Karnataka: In concert or Live in USA?

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

   Hi folks:

Recently I was trying to buy the Karnataka live DVD, called In Concert. A friend of mine found it and gave me, but I saw that there is a number of differences between my DVD and what is shown on PA. My DVD is called Live In The USA, not In Concert, although the show here seems to be the same, recorded in 2002. there are a number of songs that don´t appear on Live In USA like Shine, Writing On the Wall and The Woman In Me. And, on the other hand there is some that appear on Live In The USA that are not listed on In concet.(The Storm, After The Rain)

The line ups are confusing too: while the In Concert on PA includes a sax player (Steve Simmons) and Anne Marie Helder is listed as one of 3 backing vocalists, the Live in The USA cites her as a full member, playing the flute and singing (and no sax player).

So, in the end it seems that are two DVDs by the band. Does anyone knows if the DVDs are the same ones but with different versions or two distinctive releases? Mine was released by Classic Rock productions too, but it is quite different.  

Thank you very much

Tarcísio Moura

Author	Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic
Tarcisio Moura Members Profile Send Private Message Find Members Posts Add to Buddy List Reviewer page Prog Reviewer Joined: April 26 2006 Location: Brazil Status: Offline Points: 198	Topic: Karnataka: In concert or Live in USA? Posted: June 11 2007 at 14:01
	Hi folks: Recently I was trying to buy the Karnataka live DVD, called In Concert. A friend of mine found it and gave me, but I saw that there is a number of differences between my DVD and what is shown on PA. My DVD is called Live In The USA, not In Concert, although the show here seems to be the same, recorded in 2002. there are a number of songs that don´t appear on Live In USA like Shine, Writing On the Wall and The Woman In Me. And, on the other hand there is some that appear on Live In The USA that are not listed on In concet.(The Storm, After The Rain) The line ups are confusing too: while the In Concert on PA includes a sax player (Steve Simmons) and Anne Marie Helder is listed as one of 3 backing vocalists, the Live in The USA cites her as a full member, playing the flute and singing (and no sax player). So, in the end it seems that are two DVDs by the band. Does anyone knows if the DVDs are the same ones but with different versions or two distinctive releases? Mine was released by Classic Rock productions too, but it is quite different. Thank you very much Tarcísio Moura