Random Review link in the TOP MENU

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

 BaldJean wrote:

 asimplemistake wrote:

I like the feature a lot, I think it's interesting, but I have one quick question.  It seems to give a slight preference to people of rank (Prog reviewers, collabs, etc), and I'm wondering if that is true or just me being silly.  I'm not against that idea, in fact in think it makes it slightly more useful, but I'm just curious.

Edit: I realize that maybe it's just that PR's and Collabs write long enough reviews, but I'd still like to know.

the point is that they write more, or at least should (I plead guilty for not doing enough of that), so of course the probability of a collab review popping up is higher

yes.. and I have had non-collab reviews come up ... have played around with that feature... mainly out of pure boredom to see how long it was before a review of mine came up 

now reviewing reviews....  sounds interesting.... if feedback is to be included in the reviews...  that is the point isn't it.. .to improve reivews.. not merely see your reviews get trashed if you are not exactly the best of reviewers.  I wouldn't allow 'ratings only' reviews of reviews... doesn't serve any purpose but to give people another excuse to f**k with people and for feelings to get hurt.  If someone is 'qualifited' to rate a review that someone invested time and effort into.. they damn well better explain why they rated as they did.  I spend, even if it doesn't look like it... hours on a review... the first kid that trashes a review of mine for the hell of it is going to have answer some tough questions.

Edited by micky - March 09 2008 at 11:54