Iron Maiden or Metallica?

rogerthat wrote: Pekka wrote: Catcher10 wrote: Metallica songs all SOUND THE SAME!!!!! ... Metallica guitar riffs are the same throughout their collection Seems you haven't heard very many of them. Indeed, if anything, I would say Maiden's work can get rather similar-sounding.  Maiden is winning quite comfortably, seems consistency always wins the day over brilliance, as much as I go the other way.  Maiden at their best were a variation on a style essentially pioneered by Judas Priest.  Metallica expanded the frontiers of thrash even when it was still a fledgling genre.  Ride the Lightning is amazingly ambitious for a thrash metal album and so is MOP, they were taking risks at levels not many in the metal scene then were prepared to.  But of course, metal celebrates 'true' warriors rather than innovators.

Gandalff wrote: I have to reveal a secret: I´m neither Iron Maiden or Metallica fan. I´ve liked Iron Maiden 25 years ago until Piece of Mind. I think Paul di Anno era was more raw and harder than Dickinson era. Their last release Final Frontier seems to be a return to roots.

Pekka wrote: Catcher10 wrote: Metallica songs all SOUND THE SAME!!!!! ... Metallica guitar riffs are the same throughout their collection Seems you haven't heard very many of them.

Indeed, if anything, I would say Maiden's work can get rather similar-sounding.  Maiden is winning quite comfortably, seems consistency always wins the day over brilliance, as much as I go the other way.  Maiden at their best were a variation on a style essentially pioneered by Judas Priest.  Metallica expanded the frontiers of thrash even when it was still a fledgling genre.  Ride the Lightning is amazingly ambitious for a thrash metal album and so is MOP, they were taking risks at levels not many in the metal scene then were prepared to.  But of course, metal celebrates 'true' warriors rather than innovators.

So, I have to reveal a fact that I´m not  huge fan of neither Iron Maiden or Metallica. That´s a trial only...

Edited by Gandalff - September 04 2010 at 19:12

halabalushindigus wrote: watching Metallica in Concert, I noticed several things that alarmed me;   Hetfield won't shut up vocally, spitting into the mike and his guitar [playing literally drowns out Hemmet Can't figure out what's the problem with the first one, he sings the lines he's written and the spitting is mostly the mic's problem. Hammett's main contribution to the band are the solos, and doubling Hetfield's rhythm parts. I hear the solos and the harmonies here and there, and it's pretty damn hard to tell which guitar is louder in the rhythm parts..   There are no vocal harmonies They had more when Jason was in the band, because he could actually sing. There's still some, but yeah, they lost a great live performer in Jason. Now I prefer no vocal harmonies to messed up vocal harmonies.   Lars doesn't say a word and has no Drum solo, yet the Bass player has a solo, but at ten minutes into the set, I can't figure out for the life of me WHY? Because Rob has the ability to perform at least a remotely interesting solo. The bass solo you're referring to is probably the intro to For Whom the Bell Tolls, it's not really a solo per se. But he did a proper solo when I saw them in 2007 and it was pretty good. I'm a big fan of Metallica, but I can admit that Lars is not in the form to do a solo. He's struggling enough with the actual songs. And he always talks to the audience at the end of the set, which I think is enough. I could well do without Kirk's solos in between songs, but they serve the purpose of filling the silence when the others change instruments. He did do a great little solo piece called Melbourne on the St. Anger tour, it was a composed little clean guitar thing, very pretty. Rob is clearly the most interesting soloist in the band.   There are no choreographed band foot movements ...there's not a lot of visual or sonic fun Thank heavens for no choreography, I've always found the synchronized axe attack very silly looking. And Metallica has had some massive stage shows (the 1996 tour stage destruction for example), but nowadays they prefer to stick with the music, which is good.   Im thinking they could add harmonies, all three stand to gether and harmonize at some point, ditch the bass solo  and most of all,,turn Hetfields guitar down and let's hear Kirk's guitar for like 20 seconds for once...not too much too ask....and finally do something weird or nice like play "Yellow Submarine" as a joke and get "friendly"

Edited by Pekka - September 04 2010 at 03:38

watching Metallica in Concert, I noticed several things that alarmed me;

Catcher10 wrote: Metallica songs all SOUND THE SAME!!!!! ... Metallica guitar riffs are the same throughout their collection

Run To The Hills...Run for your Life

Maiden

Metallica, only for that bass sound.