Prog Trading Cards

King By-Tor wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=173202 That's my review for FOABP written earlier this year. Can I redeem my card from it? I wish! I'd have hundreds of cards! I think we already decided that retroactive reviews don't count

Oh, okay. That works. I misunderstood that.

Works for me anyway, since I've only written 2 reviews under this account.

MovingPictures07 wrote: http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=173202 That's my review for FOABP written earlier this year. Can I redeem my card from it?

No, sorry.  I started this looking for new reviews (otherwise I'd be swamped).

Besides, you gave it five stars...tsk tsk...I should take a card away from you...

weird. I don't think I've had any of my favorite bands drop off like that, especially not Rush

*is totally NOT wearing a Rush shirt right now *

King By-Tor wrote: It took me about 100 listens to get into TFTO, but I really love it now

I've listened to it a lot when I got into prog. I even have a t-shirt of that album.

It's just that I don't really enjoy Yes anymore when I think about all the bands I discovered since I first came to Progarchives knowing only Genesis, Yes and Tull.

I'm still a big fan of Genesis and Tull. I can't quite explain what made me like Yes a lot less.

It took me about 100 listens to get into TFTO, but I really love it now

Bern wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: Bern wrote: Just a quick review of what I have right now : Camel - Lady Fantasy Yes - Wonderous Stories Yes - The Ancient Genesis - Can-utility and the Coastliners Genesis - Seven Stones Want to trade Yes - The Ancient for either of my Genesis songs? Hmm Yes, I've never been a big fan of TFTO (or Yes as a whole for that matter). I'd like Return of the Giant Hogweed. Deal?

Certainly. I like Genesis quite a bit, but I'm a huge TFTO fan.

Deal.

Epignosis wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: Epignosis wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: Epignosis wrote: Don't know if you like Rush, Alex, but you got a song... Wow, those are some good cards. Thanks! If you review the original post, you can find out how to get more, and that you can trade with others, if they're willing. I happen to like "Dog Years." I really like "Dog Years" actually, so that works. I like every Rush song though. It's a pity I don't write reviews hardly. Maybe I will; I'm not sure. I usually don't like writing them too much, however. I'll have to look through the cards that other people have later and see if anyone is willing to trade too. You know, I happen to prefer Rush more Counterparts and beyond.  I love Test for Echo as well as Vapor Trails.  I wonder why most people are naysayers when it comes to modern Rush?

I love all eras of Rush and couldn't say I love one more than the other. I guess it's simply because Rush definitely isn't the same band that they were in the 70s, and you know how people are.

Epignosis wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: Epignosis wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: Epignosis wrote: Don't know if you like Rush, Alex, but you got a song... Wow, those are some good cards. Thanks! If you review the original post, you can find out how to get more, and that you can trade with others, if they're willing. I happen to like "Dog Years." I really like "Dog Years" actually, so that works. I like every Rush song though. It's a pity I don't write reviews hardly. Maybe I will; I'm not sure. I usually don't like writing them too much, however. I'll have to look through the cards that other people have later and see if anyone is willing to trade too. You know, I happen to prefer Rush more Counterparts and beyond.  I love Test for Echo as well as Vapor Trails.  I wonder why most people are naysayers when it comes to modern Rush?

All Rush is stonking brilliant! But I happen to be a fanboy

I don't love T4E, but the rest I love, love, love! T4E I like

Just a quick review of what I have right now :

Camel - Lady Fantasy
Yes - Wonderous Stories
Yes - The Ancient
Genesis - Can-utility and the Coastliners
Genesis - Seven Stones

Epignosis wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: Epignosis wrote: Don't know if you like Rush, Alex, but you got a song... Wow, those are some good cards. Thanks! If you review the original post, you can find out how to get more, and that you can trade with others, if they're willing. I happen to like "Dog Years."

I really like "Dog Years" actually, so that works. I like every Rush song though.

It's a pity I don't write reviews hardly. Maybe I will; I'm not sure. I usually don't like writing them too much, however. I'll have to look through the cards that other people have later and see if anyone is willing to trade too.