ERRORS THREAD Report Errors and Omissions Here - Progressive Rock Music Forum

Razors Edge wrote:

The edit to be made:

Razors Edge wrote:

1) Move "Sicilian Defence" from Compilation Section to Studio Section

Moved to Studio albums. Though it seems it was never released separately, only as a part of "The Complete Albums Collection" and should rather be deleted. Smile

Razors Edge wrote:

2) Entry "The Complete Albums Collection" in Compilation Section

If you have enough info you, as any PA member, can add it by yourself.

Razors Edge wrote:

3) Move "Freudiana" in Eric Woolfson's studio album section.

I'm afraid debates is it APP or Eric Wolfson album will never end.

If you'd like to, please contact Crossover Team (APP belongs here to Crossover Prog). If they agree they'll move the album to Wolfson's discography.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

^ Moved and otherwise updated. Thanks!

...Ah, found it.

Is this better?: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=45231

What?

Led Zeppelin's Coda is a Studio Album, not a Compilation

Sources: There are many ones, like the liner notes of Led Zeppelin Box Set, Vol. 2 and the label of The Complete Studio Recordings.

This story ends where it began.

Dean wrote:

Razors Edge wrote:

Led Zeppelin's Coda is a Studio Album, not a Compilation

Sources: There are many ones, like the liner notes of Led Zeppelin Box Set, Vol. 2 and the label of The Complete Studio Recordings.

Meh, it's a compilation of unreleased live and studio cuts spanning 9 years from 1969 to 1978, released after Bohnam's death and their subsequent disbandment. It's fine where it is.

Absolutely agree, Dean.

It was a mess of an album released by Atlantic following the demise of Bonham, the break up of the band, and a realisation that this was, at the time, the only way the cash cow could continue.

It was most certainly not a studio album in the traditional way we understand, I.e. A band going into the studio to record and release original material. Rather, it was a collection of disparate live and studio recordings. Where the site has it is absolutely spot on.

Not that it really matters, but it was also bloody awful. I remember being very disappointed when I got it on release.

Enhance your life. Get down to www.lazland.org

Now also broadcasting on www.progzilla.com Every Saturday, 4.00 p.m. UK time!

Razors Edge wrote:

lazland wrote:

Dean wrote:

Razors Edge wrote:

Led Zeppelin's Coda is a Studio Album, not a Compilation

Sources: There are many ones, like the liner notes of Led Zeppelin Box Set, Vol. 2 and the label of The Complete Studio Recordings.

Meh, it's a compilation of unreleased live and studio cuts spanning 9 years from 1969 to 1978, released after Bohnam's death and their subsequent disbandment. It's fine where it is.

Absolutely agree, Dean.

It was a mess of an album released by Atlantic following the demise of Bonham, the break up of the band, and a realisation that this was, at the time, the only way the cash cow could continue.

It was most certainly not a studio album in the traditional way we understand, I.e. A band going into the studio to record and release original material. Rather, it was a collection of disparate live and studio recordings. Where the site has it is absolutely spot on.

Not that it really matters, but it was also bloody awful. I remember being very disappointed when I got it on release.

I thought the sources were more important than the opinions of some prog fan...

Led Zeppelin's The Complete Studio Recordings box set include Coda, so it's self-evident. Jones, Page and Plant never rejected the album, that is in the discography section of LZ official site.

Clearly, it is not self evident, otherwise we wouldn't be having this rather pointless discussion, eh?

The fact that Coda is included in this box set you raise is neither here nor there. Coda was not a studio album in the sense we mean here, I.e. that the band went into a studio in 1979, recorded an album, and then, after a polite delay re Bonham dying, went on to release Coda. That never happened.

The last traditional Led Zep album was In Through The Out Door. They were touring that when I saw them live in Knebworth, Bonham's last ever UK gig.

Coda was a posthumous release of various songs recorded live and studio over a number of years, in other words a compilation of songs. That is why it is in the right place here. End of pointless discussion.

Edited by lazland - April 28 2014 at 07:11

Enhance your life. Get down to www.lazland.org

Now also broadcasting on www.progzilla.com Every Saturday, 4.00 p.m. UK time!

^ Thanks, definitely it's another band.

I'll ask Admins to delete these albums because these "pagans" are not on PA.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

^ Thanks, done.

Also added the link to the band's website.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

^ Thanks, done.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

aapatsos wrote:

I believe this is a 1977 LP with a 1996 re-release of CD+2 bonus tracks but I leave it on you to make the final decision

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=548

I agree, but insist that this album must stay.

The 1977 album only released 200 badly recorded copies that reached almost nobody

A note could be made, but this is the only reliable source that can be found