The Wall Movie: Good, Bad or Ugly?

Hi,

The film makes a lot more "sense" when the whole thing is looked at from the PF "sound effects/visual effects" that went back to the first days of David Gilmour. Thus, from a "visual" perspective, TW makes sense and is really "the end" of the possibility of doing any more with it, since it would become repetitive. Not exactly a coincidence that the group was falling apart as well.

IF, TW, as an album had been done by another band, an unknown band, without the concert history that PF already had for visual shows, no one would have cared or given a damn ... and it would be trashed for being unclear and having its story cut up in vignettes that seemed to work but its "time" element was all out of whack.