Manatee wrote:

The dichotomy here appears to be that despite being voted the most overrated band, ELP don't seem to be very highly rated 'round here.

Somewhat. But ELP were once very influential, and "always" one of the big progbands. At one point maybe they were prog rock's biggest stars? They are obviously loved by many, and clearly disliked by many as well. The dislikers consider them to be overrated because of their (fading) position and status. It's naturally reflected in the ratings here - which there are many of. I try not to use the overrated-term too often. If I were to I'd rather be using it about Brain Salad Surgery over Acqua Fragile's Mass-Media Stars. BSS is surely impressive at times. I guess (or maybe I'm just writing that to appear to have balanced wievs). But music is art not sports, and it leaves me cold (+I find Karn Evil9 headache inducing). M-MS however is one of the worst/annoying albums I can remember having heard. But nobody really cares about it anyway. It's already overlooked and poorly rated.

Hugh Manatee View Drop Down

Forum Senior Member

Joined: December 07 2021
Location: The Barricades
Status: Offline
Points: 1587

Post Options

Quote Hugh Manatee

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 01 2023 at 21:40

siLLy puPPy wrote:

Hugh Manatee wrote:

The dichotomy here appears to be that despite being voted the most overrated band, ELP don't seem to be very highly rated 'round here.

Perhaps the lowest rated of the Big Six presented but still several albums in the PA top 250

#85 - ELP debut

#179 - Brain Salad Surgery

#203 - Trilogy

if we had a top 500 then Tarkus would surely be on it with a 4.07 score from 2015 ratings

Questions:

Is that why ELP are considered overated by so many?

By what measure is something considered overrated?

Isn't this poll no more than a vield personal attack on other peoples opinions?

Does it matter?

I should have been a pair of ragged claws
Scuttling across the floors of uncertain seas

siLLy puPPy View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

PSIKE, JRF/Canterbury, P Metal, Eclectic

Joined: October 05 2013
Location: SFcaUsA
Status: Offline
Points: 15243

Post Options

Quote siLLy puPPy

Thanks(0)

Quote

Posted: May 01 2023 at 21:29

Hugh Manatee wrote:

The dichotomy here appears to be that despite being voted the most overrated band, ELP don't seem to be very highly rated 'round here.

Perhaps the lowest rated of the Big Six presented but still several albums in the PA top 250

#85 - ELP debut

#179 - Brain Salad Surgery

#203 - Trilogy

if we had a top 500 then Tarkus would surely be on it with a 4.07 score from 2015 ratings

https://rateyourmusic.com/~siLLy_puPPy

Atavachron View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: September 30 2006
Location: Pearland
Status: Offline
Points: 65250

Post Options

Quote Atavachron