Led Zeppelin

Rob The Plant wrote: But Page's style remained throughout the yardbirds. When did he start in the Yardbirds? Yah the Jeff Beck Group, can't say I'm a big Rod Stewart fan. "If you think I'm sexy..."

 That happened 10 years later. 

 He used to sing the blues once upon a time and sang them well. Check out some early Faces and the affor mentioned Jeff Beck Group.  Also around 1985 did a sang on a remake of People Get Ready on a Jeff Beck CD Flash.  That was a great song.  Really give you an idea of how well he sang the blues (also some great guitar by Beck).  

To nswer your question Rob.

Page entered the Yardbirds after the departure of eric Clapton *(introduced to the band by EC), and played bass (Jeff was the lead guitarist) untill the departure of Jeff, then he became the lead guitarist.

He was with the yardbirds from early 1966 to 1969, forming Led Zep from the ruins of that band (the new yardbirds, they had to fullfill some concert obligations)

Rob The Plant wrote: Yardbirds- Cream                    Zeppelin Yardbirds first, yardbirds turn into The New Yardbirds, which became Zeppelin. Cream arose around the same tiem, they were influenced by eachother. Mighty Different.

Rob, Cream started in 1966 and Ended in 1969 when Led Zep 1 came out.  Also, a big influence on Led Zep was The Jeff Beck Group with Rod Stewart on vocals that released Truth in 1967. No need to be upset about it.  Led Zep picked up the ball and ran further and longer than either of the groups went.  They perfected that type of blues based rock.

Yardbirds- Cream  

                 Zeppelin

Yardbirds first, yardbirds turn into The New Yardbirds, which became Zeppelin. Cream arose around the same tiem, they were influenced by eachother. Mighty Different.                                                                                                    

sigh, I've been through this whole add led zep thing three times since ive joined. here we go again.

Although Led Zepplin is good, they are not really much more than good ol' fashioned rock and roll. (with the exception of a few scattered songs.)  They do have thier own sound by, I would say, Led Zepplin 4 but just because they sound different doesnt mean that they are progressive. Rush did start out wanting to be like zepplin. to be exact Zepplin meets Yes, and Yes is prog. I think Zepplin started out as Cream wannabes with high pitched vocals. Remember what you said on the radiohead discussion "Just because you like them doesnt mean they are prog."

I could say alot more, but i dont want to damage any feelings.

danbo wrote: Speaking of Led Zeppelin, shouldn't John Paul Jones be here? Zooma and the Thunderchief are much more progressive than LZ. I think JPJ was the prog link in Led Zep. Some of his keyboard work, especially No Quarter, was pretty over the top. A multi-instrumentalist who was very underappreciated in that band.

One of the most underrated Artists I can think of, Zeppelin's most progressive work was done by him, and I've often thought that his non Zeppelin work must reflect his progressiveness. I'll check out Zooma and Thunderchief, never heard them. Thnaks for that note!

Speaking of Led Zeppelin, shouldn't John Paul Jones be here?

Zooma and the Thunderchief are much more progressive than LZ. I think JPJ was the prog link in Led Zep. Some of his keyboard work, especially No Quarter, was pretty over the top. A multi-instrumentalist who was very underappreciated in that band.  

Rob The Plant wrote: gdub411 wrote: Well I applaud you for your undying loyalty to your #1 band and cannot fault your fervor to have them included but they simply are a tremendously talented hard rock band. and even at his age Robert Plant is still a looker right Gdub?

That old geezer even looks worse than Greg Lake.

K00l Prog Guruz wrote: I think that wen you guyz put all thes e new bands to ad lists then it gets confusing for new proggers like me and stuff cuz then we really dont know wat it is to be prog. like i now know that phil collins isnt prog cuz you cabn just tell and i think zepelin (i heard some stuff0 isnt prog so stop trying to add to much, cuz it makes it harder for young proggers l;ike me to know what it is. just cuz zeplin is a bit like other prog stuff doesnt make them totaly so we shoud make this site ofr more just prog, and then we woud have a strong obvios line to not cross. thats what i think

well said Kool, I apologize, you've opened my eyes.