Palmer vs Peart

Peart's style is more unique, so i'll go with him.

BaldFriede wrote: Tony R wrote: BaldFriede wrote: You are not even well informed, Tony; first of all I usually mention a 45 minute drum solo, and second it was not by Moerlen but by Vander. Unlike the Peart fans I am not a broken record that is stuck and goes repeating "Peart...Peart...Peart" all the time; on the contrary, I have given my acknowledgements to numerous drummers again and again. It is just typically of Peart fans that they react like spoiled little brats when one does not join in their chorus. And when one repays them a bit they react like little kids who have been stolen their facourite toy. Sorry, I accidentially hit the pick-up of your record player. I will put it on again. "Peart...Peart...Peart". I voted for Palmer...... <beep...beep...beep> "National Health Service. What can we do for you?" "Can you please send an ambulance to a certain Tony Riviere? He does not seem to be well." "What symptoms does he show?" "In a 'Peart vs. Palmer" Poll thread in a progressive rock forum he mentioned he gave his vote to Palmer". "Wait a moment. You are not speaking of the out-and-out Rush fan Tony Riviere, are you?" "I am!" "That sounds very alarming indeed; I will send an ambulance immediately. Please stay close to him and try to resuscitate him by playing Rush records to him".

jajajajaja Classic Baldie

I will edit the drum solo of Pierre Moerlen out of the Knebworth live DVD of Mike Oldfield, upload it and post the link here, so you will all have a direct comparison to Peart.

Philéas wrote: Stéphane Galland.

HELL YEAH.

http://www.progarchives.com/Progressive_rock_discography_BAND.asp?band_id=1312

Edited by Visitor13 - February 03 2007 at 17:20

as an ELP fan I voted for......Peart

Peart  is the drummers drummer,   anybody who  knows  drums knows Peart is the King 

Another easy one for me.

Tony R wrote: BaldFriede wrote: Tony R wrote: BaldFriede wrote: Yawn. Another drum poll where none of my canditates gets the vote. Moerlen would have drummed circles around them, wrapped them up in aluminium foil, put them on the ends of his drumsticks and thus have given them a close experience what drumming is really about.   You've just given me a great idea! How about a facility where you can make an automatic response depending on the topic? If the topic mentions drumming you could just press a button and.......... I would, but it is not necessary; the Peart fans already invented it.   if I had to share royalties from the idea with all the Peart fans,I'd only get a one billionth share...   Anyway, isnt it time for you to mention that 30 minute drum solo....?       I suggest you watch this:   http://www.rushisaband.com/video.php?id=42

Re : this poll - I thought the proposition was a person's preference between two percussioners whose last name starts with P. Oh well, some petty people will get P.O.d over polls. . Mind you, I've always found an intriguing way of saving myself time & frustration when it comes to polls or lounges listed herein - I don't bother with them. Then with the time I've saved, I can think up my own limited choice polls to irritate people with unlimited time to spend explaining why they hate such polls. I guess it's how you bait the hook ...

It's not that i don't understand your point; it's that I don't agree with it or is it that I do understate your point but not you, or that I Allstate your paint, mutt not fool ... anyway my point is a period . not a comma , don't mind me I'm in a semi-colon ;}


Edited by pantacruelgruel - February 03 2007 at 21:13

progismylife wrote: el böthy wrote: Tony R wrote:       I suggest you watch this:   http://www.rushisaband.com/video.php?id=42   Ah, thats nothing...I can do that while drinking a coke... You can watch a video while drinking a coke? AMAZING!

And thats not all sometimes...I drink Light Coke...ohhh

Zappa88 wrote: Palmer for me, but we all know Rutsey pwns

In fact, Peart isn't an official member of the group.  He's just sitting in for a while until John Rutsey comes back.