Printed From: Progarchives.com
Category: Topics not related to music
Forum Name: General discussions
Forum Description: Discuss any topic at all that is not music-related
URL: http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=124607 Printed Date: February 24 2025 at 17:33 Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.01 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: Something incredible happened in my lifePosted By: oliverstoned
Subject: Something incredible happened in my life
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 13:19
It has been a (very) long time since i wrote on PA forums. I’ve something i’m burning to share but i had to wait for a while before i can tell my story, to make sure about it. Now it’s time and it’s something not easy to explain. Ok, i’ll try to make it short. So sit confortably and take your time to read my story. It happened three months ago, in late August.
First i must explain that i’ve always been interested in various domains such as psychology (recently the Janov’s Primal theory), esoterism, spirituality, mysticism and so on. In the recent years, i read a lot about indian spirituality and own several books from indian masters. For about ten years, i’ve been following Sadghuru, and indian « guru » who is giving a lot of teachings, freely over Internet. I was hooked from the very begining and watched a lot of his videos over the years. I was agreing intelectualy with its speech but i didn’t tried to practice what he was preaching.
Until late August.
In August, i came accross several videos about a certain meditation technique, called « Shambhavi mudra ». It’s actually a 5000 years old « Kriya Yoga » practice. This kind of Yoga has nothing to do with the denatured Yoga practiced in the West, which is more about fitness with a hint of breathing and meditation. So forget all your pre-conceptions about Yoga. Let’s go back to the facts. So one day, after work, i decided to try this meditation technique (i had no experience in meditation, just a little guided relaxation & sophrology). Let’s precise that i wasn’t expecting anything special and was just curious. So i did the meditation exercise for only 5 or 7 minutes. Just after i was feeling nicely relaxed and it was promising. But the real experience beggined the next morning. I live in the countryside in the southwest of Paris and i’ve a long bus travel every morning to reach the train station. So i sat in the bus as usual and once i was properly installed, i looked at the view as i do every morning. Then the shock happened. I realized that the sunlight was totally different and that i was feeling extremely well. The sky was like a drawing. I instantly realized that it was the after effects of the previous day meditation. This pleasant state lasted the whole day so i was very exited when back home and was looking forward to try again « Shambhavi mudra ». So i did it again and longer, (21 minutes session) and the after-effects got stronger and stronger in the next few days until a « climax », a state of bliss & extasy which is hard to describe. Sometimes, i was so overwhelmed by joy and bliss, that tears came out and also laughters. Before, i was very much into pot smoking and i also did a lot of so-called « psychedelic » (natural) drugs such as mushrooms, cacti and other seeds so i’ve been through a lot of «altered » states many many times for decades. Hence my name on the forum.
The state of extasy induced by this meditation can be compared, in a way, to cannabis or mushrooms but is much more deep and powerful on another hand. Drugs are actually a poor copy of these effects but it can give you an idea.
I must also precise that the bliss state lasts the whole day after the meditation. Like if you pop a lsd pill that would act for hours and hours. But it’s something that you can control, it’s there but when you need to work or to concentrate on something, its stays at the background. Moreover, what’s incredible is that one is in full possession of its capacities, like never. And that’s a huge difference with drugs.
So how does it works ? There are many aspects but one of them is the pineal gland’s secretions through the sixth chakra stimulation.
Once the pineal gland begins to produce various chemicals in the system, everything is changing in the brain and the whole body, hence the tremendous effects. The numerous effects are both physical & psychological, such as incredible energy, reduced sleep quota needed, addictions such as alcohol and pot smoking that i was suffering from for decades vanished in several weeks…and also an inner strenght towards life, no fear of dying. So now i’m more & more into « spirituality » (sorry if it sounds pretentious), following more & more Sadghuru’s advices to get higher & higher. For example, i changed my diet and turn almost vegetarian now. What's spirituality actually? It is to experience a dimension beyond the body & the mind.
It has been an incredible change in my life, something i wasn’t expecting to be possible but that i was longing to at the same time. The greatest gift i received in my whole life.
I’m not here to convert anyone but just to share my experience. It'll not work for everybody but it can work for a lot of people. Only thing required is the desire to experience another dimension of life.
That’s all for today…Namaskaram to you all!
Replies: Posted By: NotAProghead
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 13:43
^ Thanks, interesting experience. Good if this technique works for you.
Always liked your nick anyway.
------------- Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)
Posted By: Shadowyzard
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 14:01
I'm definitely not interested, as I'm more of a peace & tranquillity guy than high energy guy. I don't aspire such experiences as you mentioned. I sometimes astral travel though. I don't actually try to do it, it just happens several times a year. (I had practised some techniques, and it granted me that ability but it has been far less frequent in the recent years.) As a materialist, I see it as an advanced type of dreaming. Like your psyche is disconnected and you're "living" a dream. The difference is, you're fully conscious, reasonable and in control. Only the settings and some of your visions can be bizarre or very scarcely scary. Like you did, I don't want to "encourage" people to try that. Conversely, I urge people to do the research and decide for themselves. I don't want to sound ominous but I see it as a possibility to be like the K-Pax guy. Think you went some alien place, but actually lost your mind.
I'm happy for you, and hoping that it is not a vitality consuming practice. Have you any information about the people who were/have been in this for a long time?
Anyway I'm not interested but it was an interesting read, thank you.
Posted By: Catcher10
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 15:46
Yes oliver, it has been a long time since you have posted here on PA.......Interesting story and seems to be helping you overall. Anything that can help to stop addictions to chemicals and alcohol is a blessing, that alone will bring you much more peace and control of your life.
Glad it helped you!
Cheers!
-------------
Posted By: JD
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 20:17
The brain is a powerful and mostly untapped organ.
Unlocking even just a few of it's drawers can be very rewarding indeed.
I've explored various techniques of higher being over the years.
Cannabis and music work for me.
------------- Thank you for supporting independently produced music
Posted By: rogerthat
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 22:49
Whatever works for you, man. I am not a fan of Sadhguru for a different set of reasons but the yoga techniques he teaches have helped people I know.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 23:14
Shadowyzard wrote:
I'm definitely not interested, as I'm more of a peace & tranquillity guy than high energy guy. I don't aspire such experiences as you mentioned. I sometimes astral travel though. I don't actually try to do it, it just happens several times a year. (I had practised some techniques, and it granted me that ability but it has been far less frequent in the recent years.) As a materialist, I see it as an advanced type of dreaming. Like your psyche is disconnected and you're "living" a dream. The difference is, you're fully conscious, reasonable and in control. Only the settings and some of your visions can be bizarre or very scarcely scary. Like you did, I don't want to "encourage" people to try that. Conversely, I urge people to do the research and decide for themselves. I don't want to sound ominous but I see it as a possibility to be like the K-Pax guy. Think you went some alien place, but actually lost your mind.
I'm happy for you, and hoping that it is not a vitality consuming practice. Have you any information about the people who were/have been in this for a long time?
Anyway I'm not interested but it was an interesting read, thank you.
Can you tell more about your astral projections experiences ?
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 18 2020 at 23:22
Thanks for your kind answers guys. What's strange to me is that there are a lot of depressed people, something like 40% of the population is under prescription drugs, and many others are just bored with life, anxious and so on... but almost no one seems to be interested by the kind of experience i m talking about. Why is it so?
Posted By: lazland
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 00:22
oliverstoned wrote:
Thanks for your kind answers guys. What's strange to me is that there are a lot of depressed people, something like 40% of the population is under prescription drugs, and many others are just bored with life, anxious and so on... but almost no one seems to be interested by the kind of experience i m talking about. Why is it so?
Because the vast majority of people do not wish to explore in this way. I am one of them.
I like to have a few pints of ale, and I smoke cigarettes. I have never taken any mind altering drugs. I won’t even touch pot. I am relatively happy with my puny little mind just the way it is, thank you. Just like the vast majority of normal, day to day living, hard working, family raising, under the cosh human beings.
You are right that there are some cultures where prescription drugs are an issue, and by this I take it to mean antidepressants. The latest figures from the UK show that 26% of the population had prescription drugs last year. Of these, 17% were on antidepressants, so the 40% you quote sounds to me like one of Friede’s statistics, i.e. a tad overblown. It is here more like 4% of the populace. Of the remaining 96%, an even smaller proportion will be hooking tabs, injecting junk, or snorting coke up their hooters, although the proportion of those regularly smoking dope will be a lot higher.
I believe in God. My wife practices Reiki healing techniques, and both of us are very interested in the spiritual side of both ourselves and wider humanity. Being rather dull, though, neither of us feel the need to get off of our trolleys in order to do so. Very boring, I know.
I did read your original post, but chose not to respond, because I have very little interest or sympathy in such matters. Without wishing to come across as po-faced or judgmental, I personally find the need to get off of one’s head constantly pretty weak and pathetic. However, being the freedom loving chap I am, whatever floats your boat is my motto.
------------- Enhance your life. Get down to www.lazland.org
Now also broadcasting on www.progzilla.com Every Saturday, 4.00 p.m. UK time!
Posted By: Shadowyzard
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 00:38
oliverstoned wrote:
Shadowyzard wrote:
I'm definitely not interested, as I'm more of a peace & tranquillity guy than high energy guy. I don't aspire such experiences as you mentioned. I sometimes astral travel though. I don't actually try to do it, it just happens several times a year. (I had practised some techniques, and it granted me that ability but it has been far less frequent in the recent years.) As a materialist, I see it as an advanced type of dreaming. Like your psyche is disconnected and you're "living" a dream. The difference is, you're fully conscious, reasonable and in control. Only the settings and some of your visions can be bizarre or very scarcely scary. Like you did, I don't want to "encourage" people to try that. Conversely, I urge people to do the research and decide for themselves. I don't want to sound ominous but I see it as a possibility to be like the K-Pax guy. Think you went some alien place, but actually lost your mind.
I'm happy for you, and hoping that it is not a vitality consuming practice. Have you any information about the people who were/have been in this for a long time?
Anyway I'm not interested but it was an interesting read, thank you.
Can you tell more about your astral projections experiences ?
Oops. It is a very long story. I first did it about 14 years ago...
At first, I tried to do that to try something completely new to me. I wasn't really believing in that. After I tried some techniques, it didn't happen. Then after some time, it began to happen by itself. As I said, it has become much rarer in the last years.
I concluded that, that experience grants somebody (at least me) what you exactly need that time, and sometimes what you ask for. Being conjured up in space and travelling between the stars in an incredible speed? Yup, it happened and it was extremely fun and exhilerating. Gliding above beautiful landscapes full of colour, coupled with sensuality? Yup, it was one of the best moments of my life. I even felt the wind. Yet, once, I wished to see the most beautiful and pleasuresome place in the universe, but I was conjured up inside a place like an elevator shaft where there were floating ugly brown sofas that were opening and closing their mouths. Haha. So then, I began to be careful about my wishes. Hahahaha. It can be also something sexually satisfying or disturbing...
I heard that some people use astral projection for some real purposes. I really never tried that. Like I said, I'm a materalilst. I have a broad mind, and can be convinced that I can witness a real thing in somewhere far away via this. But then again, I would only think that it would be like my mind does the maths, collects the info (like you can get from the internet, maps etc.) and some mysterious inspiration like data... Long story in short, I don't think that it is really an out of body experience. But it definitely is like your psyche is/feels like disconnected from your body for a short time.
Posted By: rogerthat
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 00:46
oliverstoned wrote:
Thanks for your kind answers guys. What's strange to me is that there are a lot of depressed people, something like 40% of the population is under prescription drugs, and many others are just bored with life, anxious and so on... but almost no one seems to be interested by the kind of experience i m talking about. Why is it so?
Let me give a suitably pompous/pretentious answer being that this is progarchives. Maybe the people responding here, myself included, don't belong to those sections of population. Maybe, contrary to the critics' constant lampooning of prog, it helps fill up our lives and keeps us sane. Whatever. I know that's absolute nonsense but to echo what Steve said, I don't particularly set store for other means to alter one's mental state either.
Let's see, I try not to gloat because this has been a very difficult year for many people. I have had challenges on the work front too but was never without employment and have retained my job into the last month of the year. Who knows what tomorrow will bring, maybe something could happen to get me fired but I will face it.
In the meantime:
1) Living in Mumbai which like New York has lots of public transport and terrible traffic, I never bothered to learn to drive all these years. I did during the covid lockdown and just in the nick of time because they started calling us once, twice and now thrice a work in the workplace and I am able to drive back and forth in rush hour traffic.
Just a little sample of what driving in Mumbai looks like:
2) I used this period to invest both in terms of equipment and technical training in my singing (and also my father who also likes to sing). I won't say who but I received a wonderful voice lesson from a Broadway legend. The lockdown had her twiddling her thumbs, presumably, and she used the time to offer lessons so I got lucky. May not have happened in a different year.
3) Spent a lot more time with family because of these circumstances.
Like I said, I recognize that I am very fortunate to be in this position and I don't want to gloat. I laid out all of the above only to make the point that it's not a given that ALL of us need or seek help or intervention of some form. Life has its ups and downs but mostly I am sorted, thank you very much. Tomorrow if it throws me a curveball, I will face it.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 02:07
Shadowyzard wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Shadowyzard wrote:
I'm definitely not interested, as I'm more of a peace & tranquillity guy than high energy guy. I don't aspire such experiences as you mentioned. I sometimes astral travel though. I don't actually try to do it, it just happens several times a year. (I had practised some techniques, and it granted me that ability but it has been far less frequent in the recent years.) As a materialist, I see it as an advanced type of dreaming. Like your psyche is disconnected and you're "living" a dream. The difference is, you're fully conscious, reasonable and in control. Only the settings and some of your visions can be bizarre or very scarcely scary. Like you did, I don't want to "encourage" people to try that. Conversely, I urge people to do the research and decide for themselves. I don't want to sound ominous but I see it as a possibility to be like the K-Pax guy. Think you went some alien place, but actually lost your mind.
I'm happy for you, and hoping that it is not a vitality consuming practice. Have you any information about the people who were/have been in this for a long time?
Anyway I'm not interested but it was an interesting read, thank you.
Can you tell more about your astral projections experiences ?
Oops. It is a very long story. I first did it about 14 years ago...
At first, I tried to do that to try something completely new to me. I wasn't really believing in that. After I tried some techniques, it didn't happen. Then after some time, it began to happen by itself. As I said, it has become much rarer in the last years.
I concluded that, that experience grants somebody (at least me) what you exactly need that time, and sometimes what you ask for. Being conjured up in space and travelling between the stars in an incredible speed? Yup, it happened and it was extremely fun and exhilerating. Gliding above beautiful landscapes full of colour, coupled with sensuality? Yup, it was one of the best moments of my life. I even felt the wind. Yet, once, I wished to see the most beautiful and pleasuresome place in the universe, but I was conjured up inside a place like an elevator shaft where there were floating ugly brown sofas that were opening and closing their mouths. Haha. So then, I began to be careful about my wishes. Hahahaha. It can be also something sexually satisfying or disturbing...
I heard that some people use astral projection for some real purposes. I really never tried that. Like I said, I'm a materalilst. I have a broad mind, and can be convinced that I can witness a real thing in somewhere far away via this. But then again, I would only think that it would be like my mind does the maths, collects the info (like you can get from the internet, maps etc.) and some mysterious inspiration like data... Long story in short, I don't think that it is really an out of body experience. But it definitely is like your psyche is/feels like disconnected from your body for a short time.
I bielive in God too and this is about experiencing the divine dimension
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 02:15
oliverstoned wrote:
Shadowyzard wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Shadowyzard wrote:
I'm definitely not interested, as I'm more of a peace & tranquillity guy than high energy guy. I don't aspire such experiences as you mentioned. I sometimes astral travel though. I don't actually try to do it, it just happens several times a year. (I had practised some techniques, and it granted me that ability but it has been far less frequent in the recent years.) As a materialist, I see it as an advanced type of dreaming. Like your psyche is disconnected and you're "living" a dream. The difference is, you're fully conscious, reasonable and in control. Only the settings and some of your visions can be bizarre or very scarcely scary. Like you did, I don't want to "encourage" people to try that. Conversely, I urge people to do the research and decide for themselves. I don't want to sound ominous but I see it as a possibility to be like the K-Pax guy. Think you went some alien place, but actually lost your mind.
I'm happy for you, and hoping that it is not a vitality consuming practice. Have you any information about the people who were/have been in this for a long time?
Anyway I'm not interested but it was an interesting read, thank you.
Can you tell more about your astral projections experiences ?
Oops. It is a very long story. I first did it about 14 years ago...
At first, I tried to do that to try something completely new to me. I wasn't really believing in that. After I tried some techniques, it didn't happen. Then after some time, it began to happen by itself. As I said, it has become much rarer in the last years.
I concluded that, that experience grants somebody (at least me) what you exactly need that time, and sometimes what you ask for. Being conjured up in space and travelling between the stars in an incredible speed? Yup, it happened and it was extremely fun and exhilerating. Gliding above beautiful landscapes full of colour, coupled with sensuality? Yup, it was one of the best moments of my life. I even felt the wind. Yet, once, I wished to see the most beautiful and pleasuresome place in the universe, but I was conjured up inside a place like an elevator shaft where there were floating ugly brown sofas that were opening and closing their mouths. Haha. So then, I began to be careful about my wishes. Hahahaha. It can be also something sexually satisfying or disturbing...
I heard that some people use astral projection for some real purposes. I really never tried that. Like I said, I'm a materalilst. I have a broad mind, and can be convinced that I can witness a real thing in somewhere far away via this. But then again, I would only think that it would be like my mind does the maths, collects the info (like you can get from the internet, maps etc.) and some mysterious inspiration like data... Long story in short, I don't think that it is really an out of body experience. But it definitely is like your psyche is/feels like disconnected from your body for a short time.
I bielive in God too and this is about experiencing the divine dimension
I think you're off topic. It's not about how you face your life with courage, it's rather that we're usually identified with our body, mind, emotions, material possessions, all things that will be lost, during life or in the death process. So we're limited with the survival process.
Posted By: Shadowyzard
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 02:35
I guess you're stoned!
You quoted me in both of your last posts; the latter being also a self-quote...
Which one was a reply to me?
I don't belileve in God, so I'm assuming your last post is that one. Or was it intended to be for rogerthat?
I think the only topic here is your personal expeprience... So how does one be on-topic except for talking about your particular case?
Anyway... I think that all religions, meditations and stuff lilke that are promoted to keep people under control. I don't say that their origin was meant to be that way. But they are sinisterly used to keep people in their miserable place in the world... Yes, the only way to keep the crowds from revolting is making them believe that they live a fulfilling life... using some artificial means like this. Am I on topic now?
As I said, I'm happy for you... But that doesn't change my idea about such stuff. Tools to keep the crowds under control, disabling their true nature, blocking their minds' real transcendental ability and substituting it for artificial methods of self satisfaction. I'm a materalist, but I'm the enemy of elite materialism... Deceiving people and enjoying the material pleasures of the world themselves. Our body is like a computer. Be careful your authentic soul is your real software and beware of the people who can alter the functions of your hardware!
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 02:53
Yes, i told you, i m stoner than ever. Confusion, indeed, i m typing those messages from my smartphone, not easy on the tiny screen.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 02:55
But if there's something that is not about following the cattle, it's what im doing
Posted By: moshkito
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 07:41
Hi,
I am, and have been for many years, an avid reader of a lot of things that lead to the areas that you mention and help one's inner constitution. However, I had to work 40/50 hours or more weekly to support myself and be able to spend more time in the areas that I love so much ...
I was born into a time of movies, classical music and theater, and then rock music showed up! My tendencies tend towards what a lot of people consider "weird" and "strange" because it is not of the cookie cutter variety and definitely not of the top ten variety of diet pills that you go buy in the supermarket!
To this end, when I started reading Carlos Castaneda, I realized quite quickly that it was not about all the dope visuals that were being described ... it was about the perception of it all, and most people got stuck in the drug fueled ideas and visions, and then a few years later ... they got upset when don Juan said to Carlos when he asked if drugs were needed ... "of course not you idiot, but we had to give you something to get you to shut up and see something else!". A bit blunt, but to the point and I had no ideas about it, and felt that it was an important lesson ... it was at that time that I was trying out a little of the colorful stuff, but I was not a grass smoker (never have been!) and was not interested in the harder stuff whatsoever. The psychedelics were attractive because I was very well read on a lot of literature going all the way back to Levi, Crowley, Fortune, Rampa, Gurdjieff, and many others, and they all showed a sort of visual thing that everyone seemed to be afraid of around me ... tripping on the music in the West Coast (before the big place went out in SF), was cool, but I found out realy quick that it was mindless and for the most part many of these folks were simply trying to hide from their daily grind ... and I knew from the visualizations that it should not be mindless and HAD TO CONNECT to the outer person ... not escape from it.
That I was into the visual arts, like theater and film, was no surprise. I saw in them an outlet for a lot of imaginary stuff and how it was interpreted and it is in these things that I have dedicated my efforts, though these days I mostly write ... with one exception ... I have in the past couple of years developed an uncanny ability to write a "novel" in my half/dream state and have finished many of them, although I have not (and likely will not do so!) write any of them down in reality. The continuity was awesome ... for example ... when things only got so far on one night, the next night I could continue from that exact moment ... and this taught me something about the writing thing when you can't come up with anything ... and the story moves on like there was no break. Nothing missing in the "set" (for example) or the conversation. No "lag" in the story which showed that you continued it three months later and the feeling is now different.
I have been writing a massive document on these things, and am not in a condition to describe it, or explain it YET ... but it is about developing some of these moments into something valuable and useful ... WITHIN AN ARTISTIC ATMOSPHERE.
Many folks here have seen me describe, non stop, details having to do with improvisation and other moments, many of which are defined through a lot of my inner "spiritual" studies. Some of these details are scary for many, specially musicians that have an idea that all music is dependent on the notes ... not anything else ... doesn't say much about how music was created, does it ... but these same folks don't consider that music ... they consider that child-less-ness. You have to know this and that and this and that ... and in the end, the truth is ... you REALLY DON'T ... you just have to experience it, as you describe ... and the sad fact is that many folks here are not willing to do so, based on their cozy situations ... I'm not finger pointing ... I would rather use that finger with paints on a canvas, see? So a comment here is not necessary about anyone.
------------- Music is not just for listening ... it is for LIVING ... you got to feel it to know what's it about! Not being told! www.pedrosena.com
Posted By: ExittheLemming
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 08:04
Just waiting for the ability to donate hard earned currency toward facilitating this spiritual epiphany amongst we shallow salaried materialists who frequent Prog Archives for a glimpse of Nirvana. Blow it out your ass oliverstoned.
-------------
Posted By: Catcher10
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 10:57
lazland wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Thanks for your kind answers guys. What's strange to me is that there are a lot of depressed people, something like 40% of the population is under prescription drugs, and many others are just bored with life, anxious and so on... but almost no one seems to be interested by the kind of experience i m talking about. Why is it so?
Because the vast majority of people do not wish to explore in this way. I am one of them.
I like to have a few pints of ale, and I smoke cigarettes. I have never taken any mind altering drugs. I won’t even touch pot. I am relatively happy with my puny little mind just the way it is, thank you. Just like the vast majority of normal, day to day living, hard working, family raising, under the cosh human beings.
You are right that there are some cultures where prescription drugs are an issue, and by this I take it to mean antidepressants. The latest figures from the UK show that 26% of the population had prescription drugs last year. Of these, 17% were on antidepressants, so the 40% you quote sounds to me like one of Friede’s statistics, i.e. a tad overblown. It is here more like 4% of the populace. Of the remaining 96%, an even smaller proportion will be hooking tabs, injecting junk, or snorting coke up their hooters, although the proportion of those regularly smoking dope will be a lot higher.
I believe in God. My wife practices Reiki healing techniques, and both of us are very interested in the spiritual side of both ourselves and wider humanity. Being rather dull, though, neither of us feel the need to get off of our trolleys in order to do so. Very boring, I know.
I did read your original post, but chose not to respond, because I have very little interest or sympathy in such matters. Without wishing to come across as po-faced or judgmental, I personally find the need to get off of one’s head constantly pretty weak and pathetic. However, being the freedom loving chap I am, whatever floats your boat is my motto.
Such an awesome post....
-------------
Posted By: Woon Deadn
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 11:16
Believe it or not, I never smoked anything in my entire 37 years' life. At one time I was going to buy a tin pack (too slim to call it a box) of Cafe Creme cigarillos 'cause I had once read Kerry Minnear (Gentle Giant's keyboardist, just in case) smoked Cafe Creme cigars or so in his youth. But there were only cardboard packs of Cafe Creme where I looked for them, there were tins of Clubmaster available - Kerry did not tell whether he smoked Clubmaster. I decided not to buy the cardboard pack - although perhaps Kerry bought quite cardboard pack. Who knows...
Of all the drugs we're talking about I only drank some alcohol, terribly strong green tea and I must say that being very tired, sleeping little is probably the cheapest and the most effective drug of all.
Anyway, as an Eastern Orthodox Christian, as a religious man, I know and see that any earthly, material addiction is not a good thing, at all.
------------- Favourite Band: Gentle Giant Favourite Writer: Robert Sheckley Favourite Horror Writer: Jean Ray Favourite Computer Game: Tiny Toon - Buster's Hidden Treasure (Sega Mega Drive/Genesis)
Posted By: Gerinski
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 14:11
Oliverstoned, what is this meditation about? what makes it different from other traditional forms of meditation?
Did someone train you? or you learnt it by internet?
Tell us a bit more about it, what does it consist in exactly.
TX
Posted By: progaardvark
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 14:44
I can't say that I totally understand what it is that you have accomplished, but I am happy for you and think it's very brave of you to have shared your experience.
Perhaps you experienced an expansion of your consciousness?
------------- ---------- i'm shopping for a new oil-cured sinus bag that's a happy bag of lettuce this car smells like cartilage nothing beats a good video about fractions
Posted By: Woon Deadn
Date Posted: November 19 2020 at 15:23
You may say it's my Eastern European specifics, but I always feel suspicious about that kind of things. Like, you are getting totally relaxed, lose/loose everything - and then heaven comes to your body and mind. "Why in the world should heaven come to my mind?", - asks me my post-Soviet consciousness. Again, being from the country of Ukraine that changed its borders numerous times (and we're speaking of the last two centuries only!), I may feel somewhat neurotic about the good coming for almost nothing.
I am actually afraid to be totally open to an unknown, unnamed Higher Force, Higher Power that may bear strange for my ear Indian or Japanese name. I'd rather beieve it is a devilish force than a divine force. It is easier to contact demons than angels - that's my view on the things.
Speaking of artistic inspiration, sort of channeling - I have experienced it a lot in my life. As I have already written somewhere on the forum, I do NOT play any music instruments - but I DO love making music. For the most part, my attempts are laughable (while certainly listenable for some people in some mood) - at times, I happen to create really professional sequences of several seconds to one minute or so using DAW's or even playing in the smartphone keyboard apps. It may be my very long and dense listening experience (I have like 50,000 mp3 files in my collection), but there may also be a factor of something coming from outside of me. There were cases when I just put several tens of notes in MuseScore DAW virtually randomly - and it produced an unexpectedly charming melody.
With poems it is even more tremendously evident. I wrote several books of poetry in Ukrainian and Russian. I know very well that sometimes poems just flow, words just appear. Once, the beginning of a poem came to me in the morning when I was still sleeping. Brain activities are miraculous.
------------- Favourite Band: Gentle Giant Favourite Writer: Robert Sheckley Favourite Horror Writer: Jean Ray Favourite Computer Game: Tiny Toon - Buster's Hidden Treasure (Sega Mega Drive/Genesis)
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 03:23
moshkito wrote:
Hi,
I am, and have been for many years, an avid reader of a lot of things that lead to the areas that you mention and help one's inner constitution. However, I had to work 40/50 hours or more weekly to support myself and be able to spend more time in the areas that I love so much ...
I was born into a time of movies, classical music and theater, and then rock music showed up! My tendencies tend towards what a lot of people consider "weird" and "strange" because it is not of the cookie cutter variety and definitely not of the top ten variety of diet pills that you go buy in the supermarket!
To this end, when I started reading Carlos Castaneda, I realized quite quickly that it was not about all the dope visuals that were being described ... it was about the perception of it all, and most people got stuck in the drug fueled ideas and visions, and then a few years later ... they got upset when don Juan said to Carlos when he asked if drugs were needed ... "of course not you idiot, but we had to give you something to get you to shut up and see something else!". A bit blunt, but to the point and I had no ideas about it, and felt that it was an important lesson ... it was at that time that I was trying out a little of the colorful stuff, but I was not a grass smoker (never have been!) and was not interested in the harder stuff whatsoever. The psychedelics were attractive because I was very well read on a lot of literature going all the way back to Levi, Crowley, Fortune, Rampa, Gurdjieff, and many others, and they all showed a sort of visual thing that everyone seemed to be afraid of around me ... tripping on the music in the West Coast (before the big place went out in SF), was cool, but I found out realy quick that it was mindless and for the most part many of these folks were simply trying to hide from their daily grind ... and I knew from the visualizations that it should not be mindless and HAD TO CONNECT to the outer person ... not escape from it.
That I was into the visual arts, like theater and film, was no surprise. I saw in them an outlet for a lot of imaginary stuff and how it was interpreted and it is in these things that I have dedicated my efforts, though these days I mostly write ... with one exception ... I have in the past couple of years developed an uncanny ability to write a "novel" in my half/dream state and have finished many of them, although I have not (and likely will not do so!) write any of them down in reality. The continuity was awesome ... for example ... when things only got so far on one night, the next night I could continue from that exact moment ... and this taught me something about the writing thing when you can't come up with anything ... and the story moves on like there was no break. Nothing missing in the "set" (for example) or the conversation. No "lag" in the story which showed that you continued it three months later and the feeling is now different.
I have been writing a massive document on these things, and am not in a condition to describe it, or explain it YET ... but it is about developing some of these moments into something valuable and useful ... WITHIN AN ARTISTIC ATMOSPHERE.
Many folks here have seen me describe, non stop, details having to do with improvisation and other moments, many of which are defined through a lot of my inner "spiritual" studies. Some of these details are scary for many, specially musicians that have an idea that all music is dependent on the notes ... not anything else ... doesn't say much about how music was created, does it ... but these same folks don't consider that music ... they consider that child-less-ness. You have to know this and that and this and that ... and in the end, the truth is ... you REALLY DON'T ... you just have to experience it, as you describe ... and the sad fact is that many folks here are not willing to do so, based on their cozy situations ... I'm not finger pointing ... I would rather use that finger with paints on a canvas, see? So a comment here is not necessary about anyone.
I don't get much of your post, but thank you for quoting Castaneda & Gurdjeff, among others, two major influences on my bookish spiritual path. I've been fascinated by Castaneda for decades, more recently Gurdjeff teachings were another major shock. Also the discovery of the Janov's primal therapy was amazing and i really thought that it was a sign and that i found the answer. But eventually, i was practically impossible for me to follow the primal therapy.
Now i understand that anyway this was a dead-end as the spiritual dimension is missing.
But the primal therapy helped me to understand why official freudian psychology doesn't work as it's only trying to suppress the symptoms and is unable to act on the cause which is on the emotional level. In the primal optic, only an emotional catharsis (to make it short) can free you from trauma that caused the neurosis we all suffer from.
A fascinating theory and a very accurate vision of the neurosis mechanism, but IMO, in no way it can help you to un-identify yourself to the body (the root cause of all other identifications such as genre, race, country...), mind & emotions. I don't even talk about material possessions.
All things to which we're identify and that will be lost sooner or later. Thus a feeling of unsecurity and a repressed fear of death in our culture.
Thank you for reading me, it's sunny outside, i'm going back to the garden to enjoy the state of Samadhi
Posted By: Sean Trane
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 03:57
ExittheLemming wrote:
Just waiting for the ability to donate hard earned currency toward facilitating this spiritual epiphany amongst we shallow salaried materialists who frequent Prog Archives for a glimpse of Nirvana. Blow it out your ass oliverstoned.
Iain,
Having met Oliver on three occasions (even spending an evening at his place some 10 years ago, reviewing his homebrewed hi-fi system) and knowing of his upper-bourgeois background, unless he's totally changed since, money is not Oliver's concern in these mystical concerns/quests (he was making a good living too).
Yeah, Oliver's mind-bending interests can seem a little tutti fruity, though.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 04:27
Hi Sean! Good to hear fom you!! I hope you're well?
I must correct what you said. I indeed coming from an upper middle-class intellectual "milieu" and i've the chance that my parents have some financial means (without being very rich) but younger i was far to be spoiled compared to my mates and my parents never paid a decent bike for example. I try to make it on my own and me & my partner have very low incomes and we've always been trough financial troubles because we don't manage our money and because i've no ambition, also i didn't find my way professionaly. I'm in the IT field, but i dont like that and i must admit i'm not very good in my job. I'm lazy, too. Talking money, i can even tell you that we've financial debts, so don't think my everyday life is so easy. I don't complain, i can only blame myself. But i'm lucky, despite that, i inform you that we eventually managed to buy a kind of flat/house three years ago (in Bonnelles, not far from Cernay-la ville, you remember), with the help of our parents but we pay them back every month and we've many years left to pay. I know a lot of much younger people (let's say 25) who never rent their flat and which parents paid them cash a better house than mine, and i don't talk about rich families. So i'me aware that i'm lucky but my material life is not easy. We've an old and cheap car (i don't care at all), we never have a penny to go on vacancies and so on. But i'm very happy with my material life, i eat organic, i still have my hifi system working, i buy a CD from time to time and i live in a nice region, i created my tiny garden in my new place.
The spiritual quest is for everybody anyway, the poor like the rich. There's no relationship, as, anyway, life becomes a delight in the state of Samadhi, whatever the situation (only extreme life situations like war, where survival is really a concern would make spiritual practice difficult).
I always loved your expressions, such as this "tutti frutti"
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 05:03
Gerinski wrote:
Oliverstoned, what is this meditation about? what makes it different from other traditional forms of meditation?
Did someone train you? or you learnt it by internet?
Tell us a bit more about it, what does it consist in exactly.
TX
Thanks a lot! We can eventually go furher.
It's called "Shambhavi mudra", it's a "Kriya yoga" practice, it acts on the energy body.
There's a lot to say about it, but one major aspect is the activation of the third eye (the "pineal gland", do some research) through the sixth chakra stimulation.
Here are instructions from the master's mouth, don't do it with the video, just note down instructions and try it.
Please read carrefully!!: if you can't sit comfortably crossed-legs ,you can do it on a chair like i'm doing on which you'll sit perfecty straight, use a pillow behind your back if needed. Put yourself in the direction of the East (important).
The emptier your stomach is when you do it, the better it is.
Prefered moments: early in the morning before 6.00 AM or during the sunrise, or during/after the sunset. But you can do it at any time of the day as soon as your stomach is empty. Don't drink coffee or tea the day you're trying.
One last major tip: it must be a pleasure in order to be effective and it must be done very softly. Take your time, have a maximum pleasure when doing it and don't expect anything.
When it works for someone, the full effects begin in general at the second day of practice. Put a timer on at the beggining of the session for at least 12 mn, 21 mn is ideal. When the timer rings, open your eyes as slowly as possible. You can do it as much as you want, the longer the better.
All details are crucial, so please take your time and do it intensly.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 05:08
progaardvark wrote:
I can't say that I totally understand what it is that you have accomplished, but I am happy for you and think it's very brave of you to have shared your experience.
Perhaps you experienced an expansion of your consciousness?
Yes an expansion. Thank you for your kind words, please read my previous post
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 05:13
Woon Deadn wrote:
You may say it's my Eastern European specifics, but I always feel suspicious about that kind of things. Like, you are getting totally relaxed, lose/loose everything - and then heaven comes to your body and mind. "Why in the world should heaven come to my mind?", - asks me my post-Soviet consciousness. Again, being from the country of Ukraine that changed its borders numerous times (and we're speaking of the last two centuries only!), I may feel somewhat neurotic about the good coming for almost nothing.
I am actually afraid to be totally open to an unknown, unnamed Higher Force, Higher Power that may bear strange for my ear Indian or Japanese name. I'd rather beieve it is a devilish force than a divine force. It is easier to contact demons than angels - that's my view on the things.
Speaking of artistic inspiration, sort of channeling - I have experienced it a lot in my life. As I have already written somewhere on the forum, I do NOT play any music instruments - but I DO love making music. For the most part, my attempts are laughable (while certainly listenable for some people in some mood) - at times, I happen to create really professional sequences of several seconds to one minute or so using DAW's or even playing in the smartphone keyboard apps. It may be my very long and dense listening experience (I have like 50,000 mp3 files in my collection), but there may also be a factor of something coming from outside of me. There were cases when I just put several tens of notes in MuseScore DAW virtually randomly - and it produced an unexpectedly charming melody.
With poems it is even more tremendously evident. I wrote several books of poetry in Ukrainian and Russian. I know very well that sometimes poems just flow, words just appear. Once, the beginning of a poem came to me in the morning when I was still sleeping. Brain activities are miraculous.
I know it sounds too nice to be true, but once you experience it, no doubt anymore. And you can be Christian or atheist or whatever at the same time. It's not about belief or about the mind, it's a dimension beyond. Anyway in the Bibble is said that we must find heaven on earth.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 05:25
Posted By: SteveG
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 05:47
progaardvark wrote:
I can't say that I totally understand what it is that you have accomplished, but I am happy for you and think it's very brave of you to have shared your experience.
Perhaps you experienced an expansion of your consciousness?
Most people who claim an expansion of consciousness
usually feel a sense of inter connectiveness with nature, the universe, other people, God, or whatever. And an arrested sense of isolation, if you will, along with a profound feeling of a mystical (I hate using that word as it carries so much baggage and is misconstrued) mystery that was not present before.
There are many ways that people obtain this uplifting feeling, be it yoga, meditation, deep prayer or the like. I can't help but feel that what works for one will not necessarily work for others. There are different keys that unlock doors of different people. I'm glad that oliverstoned has become 'enlightened' but even happier for others that have obtained this feeling of contentment with less effort. I also feel bad for those that never have and never will.
------------- This message was brought to you by a proud supporter of the Deep State.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 05:51
I totally agree with you.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 06:01
SteveG wrote:
progaardvark wrote:
I can't say that I totally understand what it is that you have accomplished, but I am happy for you and think it's very brave of you to have shared your experience.
Perhaps you experienced an expansion of your consciousness?
Most people who claim an expansion of consciousness usually feel a sense of inter connectiveness with nature, the universe, other people, God, or whatever. And an arrested sense of isolation, if you will, along with a profound feeling of a mystical (I hate using that word as it carries so much baggage and is misconstrued) mystery that was not present before.
There are many ways that people obtain this uplifting feeling, be it yoga, meditation, deep prayer or the like. I can't help but feel that what works for one will not necessarily work for others. There are different keys that unlock doors of different people. I'm glad that oliverstoned has become 'enlightened' but even happier for others that have obtained this feeling of contentment with less effort. I also feel bad for those that never have and never will.
Yes the connexion with nature is very intense, especialy the sunlight is felt differently (related to the third eye opening). The perception of sunlight feels like in NDE experience testimonies: it feels brighter, softer at the same time and it feeds you with extasy. The trees and plants feel like living creatures and the sky looks like a drawing.
Posted By: SteveG
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 07:15
Well, it's easy for me to talk. I've been interconnected since 1969. At least that's what my friends and family have told me. ;)
------------- This message was brought to you by a proud supporter of the Deep State.
Posted By: progaardvark
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 07:23
SteveG wrote:
progaardvark wrote:
I can't say that I totally understand what it is that you have accomplished, but I am happy for you and think it's very brave of you to have shared your experience.
Perhaps you experienced an expansion of your consciousness?
Most people who claim an expansion of consciousness
usually feel a sense of inter connectiveness with nature, the universe, other people, God, or whatever. And an arrested sense of isolation, if you will, along with a profound feeling of a mystical (I hate using that word as it carries so much baggage and is misconstrued) mystery that was not present before.
There are many ways that people obtain this uplifting feeling, be it yoga, meditation, deep prayer or the like. I can't help but feel that what works for one will not necessarily work for others. There are different keys that unlock doors of different people. I'm glad that oliverstoned has become 'enlightened' but even happier for others that have obtained this feeling of contentment with less effort. I also feel bad for those that never have and never will.
Thanks Steve. That's a very thoughtful and nice reply. My uncle has been exploring the combination of creativity and consciousness and has said similar things. Perhaps one day I will find that key that unlocks my door.
------------- ---------- i'm shopping for a new oil-cured sinus bag that's a happy bag of lettuce this car smells like cartilage nothing beats a good video about fractions
Posted By: moshkito
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 07:32
oliverstoned wrote:
... don't get much of your post, but thank you for quoting Castaneda & Gurdjeff, among others, two major influences on my bookish spiritual path.
...
Hi,
They are not the only ones, but (for me) two folks that helped interpret many things.
oliverstoned wrote:
...
I've been fascinated by Castaneda for decades, more recently Gurdjeff teachings were another major shock.
...
Neither is "perfect" ... and if I may say it, the biggest fault in all these studies is us ALWAYS thinking that something has a clue that is going to synthesize our own spiritual side ... this pure and utter bollocks ... since it is an individual trip and you have to find your own clues and your own paths.
Quoting this or that, or even primal this or that, is only helping confusing what you want to know ... you have to study what you have WITHIN ... not look at what you "think" is right or better, outside of yourself ... and this is the greatest clue to the best "teachers" ... they don't tell you something or other ... they help you synthesize your inner side.
oliverstoned wrote:
...
But the primal therapy helped me to understand why official freudian psychology doesn't work as it's only trying to suppress the symptoms and is unable to act on the cause which is on the emotional level. In the primal optic, only an emotional catharsis (to make it short) can free you from trauma that caused the neurosis we all suffer from.
...
You're substituting one reason for another! These, in their own right, have nothing to do with your own psychology and you associating yourself with an outside "IDEA" of what things are, only means one thing ... you are afraid to move along properly and correctly and are being spread thin on many paths that are not for you ... the only path that matters is the one you can see and define inside you ... the world of "leaders" and "subjects" is a world that defines the high from the low classes ... the ones who "have it" and the ones who "don't" ... and all you are doing is not realizing that. And thinking that something out there is for you!
oliverstoned wrote:
...
All things to which we're identify and that will be lost sooner or later. Thus a feeling of unsecurity and a repressed fear of death in our culture.
...
This is your condition, not mine or pretty much anyone else's, including what you might think as non-believers.
What will be lost is that you wake up and find that all the time you wasted on things that you junked because they didn't work, since you had no clue how to see and tell what would be right or wrong, and you had to go explore in the Akhashi Library for any information to help ... in the end, you never realized that the Akhashi Library ... was YOU ... not a building or a library per se.
------------- Music is not just for listening ... it is for LIVING ... you got to feel it to know what's it about! Not being told! www.pedrosena.com
Posted By: micky
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 19:30
oliverstoned wrote:
It has been a (very) long time since i wrote on PA forums. I’ve something i’m burning to share but i had to wait for a while before i can tell my story, to make sure about it. Now it’s time and it’s something not easy to explain. Ok, i’ll try to make it short. So sit confortably and take your time to read my story. It happened three months ago, in late August.
First i must explain that i’ve always been interested in various domains such as psychology (recently the Janov’s Primal theory), esoterism, spirituality, mysticism and so on. In the recent years, i read a lot about indian spirituality and own several books from indian masters. For about ten years, i’ve been following Sadghuru, and indian « guru » who is giving a lot of teachings, freely over Internet. I was hooked from the very begining and watched a lot of his videos over the years. I was agreing intelectualy with its speech but i didn’t tried to practice what he was preaching.
Until late August.
In August, i came accross several videos about a certain meditation technique, called « Shambhavi mudra ». It’s actually a 5000 years old « Kriya Yoga » practice. This kind of Yoga has nothing to do with the denatured Yoga practiced in the West, which is more about fitness with a hint of breathing and meditation. So forget all your pre-conceptions about Yoga. Let’s go back to the facts. So one day, after work, i decided to try this meditation technique (i had no experience in meditation, just a little guided relaxation & sophrology). Let’s precise that i wasn’t expecting anything special and was just curious. So i did the meditation exercise for only 5 or 7 minutes. Just after i was feeling nicely relaxed and it was promising. But the real experience beggined the next morning. I live in the countryside in the southwest of Paris and i’ve a long bus travel every morning to reach the train station. So i sat in the bus as usual and once i was properly installed, i looked at the view as i do every morning. Then the shock happened. I realized that the sunlight was totally different and i that i was feeling extremely well. The sky was like a drawing. I instantly realized that it was the after effects of the previous day meditation. This pleasant state lasted the whole day so i was very exited when back home and was looking forward to try again « Shambhavi mudra ». So i did it again and longer, (21 minutes session) and the after-effects got stronger and stronger in the next few days until a « climax », a state of bliss & extasy which is hard to describe. Sometimes, i was so overwhelmed by joy and bliss, that tears came out and also laughters. Before, i was very much into pot smoking and i also did a lot of so-called « psychedelic » (natural) drugs such as mushrooms, cacti and other seeds so i’ve been through a lot of «altered » states many many times for decades. Hence my name on the forum.
The state of extasy induced by this meditation can be compared, in a way, to cannabis or mushrooms but is much more deep and powerful on another hand. Drugs are actually a poor copy of these effects but it can give you an idea.
I must also precise that the bliss state lasts the whole day after the meditation. Like if you pop a lsd pill that would act for hours and hours. But it’s something that you can control, it’s there but when you need to work or to concentrate on something, its stays at the background. Moreover, what’s incredible is that one is in full possession of its capacities, like never. And that’s a huge difference with drugs.
So how does it works ? There are many aspects but one of them is the pineal gland’s secretions through the sixth chakra stimulation.
Once the pineal gland begins to produce various chemicals in the system, everything is changing in the brain and the whole body, hence the tremendous effects. The numerous effects are both physical & psychological, such as incredible energy, reduced sleep quota needed, addictions such as alcohol and pot smoking that i was suffering from for decades vanished in several weeks…and also an inner strenght towards life, no fear of dying. So now i’m more & more into « spirituality » (sorry if it sounds pretentious), following more & more Sadghuru’s advices to get higher & higher. For example, i changed my diet and turn almost vegetarian now. What's spirituality actually? It is to experience a dimension beyond the body & the mind.
It has been an incredible change in my life, something i wasn’t expecting to be possible but that i was longing to at the same time. The greatest gift i received in my whole life.
I’m not here to convert anyone but just to share my experience. It'll not work for everybody but it can work for a lot of people. Only thing required is the desire to experience another dimension of life.
That’s all for today…Namaskaram to you all!
wow man.. good to see back around. Yeah.. I've always thought that drugs were a bit of a crutch. Oh I loved them myself..they are an escape from reality.. and that is what I needed in that point in my life.. but did retain some self awareness that I was using them as a crutch.
see drugs do dim that 'shock' as you called it.. I found mine by walking a very thin line.. and expending a fair number of my 9 lives.. put myself and a mass of Detroit steel into a tree at 90mph and walked away.. got shot.. stabbed..broken bones in many a bar fight...and ended up with nothing more than some sexy scars... but yes.. that is reality man.. and reality is a very beautiful thing and nothing but near death experiences can make the grass greener.. the sky bluer.. you know.. make life more beautiful.
I did eventually move on from self destruction as therapy.. it was discovering the Hindu faith which led to meditation. spiritualism..and all that jazz and it has really centered me out. I don't have the bad dreams and PTSD I used to have.. and generally can relegate the demons of my past in the deepest parts of my mind.
great post Oliver.. and again.. great to see you around the forum again.
------------- The Pedro and Micky Experience - When one no longer requires psychotropics to trip
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 20 2020 at 23:52
HI Mick, thanks for your comment About drugs :"Oh I loved them myself..they are an escape from reality.. " Depends on which ones... The late Dr Janov has a very interesting view on that: He used to say that people using cannabis don't try to escape from reality but try to feel alive, to feel real. Because of our neurosis (that we're all suffering from), we can't feel real. So he says that to a certain extent, cannabis is good for the neurotic person because it allows him to feel something...of course it has its downsides but he doesn't think that cannabis consumption is to escape from reality.
According to Janov, hard drugs such as heroin are used to kill "primal" suffering on another hand just like pain-killers for physical suffering.
Posted By: Sean Trane
Date Posted: November 21 2020 at 01:22
oliverstoned wrote:
Hi Sean! Good to hear fom you!! I hope you're well?
The spiritual quest is for everybody anyway, the poor like the rich. There's no relationship, as, anyway, life becomes a delight in the state of Samadhi, whatever the situation (only extreme life situations like war, where survival is really a concern would make spiritual practice difficult).
I always loved your expressions, such as this "tutti frutti"
Doing OK, despite the lockdown driving me nuts (both in Bel and NL) and the GF's house renovation project going wrong (her fault at 80%) taking a lot of energy out of me.
Well as for your "spiritual quests", you know that as an atheist, I don't care for such philosophies, but I prefer that direction than churches and doctrines.
Posted By: rogerthat
Date Posted: November 21 2020 at 01:49
Sean Trane wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Hi Sean! Good to hear fom you!! I hope you're well?
The spiritual quest is for everybody anyway, the poor like the rich. There's no relationship, as, anyway, life becomes a delight in the state of Samadhi, whatever the situation (only extreme life situations like war, where survival is really a concern would make spiritual practice difficult).
I always loved your expressions, such as this "tutti frutti"
Doing OK, despite the lockdown driving me nuts (both in Bel and NL) and the GF's house renovation project going wrong (her fault at 80%) taking a lot of energy out of me.
Well as for your "spiritual quests", you know that as an atheist, I don't care for such philosophies, but I prefer that direction than churches and doctrines.
I am from India. I know something about Sadhguru and have watched his 'evolution' with both intrigue and dismay. I would dare say his world is a cult and not much better than churches or doctrines. It IS less dangerous, so far, than Rajneesh but essentially an English-speaking cult for the educated and affluent set as Rajneesh was (as opposed to mass cults like the now disgraced Asaram Bapu). It is less ambitious in targeting wounded corporate warriors and their stress levels as opposed to offering a radical new way of life that embraced everything in excess, from sex to limousines, after critiquing Western civilization for said sin.
However, oliverstoned has the benefit of distance - physical and cultural - from Sadhguru and his teachings and therefore the flexibility to adapt his teachings to his own circumstances.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 21 2020 at 02:53
Sean Trane wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Hi Sean! Good to hear fom you!! I hope you're well?
The spiritual quest is for everybody anyway, the poor like the rich. There's no relationship, as, anyway, life becomes a delight in the state of Samadhi, whatever the situation (only extreme life situations like war, where survival is really a concern would make spiritual practice difficult).
I always loved your expressions, such as this "tutti frutti"
Doing OK, despite the lockdown driving me nuts (both in Bel and NL) and the GF's house renovation project going wrong (her fault at 80%) taking a lot of energy out of me.
Well as for your "spiritual quests", you know that as an atheist, I don't care for such philosophies, but I prefer that direction than churches and doctrines.
Are you still doing the same job and living in the same place? How is the lockdown overthere? I mean total or light like it is here right now ?
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 21 2020 at 02:57
rogerthat wrote:
Sean Trane wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Hi Sean! Good to hear fom you!! I hope you're well?
The spiritual quest is for everybody anyway, the poor like the rich. There's no relationship, as, anyway, life becomes a delight in the state of Samadhi, whatever the situation (only extreme life situations like war, where survival is really a concern would make spiritual practice difficult).
I always loved your expressions, such as this "tutti frutti"
Could you please elaborate on the Sadghuru cult? What i Can tell is that he gives his wisdom for free, that his organisation has planted billions of trees in India... Osho was more controversial it seems but looked an authentic master as well
Doing OK, despite the lockdown driving me nuts (both in Bel and NL) and the GF's house renovation project going wrong (her fault at 80%) taking a lot of energy out of me.
Well as for your "spiritual quests", you know that as an atheist, I don't care for such philosophies, but I prefer that direction than churches and doctrines.
I am from India. I know something about Sadhguru and have watched his 'evolution' with both intrigue and dismay. I would dare say his world is a cult and not much better than churches or doctrines. It IS less dangerous, so far, than Rajneesh but essentially an English-speaking cult for the educated and affluent set as Rajneesh was (as opposed to mass cults like the now disgraced Asaram Bapu). It is less ambitious in targeting wounded corporate warriors and their stress levels as opposed to offering a radical new way of life that embraced everything in excess, from sex to limousines, after critiquing Western civilization for said sin.
However, oliverstoned has the benefit of distance - physical and cultural - from Sadhguru and his teachings and therefore the flexibility to adapt his teachings to his own circumstances.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 21 2020 at 06:04
Here's a second gift i received that i want to share with you, it's a Kriya breathing technique. Please sit in a chair with a cushion behind your back if needed in order to be perfectly straight and put yoursef in the direction of the East with empty stomach please.
You can do it outdoor if the weather permits.
Listen to the video with eyes closed and follow the guided exercice. The effect is not as deep & powerful as Shambhavi mudra but is instantly felt if done properly.
Posted By: ExittheLemming
Date Posted: November 21 2020 at 07:02
oliverstoned wrote:
Here's a second gift i received that i want to share with you, it's a Kriya breathing technique. Please sit in a chair with a cushion behind your back if needed in order to be perfectly straight and put yoursef in the direction of the East with empty stomach please. You can do it outdoor if the weather permits.
Listen to the video with eyes closed and follow the guided exercice. The effect is not as deep & powerful as Shambhavi mudra but is instantly felt if done properly.
The only thing that my home country (Scotland) could really use, rather than your mystical hippy w**k-mongering is a roof. This probably explains the skepticism we extend towards any first world entreaties to
open our minds to the possibility that levitation can be attained in gale force wind conditions. Scottish Rom-Coms would resemble torture porn and our tenderest love songs would make death metal sound conciliatory. Even our national flower (the humble thistle) is technically a weed and if you put one of those in your hair your scalp will bleed. We too have the Glaswegian breathing technique where those who are deemed to be charlatans and sellers of snake oil quackery are asked to hold their breath for say (30 or 40 minutes usually suffices) to make the universe a better place.
-------------
Posted By: lazland
Date Posted: November 21 2020 at 07:47
ExittheLemming wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Here's a second gift i received that i want to share with you, it's a Kriya breathing technique. Please sit in a chair with a cushion behind your back if needed in order to be perfectly straight and put yoursef in the direction of the East with empty stomach please. You can do it outdoor if the weather permits.
Listen to the video with eyes closed and follow the guided exercice. The effect is not as deep & powerful as Shambhavi mudra but is instantly felt if done properly.
The only thing that my home country (Scotland) could really use, rather than your mystical hippy w**k-mongering is a roof. This probably explains the skepticism we extend towards any first world entreaties to
open our minds to the possibility that levitation can be attained in gale force wind conditions. Scottish Rom-Coms would resemble torture porn and our tenderest love songs would make death metal sound conciliatory. Even our national flower (the humble thistle) is technically a weed and if you put one of those in your hair your scalp will bleed. We too have the Glaswegian breathing technique where those who are deemed to be charlatans and sellers of snake oil quackery are asked to hold their breath for say (30 or 40 minutes usually suffices) to make the universe a better place.
Yep, and it is the same here in Land of the Sheep. Throughly bloody miserable and set for the day.
------------- Enhance your life. Get down to www.lazland.org
Now also broadcasting on www.progzilla.com Every Saturday, 4.00 p.m. UK time!
Posted By: dr wu23
Date Posted: November 22 2020 at 10:37
Well....I think 'Oliverstoned' lives up to his name.....
But all kidding aside, I spent from 1969 to about 1989 reading and practicing various eastern meditative and religious paths inlcuding Vedanta, Zen bench sitting, and various forms of mantra and breath work (hence my avatar). I found it relaxing and interesting ...never reached any state of enlightenment ,but then maybe I was simply not very good at it. I also looked into several western occult traditions including Gurdjieff.
Millions of people use various religious ideas and techniques to achieve some kind of peace..more power to them, but what I learned early on from reading Krishnamurti, Watts, Ram Dass and other wise people is not to 'get attached' to the method of what you are doing...don't let it use you but you use it to get 'free'.
"The sharp edge of a razor is difficult to pass over ; thus the wise say the path to salvation is hard."
Katha Upanishad
------------- One does nothing yet nothing is left undone. Haquin
Posted By: Woon Deadn
Date Posted: November 22 2020 at 11:38
I experienced some type of trance several times. I remember once standing in the church (Orthodox Christians, at least in the former Soviet Union's territory, stand during the liturgy) with my father on Sunday I felt something like trance. Time flew very fast, I understood everything around me, but I definitely felt otherworldly.
------------- Favourite Band: Gentle Giant Favourite Writer: Robert Sheckley Favourite Horror Writer: Jean Ray Favourite Computer Game: Tiny Toon - Buster's Hidden Treasure (Sega Mega Drive/Genesis)
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 22 2020 at 12:48
However, i must precise that the state of "enlightment" i'm experiencing is temporary and will dissipate if i stop my daily practice. A state is anyway by essence temporary. What i'm experiencing is "just" a stage of Samadhi and not of the highest level but it's already a dramatic difference compared to my psychological state before i begin the practice.
Posted By: moshkito
Date Posted: November 22 2020 at 13:13
dr wu23 wrote:
....
and other wise people is not to 'get attached' to the method of what you are doing...don't let it use you but you use it to get 'free'.
...
Hi,
This is the hard part of it all ... the "need" to think that what they do is more important than anything else ... and the person saying it, does not even realize, that this is but one small step in the thousands that have to be taken ... but at his pace and idea of it all, he will quit the whole thing in a few months when the baby in the family is born ... and you can't quite find time to meditate (instead of thinking you are the oracle for PA!!!!) ... in order to take your studies another step.
But counting the steps is fruitless, because everyone's internal constitution is different and some can do one thing easier than others and vice versa!
To me, it's what defines a "follower" ... and not a teacher or helper that can assert/verify your own improvement.
As Dr. P. L. Nelson used to say in his lectures 40 years ago ... you create all kinds of boxes to get into (your preferred methods for anything) and then one day, you get to the end and you can't find the box to remove all boxes forever!
Welcome to your mindless mind!
------------- Music is not just for listening ... it is for LIVING ... you got to feel it to know what's it about! Not being told! www.pedrosena.com
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 26 2020 at 11:56
About the pineal gland, from Wikipedia:
"Society and culture
Diagram of the operation of the pineal gland for Descartes in the Treatise of Man (figure published in the edition of 1664) Seventeenth-century philosopher and scientist René Descartes was highly interested in anatomy and physiology. He discussed the pineal gland both in his first book, the Treatise of Man (written before 1637, but only published posthumously 1662/1664), and in his last book, The Passions of the Soul (1649) and he regarded it as "the principal seat of the soul and the place in which all our thoughts are formed."[60] In the Treatise of Man, Descartes described conceptual models of man, namely creatures created by God, which consist of two ingredients, a body and a soul.[60][61] In the Passions, Descartes split man up into a body and a soul and emphasized that the soul is joined to the whole body by "a certain very small gland situated in the middle of the brain's substance and suspended above the passage through which the spirits in the brain's anterior cavities communicate with those in its posterior cavities". Descartes attached significance to the gland because he believed it to be the only section of the brain to exist as a single part rather than one-half of a pair. Most of Descartes's basic anatomical and physiological assumptions were totally mistaken, not only by modern standards, but also in light of what was already known in his time.[60][62]
The notion of a "pineal-eye" is central to the philosophy of the French writer Georges Bataille, which is analyzed at length by literary scholar Denis Hollier in his study Against Architecture. In this work Hollier discusses how Bataille uses the concept of a "pineal-eye" as a reference to a blind-spot in Western rationality, and an organ of excess and delirium.[63] This conceptual device is explicit in his surrealist texts, The Jesuve and The Pineal Eye.[64]
In the late 19th century Madame Blavatsky (who founded theosophy) identified the pineal gland with the Hindu concept of the third eye, or the Ajna chakra. This association is still popular today.[60]
In the short story "From Beyond" by H. P. Lovecraft, a scientist creates an electronic device that emits a resonance wave, which stimulates an affected person's pineal gland, thereby allowing her or him to perceive planes of existence outside the scope of accepted reality, a translucent, alien environment that overlaps our own recognized reality. It was adapted as a film of the same name in 1986. The 2013 horror film Banshee Chapter is heavily influenced by this short story."
Another interesting point is that, during the first three weeks of practice, i knew some brief moments when the extasy was so intense that i felt that it was the limit of what i could stand.
Posted By: SteveG
Date Posted: November 26 2020 at 12:20
Ooooomm.
------------- This message was brought to you by a proud supporter of the Deep State.
Posted By: dr wu23
Date Posted: November 26 2020 at 12:28
'Thesophy' was founded by Blavatsky and others and they thought Krishnamuti was going to be their 'guru and leader' one day....but Jiddu 'realized' (as a young man using basic meditation and contemplation techniques common to to those in India) that Truth was bound to no specific path but was simply Truth.
They of course were disappointed that their 'guru' didn't wan't specific followers or a religion around him.
I have read most of Krishnamurti's books many years ago when I was young. They are excellent. And imho are the thoughts of someone who has realized the foolishness of 'organized religion' and attaching oneself to a speciifc dogma or path to the point where one becomes more concerned with the religious dogma, thre actual rules around the techniques, and other aspects missing in the end the point of 'getting free' or achieving what he called 'freedom from the known'. This can be done with simple meditation and contemplation and with the asking of questions about who you are and why we do what we do.
He said this in 1929:
"I maintain that truth is a pathless land, and you cannot approach it by any path whatsoever, by any religion, by any sect. That is my point of view, and I adhere to that absolutely and unconditionally. Truth, being limitless, unconditioned, unapproachable by any path whatsoever, cannot be organized; nor should any organization be formed to lead or coerce people along a particular path. ... This is no magnificent deed, because I do not want followers, and I mean this. The moment you follow someone you cease to follow Truth. I am not concerned whether you pay attention to what I say or not. I want to do a certain thing in the world and I am going to do it with unwavering concentration. I am concerning myself with only one essential thing: to set man free. I desire to free him from all cages, from all fears, and not to found religions, new sects, nor to establish new theories and new philosophies."
------------- One does nothing yet nothing is left undone. Haquin
Posted By: rdtprog
Date Posted: November 26 2020 at 12:42
We can all experience those kinds of ecstasy, enlightenment, joy,
happiness Are we able to live those moments every day, or is it just a
momentary thing? If we say that you have to practice each day to relive
those moments, what are those practices? And why not everybody can
obtain the same results? I think most of our happiness in life comes
from our own being. Are you always happy from the start or are you
unhappy? Then after that, you can choose your own practice. If you live
like a miserable human being, you'll find nothing in those kinds of
practices. Happiness is not at the end of the road, but on the road in
the present.
------------- Music is the refuge of souls ulcerated by happiness.
Emile M. Cioran
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 26 2020 at 23:49
Are you used to be overwhelmed by joy to the point that tears comes out ? How often do you experience that?
Posted By: Sean Trane
Date Posted: November 27 2020 at 01:55
oliverstoned wrote:
Are you used to be overwhelmed by joy to the point that tears comes out ? How often do you experience that?
That still happens to me regurlarly, especially when reading/viewing/hearing something very moving or meaningful to me...
but it's nothing to do with spirituality and the use of mind-altering substances is not necessary.
Posted By: rogerthat
Date Posted: November 27 2020 at 02:39
oliverstoned wrote:
Are you used to be overwhelmed by joy to the point that tears comes out ? How often do you experience that?
Number of occasions. When I heard a symphonic orchestra perform Beethoven's Ninth Symphony live in the auditorium. After the performance, I rushed out to the Marine Drive promenade in Mumbai (the hall is right on Marine Drive) and let the sea breeze envelop me as I gazed at the moonlit sky. I was similarly ecstatic after watching Shakti live or a show of legendary Indian singer Shreya Ghoshal. I have also similarly been overcome by the beauty of nature on a number of occasions. While it's not quite as natural as may appear, the first time I saw the Niagara Falls was an overwhelming experience.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 27 2020 at 02:43
Yes because you're a sensitive person. But what i m talking about is extasy without any external stimulus, except sunlight & nature. A higher form of Samadhi is extasy without any external stimulus at all. In general, spiritual practices are about reversing the attention from going outward to inward.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 27 2020 at 08:36
rogerthat wrote:
oliverstoned wrote:
Are you used to be overwhelmed by joy to the point that tears comes out ? How often do you experience that?
Number of occasions. When I heard a symphonic orchestra perform Beethoven's Ninth Symphony live in the auditorium. After the performance, I rushed out to the Marine Drive promenade in Mumbai (the hall is right on Marine Drive) and let the sea breeze envelop me as I gazed at the moonlit sky. I was similarly ecstatic after watching Shakti live or a show of legendary Indian singer Shreya Ghoshal. I have also similarly been overcome by the beauty of nature on a number of occasions. While it's not quite as natural as may appear, the first time I saw the Niagara Falls was an overwhelming experience.
I dont deny that you're able to experience intense emotional states in a "normal" state of consciousness. Attending to a concert or seeing the Niagara falls is a very good example: it's extraordinary because its totally New for your mind. If you go to the Niagara falls everyday, over a period of Time, it will not move you anymore. What i live for three months is very different. Ive seen trees and skies all my life but now there are alive, it's intense all the time, i dont need something new externaly. I understand it's difficult to get as long as you dont experience it...
Posted By: moshkito
Date Posted: November 27 2020 at 12:17
Hi,
Sad ... that someone is not capable of climbing a 1000 steps (or more) to see that the view from the skyscraper at the top is so different from the view at the bottom ... and this guy, is just stuck in one floor and I'm not sure he will ever see the top with its wider view and much larger perspective.
Plain meditations, visions and dreams, are not the end all ... these are the "doorways" to move on ... the issue being that many people find dragons at every doorway (like The Bardo!!!!) ... which is a wonderful analogy for the fear we have to take that next step.
Sad, that this guy does not see the bigger picture and is stuck in his "visual" fields and does not even realize that this is not even the beginning of it all ... but we already know the rest of the story ... usually ... nothing but just some more ashes and atoms for the universe! All else does not matter specially the idea that the mind is greater than the universe!
------------- Music is not just for listening ... it is for LIVING ... you got to feel it to know what's it about! Not being told! www.pedrosena.com
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 27 2020 at 22:14
You know i'm a huge music lover, so i'm not stucked with my visual sense
I don't read much joy & bliss between your confuse lines...
Posted By: moshkito
Date Posted: November 28 2020 at 09:34
oliverstoned wrote:
You know i'm a huge music lover, so i'm not stucked with my visual sense
I don't read much joy & bliss between your confuse lines...
Hi,
As if a message, or email, or these posts, were any kind of indication as to what is the way that things are.
There is no confusion in my lines, in that I see something that I went through some 30 or 40 years ago, but in my case my English was bad and I could not communicate a lot, so I kept it quiet and wrote instead. Later, I resolved a lot of it in theater and some film ... I sill did not say a whole lot about it.
But I know, that the road is not about one vision, or one feeling ... and you continually supporting that stand, TO ME, shows that you are not ready for the next step, and will have a harder time getting there that you (or I) would like.
I'm not a "new age" floozy ... and if you don't see the clarity in the lines, look in the mirror. You might find something, then!
------------- Music is not just for listening ... it is for LIVING ... you got to feel it to know what's it about! Not being told! www.pedrosena.com
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: November 28 2020 at 10:05
I don't want to loose my energy to get into an argument with you.
However i think i'm already into the next step, as i enter more & more into
inner silence and it's new to me. Something i've tried before without success
and seems much easier now.
Eventually maybe i have it all wrong on all the line.
All i can say for sure is that a tremendous change happened in my life and for
the best.
Otherwise, i would not have wrote this text.
Posted By: oliverstoned
Date Posted: February 25 2021 at 13:08
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 04:05
Since the age of 18 I have been experiencing mystical states recurringly, mostly when in contact with nature, but also through particular forms of art, poetry, and music, as well as in temples such as Gothic churches. Their essence doesn't fall into the sphere of worldly exerience and is altogether indescribable by human language. I have nonetheless attempted such a description before, which I have published on another website, and which I reproduce here:
...it felt like stepping out of this world and into another,
more real, more beautiful world; or rather, like lifting an opaque veil that
would cover all things, and revealing their divine light in all its splendour,
unveiling the endless, numinous beauty which lay within them and suffusing the
heart with a childlike joy. In this place, which felt infinitely more real than
anything that exists in what we regrettably call the "real world,"
the sensation of time would vanish, and matter would be transfigured into Spirit; and
each tree, each leaf, each flower, each stream, each moss-covered stone would
glow with a pearly light, and become alive, and every thing - my own Self
included - would reveal itself as being but a reflection, an emanation, of
that which even at that time I could only describe as "God." All was a theophany, all was One - and I was one with all; and everything around me was like a sweet, diaphanous, blossoming rose of glimmering twilight, soft and serene, and perfumed
with an angel's song. All was bliss - a deep, nostalgic, melancholy bliss of
such a nature as I will never be able to put into words - all was Love and light and shade... They were the most ecstatic, achingly
beautiful sensations I had ever experienced, and had a profound impact upon my
life: not only did they turn me from a radical atheist into a deeply religious
person, but they also impacted all of my personal ideological convictions -
social, political, economical, moral, aesthetical - which had now, somehow, become certainties. Here was an endless spring of Truth whence I could drink at any
time - I needed only to be surrounded by nature (or in any other sacred place, really), to
immerse myself in its contemplation, and it would pour forth its waters; and lo, every
illusion, doubt, and sorrow would suddenly be dispelled. I have never ceased to have these mystical experiences (for those wondering: no, I have never done
drugs), and to this day they have continued to shape my spiritual identity and
my relationship with the Divine.
Remember: we who have been blessed to witness Truth in its purest form within our very hearts must never take such a gift for granted, for it does not come from ourselves, but from God, and neither does it belong to the world of matter nor to that of the mind, but to the Soul, to Atman. It is a state of Paradisal bliss, and it is but a reminder of God and a path toward Him.
Posted By: suitkees
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 04:24
As soon as someone is writing truth with a capital T, I am getting very suspicious... As soon as someone pretends to know the truth, I am getting very suspicious... As soon as someone claims to know the path to truth, I am getting very suspicious... For me truth is man made, like (any) god is man made. That's my truth. And it feels good!
-------------
The razamataz is a pain in the bum
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 04:35
I am sorry you feel that way. But remember, just because something "feels good" doesn't mean that it conforms to Truth (with a capital T)
Posted By: suitkees
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 04:49
Oh, please, you don't have to be sorry. First, it comes over as very patronizing; second, really, I'm fine. I just don't believe there is Truth with a capital T, but if someone thinks there is and is happy with that belief, that's fine with me too.
-------------
The razamataz is a pain in the bum
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 06:29
I do apologize if I came across as patronizing, that was not my intention. As for the pseudo-philosophical sophistry of relativism (which is always and necessarily an intrinsic fallacy and inherently self-refuting) and which you espouse, there is no point debating it, so I will refrain from doing so (after all, relativist arguments have no place in genuine philosophy, for Sophia is its aim, and knowledge requires an object, i.e. a so-called "objective" truth to be known). Suffice to say that an ideological framework which does not allow for the existence of absolutes (or the Absolute - there's that capital letter again) can be no more than an intellectual void wherein all truths are equally valid for the simple reason that all truths are nothing but illusions - an "equality" which, like all modern applications of the term, is wholly horizontal and reductive, and thus bereft of all value.
Posted By: suitkees
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 10:56
Nice to apologize, but don't worry, I can take a sneer. Just don't feel sorry for me because I think differently than you do. But you're not making your case easier: you project a philosophical stance on me (relativism, but it's actually a bit more complicated than that...) in order to dismiss it then as "pseudo-philosophical sophistry" and a way of thinking that is "an intrinsic fallacy and inherently self-refuting." You're making your case even worse by stating that "relativist arguments have no place in genuine philosophy", showing that you have missed the boat of a lot of twentieth century philosophy (and 21st, for that matter) and apparently prefer to remain stuck in a 19th century stance of positivism that believes there is something of an absolute knowledge (the ultimate goal of every science and every religion...). You imply that something has to "conform to Truth" in order to be qualified as knowledge, but the correspondence theory of knowledge is very outdated and simplistic. I suppose you also dismiss everything that epistemology, phenomenology and hermeneutics have brought to philosophy these last 120 years or so, since they will very much shake your foundations of absolutism.
You're absolutely free to dismiss them, but my ideological/philosophical framework does indeed not allow for absolutes. Knowledge is by definition subjective (it is always the knowledge of someone; a shared knowledge is shared by a greater number/a sum of subjectivities, that we can also call conventions or agreements). That is not the same as saying "all truths are equally valid" and then concluding that "all truths are nothing but illusions" - you actually give a nice example of sophistry here. I believe in truths! Note the plural! I don't believe in one truth that is the absolute reference for everything; in my opinion that can only lead to dogmatism and extremism. And I am not alone in that thinking: there are even Christians taking that stance. The Italian philosopher, and god-believing Christian, Gianni Vattimo for example wrote a little book that might interest you, was it only to sharpen your counter-arguments if you wish: A Farewell to Truth (2009), with a chapter titled: "Only a relativistic God can save us".
You don't have to believe the same thing(s) as I do, we can still make a society. That is: if you accept that I believe something else than you and that you don't want to impose your Truth on me. I accept that you believe in your Truth, I just don't believe in it myself, and I will remain very suspicious towards everything you claim to be Truth or Knowledge...
-------------
The razamataz is a pain in the bum
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 12:52
suitkees wrote:
Nice to apologize, but don't worry, I can take a sneer. Just don't feel sorry for me because I think differently than you do.
Hey, I just like being nice
suitkees wrote:
You're making your case even worse by stating that "relativist arguments have no place in genuine philosophy", showing that you have missed the boat of a lot of twentieth century philosophy (and 21st, for that matter)
Most 20th and 21th century "philosophy" is actually the opposite of genuine philosophy. It is a love of ignorance, conscious or otherwise.
suitkees wrote:
and apparently prefer to remain stuck in a 19th century stance of positivism that believes there is something of an absolute knowledge (the ultimate goal of every science and every religion...). You imply that something has to "conform to Truth" in order to be qualified as knowledge, but the correspondence theory of knowledge is very outdated and simplistic. I suppose you also dismiss everything that epistemology, phenomenology and hermeneutics have brought to philosophy these last 120 years or so, since they will very much shake your foundations of absolutism.
You get me wrong, I am no positivist. I have zero faith in modern "science", nor do I believe that it can get anywhere near Truth; nor am I a rationalist in any way, shape, or form. See, there is a false dichotomy in all these modern ideologies which appear to contradict one another. Underneath their superficial contraditions, all the "-isms" of modernity have the same source and lead to the same end: they begin and end in darkness.
Is the aim of religion to attain absolute knowledge? Well, yes and no. This is really not the appropriate time or place to discuss that though, and it would be pointless.
suitkees wrote:
I believe in truths! Note the plural! I don't believe in one truth that is the absolute reference for everything; in my opinion that can only lead to dogmatism and extremism.
If the "truths" you believe in are indeed "true", they must either be the whole Truth or fragments, reflections of it. If the "truths" you believe in do not mirror or emanate from the Absolute in any way, they are therefore illusory, necessarily so; and you must accept that fact from a logical perspective, whether or not you are willing to.
By "dogmatism and extremism", do you mean in religion? Dogmas are (or should be) a central component of religion on an exoteric level. However, so-called "religious fundamentalism" stems not from a true understanding of said dogmas, but from the ignorance of their very nature and reason for being. "Religious fundamentalists" take the relative for the Absolute, and either cannot or do not want to realize that on the level of Relativity the Absolute can express Itself in an infinite multiplicity of forms, each one being just as true an expression as the other. Their error is to take the effects for the cause, and the outward for that which is inward.
suitkees wrote:
The Italian philosopher, and god-believing Christian, Gianni Vattimo for example wrote a little book that might interest you, was it only to sharpen your counter-arguments if you wish: A Farewell to Truth (2009), with a chapter titled: "Only a relativistic God can save us".
Vattimo is anything but a Christian, and whether or not he claims to be one is irrelevant. I appreciate the recommendation though.
suitkees wrote:
You don't have to believe the same thing(s) as I do, we can still make a society. That is: if you accept that I believe something else than you and that you don't want to impose your Truth on me. I accept that you believe in your Truth, I just don't believe in it myself, and I will remain very suspicious towards everything you claim to be Truth or Knowledge...
I admire your tolerance and respect for different beliefs. And don't worry, I am not trying to impose anything on anyone (not the least because Truth cannot be imposed, only comprehended). I dislike engaging in discussions of any kind, and I already regret having engaged in this one, for it could never lead anywhere, and the only good thing that could come out of it would be a better mutual understanding of each other's points of view, something which is really not worth the time and effort. As it is stated in the Quran (109:6), "Unto you your religion, and unto me my religion."
Anyway, hope you have a great weekend!
Posted By: suitkees
Date Posted: February 26 2021 at 14:35
Thanks. You too.
For me it is never a waste of time to better understand the reasoning of someone else but there's indeed no point in bringing this further since our views are worlds apart.
We may have more common ground regarding music...
-------------
The razamataz is a pain in the bum
Posted By: dr wu23
Date Posted: February 27 2021 at 10:10
"Truth is a pathless land, and you cannot approach it by any path whatsoever, by any religion, by any sect. Truth, being limitless, unconditioned, unapproachable by any path whatsoever, cannot be organized, nor should any organization be formed to lead or to coerce people along any particular path". ~ Krishnamurti.
------------- One does nothing yet nothing is left undone. Haquin
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: February 27 2021 at 12:36
suitkees wrote:
For me it is never a waste of time to better understand the reasoning of someone else but there's indeed no point in bringing this further since our views are worlds apart.
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to sound arrogant or to say that I have no interest in understanding your reasoning. I just don't think we could ever reach any sort of consensus on this matter, and when consensus is impossible discussion becomes an exercise in futility.
suitkees wrote:
We may have more common ground regarding music...
Oh, I'm sure we do! And I would rather focus on that indeed
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: February 27 2021 at 12:46
dr wu23 wrote:
"Truth is a pathless land, and you cannot approach it by any path whatsoever, by any religion, by any sect. Truth, being limitless, unconditioned, unapproachable by any path whatsoever, cannot be organized, nor should any organization be formed to lead or to coerce people along any particular path". ~ Krishnamurti.
Krishnamurti was a quite misguided individual concerning many aspects, including this one. Truth is of course "limitless, unconditioned", being in itself synonymous with God. But to claim that it is "unapproachable by any path whatsoever" reveals the profoundest ignorance, not only of the fundamental nature of fallen man and Creation as a whole, as well as of the hierarchy of Divine manifestation and the relationship between the Absolute and the plane (or planes) of relativity, but also of the most basic notions of metaphysics and even of God.
It would be more correct to say that the paths toward Truth are infinite (for an infinite number of lines may link a circumference to its center) than to claim no paths lead to it (which would make Truth absolutely unapproachable indeed) - and this is not by any means to say that every conceivable "path" is a valid one, quite on the contrary.
Posted By: AFlowerKingCrimson
Date Posted: February 27 2021 at 13:52
Hey, I like Krishnamurti. He was spot on regarding education and other things as well. I do think he went a bit loopy with meditation though. He thought that practically anything could be seen as meditation and that's just downright silly. Other than that he was a cool guy. ;)
Posted By: dr wu23
Date Posted: February 28 2021 at 10:48
SolNiger wrote:
dr wu23 wrote:
"Truth is a pathless land, and you cannot approach it by any path whatsoever, by any religion, by any sect. Truth, being limitless, unconditioned, unapproachable by any path whatsoever, cannot be organized, nor should any organization be formed to lead or to coerce people along any particular path". ~ Krishnamurti.
Krishnamurti was a quite misguided individual concerning many aspects, including this one. Truth is of course "limitless, unconditioned", being in itself synonymous with God. But to claim that it is "unapproachable by any path whatsoever" reveals the profoundest ignorance, not only of the fundamental nature of fallen man and Creation as a whole, as well as of the hierarchy of Divine manifestation and the relationship between the Absolute and the plane (or planes) of relativity, but also of the most basic notions of metaphysics and even of God.
It would be more correct to say that the paths toward Truth are infinite (for an infinite number of lines may link a circumference to its center) than to claim no paths lead to it (which would make Truth absolutely unapproachable indeed) - and this is not by any means to say that every conceivable "path" is a valid one, quite on the contrary.
Spoken like someone who has misunderstood Krishnamurti's point , has chosen a path, and thinks it's the correct one. This of course has biased and distorted the search for 'unconditioned truth'.
------------- One does nothing yet nothing is left undone. Haquin
Posted By: dr wu23
Date Posted: February 28 2021 at 10:56
AFlowerKingCrimson wrote:
Hey, I like Krishnamurti. He was spot on regarding education and other things as well. I do think he went a bit loopy with meditation though. He thought that practically anything could be seen as meditation and that's just downright silly. Other than that he was a cool guy. ;)
I read several of his main books many years ago...and watched a few old videos also back in the 80's.
Some great wisdom and insights into religion, truth ,and non attachment. I don't recall anything about meditation on 'anything' at all. Can you link to a part in a book or a talk that shows this or is this just a sense you got from his ideas?
------------- One does nothing yet nothing is left undone. Haquin
Posted By: AFlowerKingCrimson
Date Posted: February 28 2021 at 12:48
dr wu23 wrote:
AFlowerKingCrimson wrote:
Hey, I like Krishnamurti. He was spot on regarding education and other things as well. I do think he went a bit loopy with meditation though. He thought that practically anything could be seen as meditation and that's just downright silly. Other than that he was a cool guy. ;)
I read several of his main books many years ago...and watched a few old videos also back in the 80's.
Some great wisdom and insights into religion, truth ,and non attachment. I don't recall anything about meditation on 'anything' at all. Can you link to a part in a book or a talk that shows this or is this just a sense you got from his ideas?
I don't remember which book I read that in but I think it was a book he wrote on meditation. I just don't know where it is or if I still have it. He basically didn't agree with the idea of meditation being just this thing where you sit still and do nothing. In a sense I agree because if you wash the dishes and only pay attention to the washing aspect and don't let your mind wander in a sense that is sort of a meditation. He just seemed to get a little carried away with that concept though. Unfortunately, like I said, I don't know where that book is. I can send you a pm with more specifics if I find it though.
Posted By: dr wu23
Date Posted: February 28 2021 at 13:37
AFlowerKingCrimson wrote:
dr wu23 wrote:
AFlowerKingCrimson wrote:
Hey, I like Krishnamurti. He was spot on regarding education and other things as well. I do think he went a bit loopy with meditation though. He thought that practically anything could be seen as meditation and that's just downright silly. Other than that he was a cool guy. ;)
I read several of his main books many years ago...and watched a few old videos also back in the 80's.
Some great wisdom and insights into religion, truth ,and non attachment. I don't recall anything about meditation on 'anything' at all. Can you link to a part in a book or a talk that shows this or is this just a sense you got from his ideas?
I don't remember which book I read that in but I think it was a book he wrote on meditation. I just don't know where it is or if I still have it. He basically didn't agree with the idea of meditation being just this thing where you sit still and do nothing. In a sense I agree because if you wash the dishes and only pay attention to the washing aspect and don't let your mind wander in a sense that is sort of a meditation. He just seemed to get a little carried away with that concept though. Unfortunately, like I said, I don't know where that book is. I can send you a pm with more specifics if I find it though.
Ok...no problem. Meditation and the various types is tricky. There isn't one way only to meditate.
One can us a mantra, or empty mind type, or watching the breath, etc...to me his main point was not to get hung up on a particular religion or path and lose sight of the goal...which was to be free of these things in the end.
------------- One does nothing yet nothing is left undone. Haquin
Posted By: Shadowyzard
Date Posted: February 28 2021 at 16:49
I don't believe in any religion or God. Yet, I've been apathetic about such concepts, more than feeling resentment or hostility towards them, for a very long time. I think if I have to fit in a "belief category", it'd be apatheism.
The one below is one of my favourite quotes. Don't get me wrong, I see my intellect and wisdom as mine. You know? I believe in individuality and everyone has their own unique wits and they are not quintessentially "superior" to one another. In technical terms, we may have superior or inferior mental qualities, but I see IQ tests and stuff within the scope of the nuisance called the "Western categorization". As far as I've inferred; in technical, scientific etc. fields, categorization can be a very useful tool, but other than that, I see it like a sickness. This is a long story, so I'll not delve into the details now. I can give just one example though: I assert that a person with a solid geometry education can do better in an IQ test than a person without one... (I was once interested in these tests when I was "naive", and got quite high scores, by the way.)
Anyway, upbringing is a critical issue in being religious or not, I think. People who never experience religious imposition (like myself) or people who grow up with overwhelming religious pressure can easily become atheists; the former may naturally not be enemies of those concepts, while the latter can naturally and understandably be. As I said, we are all individuals, so my deduction concerning this matter is not exhaustive.
Anyway, some things incredible happened in my life too. Let them be a mystery here.
Posted By: CosmicVibration
Date Posted: March 01 2021 at 11:52
There’s only one Truth with a capital T.There’s only one Singularity... Everything else
is just a fragment of the One.
There is never a separation from the One, only a delusion of
it, which is very hard to get rid of.
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: March 02 2021 at 11:37
dr wu23 wrote:
Spoken like someone who has misunderstood Krishnamurti's point , has chosen a path, and thinks it's the correct one. This of course has biased and distorted the search for 'unconditioned truth'.
I have indeed chosen a path (or rather, God has appointed a path for me), but I would never think of it as *the* correct one, as in "the only valid one". To understand what I mean when I say Krishnamurti (whose worldview was fundamentally anti-traditional and intrinsically heretical and profane) was misguided, I highly recommend the book The Fall of Spirituality: The Corruption of Tradition in the Modern World by Julius Evola, as well as the works of authors such as René Guénon (who would most certainly regard Krishnamurty as an agent of what he termed the "counter-initiation") and Frithjof Schuon (particularly his books The Transcendent Unity of Religions, To Have a Center, and From the Divine to the Human).
I have no wish to start a lengthy discussion on this matter, being busy as I am, but I will leave here a couple of relevant excerpts by two genuine philosophers of Tradition, the first being Marco Pallis, who writes:
Krishnamurti (...) must be accounted something of a fringe manifestation of "the new
religions" seeing that he himself rejects, as self-imprisoning products of
a bad habit of thinking, practically all that the word "religion"
covers for an ordinary mind. For him there is no question of revelation,
therefore not of tradition either; doctrines or formal elements of any kind
which others regard as reliable supports for truth and as its eventual
catalysts in the soul are discounted by him as being no more than creations of
a wish to feel comfortable and secure; the inter-relationship between
Intellect—the intelligence uncreated and untreatable, as Meister Eckhardt put
it—and Truth on which all acts of discernment ultimately rest seems to be
omitted from Krishnamurti’s calculations so that, for him, the human task
reduces itself to a psychological process of self-observation sufficing unto
itself, a kind of "art for art's sake" from which all ascertainable
finality is a priori excluded as being but one more deception of the arch-enemy
"thought" (...).
If Krishnamurti showed good sense in breaking loose from the
grotesquely inflated role for which he was being briefed by his Theosophist
sponsors—for a young man of spirit, life under their ceaseless battery of adulation
must have been terribly boring—one may yet wonder whether, after that, he might
not have done better to retire quietly into the fold of his ancestral Hinduism
where his remarkable gifts could then have ripened in the normal way, and who
can say how far this course might subsequently have taken him? This is only
speculation, of course, since in fact the world-stage has continued to be his
field of activity: which leaves one with the thought that Annie Besant and C.
W. Leadbeater may, after all, have carried out their briefing more thoroughly
than they knew of, even if things did not work out exactly according to plan
from their own point of view.
And the second author being Whitall Perry, who addresses the topic of Krishnamurti in his essay Anti-Theology and the Riddles of Alcyone:
As a prerequisite for understanding his "method," Krishnamurti says it is essential that we discard all our previous thought reflexes and conditionings. The first condition to get rid of, then, is that this work has anything whatever to do with religion—unless the word is to lose all meaning. This is given on his own authority (although he says "there is no authority whatsoever") throughout his teachings which hold the revelations and practices of the world faiths in contempt (...).
But since Krishnamurti claims not to be a teacher, what is the sound all about? He claims that a teaching received "is already a secondhand thing"; therefore who is beguiling whom? Is he the dupe of his audience, or vice versa? The answer is: both—it is only through their mutual ignorance that the comedy is perpetuated; while criticizing the thought of his questioners for "chasing its tail," he is doing nothing other himself. To use another metaphor, he saws the branch on which he sits; for in default of a common denominator or minimal cognitive adequation between agent and recipient, no communication is possible, and ideas are voided in a flux of empty utterances.
Furthermore, either his "message" is timeless, in which case it is madness to believe Krishnamurti the first to promulgate it, or it is not, in which case it is a passing fad without interest. The man is in fact a victim of the very thought conditioning he would reject, being a product of the Brahmanic heritage from which he has deviated. The violence of his reaction against religion is a manifestation even of exactly the sort of antagonism, resistance, opposition, and conflict which he pretends to be rejecting. Moreover, every spiritual anomaly is nothing but the distortion of truth. (...) Krishnamurti's aberration is [a perversion of negative theology and a confusion between the ego and the Self] in a more "Hindu" mode, a distortion of the via negativa (neti, neti) of Advaita Vedanta. If he were a caste Hindu practicing the sadhanas and dharmasastra, he could have an ashram and pursue the Shankaran method of "non identification of the self with the non-Self." For it is perfectly true that the map is not the country it portrays, that spiritual attainment can only be had through a reversal of values, a rupture of habit, a spontaneous immediacy that cannot be "communicated," and hence a "leap into the dark." But these are things that every spiritual master knows.
People like (...) Krishnamurti (...) are all in one way or another spokesmen for a New Religion (...) and have in common these salient characteristics: a patent individualism, a scientific and moralistic humanism, evolutionism, a relativistic "intuitionism," inability to grasp metaphysical and cosmological principles and the realities of the Universal domain, a mockery (latent or overt) of the sacred, a prodigous dearth of spiritual imagination, no eschatological understanding, a pseudo-mysticism in the form of a "cosmic consciousness."
Posted By: SolNiger
Date Posted: March 02 2021 at 12:26
CosmicVibration wrote:
There’s only one Truth with a capital T.There’s only one Singularity... Everything else
is just a fragment of the One.
There is never a separation from the One, only a delusion of
it, which is very hard to get rid of.