Forum Home Forum Home > Progressive Music Lounges > Top 10s and lists
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - 1000 Prog Albums Over 46 Years:  1966-2011
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

Topic Closed1000 Prog Albums Over 46 Years: 1966-2011

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 1011121314 21>
Author
Message Reverse Sort Order
Dean View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Retired Admin and Amateur Layabout

Joined: May 13 2007
Location: Europe
Status: Offline
Points: 37575
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 19:27
Originally posted by dboulet dboulet wrote:

Dean I accept you apology about putting down Scott. No harsh feelings! Have a great evening.
 
Confused I didn't apologise and I wasn't putting him down.
What?
Back to Top
dboulet View Drop Down
Forum Newbie
Forum Newbie
Avatar

Joined: January 03 2012
Location: Montreal
Status: Offline
Points: 3
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 19:14
Good evening Dean, I do not want to get into a fight with you. I understand better what you are trying to tell Scott. I think now it is only the way it is said and the timing of it. ACR will probably keep in mind your suggestion about significance of an album in relation to others. He will correct me if I'm wrong. I think he is busy doing the first draft of this huge project.
Your suggestion to point to appropriate reviews on the album page is alright but would it not be easier for a person browsing this thread to have it right there in front of him or her and simply scroll down?. I often get distracted by my kids, my wife, the doorbell and phonecalls from work when I'm at home and for me it is a plus to just come back to the computer and continue reading. I find it convenient but am aware it takes more space on the site.
Dean I accept you apology about putting down Scott. No harsh feelings! Have a great evening. Now I have to ask ACR a question.
Back to Top
AtomicCrimsonRush View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14258
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 19:04
-
Originally posted by Dean Dean wrote:

Thank you Scott - In my hamfisted way, that's what I was trying to point out.

I hear you. I already started by removing all comments on the albums referring to 'I' such as "I really love the sax on this" might be changed to "The sax is played with incredible skill" or something. Its basically the removal o more personal opinions tho not all can be removed. I also removed negativity where possible so it sounds better as info on the album. Some album listings dont require a lot of rewriting I noticed because its not as personal. "I hated this nonsense" is deletedWink and comments on Barrett being a nutterTongue - i wouldnt think that is very publishable.

anyway I finished albums up to 1968 so far and I am happier with them. Its making the listings shorter and more readable - cant wait till i get to edit the massive Genesis reviews LOL 
Back to Top
Dean View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Retired Admin and Amateur Layabout

Joined: May 13 2007
Location: Europe
Status: Offline
Points: 37575
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 18:16
Thank you Scott - In my hamfisted way, that's what I was trying to point out.
What?
Back to Top
AtomicCrimsonRush View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14258
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 18:13
Okay everyone lets cool the jets for a sec - I have slept on this (and it hurt my back as the laptop is rather lumpy)LOL

what I propose to do is simple. And I believe it will help the list. 

i went back and rewrote parts of the Pink Floyd album reviews so they do not sound so negative. I looked back at the "1001 albums" book available and it seems to be more info based and impartial despite how the editors feel about the album.
Thats a good thing and i want to do that too!

Anyway what i will do is rewrite the other reviews in a way that is more impartial and not sounding like a review as much. I can take what i reviewed, the info and just rewrite it so it is more informational. it wont take that long. I agree that it would be a better resource if the info was not sounding like a review as much. 

I can take criticism and have to agree that this would be better than just posting old reviews.
I also noted as all the reviews were from me that i tend to repeat info and phrases - how can you help it when you are the one writing them? So I will definitely look into fixing that too. the reviews on the site wont change but at least the book will read better - Also the reviews are at times too long and not suitable for this publication. So from now on I will add simple info to each album. 

One benefit is I can simply research the albums I have never heard and post info and therefore there will be no gaps. 

You don't have to listen to an album to post factual info about it so that will benefit the list too. Though it wont be as good admittedly as hearing the album.

Anyway lets leave it at that. I really appreciate the time people have taken to make comments and there is definitely some truth in all the critiques and I have to take that on board.

I also agree that many will use this site as simply a resource by going to home page and checking the top lists. Granted that is what the site is all about. But I was more thinking along the lines of having a book that you can thumb through to check as a resource, not online. I will keep at it anyway. I hope the changes I make improve the listing.  

Back to Top
Dean View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Retired Admin and Amateur Layabout

Joined: May 13 2007
Location: Europe
Status: Offline
Points: 37575
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 17:49
Originally posted by dboulet dboulet wrote:

Good afternoon to all, I have read the latest posts and I nearly fell off my chair.
Why? What did I post that was so offensive, harsh or hillariously amusing that caused you such discombobulation that your arse was having so much difficulty in maintaining contact with the item of furniture that you use when the need to sit is required?
Originally posted by dboulet dboulet wrote:

 
What I see here is a man that thought of an idea and wants to share it with the world. I think it is a wonderfull idea to do such a list that will become a book. One has to believe in it really hard to start such a big project and persevere to get to the end of it. In the finale, a great reference will emerge.  AtomicCrimsonRush is giving us his time and effort so we can enjoy prog even more. I'm sure AtomicCrimsonRush is open to ccriticism, otherwise he would not publish here. Obviously not everyone will agree with the choices but remember it is his idea.
I actually dissagree, but that's not important as I would not criticise the idea or the list of albums chosen. I never said "don't do this" nor did I  say "it's a dumb idea" - I seem to recall giving advice as to how this could be converted into a printed form.
Originally posted by dboulet dboulet wrote:

 
Another thing, I did not see in the rules of the site that if we wrote about an album that we should we should include  'giving any reason why these albums are significant, their relationship to each other and other albums by each band or their place in any chronology of Progressive Rock or its development'.
When people use the trite "I did not see it in the rules" my heart sinks into my boots and today is no exception. Scott writes reviews and in general he writes bloody good reviews that are well detailed track-by-track opinions and impressions of the music contained within. These reviews are written in issolation from each other and posted on the respective album page for each album - this I decree to be "a good thing" - reprinting them here verbatim to me is pointless - a link to the appropriate review would suffice if no further comentary is to be added - and that is the crux of the point I was making (though quite how it became such a big deal is a *@%^$£ mystery to me) - a little comentary as to why each album was chosen and what significance it has in relation to all the others seemed like logical consequence of such a list to me.
Originally posted by dboulet dboulet wrote:

 
AtomicCrimsonRush is a fan of prog music, not an expert with a doctor's degree in prog. I think we should all help him in ant way we can by making suggestion, submitting album reviews, not putting down the man because he is imperfect. I can only imagine how this man is gaining knowledge about prog. We all have different opinions and we can share that but we must not get personal and shoot on anyone trying to do something. I wish very much that AtomicCrimsonRush is given a chance to do this to the end. Eventually this thread will become a reference. 5 stars to AtomicCrimsonRush.
I'm sorry if it appeared to you that I was putting Scott down - I assure you that if I ever do you will notice.
 
What?
Back to Top
ExittheLemming View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: October 19 2007
Location: Penal Colony
Status: Offline
Points: 11420
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 17:43
Originally posted by dboulet dboulet wrote:

Eventually this thread will become a reference. 5 stars to AtomicCrimsonRush.


I applaud the time and effort ACR has put into this thread certainly but the SITE is the reference NOT a single thread driven by a list of albums already covered by charts. The front page of PA is the portal for those visitors inquisitive about Progressive Rock. It strikes me as self evident that as worthy as such an undertaking as this is by ACR, more people would be directed to our portal if his project was hosted at a location outside PA i.e. people who have already arrived at their destination rarely seek a map




Back to Top
Snow Dog View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: March 23 2005
Location: Caerdydd
Status: Offline
Points: 32995
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 17:04
^oh no!


Clown
Back to Top
AtomicCrimsonRush View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14258
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 17:00
Okay now that the dust has settled I will get on to the albums of 1973. It was such an amazing year for prog that it will take some time to collate together the info.

Will get to it now.
Back to Top
dboulet View Drop Down
Forum Newbie
Forum Newbie
Avatar

Joined: January 03 2012
Location: Montreal
Status: Offline
Points: 3
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 14:49
Good afternoon to all, I have read the latest posts and I nearly fell off my chair.
 
What I see here is a man that thought of an idea and wants to share it with the world. I think it is a wonderfull idea to do such a list that will become a book. One has to believe in it really hard to start such a big project and persevere to get to the end of it. In the finale, a great reference will emerge.  AtomicCrimsonRush is giving us his time and effort so we can enjoy prog even more. I'm sure AtomicCrimsonRush is open to ccriticism, otherwise he would not publish here. Obviously not everyone will agree with the choices but remember it is his idea. Another thing, I did not see in the rules of the site that if we wrote about an album that we should we should include  'giving any reason why these albums are significant, their relationship to each other and other albums by each band or their place in any chronology of Progressive Rock or its development'. AtomicCrimsonRush is a fan of prog music, not an expert with a doctor's degree in prog. I think we should all help him in ant way we can by making suggestion, submitting album reviews, not putting down the man because he is imperfect. I can only imagine how this man is gaining knowledge about prog. We all have different opinions and we can share that but we must not get personal and shoot on anyone trying to do something. I wish very much that AtomicCrimsonRush is given a chance to do this to the end. Eventually this thread will become a reference. 5 stars to AtomicCrimsonRush.
Back to Top
Dean View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Retired Admin and Amateur Layabout

Joined: May 13 2007
Location: Europe
Status: Offline
Points: 37575
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 08:09
Originally posted by AtomicCrimsonRush AtomicCrimsonRush wrote:

  I have someone who is interested in this as a resource and wants to print it all out as a resource.  


Can I suggest Createspace as a means of putting this into print - apart from time it doesn't cost you anything other than the purchase of the first "proof" copy (generally reasonable cost but can be expensive on postage), .
What?
Back to Top
Snow Dog View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: March 23 2005
Location: Caerdydd
Status: Offline
Points: 32995
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 08:07
Originally posted by AtomicCrimsonRush AtomicCrimsonRush wrote:

Okay I read that and understand.

But I spent hours on this thread to get it right, 
I will continue on the thread in the way that I have been. Hopefully it will be a quick reference resource to check out the albums of each year but only up to the 70s as i cant be bothered with the 80s. 

The albums were chosen by referencing the highest rating albums per year on this site and just general knowledge. I will likely go over each later and rewrite each album entry and turn it into general discussion rather than just a review, as it would be more beneficial. I rewrite parts of some reviews though, but its time consuming as it is. I have someone who is interested in this as a resource and wants to print it all out as a resource.  

I have been very encouraged by many about this thread. But this conversation tonight has been rather of putting after all the hard work. Maybe I should just stick to writing reviews for a while, because sadly the forums has not been a pleasant experience of late...



No. Carry on Scott. If you enjoy it and people get something out of it, that is reason enough.
Back to Top
dreadpirateroberts View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: May 27 2011
Location: AU
Status: Offline
Points: 952
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 07:56
I've found this useful - which is more than I can say for about 50 percent of the forum, which is made up of Genesis polls. (I do exaggerate.)

I can see vast potential for interactivity here, especially if, as you mentioned Scott - (have) contact(ed) other members to utilise their reviews/thoughts on albums you don't have.     Further to this, there's already been interactivity and consultation/adjustment via other members' input in regards to changing albums and adding albums.

This project is in early stages. Patience is cool.
We are men of action. Lies do not become us.
JazzMusicArchives.
Back to Top
AtomicCrimsonRush View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14258
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 07:47
Okay I read that and understand.

But I spent hours on this thread to get it right, 
I will continue on the thread in the way that I have been. Hopefully it will be a quick reference resource to check out the albums of each year but only up to the 70s as i cant be bothered with the 80s. 

The albums were chosen by referencing the highest rating albums per year on this site and just general knowledge. I will likely go over each later and rewrite each album entry and turn it into general discussion rather than just a review, as it would be more beneficial. I rewrite parts of some reviews though, but its time consuming as it is. I have someone who is interested in this as a resource and wants to print it all out as a resource.  

I have been very encouraged by many about this thread. But this conversation tonight has been rather of putting after all the hard work. Maybe I should just stick to writing reviews for a while, because sadly the forums has not been a pleasant experience of late...




Edited by AtomicCrimsonRush - January 14 2012 at 07:49
Back to Top
Dean View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Retired Admin and Amateur Layabout

Joined: May 13 2007
Location: Europe
Status: Offline
Points: 37575
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 07:28
Originally posted by AtomicCrimsonRush AtomicCrimsonRush wrote:

Originally posted by Dean Dean wrote:

Confused Why are you posting your already published reviews in this "blog"? I neither understand.nor do I see the point as you are not adding any thing or giving any reason why these albums are significant, their relationship to each other and other albums by each band or their place in any chronology of Progressive Rock or its development.

I was trying to make a booklet like the books "1001 albums you must hear before you die" except it would be all prog. I started off making a blog but it was called a list and moved here. I wanted to add some info on each band per album. I didnt mean to just paste in reviews but i had to start somewhere. My intention was to create something that could be a guide to people into prog music. I was first going to just paste in the reviews to make it easier to reference and later edit each entry by year with only adding a little bit of info per album. But its  slow process and editing takes time. I have a few people helping me with reviews and all the gaps will be their review as i dont have the albums. If you want me to stop I can take this eslewhere and create a different site. But I thought it would be helpful...
I suspect it was moved from Blogs to Lists because for the first half dozen pages it was nothing but a list with no commentry. Since there is no "ownership" of threads in this forum, even in the Blogs section, I would expect that other members could/should add their own 1001 albums to it. Now you are adding your personal views by way of cut'n'pasting selected reviews, and my initial comment stands - I would have prefered something more and something original that covers why you chose each album. I do not beleive that is an unreasonable expectation.
 
If I were to comment on content I would question such things as why you dismiss Grantchester Medows as "a Waters experiment gone wrong" without saying why you feel that for example (but I'm not so don't answer it). Personal opinions are fine in a review, in a forum commentry I would expect explanation and discussion.
Originally posted by AtomicCrimsonRush AtomicCrimsonRush wrote:

I just dont know why you guys are on my back lately.Confused I thought I was adding something to the site but you seem to think I am self indulging, but I just want to create something special. i enjoyed my Genesis blog but thats getting dull now. The prog through the years blog is finished for the time being so I was just going to do this during the year.
I never said anything about being self indulgent or even implied such, and to date I've never been "on your back". My discussions in Reviews Discussion may have been sparked specifically by your reviews, but they were not "personal", nor were they uniquely about you, they were between myself and Luca over the general idea of reviewing on low quality samples. Similarly my discussions over moving bands was with Iván - something that has been on-going for several years - and not with you or Torodd since neither of you contributed to that discussion. However, I was fully aware that making any comment in this thread would be taken personally and there was little I could do to avoid that except hold my tongue, and I wasn't prepared to do that.
Originally posted by AtomicCrimsonRush AtomicCrimsonRush wrote:


PLease let me know what you want here? I cant use info that is not mine per album as thats not allowed.  
You can do whatever you like, just as I can comment on whatever I like. You can use info that is not yours if you cite it correctly.
What?
Back to Top
AtomicCrimsonRush View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14258
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 06:59
Originally posted by Dean Dean wrote:

Confused Why are you posting your already published reviews in this "blog"? I neither understand.nor do I see the point as you are not adding any thing or giving any reason why these albums are significant, their relationship to each other and other albums by each band or their place in any chronology of Progressive Rock or its development.

I was trying to make a booklet like the books "1001 albums you must hear before you die" except it would be all prog. I started off making a blog but it was called a list and moved here. I wanted to add some info on each band per album. I didnt mean to just paste in reviews but i had to start somewhere. My intention was to create something that could be a guide to people into prog music. I was first going to just paste in the reviews to make it easier to reference and later edit each entry by year with only adding a little bit of info per album. But its  slow process and editing takes time. I have a few people helping me with reviews and all the gaps will be their review as i dont have the albums. If you want me to stop I can take this eslewhere and create a different site. But I thought it would be helpful...

I just dont know why you guys are on my back lately.Confused I thought I was adding something to the site but you seem to think I am self indulging, but I just want to create something special. i enjoyed my Genesis blog but thats getting dull now. The prog through the years blog is finished for the time being so I was just going to do this during the year.

PLease let me know what you want here? I cant use info that is not mine per album as thats not allowed.  
Back to Top
Snow Dog View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: March 23 2005
Location: Caerdydd
Status: Offline
Points: 32995
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 06:35
deleted

Edited by Snow Dog - January 14 2012 at 07:41
Back to Top
Dean View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Retired Admin and Amateur Layabout

Joined: May 13 2007
Location: Europe
Status: Offline
Points: 37575
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 06:29
Confused Why are you posting your already published reviews in this "blog"? I neither understand.nor do I see the point as you are not adding any thing or giving any reason why these albums are significant, their relationship to each other and other albums by each band or their place in any chronology of Progressive Rock or its development.
What?
Back to Top
AtomicCrimsonRush View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14258
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 06:28

1972 - continued


#137

Little Red Record 
Matching Mole

Matching Mole Little Red Record  album cover

A review by Warthur:

Matching Mole's first album was Robert Wyatt's chance to finally get on record musical concepts developed during his tenure in Soft Machine which, for whatever reason, had been vetoed by the rest of that band. For the second album, the group took a more democratic approach to songwriting, resulting in a more diverse album that isn't quite so dominated by Wyatt's songs - Wyatt perhaps wanting to avoid repeating in his new band the same mistakes that drove him out of his old band.

As a consequence, the album is a bit of a patchy affair, with the band as a whole casting about and trying to decide what sort of music it wants to perform. Opening track ‘Gloria Gloom’ (on the CD version - Wyatt decided for CD releases to swap around side A and side B from the vinyl since he thought that yielded a better running order) begins with ambient noises - perhaps courtesy of guest synth wizard Brian Eno - that sound like a decades-displaced-in-time Aphex Twin before launching into avant-Canterbury strangeness, whilst other tracks start pointing the way to Phil Miller's later work in Hatfield and the North. (An instrumental version of Nan True's Hole, for example, would be performed live at Hatfield concerts under the anagrammatic title of Oh! Len's Nature.)

Still, as a whole the album lacks focus, and sounds more like experiments towards a band identity rather than the group manifesto the album title suggests. Perhaps a third Matching Mole album would have been more cohesive; unfortunately, that was not to be. Wyatt, worse for wear at a party, would take a startling fall from a balcony a short time after this album was released, paralysing him for life - and whilst Wyatt did thankfully escape an untimely death, the change in his circumstances meant that Matching Mole was not so lucky. Fans of Wyatt's “Rock Bottom” album or Miller's work with the Hatfields will be interested in the context this album provides for those works, but otherwise this is not an especially essential Canterbury release, and certainly not as gripping as Matching Mole's debut.


A review by Sean Trane:

4.5 stars really!!!

Less than seven months after recording their debut album, having toured constantly recording a few radio sessions throughout Europe, MM entered the studios in July 72 for their second (and last, but they weren't aware of it) album that was produced by Robert Fripp. Armed with a highjacked Chinese propaganda poster, the sleeve (and the album title) leaves little doubt as to their political aspirations, although I suspect that this was probably not shared by everyone in the group, because the ambiance within the group quickly became detestable and two months after its release, the group over, even if the explanation was about gigs not being paid and bankruptcy. So with Sinclair gone just after the debut's release, McRae is alone on keys, but the major difference with their first is Wyatt's songwriting, that had filled almost all of the album, was reduced to absolutely none in LRR, if you'll except the lyrics and other vocals, but these hold a big part of creativity.

Starting on one of the most surprising tracks that Wyatt ever recorded, Drink Our Politics Away is a strange semi-operatic over some McRae keyboards and Eno synth layer. Directly and abruptly segueing into Marchides (much the same way Signed Curtain had given in to Part Of The Dance on their previous album), the group takes its vengeance with a wild and torrid 100MPH jazz-rock that veers a bit dissonant in its middle section, before coming back more relaxed. Some exceptionally inventive drumming from Wyatt on this track that had received much previous rehearsal since it was concert standard, but everyone contributes greatly. Again segueing straight into Nan's True Hole, Robert develops some very strange gossipy vocals with him, wife Alfie and friendly model Julie just yapping away over Wyatt's jaw-dropping drumming and a Frippian guitar solo, courtesy of .. Phil Miller; the whole thing falling into Righteous Rhumba without really noticing much a change. Closing on the wild Brandy for Benj (a roadie), with McRae on a rare organ part at the start and Miller's brilliant solo.

Being shutout throughout the first half of the album, McCormick scores Gloria's Gloom as the flipside opens with the second centrepiece, which starts nightmarishly percussive and hauntingly spooky with Eno's VCS-3 deranging many listeners and remaining dissonant through a few minutes, until chattering gossipy vocals take the track slowly into the middle section where Wyatt singing his heart out until Eno's Martenot-like synth layers take us back to earth. After the popish God Song (sticking out like a sore thumb), Flora Fidgit (Frigid Flora? Yashure?? ;-)) where McRae's el piano steals the show. The closing Smoke Signal is the third highlight, a slow developing ambient cosmic piece with Wyatt's astounding drumming, and slowly dying in death throes.

Although MM's last studio album is generally not as reputed as its debut album, bit it's certainly no worse an album, with this one being more of a group effort. Both MM are absolutely essential to Canterbury fans, but it's not recommended to start with them, if you're a newbie.

#138

The Magician's Birthday
Uriah Heep

Uriah Heep The Magicians Birthday album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

A Prog Birthday treat. Perhaps one of the proggiest Uriah Heep releases "The Magicians Birthday" is a fantastic collection of songs that often find their way onto compilations of the group. There are no dull moments and most of these tracks tell a story that is compelling and surreal. 'Sunrise', 'Spider Woman' and 'Blind Eye' start this off with huge blues riffs and heavy distorted hammering riffs. Hensley's Hammond is an impactful force on each track giving a decidedly eerie effect.

'Echoes In The Dark' begins with a downright chilling intro with ethereal organ and dark riffs. It turns into a song full of very powerful atmospheres. 'Rain' is one of the quieter Heep songs and it works as a break between all the mayhem. It became a popular entry in live performances as did 'Sweet Lorraine'. The album really gets into prog territory with the incredible 'Tales', but the piece de resistance is undoubtedly the 10 minute 'The Magician's Birthday'. This veritable icing on the cake features lengthy solos, tons of Hammond and guitar fills, along with isolated drums and even a kazoo for good measure. The quirky birthday tunes embedded are fun and of course the band were never taking them seriously.

Overall, this album comes recommended for heavy prog fans and it is undoubtedly one of Uriah Heep's finest achievements.


A review by Ivan_Melgar_M:

Still before URIAH HEEP managed to form their ideal lineup, they had already released their IMO best album "Look at Yourself" and immediately after they recruited the strong drummer Lee Kerslake and the superb bass player Gary Thain with whom they released the excellent "Demons and Wizards" and after it comes "The Magician's Birthday" a magnificent album even when less Prog' than the two previous with a beautiful Roger Dean cover.

I remember reading that Ken Hensley wanted to make this album the most experimental one but the rest of the band didn't fully agree so they reached an intermediate point combining Hard Rock/Metal tracks with strong Prog arrangements and tracks.

The album starts with "Sunrise" and the song is introduced by a haunting Byron scream that leads us to something that seems as an experimental and extremely hard power ballad, but the vocal explosions, controlled screams and radical changes makes this a very elaborate track, the wah-wah guitar of Mick Box and at last a powerful drumming makes this song a pleasure, whoever doubts URIAH HEEP as one of the oldest ancestors of Prog Metal should listen to this track.

"Spider Woman" is a classical Heep Hard Rock track with more conservative sound and less spectacular vocals than the previous, but an impeccable bass performance by Gary Thain, good, but not awesome.

"Blind Eye" is another very good song where Hensley keyboards, Box's electric and played rhythm guitar and the correct vocals of David Byron blend gently, again as usual elaborate outstanding vocal arrangements in a band where almost every member contributed with the backing vocals, flows gently from start to end not very complex but the quality is obvious.

"Echoes in the Dark" is another proggy track that starts with the haunting sound effects plus a dramatic guitar and piano creating a mysterious atmosphere, suddenly out of nowhere Baron's vocals join the band almost as a whisper, this leads to another strong instrumental section and several changes, this album keeps getting better.

"Rain" is probably the weakest song of the album, not a bad but a simple ballad, of course has beautiful moments but after the first tracks and two previous albums we expect much more of the band, less than the average.

"Sweet Lorraine" is breathtaking from start to end, a synth intro that wakes after Rain leads to a hard Rock track with great drumming by Lee Kerslake, it's amazing how Gary Thain manages to take his bass from the rhythm section and joins the melodic part as if it was a second guitar but keeps supporting Kerslake.

"Tales" works as a reliever after the strong material and to prepare the audience for the semi-epic and central piece of the album, not bad but plain simple, still the rhythm section work is outstanding.

"The Magician's Birthday" is a 100% prog epic that has everything, powerful moments, absolutely radical changes, drama, mystery, in other words a complete song that any proghead must listen to and that I won't ruin with plain words, all I will add is that the closing section is absolutely breathtaking, probably one of the best vocal works I heard inside or outside Prog, David Byron goes from the lowest to the highest ranges in fraction of seconds and the chorus is absolutely perfect surrounded by great Moog backup. I love this track from start to end, and if you don't like the lyrics in the Magician's Birthday greeting that I admit are a bit cheesy, don't listen as they only last a few seconds, and for me it's a complete masterpiece from start to end.

Even though I won't review the bonus tracks (I like to listen to the albums as they were originally recorded) I must say that the two I have in my 1996 Remastered Edition ("Silver White Man" and "Crystal Ball") are not in the level of the album but I won't consider them for the rating because they were not recorded for the original album and only added to have less free space on the CD being that the old LP format only allowed about 40 minutes.

Being that "The Magician's Birthday" is not as good as "Look at Yourself" because of the weaker "Rain" and "Tales" I can't give 5 stars without being dishonest, but surely the album as a whole and all the other tracks deserve no less a high rating.

Four solid stars for the last album of URIAH HEEP'S golden trilogy.

#139

A Toast to Panama Red

The Master's Apprentices

 

The Masters Apprentices A Toast to Panama Red album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

“A Toast to Panama Red” is Masters Apprentices most accomplished approach to prog rock. Each track chugs along with some excellent guitar from Ford and the wonderful vocals of Keays. Time sig changes are prevalent throughout and very well structured compositions that begin and end without flourish.

'The Answer Lies Beyond' pumps along at a nice medium pace with cool riffs and pulsating drum beats of Burgess. The slow meandering phased guitar of Ford carries along 'Beneath the Sun'. The vocals are quiet, and there is no chorus, as is the case for most of the tracks. It changes direction mid way through with a hypnotic riff, strange effects and psychedelic nuances.

This was 1972 and prog had survived the birth pangs and was beginning to flourish with this type of heavy psych approach which was complex and not just designed for pot heads. Keays drew the album cover and his wife wrote out the lyrics in her own hand, it was a real collaborative effort. 'Games We Play 1' is surrealistic and off kilter with an early Sabbath feel in the guitar work with very erratic drumming. The 7 minute track changes moods and launches into an ace bassline by Wheathers that drives it along, than Ford's lead punctuates the track with high pitched fret screams.

'Games We Play 2' is an instrumental that heavily relies on a driving guitar riff and showcases the musical prowess of the band. 'The Prophet' poem is read over the music in true Hawkwind style and choral voices from the Crikey Choir! This enhances the track with an ethereal quality. The next track 'The Lesson So Listen' opened the vinyl album side 2 and is held together by a progtastic riff; angular guitar and intricate drum patterns propel it along. The contagious melody of 'Love Is' is a definite highlight, and is a track that boasts some imaginative use of brass and acoustic flourishes. 'Memories of St Kilda' is intriguing and works as a rocker that changes signature and blasts to a sudden conclusion.

'Southern Cross' is the highlight of the album featuring an excellent lead guitar solo from Ford, a key to the success of the group. There is some great bass on this and vibrant drum beats. 'Thyme to Rhyme' is a soft album closer with acoustic guitar and, though short, it is to the point.

Conclusively, this album is perhaps the best of Masters Apprentices apart from the plethora of compilations that are still being churned out. It features great arrangements throughout and innovative structures creating a strange ethereal atmosphere. This is an early 70s look at Aussie Prog at its best.

 

#140

Psychonaut
Brainticket

Brainticket Psychonaut album cover

A review by Mellotron Storm:

BRAINTICKET basically dissolved after the first "way out there" release called "Cottonwoodhill". Joel Vandroogenbroeck, the organ and piano player brought the band back to life though with all new members. The first album was very much a band effort, but this one features all songs composed by Mr.Vandroogenbroeck. The female singer he added does sound like the lady on the first release, but without the craziness.

"Radagacuca" opens with flute and spacey organ sounds. Percussion arrives a minute in until that is all you hear 2 minutes in. We get some sitar and male and female vocals 3 minutes in. The flute is back in this cool, meditative song. That is until 6 minutes in when the organ is back with guitar and drums offering up a fuller and faster sound.

"One Morning" opens with the sound of a storm with rain, as piano, percussion, drums and vocals create the soundscape. "Watchin' You" has a heavier sound with female vocals. The guitar is raw with drums. Reserved but heavy guitar solos arrive  2 minutes in, one of the best parts of the album. Vocals are back. The beat stops as sitar and spacey, psychedelic sounds arrive.

"Like A Place In The Sun" opens with heavy drums and powerful organ. Female vocals come in, she's speaking now. We then get a drum solo before organ comes back. She's speaking then singing before the song ends with organ and drums. "Feel The Wind Blow" is a reserved song. It opens with people talking and smoking something. Gentle guitar and female vocals before percussion joins in. The last 30 seconds features the wind blowing.

"Coc'o Mary" has some cool drumming as guitar comes in, and then organ. Check out the drumming though. Flute comes in as the song calms down after 3 minutes with percussion. Drums and organ are back. For me this is a step up over the "over the top" debut. This one has some great sounding psychedelic tunes, even recalling the sixties at times.

#141

DNA
Jumbo

Jumbo DNA album cover

A review by Finnforest:

Not to be missed, bluesy-prog fans.

Strange. Usually when a band presents two sides of itself I will enjoy the more elaborate, the more "out there" work. This time it doesn't hold true. While Jumbo's final classic- era recording is rated slightly higher, it is their 2nd album, the gripping "DNA", which I find to be their masterpiece. Direct and raw with a nice balancing of contrasting sounds and cohesive themes. Nothing but pure human emotion, graced by melancholic acoustic beauty on one hand and charged with a raw bluesy power on the other. Atop these two dynamic legs you have the gut wrenching vocals of Mr. Jumbo himself. Sans the attempts at sophistication that the next album brought, there is only the pure magic here. Jumbo is one of RPI's first tier bands who actually managed to record more than one album and they are certainly one of the best in my opinion.

"DNA" was recorded in just one week, so typical of the time and place, and proof that the old Italian bands could use pressure to create more magic in days than today's stars can manage in months, with their budgets, tour riders, and computers. It is true that the second side of this album does not quite rise to the level of the side-long masterpiece suite of the first, but it is still good. Side one's "Suite per il Sig. K" is just phenomenal in its simplicity, passion, and connection to something inside. It combines bold and forceful piano with delicate and melodic flute play, backed by sprightly acoustic play and jamming electric rock guitar. The electric has a tortured fuzzed-up distortion that manages to rival Alvaro's grizzly bear roar. Throw in the occasional organ textures and you've got it made.

As with "Thick as a Brick," to whose fans I highly recommend this baby brother of an album, the piece alternates between extremes and features a good composition. While perhaps not as fancy as "Thick" or polished as some of its more elegant Italian peers, Jumbo makes up by pushing harder. This album combines the raucous energy of Flea's "Topi o Uomini" with the stunning authenticity of the Grateful Dead's seminal "American Beauty." Different style than the latter of course, I'm talking about feelings and impressions here. Scented Gardens correctly notes DNA as combining "heavy progressive and blues-rock with classical references." There's no need for me to bring out the charts and graphs here, this album is the real damn deal. Just one more home run for 1972.

Get the BTF gatefold mini-lp sleeve CD edition for great sound and a nice booklet.

#142

Phantasmagoria 
Curved Air

Curved Air Phantasmagoria  album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush: 

“Phantasmagoria” is one of the proggiest Curved Air’s albums featuring some of their most challenging time sigs and musicianship. The fuzz guitar from Francis Monkman, the ethereal synths of Darryl Way and Sonja Kristina as the high octave queen of prog, is an irresistible musical explosion, and it climaxed on this album. It begins with the slow and meandering ‘Marie Antoinette’, with the brooding vocals of Kristina; “Fire in their eyes, steel in their hand, they ride, chanting revolution, Vive le Nation!” She sings of the guillotine that is coming for the queen.

Kristina plays acoustic guitar on ‘Melinda More or Less’, a lovely mediaeval paean by Sonja’s lilting vocals that transcend beauty. Way's violin, Monkman's harpsichord, Mike Wedgwood's pulsing bass and Annie Stewart ‘s flute make this a mesmirising journey back to the ancient days of kings, queens and guillotines. ‘Not Quite the Same’ is an oddity about impossible love and self abuse, with some amusing lyrics; “Out in the park, he was walking his doggy, he saw a young lady, who made him feel soggy.” The medieval brass section that plunges it back to the dark ages continues the concept, before the jazziness of the Canterbury music takes over. Way and Monkman masterfully duel off on synthesizers in the instrumental break.

‘Over and Above’ has one of the zaniest off beat time sigs that is irregular throughout, diverging wildy in all directions. Monkman’s twisted signature keys are played with abandonment and astonishing virtuosity. Way's violin is way out of the box and he absolutely gives the bow a major workover. Sonja's theatrical vocal expertise is as amazing as ever and the opening section may be described as a jazz circus. There are some spacey sections on the track with chiming vibraphones and xylophones played by Crispian Steel-Perkins, Paul Cosh and Jim Watson. The erratic bassline, massive brass sound and wah-wah guitar really adds to the power of the soundscape. The sound captured is really symphonic prog meets jazz rock fusion. This is a complex killer track and certainly the most powerful progressive song from Curved Air.

‘Cheetah’ is an instrumental that features Darryl Way masterfully blasting huge slabs of violin, and there is a reworking of "Air Conditioning"’s ‘Ultra-Vivaldi’ that is much faster and dominated by keyboards; speeded up using a sequencer. The title track is a short song with wild Hammond and Sonja’s jaunty vocals on how to deal with loneliness and depression; “don’t ring for a taxi, don’t call a policeman, don’t send for a doctor, he’ll just give you pills, don’t hide in the sand man, you may not believe it.”  She sings of the summer of love and the lyrics cater to the flower power movement; “So if you get lonely just think of the summer, and swim in the sky blue, drift your mind away.” The uplifting breezy feel sounds like a happy song but it is really about coping with depression.

‘Whose Shoulder Are You Looking Over Anyway?’ Is a weird curio with lovely Kristina sounding like a constipated Dalek. Her vocals are battered by a PDP8/L computer mixed with a Synthi 100 Synthesizer. It is meant to evoke the spiritual manifestation of the dead; “But I keep looking over your shoulder to see if I'm there, Oh, when I was a little Ghost, a merry time had we! Each seated on his favourite post.” The electronic vocals make this as creepy as it gets for Curved Air.

After this album, Curved Air’s bubble popped with the walk out of maestros Way and Monkman, and it was too big an ask to replace the classic sound the band once generated. “Phantasmagoria” definitely contains some of the proggiest and most experimental music from Curved Air. 


#143

Waterloo Lily
Caravan

Caravan Waterloo Lily album cover

A review by Warthur:

Although there is undeniably a little bit of jazz in temporary keyboard player Steve Miller's performance on this album, I think it's possible to overemphasise the jazz influence this time around. The music on Waterloo Lily is still very recognisably caravan - Pye Hastings and Richard Sinclair's vocals are as distinctive as they ever were, the dirty jokes are still very much present and correct, and musically speaking we're still at the lighter, more approachable end of Canterbury territory.

Still, there's no denying that it isn't quite as iconic as its two predecessors. Steve Miller's playing might not drive the band into full-on fusion territory, but it is still an odd fit for the band's sound. It's not jarring enough to spoil the album, but it is distracting enough to stop it being amongst the best of the best of Caravan's material. It's not the first Caravan album I'd recommend to people interested in the group's work, but I'd very strongly recommend it to anyone who'd already experienced and enjoyed classic Caravan material.

#144

Argus 

Wishbone Ash

Wishbone Ash Argus  album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

"In the fire the king will come..." This is the lone masterpiece of Wishbone Ash.

Wishbone Ash's "Argus" is the band's most famous album and in fact is the best thing they ever did though the live material is excellent especially the "Time Was Anthology". What makes this album great is it contains no less than four of their all time classic tracks 'The King Will Come', 'Throw Down The Sword' and 'Blowin' Free', not to mention 'Warrior'. The great WA sound consists of duel guitar playing from the excellent musicianship of Andy Powell and Ted Turner; they would always be remembered for this album. The guitar breaks are nothing short of extraordinary, before Iron Maiden and before Judas Priest's twin guitar solos there was Powell and Turner. Martin Turner's vocals are easy to take and he doesn't go for high octave but stays in the mid range, his bass playing is noteworthy too.

'Time Was' is a classic track with very soft folk guitar and melancholy singing. The guitar jamming is a feature and there is a lengthy solo with a driving rhythm, after 9 minutes 40 the track finally comes to a close. A very good opening track to prepare us for better to come.

Steve Upton's drumming is fairly average though he does some lovely things with the cymbals on tracks such as'Sometime World'. This track is kind of bluesy and speeds up in tempo as the song progresses.

'Blowin' Free' begins with the killer riff that drives the song. The lyrics are great to sing to; "I Thought I had a girl I know because I seen her, her hair was gold and brown, blowin' free like a cornfield..." The twin guitar solo is a feature once again and this is a real favourite with the band and they always include it on their live set, which sound jammier and better than this. There are some delicious passages of soaring guitar and blues scales on this. The time sig remains fairly much the same apart from some slower bits thrown in such as; "In my dreams..." section.

'The King Will Come' is a favourite Wishbone Ash song featured on the Classic Rock Anthology DVD. The band have so much fun rockin' it out and the lead guitarist wears flowing white flares. Powell moves back and forth playing a flying V guitar staring into the camera just having the time of his life. They sound incredible live, so this studio version is not as loud and aggressive though it's still great. The guitars are not as up in the mix but the harmonies are divine. It is a song about the Biblical end times when the king (Jesus) will return and apocalypse will reign; the Revelation. The lead break is magnificent from both guitarists using wah wah pedal effects and huge scales. Once again this is a staple of the live set and would not be complete without it. It is brilliant prog rock. "See the word of the prophet on a stone in his hand, poison pen Revelation, just a sign in the sand..."

'Leaf and Stream' is the weakest track on the album, very quiet and melancholy, but still listenable and marks a transition point to lead the next huge rocker.

'Warrior' has a rocking riff and lead intro before the gentle lyrics; "I'm leaving to search for something new, leaving everything I ever knew, a hundred years in the sunshine, hasn't taught me all there is to know..." The theme centres around the conquest of the vanquished or fallen and how they triumph over the war to find the sword of destiny. The time sig changes to a faster tempo on "Time will pass away, Time will guard our secrets..." Then there is an anthemic section with the chorus repeated over and over with striking harmonies; "I have to be a warrior, a slave I couldn't be, a soldier and a conqueror, fighting to be free." Another great harmony and melody on this memorable track.

The second best WA track is 'Throw Down the Sword' which is among the live sets. It features a fade in intro with a very nice guitar riff that sounds medieval in tune. The quest is not over, and this track encompasses the tired traveler who is searching but not finding and throws down the sword in frustration; "Throw down the sword the fight is starting over neither lost neither won, to cast away the fury of the battle, turn my weary eyes for home... leave the glory, a story time could never change, to walk the road the load I have to carry..." It is the journey's end for the warrior, and this reminds me of the cover, a lone soldier watching over the battlefied awaiting death or will he be spared? The uncertainty is reflected in the music which meanders slowly along with very precise guitar lead breaks.

'No Easy Road' is a bonus CD track and not much really, just a solid rocking track that doesn't belong here, but interesting.

There is a kind of concept running through this album though it is not as blatant as a concept album usually is but with the theme of battle and quests, it is there. So this last track is a perfect ending to a perfect album. Wishbone Ash could never live up to the reputation of this album so "Argus" is their most accomplished work and worthy of masterpiece status.

#145

Seventh Sojourn
The Moody Blues

The Moody Blues Seventh Sojourn album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

It is always a pleasure to listen back to such a relaxing innovative band as The Moody Blues. “Seventh Sojourn” is really a less discussed album than some of the earlier material perhaps as it does not have the creative consistency of previous albums. However, there is enough on this to warrant serious consideration. It begins with a melodic reflective piece ‘Lost In A Lost World’ with Mike Pinder soothing on vocals, and the band searching for the answer as always, accompanied by flute passages and uplifting harmonies.

‘New Horizons’ is full of beauty, generated by sweeping violins and very soft vocals with a romantic flavour. ‘For My Lady’ is a single and always one of my favourites with a lovely melody and memorable happy woodwind. Justin Hayward has golden tones on these ballads. The medieval sounds are strong and it has some of the more poetic lyrics of the album. It is more like the Jane Eyre period of the 1800s in feel then anything else on the album. The romantic flutes are simply gorgeous; best song on the album easily.

‘Isn't Life Strange’ is another very popular song gracing many compilations with the previous song. Personally I tire of this easilty and can’t stand the monotony of the tune and that warbling vocal is mush to my ears. You And Me’ is better with a rockier beat and some nice orchestra. The guitar riff is rather heavy for The Moody Blues and the violins are majestic throughout.

‘The Land Of Make-believe’ is an acoustic and flute-driven quiet piece. It sounds rather dated due to the lyrics and overall style. A real flower power throwback that is a throwaway, only saved by Hayward’s uplifting vocals and moving orchestral arrangements. A genuine album track found on this release alone. ‘When You're A Free Man’ is another song only found on this album for good reason. It is forgettable lush.

‘I'm Just A Singer (In A Rock And Roll Band)’ ends the album on a high point. It rocks hard and is perhaps as heavy as the band gets. It works on all levels, vocally, melodically and lyrically. The song was a live staple for The Moodies and often is found on compilations.

Here once again is an inconsistent album that will be the hallmark of most of The Moody Blues albums following. Parts are excellent and parts are okay, but it is nevertheless full of beauty and some of the Moodies best songs. After this it all went belly up and the band became a top 20 singles pop group, with hit and miss tracks; the albums usually with only about 3 tracks of any significance.

#146

Doremi Fasol Latido 
Hawkwind

Hawkwind Doremi Fasol Latido  album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

Lemmy the Lurch jumped on board the Hawkwind Spaceship and he injected the right amount of bass rythym to this unit. The album as a result works well as a proto Motorhead journey into space. The Hawkwind trademark of weird spacey effects from keyboards saturate each track and its a voyage from beginning to end into another universe. The voyage bgins with the gatecrashing rocker 'Brainstorm'. It is featured on many compilations and in various lengths as well as on the live "Space Ritual" masterpiece. A track to savour, its a highlight of the Hawkwind repertoire.

'Space is deep' is another space effect laden track with some mesmirising guitars and vocals. The enchanting 'Lord of light' merges seamlessly into the quieter 'Down through the night' where Brock excels on vocals. 'Time We Left This World Today' has terrific bass from Lemmy showing his dexterity.

The bonus tracks are excellent featuring the obligatory classic 'Silver machine' again. It’s so great though one can't complain about its insertion. 'Urban Guerilla', 'Brainbox Pollution' and 'Ejection' are fabulous hard driving tracks with tons of echoing vocals, effects, and crunching fuzz guitar.

Overall this is one of the best albums from Hawkwind. Of course the best was yet to come with the live extravaganza, "Space Ritual".


A review by Warthur:

Hawkwind's third album sees the group struggling against difficult circumstances and turning these problems into opportunities. For starters, it's the first album with Lemmy on bass - an instrument he wasn't used to, having learned to play lead guitar, with the result that his playing is somewhat unorthodox on here - and it was recorded in Rockfield Studios at a point when the studios were just a barn with mattresses on the walls.

As a result, the mix of the album is murky, but in a stroke of genius which laid the groundwork for the sound of Hawkwind's classic period, the band decided to make that very murk a defining feature of their sound. On the best songs, such as the opening Brainstorm, the thunderous basslines, mysterious synthesiser tweets, and portentous vocals emerge from out of the fog and merge to create a strange, hypnotic melange. Whilst material like the closing The Watcher is a bit weak, the bulk of the album follows the lead of Brainstorm and the end result is a fascinating slice of space rock, with the lo-fi production values and Lemmy's bass technique giving it an almost proto-punk edge that sets this incarnation of Hawkwind apart from gentler, smoother, less abrasive space rock groups.

Still, I have to admit that Space Ritual just plain sounds better, and I tend to prefer the versions of this album's songs to be found on there. 

#147

Lord Of The Rings
Bo Hansson

Bo Hansson Lord Of The Rings album cover

A review by Warthur:

(Note: having satisfied myself that there is little to no appreciable difference between the Swedish and English releases of this album, I'll be posting my review under both versions).

Bo Hansson's debut album - first released in his native Sweden in 1970 before being given a wider release in 1972 - could well be one of the first great symphonic prog albums to come out of Scandinavia. Not only that, it's one of the earliest examples of an all-instrumental symphonic concept album - Krautrock bands had been releasing all-instrumental albums prior to this, mind, but those tended not to be concept albums and of course ploughed a very different furrow.

A series of keyboard-heavy instrumentals inspired by Lord of the Rings sees Bo backed up by a very capable band that he is more than happy to share the limelight with, knowing when to back off on his keys or guitar to let the sax or flute melodies breathe. The album is also surprisingly diverse - the concept might make you expect a disc heavy on medieval-influenced fare, but I also detect a certain Santana influence at points. A very, very capable debut album, and surely an important contribution both to the early-70s prog scene as a whole but especially the development of the genre in Scandinavia. Easily five stars.


A review by Ivan_Melgar_M:

The first time I heard about BO HANSSON'S "Lord of the Rings" and read the reviews, I had the misconception that this was the "Non Plus Ultra" example of early Swedish Symphonic, so when I heard it I was really surprised, this album has almost no connection with Symphonic, as a fact it’s much closer to early PINK FLOYD than to YES, GENESIS or ANGLAGARD.

So if any listener wants to try this album, I recommend to search for a copy of "Live at Pompeii" and try it, because that's the closest you will get to the overall sound of "The Lord of the Rings".

Of course this is not a negative commentary, I love the album, but if you want to listen to something, you need to have a clear idea about what you are going to have before you buy, instead of being disappointed because of lack of information.

Now, despite it's quality, the album has a serious problem, BO HANSSON was too ambitious, you can't make a conceptual album about a trilogy of epic proportions as The Lord of the Rings, with 12 songs of 3 or 4 minutes length as average as HANSSON does, as you would be only able to scratch the cover of the book. There's no time for a coherent development and for a real musical narration as you should expect from a conceptual album.

But, even when Psyche Prog is not the best style to suit the famous trilogy, it would be unfair to say that the sound is something less than excellent and more than adequate, "HANSSON" with his skills managed to adapt two styles that IMO were almost incompatible.

One of the reasons I didn't review this excellent album before is because it's based mostly in atmospheres, keyboards and guitar jamming, and being that the songs are so similar, it's very hard to make a track by track review as I usually do.

The music as I said before has a strong Psyche PINK FLOYD influence, the guitar jamming is much less aggressive than Gilmour's but honestly more delicate and elaborate.

The organ is another issue, sounding incredibly close to the sound of "Piper at the Gates of Dawn" but in other moments with a strong resemblance to 666 by "APHRODITE'S CHILD", something very positive, because the pompous Greek Orthodox Canonic influenced music suits perfectly with an album based on a book about the fight of good against evil with an obvious religious background.

Before rating "The Lord of the Rings" I must mention the superb drumming work by "Rune Carlsson" whose perfect timing and dexterity with the cymbals is the spine over which the music is supported.

Not a masterpiece of Progressive Rock, but for sure an album that must be included in any Progressive Rock collection, so I will go with 4 solid stars.

#148

Mediterranean Tales
Triumvirat

Triumvirat Mediterranean Tales album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

Triumvirat stamp their authority on the prog scene of the 70s. The debut, "Mediterranean Tales", launches with an epic multimovement suite ‘Across The Waters’ that took up one side of vinyl in it's day. The Hammond solos by Jürgen Fritz are alluring, though the missing factor is the vocalist Hans Pape is not as good as Helmut, who joins later. There is a rather exuberant melody throughout and it twists and turns enough to satisfy the average prog addict.

The next track of note on side 2 is a sombre piece with a strange beginning, and hyper pulsating keyboards making the atmosphere quite dark, ‘E Minor 5/9 Minor/5’. The instrumental works exceptionally well as all Triumvirat instrumentals do, and this music is rather bleak in comparison to the uplifting music of other albums. The Hammond solo is well executed and precise, making this one of the best tracks on the album. The end is sublime with minimalist piano. This is a very atmospheric piece, and it bursts out again towards the end returning back to the disturbing pulse metrical pattern.

Another track worthy of mention is ‘Broken Mirror’, beginning with a piano, and then more layered keyboards. Hans Bathelt's drums are great especially the cymbal work. The song is as usual a work of virtuosity. The emphasis is on Fritz's keyboards. The time sig change after 2 minutes is delightful, the melody really takes off with a hypnotic riff, and amazing finger work on shimmering Hammond organ. Eventually lyrics are sung, with a fair amount of passion by Hans Pape. Overall the debut is a solid opening statement from one of the most innovative virtuoso German prog bands of the 70s.


 

A review by Ivan_Melgar_M:

In 1972 this German trio had the courage to start their careers releasing a semi conceptual album in a foreign language, and they did a great job. Often dismissed by critics as "B" class ELP clones, Triumvirat is far from being that simple, specially because Mediterranean Tales is a Symphonic album and ELP is a Classic Prog' band something absolutely different, we know of course "The Rat" and specially Fritz have some Emerson influences (they are declared fans of "The Nice") but their arrangements and lyrics are absolutely unique that deserve much more recognition than they got.

I must add that I believe Triumvirat at their peak is not less than ELP and most of the "big 5" prog' bands.

The founding members were Jürgen Fritz, Hans Bathelt and Werner Frangenberg but the third one decided to continue his career in a pop band, so he was replaced by Hans Pape, a talented bassist and very decent vocalist, this is the lineup that recorded Mediterranean Tales.

Incredibly the album starts with a 16 minutes multi part epic "Across the Waters" in which the band combines various classical influences that go from Baroque to Romantic, Jurgen Fritz is impeccable with his keyboards even when his German accent is hard to swallow by purists. A very good song and impressive starting point for a career.

"Eleven Kids" is a simpler song, which starts with a classical keyboard instrumental strongly supported by powerful bass and drums, but soon changes into a simpler tune where the band shows their pop side even when you can find some psychedelic fugues and classical chords, weaker than the previous but still a pretty good track.

"E Minor 5/9" is a more eclectic song with strange timing where bass and drums carry the weight of the music except in the middle section where a psychedelic keys semi solo breaks the repetitive rhythm and gives extra brightness, probably the track that reminds me more of The Nice or early ELP.

The original album ends with "Broken Mirror" which IMO is the best track because the band shows what their classical sound will be, incredible piano and complex structure that prepares the listener for Triumvirat's next two releases adding a jazz fusion section.

The Digital Remaster edition contains four more tracks "Be Home by Tea" (edition of part of the opening Track), an also edited version of "Broken Mirror" and two more songs ("Ride in the Night" and "Sing Me a Song") that probably didn't reached the original album due to the limitations of the vinyl format, but much weaker than the all the previous.

A very good album even when the band is not in the peak of their creativity that will be reached with Illusions on a Double Dimple and Spartacus. An excellent addition for any prog' collection and a must have for Triumvirat fans.

#149 - live

Pictures at an Exhibition
Emerson Lake & Palmer

Emerson Lake &amp;amp;amp;amp;amp;amp;amp;amp;amp;amp; Palmer Pictures at an Exhibition album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

“Pictures at an Exhibition” is an enjoyable romp in to the bombastic world of power trio ELP. It begins with off kilter time signatures that stop and start and clearly the band are having the time of their lives as they confound and dazzle the audience. Symphony music never sounded so good. ELP are able to create wonderful music and the live experience of their early sound is different than anything they have done before or since.

After a while all the majestic Hammond and Moog sweeps become challenging to the ear and one may long for some vocals. They come in on ‘The Great Gates Of Kiev’ which has become the greatest track to quote from as far as compilations of the band are concerned.

The album is best heard as an entire piece, but it is definitely not your standard ELP album. It is unique in that it is really a retelling of Mussorgsky's master work ‘Pictures at an Exhibition’, with a distinct rock interpretation.

The album has become one of the most discussed and revered of prog history and is a marriage of classical music meets rock. 


A review by Sean Trane:

As I said elsewhere, I dislike albums from Trace and Ekseption and Ars Longa Vita Brevis or Five Bridge Suite from the Nice for what I find to be useless and pointless reworkings of classical stuff. This album is the exception that confirms that rule but mostly because it is quite a daring and surprising rendition of Mussorgsky's major oeuvre and ranks up there along with Japanese-Real-Synthesizer-Wizzard Isao Tomita's version . Weird and daring idea to put lyrics to this stuff, and it does work in a strange ELP way. The end piece is a spoof/poke at Tchaikovsky Nut-Cracker and is also a pleaser. However this album usually takes a lot of heat from ELPheads but also with many people into classical music. I personally applaud the audacity of this adaptation.

Well done, boys.

#150 - live

Made In Japan

Deep Purple

Deep Purple Made In Japan album cover 

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

Deep Purple's History Making Live Masterpiece.

Deep Purple's "Made in Japan" is one of the all time greatest immortal live albums in rock history. It features the band at their brilliant best and promoting their masterpiece albums "In Rock" and "Machine Head", both milestones in themselves. The lineup is the infamous Deep Purple lineup that has become rock legend; featuring on vocals the air raid sirens of high octave metal hero Ian Gillan, the pounding drums of Ian Paice, the guitar wizardry of Ritchie Blackmore, the keyboard magician Jon Lord and the wonderful Roger Glover, bass guitarist extraordinaire. The live performance features the best of the band to this point and these lengthy versions are even better than the studio renditions. The album hits the mark with a rocking start with the hard driving 'Highway Star', the kid sister of 'Speed King'. The dynamic interplay of guitar and organ is wonderful and draws the listener in as it builds into the first verse. "Nobody Gonna Take My Car, I'm Gonna Race It To The Ground, Nobody Gonna Beat My Car, It's Gonna Break The Speed Of Sound" The lyrics embody the essence of the revhead and live Gillan is able to use his power vocals to full effect. But it's all about the riffs for this band and Blackmore delivers everytime; the true metal progenitor of lead guitar finesse, becoming a guitar hero with this album.

'Child In Time' is next running or a whopping 12 minutes. The song is a masterpiece, but live it surpasses even the album version. Gillan explodes on vocals reaching ear splitting notes after a gentle start. The song builds into a paroxysm of thunderous guitar riffs and Lord's keyboards are incredible. It builds into heavier sections with massive keyboard sweeps and fret melting lead guitar. An amazing wall of sound is generated with the rhythm machine of Paice and Glover. Eventually it settles into a serene passage until the finale where all members of the band blaze away and lift off into the stratosphere with crunching chord changes and a freak out of shattering noise as Gillan moans the pangs of child birth; perhaps it represents the birth of heavy metal, and the band deliver.

'Smoke On The Water' follows, beginning with a terrific variation of the opening classic riff. It is the most recognizable riff in rock history that every guitarist knows. The actual thematic content is fascinating about how a "stupid with a flare gun" burned down the recording studio of Frank Zappa and the Mothers in Montreux. Now the event is immortalised forever in song. This will perhaps remain the all time greatest Deep Purple song especially due to the 7 note chord riff. The live version is sensational with a scorching lead break and Lord's shimmering keyboard attack.

'The Mule' follows next with a lengthy instrumental break, and the song runs out to 9 ½ minutes in length. Ian Paice drums up a storm on his Ludwig kit soloing for quite some time. His precision drumming and atmospheric arrangement has become a benchmark for drummers worldwide.

'Strange Kind Of Woman' is also lengthy at 10 minutes and is great to hear as it was one of the biggest singles or the group not available on studio vinyl during this time. It was a chance for the band to kick back and groove along to a pleasing riff. The section where Gillan imitates Blackmore's guitar is often quoted as a master stroke and was influential to many bands to follow. It sounds as though Blackmore was trying to trick Gillan but they trade off perfectly and it is amusing and part of the experience of the live set, reminiscent of Plant and Page of Led Zeppelin.

'Lazy' is a 10 ½ minute opus with tons of keyboard soloing and Blackmore insane on bluesy guitar. It is a terrific lengthy jamming track about a dude so lazy he just stays in bed. Lord is awe inspiring on the organ solo and it really showcases his skill.

'Space Truckin'' follows and clocks in at a mammoth 20 minutes. It is another of the quintessential DP tracks. The power riffs and grinding organ absolutely slam to the wall. The lengthy version originally took up an entire side of the double vinyl album. It features huge spacey solos with Jon Lord's Hammond and his experimental ring modulator sounds. He unleashes a furious tirade of powerful organ stabs as Glover maintains a consistent bassline with Paice backing on drums. The session lasts for almost 15 minutes and is technical and progressive while maintaining strong rock rhythms. The Hammond solo is based on 'Mandrake Root' from the early DP albums.

"Made In Japan" is a classic masterpiece that is one of the most famous live albums in history. Every track is killer and the band are at the peak of their powers. It is a testament of the greatness of Deep Purple in the early years of proto-metal and the progressive nuances throughout, with intricate time sig changes and lengthy jamming solos, make it the ultimate live album of 1972.



Edited by AtomicCrimsonRush - February 03 2012 at 19:32
Back to Top
AtomicCrimsonRush View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14258
Direct Link To This Post Posted: January 14 2012 at 06:11
1972 - continued

#125

Moving Waves 
Focus

Focus Moving Waves  album cover 

A review by SouthSideoftheSky:

Let's focus!

This second Focus album brings some great stuff to the Prog table. ‘Hocus Pocus’ is fun but I actually think it is the least good song on this album. It is too long and repeats itself a couple of times too many in my opinion. The rest of the first half is, however, very good. Akkerman's acoustic ‘Le Clochard’ may not be too interesting, but his ‘Janis’ is a beautiful piece with flutes that reminds me of Camel. The title track is the only vocal piece on the album (if you don't count the yodelling on ‘Hocus Pocus’ as vocals) and it is another beautiful one. None of these songs are particularly progressive, though.

The music of Focus sounds a bit like a crossover between Jethro Tull, Camel and Emerson Lake & Palmer, perhaps with a sprinkling of Caravan. Keeping in mind that this album was released in 1972 it was quite fresh and interesting.

The long piece that fills the second half on the album has some great parts, but overall it is rather unfocused. They could have distilled it a bit I think.

I like this album, and I wish I could give a higher rating. But it has some flaws that make a higher rating undeserved.

Good, but non-essential.

#126

A Tab In The Ocean
Nektar

Nektar A Tab In The Ocean album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

“A Tab in the Ocean” is a prog classic of epic proportions. The opening mini epic 'A Tab in the Ocean ' is an intricate narrative that shifts in metrical patterns and detours in multiple directions yet it all holds together beautifully. This is one of the best tracks of the early 70s. Every section of the multi movement suite is dynamic.

'Desolation Valley' has a labyrinthine array of stabbing riffs, pounding drums, a clamour of keyboards and guitars that drive it to its incredible conclusion. 'Waves ' acts as a type of intermission; peaceful, preparing us for the onslaught. 'Cryin' In The Dark' has a wonderful guitar riff and terrific vocal performance from Roye Albrighton. This blends seamlessly into 'King of Twilight' both concert favourites and deservedly so.

In fact every track is undoubtedly the best Nektar has in the catalogue and they would not deny this, having used the majority of album material in their recent reunion.


A review from SouthSideoftheSky:

what in the ocean?

A Tab In The Ocean was Nektar's second album and a great improvement over their debut. While the debut album was very much of it's time and could have been made by any one of a large number of contemporaries, A Tab In The Ocean is an album that stands out as quite unique. It was with this album that Nektar began to find their very own distinctive sound that they would carry with them until the present day (in a number of different forms). The biggest difference between the two first Nektar albums is perhaps their discovery here of their melodic sensibility that was clearly a bit lacking on the debut. It would improve even further on albums like Remember The Future and Recycled, but A Tab In The Ocean has much more melodic and memorable songs compared to the Journey To The Centre Of The Eye.

The songs from this album would become strong live favourites for the band. On a recently recorded live DVD that I have, called Pure: Live In Germany 2005, all the songs from this album are performed!

There is not much more to say, I think. While I enjoy Remember The Future and Recycled more, A Tab In The Ocean is also highly recommended! 

#127

Quella Vecchia Locanda 
Quella Vecchia Locanda

Quella Vecchia Locanda Quella Vecchia Locanda  album cover

A review by Finnforest:

A good prelude for what would follow

From the first sound of Donald Lax's marvelous violin which opens "Prologo" you know that the QVL sound is unique. They are one of the most distinct and important bands from the classic Italian scene. Mixing rock with a classical or jazzy sound and incorporating flute, violin, guitar, and keys with a tightly wound "Fragile" style rhythm sound. Add to that very good Italian vocals and lots of mood changes and you have the right ingredients for a great debut. Some think there is a Tull comparison here but it is only fleeting to me-QVL sounds like no one else. These songs have the punchy quality that PFM sometimes has and maintains the sound quality level.

Lax now lives in Hawaii and is still performing. While recalling his time in QVL very fondly, in a 2004 interview he sadly reports that the band never made a cent from the albums, were treated poorly, and were not even informed of the reissues. He says he had to go on the Internet and pay for his own music just to get a copy!

"Un Villaggio, Un Illusione" does sound a bit Tullish when the flute kicks in albeit with mad violin the comparison is only partially worthwhile. It is Lax's marvelous playing that steals the show here, without it this track is basically a grooving rocker.

"Realta" begins softly with acoustic guitar before the warm vocals usher in a nice melody. This track sounds very PFM with piano, flute and percussion all very good. This has to be one of the most perfect examples of the beautiful Italian sound.

"Immagini Sfocate" sounds quite experimental at first but devolves into a guitar rocker with some great drumming at the end and a nice guitar solo. The lead guitars on this album have a unique sounding distortion to them, quite dry.

"Il Cieco" and "Dialogo" both have some nice moments but with less of the magic of the other tracks. "Verso la Locanda" is better than the previous two but again I sense some lack of direction in the overall song.

"Sogno, Risveglio" may be the highlight of the album and I think it hints at the potential that this band would realize on their masterpiece two years later. Gorgeous pastoral moments mingle with occasionally edgy violins and an unsettled piano that keeps trying to rock the boat. But they come together at the end for a lovely closing.

Both QVL albums are a must for anyone interested in putting together even a modest Italian collection. This debut is more accessible at first and more instantly likable but their follow-up is the real thing, even if it takes longer to appreciate.

The Japanese mini-lp sleeve is another gatefold that shows off the beautiful cover art that I never get bored with. The remastered sound is excellent for the time period. 3 ½ stars.

#128

Neu!
Neu!

Neu! Neu! album cover


A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

A listener’s first excursion into the murky dense world of Neu! can be a love hate relationship. The tracks range in emotion from dynamic, vibrant exhilaration (‘Hallogallo’) to brooding impenetrable intensity (‘I’m Gluck’). This early pioneering album is as important to Krautrock as it is to independent alternative modern music. 

At times the rhythms are positively hypnotic such as the spacey ‘Negativland’, and the album does have its fair share of disturbia reminiscent of God Speed You! Black Emperor. ‘Sonderangebot’ has some unsettling gong splashes and distant cries and is one to avoid in pitch darkness.  

The motorik beat of Michael Rother's guitar is a force in itself on the 10 minute hypnosis of ‘Hallogallo’. A first time listener to the album, may be delighted Neu! does not over indulge in experimental avant-garde ramblings. ‘Weissensee’ is as close to Pink Floyd’s musicality as one can get and its slow crawling psychedelic tones drone beautifully with measured guitar wah-wah swells.  

‘Lieber Honig’ has a vocal performance in the form of Klaus Dinger's mournful intonations about the pain of feeling isolated; at least that is how it sounds in a language as foreign as Kobaian. The minimalism is unnerving in places but Neu! never overdo things by releasing a loud blast to induce a cheap heart failure as some bands do so. Actually, in the most curious way, the song is rather relaxing. 

‘Im Glück’ is memorable for its ambient textures especially the soundbytes of a rowboat paddling on the river slowly. One may be reminded of a scene in a horror movie where the paddlers are being watched from afar by rednecks ready to strike terror; cue the banjo. 

One may hear the makings of alternative indie such as Sigur Ros, Radiohead, GSYBE or Stereolab. This debut was light years ahead of its time and would have stunned listeners and of course it carved an indelible mark in the foundation of Krautrock.


A review by Warthur:

From the avant-garde end of Krautrock, Neu!'s first album combines pulsing, hypnotic rhythms with moments of spacey drifting. Vocals here and there on the album in a strange, strangled voice emphasise that this is no ordinary Krautrock album - Dinger and Rother have stated that the whole point of Neu! was to explore musical possibilities that they felt their compatriots in the German cosmic rock scene were neglecting - so fans of the likes of Amon Duul II, Tangerine Dream or Ash Ra Tempel may find the material here isn't necessarily to their liking, though I suspect many will enjoy it on the strength of its successful experimental approach and the unique atmospheres evoked. A great start to the band.

#129

Demons and Wizards
Uriah Heep

Uriah Heep Demons and Wizards album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

Uriah Heep's “Demons And Wizards” is a hard rocking melodic excursion into fantasy and whimsical landscapes of castles inhabited by wizards. The Roger Dean cover spells out the concept from the outset but as far as actual prog material, this album is great melodic rock and highly memorable. It starts with 'The Wizard' which begins with a melancholy acoustic three chord structure and then the distorted guitars and organ take over. A great track with iconic lyrics and remains a live favourite to this day.

'Traveller in Time' is essential Heep and a definitive highlight. The killer riff is classic Sabbath, Purple or Zeppelin; in other words classic rock. There is a delicious keyboard solo over scorching guitar riffs and the lyrics are downright fanciful but somehow appropriate. 'Easy Living' is the legendary single that always appears on compilations as quintessential Heep. It just motors along at a quick tempo and drives headlong with grinding organ and guitar riffs.

'Poet's Justice' features a booming walking bassline and organ riff. 'Circle of Hands' is a more progressive song than the previous tracks with irregular beats and a great organ driven sustained motif. It is a strong track and one of the longest with a credible lead break that takes the song in a new direction. 'Rainbow Demon' is definitely one of the better tracks with a slow paced hard driving guitar and organ riff with a catchy chorus. The closing track, 'The Spell' has become a concert closer in a medley with 'The Wizard' to good effect.

Overall this album is a great rocking delight for the Heep fan. The band would do better with albums to follow but this is still full of highlights. Very 'eavy and not very 'umble, “Demons and Wizards” is still an album that is bombastic enough to confirm the hype surrounding it.

 

#130

The Rise And Fall Of Ziggy Stardust And The Spiders From Mars
Bowie, David

David Bowie The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

"Ziggy really sang, screwed up eyes and screwed down hairdo like some cat in Japan."

The iconic persona of Bowie, that was transmogrified into a glam queen androgynous guitar god, was exemplified on "The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars." Everytime I think of this album it takes me back to the vinyl years and I remember sitting down and letting the music flow over me as a teen. David Bowie was one out of the box. His red hair and lightning bolt makeup was irresistible and captured my imagination. His visage was pasted on every magazine looking weird and alien and it was the image of the 70s. This album cemented Bowie as a rock legend and he never looked back.

The songs are loud and abrasive and Bowie rocks out like no other album he produced before this. It was a real starting point to his rise to meteoric fame after the immortal 'Space Oddity'. It begins with the weird 'Five Years' that is too long but has plenty of rock to drive it on; "we've got five years, my brain hurts a lot..." The next stand out is the wonderful melodic 'Moonage Daydream' with an unforgettable hook; "Keep your 'lectric eye on me babe, Put your ray gun to my head, Press your space face close to mine, love, Freak out in a moonage daydream!"

'Starman' is fantastic space nonsense, harking back to the spacey thematic content of earlier Bowie. His film "The Man Who Fell to Earth" is certainly influenced from such whimsical concepts of the lonely alien "there's a starman waiting in the sky, he'd like to come and meet us but he thinks he'd blow our minds."

'Lady Stardust' is a nice acoustic space ballad, similar to T-Rex. The best song on the album is 'Ziggy Stardust' with the awesome riff and glam poetry, "making love with his ego Ziggy sucked up into his mind, like a leper Messiah, when the kids had killed the man I had to break up the band."

There are 2 more songs worth mentioning to end the album; the raucous 'Suffragette City' "don't lean on me man cos you can't afford the ticket", and 'Rock 'n' Roll Suicide' "all the knives seem to lacerate your brain". The album was edgy and crass and nasty and teens loved it. Parents hated it. And I loved it too.

#131

Malesch
Agitation Free

Agitation Free Malesch album cover

Mellotron Storm:

I love how melodic and atmospheric this record is. They used little snippets of things they had recorded on their recent trip to Egypt and added them to the beginning of some songs, to act as dividers between songs. "You Play For Us Today" takes awhile to get going like some of the other songs here. It features layers of keyboards, with guitar sounds scattered throughout, but it's the last 2 minutes where the guitar really takes it up a notch as we are treated to some wonderful guitar melodies.

"Sahara City" opens with an eastern sound that is over quickly as we get outbreaks of guitar and drums and noises for the next 5 minutes. Included in this soundscape are silent moments, as well as a haunting atmosphere at times. There is no flow at all until 5 and a half minutes in when the guitar and drums come to the fore, and we are treated to some of the best music on this record during the last 2 minutes of this song.

"Ala Tul" features some good drum work as the organ and bass come in, but it's the percussion that steals the show on this song. "Pulse" sounds like someone left the power on and it's pulsating, as guitar and drums come in on this hypnotic tune. "Khan El Khalili" has this low sounding synth and a vocal melody as the drums come and go, things settle down as the guitar comes in, and it sounds fantastic with the drums.

"Malesch" is a song that builds, with the focus on the bass, drums and guitar. "Rucksturz" is way too short, as it just seems to be hitting it's stride with some amazing melodic guitar and drums when it's over. I love this record, it's a trip, with some very good instrumental work by the band.

#132

Roxy Music
Roxy Music

Roxy Music Roxy Music album cover 

A review by Warthur:

It is, of course, the two Roxy Music albums featuring Brian Eno which are of particular interest to prog fans, and for good reason. The tension existing between Eno's eternally experimental approach and the slick, crooning glam rock stylings of Bryan Ferry creates not chaos, but a unique hybrid approach with plenty to offer. Suites such as ‘The Bob’, and ‘Sea Breezes’ show the technical complexities the band could attain when they put their mind to it, whilst electrifying pop numbers like ‘Remake/Remodel’ or ‘Virginia Plain’ see the band members injecting fast, sharp jolts of technical wizardry and sudden, unexpected twists into warped pop formats. Easily the most prog-friendly of the three great glam rock releases of 1972 - the other two, of course, being Bowie's “Ziggy Stardust” and T. Rex's “The Slider” - Roxy Music's debut album is an essential reminder of a time when art rock could storm the charts.

#133

Hölderlins Traum
Hoelderlin

Hoelderlin Hölderlins Traum album cover

A review by Finnforest:

Classic dreamy prog-folk from Germany.

When I first heard this album I thought instantly of the Brit-folkie classic "Just Another Diamond Day" by Vashti Bunyan. Vashti's album is a more stripped-down affair than this one but the spirit and the beauty of the simple music is quite similar. Hoelderlin takes the basic template of Bunyan's classic and adds a touch of hippie rock to the folk music. The acoustic guitars and lovely, delicate vocals that make up the basic framework here are adorned with bass, drums, flute, cello, organ, and mellotron. The result is some of the dreamiest and sublime folk rock you've heard, to my ears much better than what I heard from Trees. All vocals are in German but don't let that stop you.

"Waren Wir" begins so beautifully with violin and acoustic guitar, enter the soul stirring singing of Nanny DeRuig. After the introduction the song changes a bit and we get a fairly snappy beat over mellotron with flute improvisation. In the middle of this section some male spoken vocals briefly intrude. Strange opener. "Peter" has a very traditional folk music sound and this one reminds most directly of Bunyan's album. The pleasant vocal melody carries the song over acoustic and bouncy bass.

"Strohhalm" is another fairly traditional folk song with sitar, tablas, flute, and male vocals this time. "Requiem" injects some tension with the nervous violin in places and is considerably more dramatic in mood. Some room is allowed for a string solo in the middle. “Erwachen" has a flute solo for an introduction, very nice. After a short pause the song continues with piano, acoustic guitar, and nice vocal. A bit of cello comes through now and again.

"Wetterbericht" starts with two acoustic parts and Nanny's fragile childlike singing. The guitar work sounds simple but is actually quite well thought out and trance inducing. "Traum" continues the meditative picking of the previous track but soon adds some hopping percussion, flute and violin. The pace is much more upbeat here and would make a great track for some of that free-form Deadhead style of dance. The violin and bass interplay gets fairly crazy towards the end and then fades.

Essential for fans of the folk prog genre. The album cover is perfectly fitting. The music of Holderlin's Traum is like a dreamy summer afternoon flitted away in a meadow. When I listen to this at work it makes me want to turn off my computer, walk out the door, and drive to the country. Music like this could cost you your job. Oh well, life is short. I really encourage fans of this album to hunt down Bunyan's "Diamond Day." It's every bit as good as this although much sparser and without the proggy touches. 3.75 stars.

#134

Return To Forever
Return To Forever

Return To Forever Return To Forever album cover

A review by Mellotron Storm:

This has to be the best cover ever! I wish the music was as good. Actually check that, the title track is that good! No electric lead guitar on this one either. "Return To Forever" sounds incredible 1 1/2 minutes in with Corea's liquid electric piano sounds and the wonderful percussion by Airto Moreira. Female vocal melodies follow from Flora Purim the partner of Airto. They are a Brazilian couple by the way. I have to tell you I was shocked when I first heard her vocal melodies because they sounded so much like the female vocal melodies in ESKATON and even KULTIVATOR, both Zeuhl bands. Flute comes in with an extended solo. The song almost stops and starts again with the same melody of percussion,electric piano and bass, only this time Clarke's bass playing is more prominent. This melody is truly remarkable! Flora's back with her vocal melodies, and before 9 1/2 minutes Corea's on fire! Like I said in the intro, this song is a masterpiece that I wish every prog fan could hear.

"Crystal Silence" features a piano and sax melody that is both played slowly and gently. It's ok. "What Games Shall We Play Today?" is the hardest for me to digest. It sounds like a corny seventies song due mainly to the vocals and flute. This song makes me cringe. "Sometime Ago/La Fiesta" is a side long suite that has Corea's piano all over it to begin with.Clarke reveals how skilled he is with his bass playing before Corea comes back after 5 minutes. Flute melodies come and go, as we get a real groove going before 8 minutes. Vocals follow. The Brazilian influence comes to the fore 15 1/2 minutes in before we get some sax and later more great bass. This song is a ride. 3.5 stars. Although for the title track alone I urge you to seek this record out. If you can't find it under RETURN TO FOREVER than look under Chick Corea.

#135

Captain Beyond
Captain Beyond

Captain Beyond Captain Beyond album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

Thanks to the glowing reviews of this album many will hopefully be drawn to “Captain Beyond” like a moth to a flame. Immediately the listener will be dazzled by crunching riffs with heavy guitars and then amazing time changes locking into killer riffing with dirty guitar sounds and serious vocals. The time sigs changes so dramatically it is hard to keep up but it is such a delight to be treated to an obscurity like this hiding in the prog vaults. It begins with 'Dancing Madly Backwards (On a Sea of Air)' with all the time shifts and then blazes straight into 'Armworth' with Rod Evans' vocals, from Deep Purple, and hard rocking non stop rock rhythms.

The riffs are always prevalent and driving headlong to new half time feels and awesome instrumental breaks with the mind bending guitars of Rhino, from Iron Butterfly. His slide guitar work is absolutely psychedelic and atmospheric. Bobby Caldwell was a brilliant drummer and has a field day on percussion injecting timpani triplets and odd beats throughout. The bass of Lee Dorman is a constant pulse. 'Mesmerization Eclipse' is the first break into a different feel after the non stop opening suite of songs. There is another heavy riff and Deep Purple style vocals. They are much more progressive though, and once again the song reaks into several signatures, the band are brimming over with creativity and one never knows where they will go next, fast to slow to downright out of place, each meter is a pattern that locks on with that ever present heavy guitar. I didn't like the way this faded out slowly but immediately the next riff settles in on 'Raging River Of Fear'. This has a heavy bluesy feel, aggressive vocals and accomplished rhythm changes. The drums on this are incredible, constantly providing new tempos and fast paced beats and fills.

'Thousand Days Of Yesterday (Intro)' settles down the fury with quiet acoustic picking and gentle vocals. The harmonies are nice and the overall feel is melancholy to break away from the heaviness before and after. It doesn't last long as the next moment guitars crunch in and a fast tempo with forced vocals on 'Frozen Over'. The half time feel on this is astonishing injecting new metrics and it then changes completely in the next section. Nobody changes time sigs like Captain Beyond; so rapid and always appropriate. It fades into an accelerated acoustic rhythm on 'Thousand Days Of Yesterdays (Time Since Come & Gone)'.

A fantastic rhythm locks in and Rhino is dynamic in the lead break. It fades and hammering chords intro 'I Cant Feel Nothin (Part 1)'. The drums are dazzling along with another massive riff. The vocals are easy on the ears and close to the Bachman Turner Overdrive style. The music continues non stop with a suite of songs; 'As The Moon Speaks (To the Waves of the Sea)' a quiet acoustic piece of beauty with narrative vocals, 'Astral Lady', 'As The Moon Speaks (Return)' back to the pounding rock of 'I Cant Feel Nothin (Part 2)'.

What a fantastic heavy slice of prog with an obscurity that should be unearthed and played often. A great find for any heavy prog fan and one to return to habitually.


A review by SouthSideoftheSky:

Here we have a great piece of Heavy Prog from the 'other' side of the Atlantic. There is a connection to the UK, however, with Rod Evans previously of Deep Purple handling the lead vocals here. This might lead you to suppose that the music of Captain Beyond is similar to Deep Purple Mk. I which it is not and neither can it be compared to Deep Purple Mk. II. This is a completely different beast and one of the very best I've heard of its kind!

The album is basically one complete piece of music with a handful of great riffs that come and go, and we are given several interesting variations on these riffs. The whole thing is a rather loud affair and a tour de force of good guitar riffs, fast and moderately complex drumming. The instrumentation is rather simple with electric guitars, acoustic guitars, bass, drums, lead and harmony vocals, and the occasional very discrete piano and some percussion instruments. There are many interesting tempo changes and mood changes keeping it interesting throughout. Some passages remind me of Black Sabbath others of Camel!

The second half of the album is the best one, with a bit more variation due to slower acoustic sections, and its great build up towards the finale. What I particularly like about this album, in addition to that is presented as a whole, is also how loaded and well structured it is. There are no mindless improvisations or long psychedelic jam sections, all too common in the psychedelic bands of the time. Captain Beyond might very well have come up with this music by doing long psychedelic jams, but what is left here for the final product is well arranged and they don't waste a minute on that stuff. There is a sense of urgency here lacking in the works of, say, Hawkwind or early Pink Floyd or American acts like Hendrix and The Doors for that matter.

What I also like is the fast and constantly changing rhythms, something that bands like Pink Floyd and Hawkwind really needed to learn. Hawkwind, for example, had a very strong tendency to settle into a constant groove and keep it throughout the whole song and let the guitars and keyboards do all the work on top. Captain Beyond, on the other hand, had all the instruments, including the drums, competing for attention. What is psychedelic about Captain Beyond is more in the overall space theme and the image of the band than in the actual music, I think.

By way of criticism I should say that this album is not perfectly recorded and produced, but it does not sound bad. There could also be more solos and instrumental sections (but well-structured ones as opposed to mindless jamming) and the sound could be fuller if they added some more keyboards to the mix. Still, this is a classic of Heavy Prog and no fan of the genre should do without a copy of this near-masterpiece album.

Highly recommended!

#136

666
Aphrodite's Child

Aphrodites Child 666 album cover

A review by AtomicCrimsonRush:

A multimovement suite that leads from heaven to hell in Revelation makes a stunning concept album  Vangelis and Demis Roussos hopped on board the ambitious fiasco to produce perhaps one of the most memorable, if slightly disconcerting, conceptual epic. There is a combination of symphonic psychedelia, blended with Greek Orthodox liturgical overtones, and the end of the Bible thrown in for good measure. There are scintillating guitar passages and atmospheric synth melodies creating a unique ambience. To keep the thing together, an echoing deep voice introduces main sections. Soundbites that will have the listener glued to their seat include: "That. Was. The wedding. Of. The lamb." Or how about: "7 trumpets, the threatening anger, 7 trumpets, the trembling voice, 7 trumpets, you've got no choice, 7 trumpets, 7 angels, 7 trumpets, the music changes".

The main drawcard is to hear the wonderful Vangelis in his early years. Demis Roussos shines in the tracks he is involved particularly the awesome '4 Horsemen', the highlight of the album that is reprised at the finale. This is endearing and melodic but many of the tracks are unfathomable, though never less that entertaining. Each track runs into the next in true prog concept style.

It is difficult to describe the track on side 2 titled enigmatically with the 'Infinity' symbol, but one word may suffice.  Orgasm. Irene Papas lets loose vocally unlike anything put to vinyl. The vocals are pleasurable screams and moans, unaccompanied by music, guaranteed to send some listeners running for cover. Weird and wonderful and totally off kilter, the track upset many people in its heyday for good reason.

The centrifugal force of the album is of course the text of Revelation and perhaps the album drew many flower children to checking out the last mysterious pages of the Holy Word. In the same way as Poe was reinvented by Peter Hammill and Alan Parsons Project, Aphrodite's Child have approached this reimagining of Revelation with a great deal of seriousness injecting chunks of dialogue and lengthy instrumental passages that rise to a crescendo, and fall to dead silence.There are certain points in this album that challenge but as a whole concept there is enough hold the interest. The most memorable are 'Babylon', '4 Horsemen', 'The Battle of the Locusts' and 'Do It' with guitar excellence bar none, and 'Infinity'. The huge 20 minute finale is a cacophony of sounds and lengthy instrumental sections of Vangelis, with glorious collages of previous melodies. Then it collapses into a psychedelic freak out, a maddening, macabre, majestic mess.

The album has become legendary and it was the end of the band too; Vangelis made squillions of dollars with “Chariots of Fire” and “Blade Runner”; Roussos met the great Pavarotti and later met other tenors to produce classical operatic concerts. Papas stopped moaning and continued her acting career in Greece to much acclaim.

 “666” is essential listening guaranteed to elicit a strong response and it never fails to transport the listener into another place and another time.



Edited by AtomicCrimsonRush - February 02 2012 at 05:40
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 1011121314 21>

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



This page was generated in 0.242 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.