Dog Fashion Disco

Let's take it one step at the time and try to get Knives Out! on PA seeing that they just released a new album. 

Knives Out! – Black Mass Hysteria


Edited by Rune2000 - February 18 2012 at 13:05

I think it's time Admin had another look at this rule whereby a rejected band can only be re-evaluated if they release new material or get taken up by another sub genre team. There are obviously several cases where bands have been rejected by previous incarnations of the evaluation teams, and the vast majority of members expressing an opinion believe these rejections to have been in error. Dog Fashion Disco is one example, Coroner is another that cropped up only yesterday. I believe that if a completely new evaluation team is in place from the one that rejected the band initially, and the resolve of the members of that team is sufficiently strong to vote unanimously for the band to be added - then they should be allowed to do so. This is after all an archive site, and if the archives have gaps in the database due to 'errors' on the part of previous evaluation teams, then it isn't entirely fulfilling its role as an archive site. A procedure needs to be made available to us so that we can correct cases such as these without having to wait for new material to be released by the band/artist concerned, material which indeed may never be forthcoming.

Edited by yam yam - February 17 2012 at 20:00

I know I'm late. I just came here to post in the suggest bands and saw someone else did first. Then I saw they were rejected which shocked me greatly. 

I just can't fathom them being rejected. They are the textbook definition of proggy avant-garde metal.

So a band that's basically the exact same is here and they aren't? That's...odd.

Edited by DisgruntledPorcupine - February 17 2012 at 09:42

Deathrabbit wrote: The really funny thing is that Polkadot Cadaver is already here and they are basically a less prog version of the same band.

It's not funny at all, mr. Rune would have come to slit our throats had we voted against them

Deathrabbit wrote: @Bonnek-I agree wholeheartedly. The really funny thing is that Polkadot Cadaver is already here and they are basically a less prog version of the same band. Sex Offender was almost radio-viable.

That's a pretty big almost!

Let's skip this discussion and hope that Knives Out will get added once their new record hits the streets!

^ Very good post, Bonnek.

^ we don't think like that here.

I support DFD for PA, and suggested it myself at one time (been suggested once before that and twice after that including this one), though I think I should have put it to the art rockers (Crossover or Eclectic) rather than having it go through the PMT (was rejected by avant before that).  Sometimes bands have been rejected when they probably should have given a move vote (after all, one team is usually not an expert on another team's category).  Adultery is PA relevant to me.

Edited by Logan - October 14 2011 at 16:33

Rules I guess. Something about decisions being final unless there is new information.