'Selling England' and 'Duke' suite?
Printed From: Progarchives.com
Category: Progressive Music Lounges
Forum Name: Prog Polls
Forum Description: Create polls on topics related to progressive music
URL: http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=132103
Printed Date: November 26 2024 at 07:48
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.01 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: 'Selling England' and 'Duke' suite?
Posted By: Frets N Worries
Subject: 'Selling England' and 'Duke' suite?
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 11:13
|
I'm sure as many of you know, Selling England by the Pound and Duke were originally supposed to each have a suite. As I understand it, this is how each of them would've been. (If I got anything wrong, let me know, I'll edit it) 'Selling England by the Pound Suite' (Comprising Parts of 'Dancing With the Moonlit Knight', 'Cinema Show' and 'Aisle of Plenty') I. Citizens of Hope and Glory II. Join the Dance! III. Britannia's Lullaby IV. Romeo and Juliet V. Father Tiresias VI. Earth and Sea VII. Citizens of Hope and Glory (Reprise) / Aisle of Plenty And of Course, Duke's Suite (About 28 Minutes) I. Behind the Lines II. Duchess III. Guide Vocal IV. Turn it On Again V. Duke's Travels VI. Duke's End Personally, I think the track list for Selling England by the Pound is perfect, but I think Duke's suite could've been amazing. As far as I'm aware, there were no other planned and not fulfilled suites in the Genesis catalouge. Thoughts? ------------- The Wheel of Time Turns, and Ages come and pass. What was, what will be, and what is, may yet fall under the shadow. Let the Dragon ride again on the winds of time... |
Replies:
Posted By: Sean Trane
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 12:58
Never heard of this one (but the Duke suite was indeed in the works), but I like this idea, but not sure about how the tracks would've been reshuffled, though. I guess Firth would've been relegated to the flipside along with the horrible MFM Though it's hard to believe Epping Forest would have been left out of it (the suite), but in a way, it is its own suite. . ------------- let's just stay above the moral melee prefer the sink to the gutter keep our sand-castle virtues content to be a doer as well as a thinker, prefer lifting our pen rather than un-sheath our sword |
Frets N Worries wrote:Posted By: Mormegil
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 12:59
|
Neither. Totally biased, but I dig both just they way they are. ------------- Welcome to the middle of the film. |
Posted By: progaardvark
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 13:06
|
Both. They should have went with their instincts. Ditto to the Naminanu/Dodo/Lurker/Submarine suite idea they had. Part of what's wrong with me is that I have a porch in my stomach and my stomach has too many knees. ------------- ---------- i'm shopping for a new oil-cured sinus bag that's a happy bag of lettuce this car smells like cartilage nothing beats a good video about fractions |
Posted By: Steve Wyzard
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 13:09
|
Until reading this post, I was completely unaware that Selling England was originally going to have a suite, even though I have a lot of literature about the band's history. I think the album works flawlessly as it is, with the "Citizens of Hope and Glory" theme at both the beginning and end of the album. It's "cyclical". I was aware of Duke originally having a suite because the band performed it that way on that album's tour. To this day, I've never heard an explanation as to what this suite is actually about, as the lyrics tell a story from a number of different viewpoints. As to whether they should have included the suites on these albums, I've voted "neither". The band explained that the Duke suite was broken up because it would have made the album "unbalanced": one suite of six connected songs on one side, and six stand-alone songs on the other. I agree with this view, as the track listing on both albums works perfectly (although I still wish "Heathaze" and "Please Don't Ask" would have been excluded from Duke, which runs way too long). Right before Duke, Mike Rutherford recorded his Smallcreep's Day album, which has a suite on one side, and five stand-alone songs on the other. This album also works perfectly as is, although in the UK, the suite is "side one", while in the USA, the suite is "side two". Of course, after listening to these albums for 35+ years, we become very comfortable with our ingrained listening experiences!
|
Posted By: Big Sky
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 15:01
|
The album that would have benefited from a suite was Abacab. The Naminanu/ Dodo/ Lurker/ Submarine suite that was being considered is quite good. Especially if it meant jettisoning the awful Who Dunnit? on the second side and the not much better Like it or Not. The approximately 16 minute long Naminanu/ Dodo/ Lurker/ Submarine suite to go along with Man on the Corner would have for a good second side to go with a pretty good first side. I voted neither for this poll. |
Posted By: Catcher10
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 18:04
|
I think each should have been a 4-LP set, with 2 of the LPs being one suite.......Phuck it! -------------   
|
Posted By: Manuel
Date Posted: November 22 2023 at 22:48
| SEBTP is quite a record, hard to improve. Duke, on the other hand, could use some help to make it better, so probably a suite would have been good, depending on how it would have developed. |
Posted By: Awesoreno
Date Posted: November 23 2023 at 00:57
|
The lads did play the Selling England "suite" live, considering they would play Dancing and then immediately play Cinema Show in '73. This changed after Peter started adding an intro with an explanation of the story of Cinema Show. The explanation of the Duke suite by Phil can be heard if you watch the Live at Lyceum '80 concert video.
|
Posted By: Octopus II
Date Posted: November 23 2023 at 01:14
Neither, I like them as they are. 
|
Posted By: Cristi
Date Posted: November 23 2023 at 05:18
This |
Posted By: richardh
Date Posted: November 23 2023 at 05:19
|
I tend to think like Steve Vyzard that Duke would have been better if it had been shorter. Back in the day (when I could be bothered to program a CD player) I would listen to a 36 minute version of Duke which was pretty much the Duke suite plus Man Of Our Times and Misunderstanding. I always thought of that as a suite in some ways as it still follows a narrative of sorts. (someone 'lost' trying to find their way). The rest is just a lot of padding really. Not then biggest fan of SEBTP nowadays (Epping Forest  ) but don't see any reason to have a suite. It's kinda of a 3 star album to me and by far the weakest of the most vaunted prog albums from that time. (NC, Foxtrot, Lamb and Trick are all stronger releases IMO)Voted neither.
|
Posted By: Sean Trane
Date Posted: November 23 2023 at 06:05
TBH, all genesis albums since Foxtrot were above 50 minutes (even Lamb bad 94 minutes over two disc, which is an hefty 47'+ per disc), so I didn't think Duke was especially lengthy (well it is 55', which 90" longer than ATTWT). However, indeed both of Duke & ATTWT can give the overlong feeling, but it's more to do with the quality of the songwriting. I don't think anyone complains that SEBTP is 53:40 or that W&W is 50:30, because we like/love them both. So if we feel that ATTWT & Duke are, it's because the songs are weaker and album cohesiveness isn't there as much. ------------- let's just stay above the moral melee prefer the sink to the gutter keep our sand-castle virtues content to be a doer as well as a thinker, prefer lifting our pen rather than un-sheath our sword |
Posted By: twosteves
Date Posted: November 24 2023 at 07:36
| I did a playlist with Duke suite - but agree with Manuel SEBTP is perfect— for me the Duke suite songs are the best on the album - a side two of the other songs might sound weak. |
Posted By: richardh
Date Posted: November 25 2023 at 00:27
I've always considered ATTWT to be one of Genesis strongest albums from a writing perspective. I don't honestly hear any filler or wasted moments, even FYFM is an okay pop track unlike the filler on Duke. However soundwise less so and it brought nothing knew to the party (although the 'party' was fizzling out at the time and the host was left to put all the bottles in the recycling bin, ok that's a ropey anology for the decline of prog generally in 1978)
|
Posted By: Dellinger
Date Posted: November 27 2023 at 23:45
| I guess it would have been a sad loss to have had only parts of those Selling England songs instead of the whole thing, so interesting as it might have been, I guess it's better the way the album ended up. As for Duke, I'm not sure it would have worked as a single song within the album, but given how they liked to do Medleys in their concerts, they could actually have disguised their Duke Suit live playing it as a Duke Medley. |
Posted By: Awesoreno
Date Posted: November 28 2023 at 01:22
| ^They did. As I said above, check Live at Lyceum. Phil explains the story between the tracks, but the suite itself is acknowledged and played in full. |
Posted By: Dellinger
Date Posted: December 07 2023 at 21:24
| ^ Nice. And where can I check that concert? Well, it seems there's something on Youtube. There's a Lyceum concert 1980, and I'm even seeing particularly the duke suit, but in London (also 1980). Let's see how it sounds. |