| Author |
 Topic Search  Topic Options
|
someone_else 
Forum Senior Member
VIP Member
Joined: May 02 2008
Location: Going Bananas
Status: Offline
Points: 24315
|
 Topic: Phil Collins vs Nick Mason
Posted: September 07 2010 at 02:43 |
A discussion between two fellow countrymen in Gandalff's negative poll about Genesis members kindled my interest in how PA members think about these two drummers:
 Anthony wrote:
friso wrote:
I haven't been smoking at all. Compared to, let's say; Gentle Giant, Pink Floyd, Magma, King Crimson and even Yes, Genesis has by far the worst sounding drums. They completely destroy the sound of their recordings. This is due to the bad recording for which I blame Collins, since his predecessor had a fine recording on Trespass. |
Say whatever you want about the sound, but at least Phil can play drums at all, unlike the boring stuff you find on most Pink Floyd albums. |
This poll concerns just their drumming. Be welcome to tell me whom you prefer (and why).
|
|
|
 |
fuxi
Prog Reviewer
Joined: March 08 2006
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 2459
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 02:50 |
|
Well, A TRICK OF THE TAIL was the first Genesis album where the drums sounded as they should - but was Collins really to blame for earlier weaknesses?
Nick Mason has admitted, I believe, that he's only a mediocre player.
Finally, you only need to listen to Phil's playing on SECONDS OUT, with Brand X, and for the likes of John Cale and John Martyn, to know that he once was a very fine drummer.
|
|
Any Colour You Like
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 15 2009
Status: Offline
Points: 12294
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 02:54 |
|
Mason is a mediocre player compared, but at least he wasn't responsible for Invisible Touch.
I actually do like Mason's drumming, it fits with much of PF's music. Collins has never really done much for me as a drummer (although he is a better drummer than Mason), I've never really enjoyed his work that much.
Edited by Any Colour You Like - September 07 2010 at 03:02
|
|
sydbarrett2010
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 08 2010
Location: iran
Status: Offline
Points: 595
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 02:55 |
|
i dont know about collins but i believe that nick ruined the whole pf band
|
|
40footwolf
Forum Senior Member
Joined: March 08 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 651
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 02:59 |
|
Phil Collins is one of the best drummers alive. Nick Mason...is a drummer.
|
|
Heaven's made a cesspool of us all.
|
|
chopper
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 13 2005
Location: Essex, UK
Status: Offline
Points: 20030
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 03:57 |
|
No contest. Listen to Genesis Live and tell me that isn't one of the best performances by a prog drummer.
|
|
chopper
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 13 2005
Location: Essex, UK
Status: Offline
Points: 20030
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 03:59 |
fuxi wrote:
Well, A TRICK OF THE TAIL was the first Genesis album where the drums sounded as they should - but was Collins really to blame for earlier weaknesses?
. |
Actually I like the drum sounds on SEBTP and LLDOB. Neither are particularly "true to life" I suppose but they still sound good. As for earlier albums,  .
|
|
antonyus
Forum Senior Member
Joined: January 30 2006
Location: Munich
Status: Offline
Points: 541
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 04:03 |
|
by miles Phil !!!
|
|
fuxi
Prog Reviewer
Joined: March 08 2006
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 2459
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 04:06 |
chopper wrote:
fuxi wrote:
Well, A TRICK OF THE TAIL was the first Genesis album where the drums sounded as they should - but was Collins really to blame for earlier weaknesses? . |
Actually I like the drum sounds on SEBTP and LLDOB. Neither are particularly "true to life" I suppose but they still sound good. As for earlier albums, . |
As a matter of fact, I agree! I was just thinking of what Armando Gallo (the Italian Genesis expert) said when TRICK appeared: "At last you can hear the drums!" (The irony being, of course, that as Phil's solo career developed, we all got to hear his drums FAR TOO WELL!  )
|
|
octopus-4
Special Collaborator
RIO/Avant/Zeuhl,Neo & Post/Math Teams
Joined: October 31 2006
Location: Italy
Status: Offline
Points: 14122
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 04:32 |
Phil Collins is probably more skilled as drummer, he sings and has a good voice. But I like that metronome with moustaches more. I think I prefer Ringo Starr to Phil Collins, too.
Of course if we are speaking of "drumming only" Phil is the best of those three.
|
|
I stand with Roger Waters, I stand with Joan Baez, I stand with Victor Jara, I stand with Woody Guthrie. Music is revolution
|
|
Chris S
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: June 09 2004
Location: Front Range
Status: Offline
Points: 7028
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 04:47 |
Both absolute genius drummers in their day. Mason could play totally random riffs, Collins was truly innovative and at his prime one of the best in the world. You need to compare them in their prime not twilight years  Not that Neil Peart is losing his grip - he is a freak of nature!.
Edited by Chris S - September 07 2010 at 04:48
|
|
<font color=Brown>Music - The Sound Librarian
...As I venture through the slipstream, between the viaducts in your dreams...[/COLOR]
|
|
progkidjoel
Prog Reviewer
Joined: March 02 2009
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 19643
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 04:56 |
|
Definitely Phil.
|
|
|
|
Snow Dog
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: March 23 2005
Location: Caerdydd
Status: Offline
Points: 32995
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 05:02 |
|
Mr Collins.
|
|
|
|
zbida
Forum Senior Member
Joined: January 16 2006
Location: Poland
Status: Offline
Points: 748
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 05:04 |
I completely can't understand so (trendy?) negative comments of Phil Collins here. He was (is?) a very good drummer with unquestionable 'feeling' and doesn't matter if somebody likes him or not - he is undeniable part of one of the greatest bands ever (responsible for new directions in its style - not ALL of them negative) and prog music at all.
Fro the other side, I've never regarded Nick as an unique technician, but I like his drumming.
A vote for Phil.
|
|
lazland
Prog Reviewer
Joined: October 28 2008
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 13635
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 05:16 |
|
I think that even the veritable Mr Mason would vote for Phil in this poll. Mason was always very honest about his limitations as a musician, and recall him actually being replaced by session drummers on The Wall & The Final Cut on tracks that called for different signatures - that certainly never happened to Collins.
|
|
Enhance your life. Get down to www.lazland.org
Now also broadcasting on www.progzilla.com Every Saturday, 4.00 p.m. UK time!
|
|
seventhsojourn
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: December 11 2009
Location: .
Status: Offline
Points: 4006
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 05:40 |
|
The Artful Dodger.
|
|
octopus-4
Special Collaborator
RIO/Avant/Zeuhl,Neo & Post/Math Teams
Joined: October 31 2006
Location: Italy
Status: Offline
Points: 14122
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 05:58 |
zbida wrote:
I completely can't understand so (trendy?) negative comments of Phil Collins here. He was (is?) a very good drummer with unquestionable 'feeling' and doesn't matter if somebody likes him or not - he is undeniable part of one of the greatest bands ever (responsible for new directions in its style - not ALL of them negative) and prog music at all.
Fro the other side, I've never regarded Nick as an unique technician, but I like his drumming.
A vote for Phil. |
Having expressed a negative comment, let me clarify: I don't have anything against Phil Collins as drummer. He's surely more skilled than Mason. It's that I don't like his solo works at all and I barely like Genesis. Mason gives me more emotions and is perfect for Pink Floyd. I don't think Pink Floyd would have been the same with a different drummer, even a more skilled one.
If the post is about skill, there's no discussion, instead. Phil Collins is a drummer, Mason plays drums.
|
|
I stand with Roger Waters, I stand with Joan Baez, I stand with Victor Jara, I stand with Woody Guthrie. Music is revolution
|
|
Progatron
Forum Senior Member
Joined: March 28 2009
Location: Ontario, Canada
Status: Offline
Points: 187
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 06:34 |
I like Nick Mason, but this is like asking which is better: a nickel or a suitcase full of hundred-dollar-bills. Collins by an immeasurable distance! 
|
|
Genesis/Yes/Rush/Marillion/VDGG&PH/The Flower Kings/Zappa/Änglagård/Wobbler/PFM/Banco/Le Orme/Jethro Tull/Spock's Beard/Transatlantic/Ayreon/Beardfish/IQ/Dream Theater/Opeth/P.Tree/Arena/Camel/Kaipa!
|
|
someone_else
Forum Senior Member
VIP Member
Joined: May 02 2008
Location: Going Bananas
Status: Offline
Points: 24315
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 06:40 |
sydbarrett2010 wrote:
i dont know about collins but i believe that nick ruined the whole pf band |
I don't think that Nick Mason ruined anything at all. I have been a Pink Floyd fan since 1972 and I can't hear anything on their albums that might make me think so. Nevertheless, I think that Phil Collins is the most skilled of these two drummers and therefore I abandon my default behaviour of voting for Pink Floyd in this poll.
|
|
|
|
Epignosis
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: December 30 2007
Location: Raeford, NC
Status: Offline
Points: 32524
|
Posted: September 07 2010 at 06:47 |
|
Nick Mason is a perfect drummer for Pink Floyd- he doesn't choke the music and allows it to breathe (no pun intended).
Phil Collins is a more dynamic drummer, and I think fits Genesis well both as a drummer and vocalist (up until Duke).
No vote.
|
|
|
|
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.
/PAlogo_v2.gif "Progarchives.com Homepage")
Phil Collins vs Nick Mason
