Interpreting songs

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

 Harold Demure wrote:

 rileydog22 wrote:

In response to the question about Tubular Bells, the grunting on the "Caveman" section was a joke.  Virgin asked Oldfield to add prominent vocals to at least one section of the album, so it could be released as a single.  The rest, as they say, is history.   

Thanks for your answers, I had even thought that no one would reply to his topic. 
It's very possible that Atavachron and soundspectrum are right. Maybe often artist compose certain strange, complex songs to let us interpret them in our own way, especially the instrumental ones, but they didn't mean anyhing particular when composing it. 
Please, give your interpretation to songs with lyrics if you've come up to one . 
Has anybody an idea about "I talk to the wind", already mentioned before? Or "Lucky Man" by ELP - what is the moral of this song? 
And one more thing, I don't want you to think that I'm concerned only on lyrics and message of songs. Of course, music is the most important thing and that's what makes prog so interesing, while words add yet more charm to the music (look at my signature)  
 My analysis:

I Talk to the Wind is the old hippy ideal: a return to nature. The "straight man" is an amalgam of society and its expectations. (To be a "straight" in those days did not refer to sexual orientation, but to someone who was not "turned on" to grass and psychedelics, etc. You can hear the word used in the same way in Black Sabbath's old ode to marijuana, Sweet Leaf: "Straight people don't know, what you're about...." The "late man" is the hippy-type, the mystic, who finds more "wisdom" in nature, than in the shallow, temporal ways of man. He has rejected modern, materialistic society and the "rat race." ("You don't possess me, don't impress me," etc.) The wind is timeless and immortal in its secret, all-knowing wisdom. The words (and works) of man mean nothing.

Very much a late 60s hippy ideal. (Though they weren't the first to long for simpler, natural, "animalistic" ways, by any means.)

Lucky Man is very transparent. Its tale of the early death in battle of a man who "had it all" shows that money does not bring happiness ("no money could save him"), and that death is the great "leveller" that awaits for all men, making no distinctions from king to pauper. Very moralistic, and an age-old theme. Death is there to keep us humble.

Edited by Peter Rideout - April 02 2007 at 22:05