Let's see here:
Gabriel vs. Anderson....................Gabriel wins, Anderson is too short, and won't fight because he is a hippy. Hogweed Lives!
Hackett vs. Howe..........................they don't feel like fighting, so they shake hands, and go form GTR.
Rutherford vs. Squire....................Rutherford wins on dry land because a fish can't fight out of water (Squire).
Collins vs. White/Bruford.................Phil begins singing his remake of "You can't Hurry Love", and White and Bruford shrivel into submission.
Banks vs. Wakeman.........................Wakeman swoops around in his colorful capes, and engages Banks into a mideival sword duel (on ice of course), while playing "King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table." Wakeman wins.
So Genesis wins the fight, but it's close.