Are you tired of DT polls?

 

heyitsthatguy wrote: There's enough fighting in this world, we don't need more

 No, there's not, and yes we do!

heyitsthatguy wrote: Isn't it ironic that this in and of itself is a DT based poll? Anyways, I'm getting sick of the polls as well, and they're like my favorite band, whom I surprisingly don't listen to for technical virtuosity And as far as the Symphonic Team, I don't care, go ahead, bash away, its funny as hell! everyone's entitled to their opinion. However, when serious, angry debates erupt between people ignited by needless polls, it just pisses me off. There's enough fighting in this world, we don't need more

yeah.. I saw that remains of that fiasco...  oh well ... some people do take this stuff FAR too seriously (not pointing fingers.. I didn't see exactly what happened.. or really didn't look close enough ahhaha)

Ghost Rider wrote: TheProgtologist wrote: Tired of them...no I am absolutely SICK of them. What he said. I may joke about bashing them, but the truth is, I find that some people are absolutely obsessed with them. They sure can play, but they are not the only ones on earth who are technically proficient.

I'm sick of Dream Theatre in general.

stonebeard wrote: The dissing of Dream Theater is far worse than the Dream Theater threads.   I bet that if I turned to the Prog Polls section right now, there will be more Yes, Genesis, Tool, or Porcupine Tree threads than Dream Theater threads.   The mob mentality on this site is sickening sometimes.   Raise you're hand if you're a hypocrite.

*emoticon for raising hand*


I've always been accused of following the mob mentality hahahha

stonebeard wrote: The dissing of Dream Theater is far worse than the Dream Theater threads.   I bet that if I turned to the Prog Polls section right now, there will be more Yes, Genesis, Tool, or Porcupine Tree threads than Dream Theater threads.   The mob mentality on this site is sickening sometimes.   Raise you're hand if you're a hypocrite.

"I want to stab my eye out with a pitchfork"

OpethGuitarist wrote: xtopher wrote: OpethGuitarist wrote: xtopher wrote: The Miracle wrote: I love them, they are one of my favorite bands ever, and I think that all this DT poll madness is giving this amazong band a bad name. It also gives a groung for hates to bash them and turn people who don't even know DT off from listening to the band. Sorry DT Everyone: ENOUGH ALREADY!!! Tony shoould put a permanent ban on them, period. I couldn't agree more. I love DT, and I also like talking about them, but I'm sick of seeing the DT bashers out in full force. Take away their provisions and they will shrink up into little, humble masses with nothing to talk about. But give them a DT poll and BAM!—they live to hate another day. It's amazing how highly scrutinized DT seems to be compared to the other prog giants on this site. Definitely the scapegoats of PA. There's probably a reason for that, just a hunch When you have a group of 5 very talented musicians(don't get me wrong, they are definitely good at their instruments) sometimes that doesn't work for a group and composing good songs. I'm sorry. I just disagree with this. There are plenty of bands out there who can play the hell out of their instruments. Dream Theater can play the hell out of their instruments AND compose excellent songs. There's no way they'd be garnering so much attention if they weren't great songwriters in addition to their instrumental pyrotechnics. You've just got to ask yourself: why are you here in a DT poll? Are you here to be negative to bash everything, or do you actually care about the topic in question? All the DT bashers should know this: trashing DT is perpetuating the attention towards DT that you so despise.  Nobody wants this. Give it a rest. No, they can't compose excellent songs. That's why a large number of people don't like them, because they are of the opinion they are not very good songwriters. Sure they can write a riff in 9/8 time and do a crazy solo but that doens't make anything worth listening to. They get attention becuase of their ability to play their instruments and the fact that they sometimes are "circusy" with their music. And I made the poll, so don't ask why I'm here. Don't assume anything either. I didn't trash the band per se until this post, becuase you went out of your way to make it look like I am some sort of d*ckhead. The majority of DT polls are being made by the fans, not the "bashers". Reconsider yourself for just a second.

You misunderstand me. My first paragraph was directed towards you, my second paragraph was towards everyone. I should've specified that.

You are of the mind that DT can't write songs, and only get all their attention through being "circusy" with their music. I'm paraphrasing; excuse me. But there's a reason I like listening to DT more than I like listening to Yngwie Malmsteen or Symphony X (although I like them too); and it has to do with DT being more dynamic and better overall songwriters. There's no way I'd be wasting my time with DT if I didn't think their songwriting skills are, in fact, extraordinary. It's fine to hold your own opinion. You have yours and I have mine.

Now again, my second paragraph (the one with the magnified font) was for everyone. Again, I apologize for failing to point this out. You're right, the majority of the DT polls are made by the fans. Not me, personally; I've never started a DT thread of any sort. Hey, I mean, I like talking about DT. But I'm sick of seeing polls about them because it just clears the path for the flames. And think about it: if the people who don't like DT but who complain about all the DT polls could just help themselves by abstaining to all these polls, think how much less attention DT would get. No more DT polls, no more brainless DT zealousness, no more brainless DT bashing. Everybody wins.

Look at what I said. I said its an opinion. Please read what I am typing. Thank you.


Whether he has a point or not is NOT the point. The point is he was using me as a scapegoat for w/e reasoning he wanted to have, when I had little to do with the issue.

However, if there's 100 polls and 50 of them are DT, then what else do you have to respond to as a forum member?

I would like to either propose a permanent ban on the creation of new DT polls or have a separate forum for all the DT polls that way other members do not have to sift through them.

xtopher wrote: OpethGuitarist wrote: xtopher wrote: The Miracle wrote: I love them, they are one of my favorite bands ever, and I think that all this DT poll madness is giving this amazong band a bad name. It also gives a groung for hates to bash them and turn people who don't even know DT off from listening to the band. Sorry DT Everyone: ENOUGH ALREADY!!! Tony shoould put a permanent ban on them, period. I couldn't agree more. I love DT, and I also like talking about them, but I'm sick of seeing the DT bashers out in full force. Take away their provisions and they will shrink up into little, humble masses with nothing to talk about. But give them a DT poll and BAM!—they live to hate another day. It's amazing how highly scrutinized DT seems to be compared to the other prog giants on this site. Definitely the scapegoats of PA. There's probably a reason for that, just a hunch When you have a group of 5 very talented musicians(don't get me wrong, they are definitely good at their instruments) sometimes that doesn't work for a group and composing good songs. I'm sorry. I just disagree with this. There are plenty of bands out there who can play the hell out of their instruments. Dream Theater can play the hell out of their instruments AND compose excellent songs. There's no way they'd be garnering so much attention if they weren't great songwriters in addition to their instrumental pyrotechnics. You've just got to ask yourself: why are you here in a DT poll? Are you here to be negative to bash everything, or do you actually care about the topic in question? All the DT bashers should know this: trashing DT is perpetuating the attention towards DT that you so despise.  Nobody wants this. Give it a rest.

No, they can't compose excellent songs. That's why a large number of people don't like them, because they are of the opinion they are not very good songwriters.

Sure they can write a riff in 9/8 time and do a crazy solo but that doens't make anything worth listening to.

They get attention becuase of their ability to play their instruments and the fact that they sometimes are "circusy" with their music.

And I made the poll, so don't ask why I'm here. Don't assume anything either. I didn't trash the band per se until this post, becuase you went out of your way to make it look like I am some sort of d*ckhead. The majority of DT polls are being made by the fans, not the "bashers". Reconsider yourself for just a second.