PA AOTY 2024 (Deadline extended until Feb 2)

Gilmour's album won prog magazine album of the year yet has been largely shunned by PA listeners it seems. A view I hear echoed generally is that 2024 was a year that ran deep for good releases but the quality at the top was below that of the previous year. I tend to agree.

FYI: During the last 24 hours some users have updated their list through AP ... nice job! It is not visible in this thread, so don't assume that things aren't happening just because there are no posts here 

MikeEnRegalia wrote: I'm curious - to everyone who submitted a really long list (e.g. more than 40 entries), like I also did previously: How often have you listened to the releases? Obviously it's hard to say unless you have a tool to keep track of it, but for me, when I had like 50 releases in the list there were many which I had only heard once. This year I'm filtering the list for releases that I still find truly outstanding after repeated listens throughout the year. I'm NOT saying that this is better or worse than any other strategy - what's your opinion?

1	AP YT BC SPO RYM	Present this is NOT the end
2	AP BC	Spinifex Undrilling The Hole
3	AP BC SPO RYM	Yoo Doo Right From The Heights Of Our Pastureland
4	AP BC BC SPO RYM	Gordon Grdina Duo Work (with Christian Lillinger) Collaboration
5	AP BC SPO RYM	Circe Link & Christian Nesmith Arcana
6	AP RYM	The Flying Luttenbachers Losing the War Inside Our Heads
7	AP BC SPO RYM	Alber Jupiter Puis Vient La Nuit
8	AP BC SPO RYM	Jupiter Fungus Garden Electric
9	AP BC SPO RYM	The Tangent To Follow Polaris
10	AP BC SPO RYM	Beardfish Songs for Beating Hearts
11	AP BC SPO RYM	Isobar Isobar IV
12	AP BC SPO RYM	Oddleaf Where Ideal And Denial Collide
13	AP SPO RYM	Vientos Moderados del Este Un Manual de Signos y Síntomas
14	AP BC SPO	Quantum Fantay Oneironauts
15	AP BC SPO RYM	Zombi Direct Inject
16	AP BC SPO RYM	Izz Collapse The Wave
17	AP BC SPO RYM	Alex Carpani Band The Good Man
18	AP BC SPO RYM	Mula Cúmulo Abierto
19	AP BC SPO RYM	Beak> >>>>
20	AP BC SPO RYM	Sleepytime Gorilla Museum of the Last Human Being
21	AP BC SPO RYM	Tom Penaguin Tom Penaguin
22	AP BC SPO RYM	Mauro Montobbio Scattered Memories
23	AP BC SPO RYM	Actionfredag Lys Fremtid I Mø​rke
24	AP BC SPO RYM	Greco Bastián With a Little Hell from MORE friends
25	AP BC SPO RYM	Bent Knee Twenty Pills Without Water
26	AP BC SPO RYM	Sykofant Sykofant
27	AP SPO RYM	Le Orme Il Leone e la Bandiera
28	AP BC SPO RYM	Infringement Black Science & White Lies
29	AP BC SPO RYM	Airbag The Century Of The Self
30	AP BC SPO RYM	Kaipa Sommargryningsljus
31	AP BC SPO RYM	Needlepoint Remnants Of Light
32	AP BC SPO RYM	Drifting Sun Veil
33	AP SPO RYM	Solaris Martian Chronicles III: I Or A.I.
34	AP BC SPO RYM	Alphataurus 2084: Viaggio Nel Nulla
35	AP BC SPO RYM	Elephant9 Mythical River
36	AP BC SPO	The Pneumatic Transit Forbidden Trinkets
37	AP BC	Pierre Vervloesem Saucers
38	AP BC SPO RYM	Plantoid Terrapath
39	AP BC SPO RYM	Argos Halfway Between Heaven And Mirth
40	AP RYM	Tantric Bile Unbidden
41	AP SPO RYM	Ritual The Story Of Mr. Bogd Part 1
42	AP BC SPO	Leon Alvarado The Changing Tide
43	AP BC SPO RYM	Ellesmere Stranger Skies
44	AP BC SPO RYM	Magick Brother & Mystic Sister Tarot, Part I
45	AP SPO RYM	David Gilmour Luck and Strange
46	AP BC	FILUM 2Q2Q
47	AP BC SPO RYM	Monkey3 Welcome To The Machine
48	AP BC SPO RYM SPU	Chelsea Wolfe She Reaches Out To She [...]
49	AP BC SPO RYM	Fractal Sextet Sky Full Of Hope
50	AP BC BC SPO RYM	Big Big Train The Likes of Us
51	AP YT SPO RYM	Papangu Lampião Rei
52	AP SPO RYM	Jon Anderson Jon Anderson & The Band Geeks: True
53	AP BC SPO RYM	Mono OATH
54	AP BC SPO	Aquaserge La fin de l'économie
55	AP BC SPO	Cen-ProjekT Arcane Sonic
56	AP BC	Dave Newhouse Natura Morta
57	AP BC SPO RYM	Electric Eye Dyp Tid
58	AP BC SPO RYM	Steve Hackett The Circus And The Nightwhale
59	AP BC BC SPO RYM	Pure Reason Revolution Coming Up To Consciousness
60	AP BC SPO RYM	Magick Brother & Mystic Sister Tarot, Part II
61	AP BC SPO	Cyano Sarek
62	AP BC SPO RYM	The Smile Wall of Eyes
63	AP BC SPO RYM	Elephants Of Scotland Brains!

MikeEnRegalia wrote: ^ Impressive! I'd be curious how you would tier all these releases, how many would end up in the S or A tier. Possibly all of them?

Mirakaze wrote: progaardvark wrote: Great list! Awesome to see Spinifex and Grdina getting some more love