Progarchives.com has always (since 2002) relied on banners ads to cover web hosting fees and all. Please consider supporting us by giving monthly PayPal donations and help keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.
Joined: March 23 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 2447
Posted: March 28 2013 at 10:09
dennismoore wrote:
infandous wrote:
As I said, I have great respect for the members of Yes, especially Steve Howe. He was a huge influence on my guitar playing........to the point that I could probably pull off a very passable (though certainly not better or even as good) version of Awaken. But maybe I'm being immodest
As to Fripp and Phillip Glass........no thanks. I'd love to see Fripp with a new version of King Crimson though (as long as it wasn't a nostalgia act trotting out aging past members......Fripp himself being the exception, since he's aged much better than most prog rock stars of the past).
You can pull off the solo in Awaken? Dude! I am not worthy!
He does that on a 12 string you know.. I could do most parts of it but that blazing speed run that ties it all together is
beyond me, and I have no trouble playing, Clap, The Ancient(acoustic part) and Mood For A Day. You rock skippy!
As far as Fripp goes, that would be a tough comparison, he has always kinda "hid" behind other guitarists.
Steve Howe, Gary Green, Steve Morse, even Pete Townshend alldid the "heavy lifting" (guitar playing)onstage by themselves. Basic rock bands like Aerosmith, Def Leopard or Judas Priest pack a bunch of guitars on stage, but I never understood Fripp's need for guys like Adrian Belew(who I think is phenomenal). And don't say it "adds" to the music. Multi guitarists sonically all kinda merge live, its so hard to hear them indivudally...unless you do the Pink Floyd live thing where each guitarist plays a discreetly orchestrated part....
No Fripp bashing here, lets just keep him aside from single guitar player bands.
As far as Fripp being fresher.... Fripp has never been fresh or old. He always plays the same kinda "pattern rock"
or "math fusion rock" with other guitarists. You seen one Fripp show you have seen them all! Oops, now I have done it!. All the Fripp fans are gonna be out for blood now...
Well, I would need lots of practice to get back in shape, but I think I could do it.........if I had a 12 string
As to Fripp, well, he was the ONLY guitarist in the band from '69 to '78, which is the only period I care about. He did far more than 'pattern rock" for most of that time. Even in the 80's and beyond Crimson, you have to understand that his guitar patterns are the base for the entire compositions.......all the "heavy lifting" as you say, is him. The rest of the band work their parts around him. So it's pretty funny you thinking he doesn't do the "heavy lifting". I'd like to see Howe try to play his "patterns". I doubt he's capable (but then, I'm certainly not........very few are)....or would want to
Anyway, we've veered way off topic here. Jon Anderson rules, Yes is a hollow shell without him. Yet still this petition is silly, IMO.
Joined: April 19 2011
Location: America
Status: Offline
Points: 877
Posted: March 29 2013 at 12:43
infandous wrote:
As to Fripp, well, he was the ONLY guitarist in the band from '69 to '78, which is the only period I care about. He did far more than 'pattern rock" for most of that time. Even in the 80's and beyond Crimson, you have to understand that his guitar patterns are the base for the entire compositions.......all the "heavy lifting" as you say, is him. The rest of the band work their parts around him. So it's pretty funny you thinking he doesn't do the "heavy lifting". I'd like to see Howe try to play his "patterns". I doubt he's capable (but then, I'm certainly not........very few are)....or would want to
Anyway, we've veered way off topic here. Jon Anderson rules, Yes is a hollow shell without him. Yet still this petition is silly, IMO.
Ok, you win the Fripp thing, I was really thinking of his eighties work till now, I was never a big fan of his early "bang the gargabe can lids"(Moonchild) thing.... I do love Greg Lake, so nice he was in early KC, don't worry bout the sidetrack, not much activity for YES here on PA, so I bet this thread dies out sooner then later, at least we are talking guitarists...
Speaking of..., Steve Howe(even now) could wipe the floor with Fripp and 3 others like him, so I can't let that Howe slam stand. If you wanna find a guitar player who comes close to Howe then venture on out to Austin,Texas and look for a young man named Johnson.
Oh, and YES are doing just fine with JD, just as fine as they did back in 1968 with Peter Banks & Tony Kaye & Bill Bruford.
"Yeah, people are unhappy about that - but you know what, it's still Yes." - Chris Squire
Joined: September 03 2006
Location: .
Status: Offline
Points: 9869
Posted: March 29 2013 at 22:23
infandous wrote:
Well, I would need lots of practice to get back in shape, but I think I could do it.........if I had a 12 string
As to Fripp, well, he was the ONLY guitarist in the band from '69 to '78, which is the only period I care about. He did far more than 'pattern rock" for most of that time. Even in the 80's and beyond Crimson, you have to understand that his guitar patterns are the base for the entire compositions.......all the "heavy lifting" as you say, is him. The rest of the band work their parts around him. So it's pretty funny you thinking he doesn't do the "heavy lifting". I'd like to see Howe try to play his "patterns". I doubt he's capable (but then, I'm certainly not........very few are)....or would want to
Anyway, we've veered way off topic here. Jon Anderson rules, Yes is a hollow shell without him. Yet still this petition is silly, IMO.
This is a live performance of Frame by Frame and it's Fripp who plays that complex, fast pattern (you can see it at 0:53).
What Belew does is also incredibly difficult because his parts intersect with Fripp while he has to sing at the same time. You can see he gets out of time at "Step by step" but adjusts and covers it. Yes, he adds to the music. It's a completely different kind of music from what Yes envisioned, if I may say so.
Joined: March 10 2013
Location: Hollywood, CA
Status: Offline
Points: 869
Posted: March 29 2013 at 22:42
Well, as long as this little Steve Howe vs Robert Fripp sidebar thing is happening now...
All I am going to say is this... Strictly as guitarists, putting their individual bands and their unique compositional approaches aside, I think Steve Howe could probably figure out and play Fripp guitar easier and better than Fripp could figure out and play Steve Howe guitar. Because to me, Steve Howe is more of a guitarist's guitarist, while Fripp is simply from outer space and probably never cut through the basic rudimentary chops that the rest of us mortal guitar players had to cut through. Just sayin'
Joined: September 03 2006
Location: .
Status: Offline
Points: 9869
Posted: March 29 2013 at 22:45
Just to clarify....I am not saying one is technically better than the other, strictly as a guitarist. That's not for me to judge. But I do consider Fripp a lot bolder and more imaginative than Howe.
Are we throwing all our toys out of the pram about this? Don't be ridiculous.
"I demand that my favourite band replaces their current singer with my favourite singer, even if neither singer nor band wants that to happen." How would that actually work? Pay them a few extra million, maybe? And get them to not argue much too, eh?
What if I were to demand a Prog Supergroup featuring Chris Squire, Robert Fripp, Ian Anderson, and Nick Mason (each being the only person on every album by their respective bands) they could get Keith Emerson in there as well, and name the band CRINK after their first initials. I demand that they do this!! *shakes fist pointlessly*
Joined: February 10 2010
Location: Barcelona Spain
Status: Offline
Points: 5154
Posted: March 31 2013 at 04:53
Larree wrote:
Well, as long as this little Steve Howe vs Robert Fripp sidebar thing is happening now...
All I am going to say is this... Strictly as guitarists, putting their individual bands and their unique compositional approaches aside, I think Steve Howe could probably figure out and play Fripp guitar easier and better than Fripp could figure out and play Steve Howe guitar. Because to me, Steve Howe is more of a guitarist's guitarist, while Fripp is simply from outer space and probably never cut through the basic rudimentary chops that the rest of us mortal guitar players had to cut through. Just sayin'
Yeah, Fripp is so unconventional that I'm not sure if he would be able to play Puff The Magic Dragon
Joined: March 10 2013
Location: Hollywood, CA
Status: Offline
Points: 869
Posted: March 31 2013 at 12:12
Gerinski wrote:
Larree wrote:
Well, as long as this little Steve Howe vs Robert Fripp sidebar thing is happening now...
All I am going to say is this... Strictly as guitarists, putting their individual bands and their unique compositional approaches aside, I think Steve Howe could probably figure out and play Fripp guitar easier and better than Fripp could figure out and play Steve Howe guitar. Because to me, Steve Howe is more of a guitarist's guitarist, while Fripp is simply from outer space and probably never cut through the basic rudimentary chops that the rest of us mortal guitar players had to cut through. Just sayin'
Yeah, Fripp is so unconventional that I'm not sure if he would be able to play Puff The Magic Dragon
Well, not without a bunch of whole tone scale runs thrown in!
Joined: June 10 2011
Location: Colorado, USA
Status: Offline
Points: 4671
Posted: April 01 2013 at 21:17
Dean wrote:
infocat wrote:
I just saw Yes on Cruise To The Edge. When "introduced", JD got the biggest applause of all of them. Just saying!
More comments in a different thread, if/when I get around to it.
How's the cruise going Frank? Sun, sea and Prog - can anything be better than that? (I'm green with envy)
It ended Saturday morning (I posted the above after I got home), but it was pretty fine. Musically it was very good. The cruise itself was so-so, but I still found it to be worth it. (Not much sun, though! Mostly overcast the entire time.)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
This page was generated in 0.168 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.
/PAlogo_v2.gif "Progarchives.com Homepage")
Petition to get Jon Anderson back into Yes
Topic Options
dennismoore wrote:
(as long as it wasn't a nostalgia act trotting out aging past members......Fripp himself being the exception, since he's aged much better than most prog rock stars of the past).
. All the Fripp fans are gonna be out for blood now...
It's a completely different kind of music from what Yes envisioned, if I may say so. 
