NotAProghead wrote:

^ After adding a comma it may be automatically turned to something like GILES & FRIPP GILES.

^ Oh boy, I wouldn't imagine - another bug, no?
Thks Eugene

^ I understand...look at THIS weird result I just found (it should read

GOWEN, MILLER, SINCLAIR, TOMKIN)

Edited by Quinino - June 02 2017 at 11:18

Eugene, I guess we'll end up like these two below Beer

Edited by Quinino - June 02 2017 at 13:48

^ Thanks, done.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

^ Thanks, done.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=618

The fully correct band name is Gòtic, could anyone please change it, thks

Quinino wrote:

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=35382

This is unofficial, it's up for deleting - BUT - the band recently remastered the tapes and released the (renamed) tracks under the title Gegants i Serpentines (2016) which as you can see is already on PA

The bootleg has only a review that could be moved and nothing would then be lost
If all agree I'll PM the reviewer and get on with it, right?

As you say tracks renamed.

Lets's look:

Maqueta
1. Alba Cosmopolita 8.38
2. Passejant per Zarantz 6:24
3. Juventut Audac 4:20
4. Amanda d'Estiu 7.16
5. Bulerias 2:12
6. Somiant 1:03
7. Pluja Sabatina 4:33

Gegants I Serpentines

1. Gegants I Serpentines (3:17)
2. Funky (4:18)
3. Suite (6:22)
4. La Noia Que Tenia Els Ulls Verds De Tant Mirar El Mar (8:42)
5. Record De Rosa (1:02)
6. Carnaval (2:12)
7. Variacions (7:14)
8. Gotes De Gel (5:28)

Then let's try to understand "who is who" comparing track times:

Gegants I Serpentines Maqueta

1. Gegants I Serpentines (3:17) --> no such track
2. Funky (4:18) --> Juventut Audac 4:20
3. Suite (6:22) --> Passejant per Zarantz 6:24

4. La Noia Que Tenia Els Ulls Verds De Tant Mirar El Mar (8:42)   -->   Alba Cosmopolita 8.38
5. Record De Rosa (1:02) -->   Somiant 1:03
6. Carnaval (2:12) -->   Bulerias 2:12
7. Variacions (7:14) -->   Amanda d'Estiu 7.16
8. Gotes De Gel (5:28)   -->   no such track

It's not obviuous, at least without additional info, that Gegants I Serpentines is an official remake of Maqueta

You can contact the sole Maqueta reviewer first (and then contact admins), but most likely he have not heard 2016 edition (his review is from 2012).

From the other hand, formally according to PA policy bootlegs have to be deleted regardless of reviews. Think!

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

This release lacks a few players in the line-up section: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=53032

Should be this way:

- Einar Solberg / lead vocal, synth
- Tor Oddmund Suhrke / guitar, backing vocals
- Øystein Landsverk / guitar
- Baard Kolstad / drums
- Simen Daniel Lindstad Børven / bass

with guests
- Tobias Ørnes Andersen / drums
- Håkon Aase / violin
- Ihsahn / vocals, guitar

It's on PA!

Hi all, I'm the one who reviewed Gòtic's "Maqueta". Indeed the band happened to find the original tapes of that unreleased 1978 2nd album (they had somehow ended in the hands of an anonymous Japanese fan) and finally issued the album officially in 2016 with the name Gegants i Serpentines. I was lucky to attend the album presentation show in Barcelona and purchased the newly released version of the album. Some of the material was reworked, tracks renamed and track order changed. It's quite some time I do not listen to those albums but since I have both if you give me a couple of days I can re-listen and confirm which track is what in the new album and eventually edit my review to fit the official release. Of course you can move it to the official release and delete the bootleg from the database, you can do so immediately if you wish and I will update the review asap under the new official album page.

Cheers

Gerard

Quinino wrote:

^ Gerard, I PM'd with suggestion on how to do it (in case you didn't already know, of course Big smile

)

Thanks, Cheers

Done, the bootleg's page may now be deleted. I'l try to update my review to fit the official release asap. Cheers all.

ERRORS THREAD Report Errors and Omissions Here

GOWEN, MILLER, SINCLAIR, TOMKIN)