Is Pink Floyd prog rock?

@The Dark Elf

http://www.rushweb.net/hail-rush-these-5-bands-cite-rush-as-a-major-musical-influence/

"1. The Foo Fighters
This Seattle group, which is considered to be the spiritual successor of mega-group Nirvana, has been one of the most widely known artists of the last two decades. Lead by lead guitarist, front man and former Nirvana drummer Dave Grohl, their own unique sound has drawn a lot of influence from Geddy Lee and crew.

Grohl himself a famous drummer and vocalist, cites Lee’s vocals and Peart’s famous drum beats as major influences. During the group’s induction into the rock and roll hall of fame, Grohl and his fellow Foo Fighter member Taylor Hawkins, were selected to provide the accompanying speech.

2. Nine Inch Nails’ Trent Reznor

Not many artists are as famously multi-instrumental as Nine Inch Nails’ Trent Reznor. A complex talent, Reznor has performed in various positions in the entertainment industry, from working behind the scenes as a song producer, to his vocal and instrumental duties for NIN. Not afraid to experiment since the 1980s, Reznor is considered one the the recording industries’ most prominent Jack of all Trades.

In an interview in 2010 Reznor said the famous act was, “One of the best bands ever” and stated that the sound from the group’s offering Signals in 1982 was one of the motivating factors in his inclusion of keyboards into his performances.

3. Smashing Pumpkins

There are few artists in existence which exemplify the dynamic world of alternative music better than Billy Corgan’s Smashing Pumpkins. Rocketing to stardom with their complex offering Siamese Dream, Smashing Pumpkins is still to this day making excellent records. Corgan, a known auteur has created a constantly evolving, yet identifiable sound throughout the years. Known for layering guitars, he has cited on numerous occasions that his influences have ranged from the heavy metal songs of the 70’s and 80s to the arena sound typical of groups like KISS.

Recently in an interview about Rush in Hollywood, Corgan said, “If you had told me in Chicago when I was a kid that I’d be introducing them someday for their Hollywood star, I wouldn’t have believed it, because they were literally my favorite band when I was a kid.” He has also stated in the past that some of the distinct sounds that he has created, including his famously creative guitar layering, was directly as result of Geddy Lee and crew’s guitar-laden influence.

4. Dream Theater

Dream Theater, the technical juggernaut of progressive metal, has been filling arenas with their creative authenticity and expertise since the eighties. Their sound, which explores their singular expertise using various instruments has been appreciated for many years. Formed in 1985 by guitarist John Petrucci, bassist John Myung, and drummer Mike Portnoy originally played under the name Majesty, and has been rocking auditoriums for nearly three decades.

Of all the groups listed, Geddy Lee and his groupmates’ influence is most clear here. In 2014 John Pertucci said, “If I had to pick a favorite band of all time, it would be Rush. As a teenager, I was already familiar with the group and its albums like Moving Pictures and Signals. But once I discovered 2112, it opened me up to this whole concept that rock music could be bigger than just a tune—that it could be used as a vehicle to tell a story or to transport you to some other world.”

Also to this day, a Dream Theater performance is a great place to hear some amazing covers.

5. Rage Against the Machine

Socially Rebellious artists Rage Against the Machine, while currently not recording and in a hiatus, was one of the more riotous acts to debut in the later 1990s-early 2000s. Their authority shrugging style and raucous lyrics made for incredibly exciting concerts and left an indelible mark on music history.

Tom Morello the eclectic guitarist of Rage once said, “I was always drawn to metal, but the devil stuff and the groupie stuff never really spoke to me. But they were great musicians. Three of the greatest musicians on their particular instrument somehow all managed to be in one band.”

Five history making artists all drawing influence from another history making act? Clearly this displays the reciprocal nature of the music business and how much a group can influence later generations of music makers. What will be interesting is observing how these groups themselves influence the next generation."

From AllMusic's review of 2112:

"Instead of choosing between prog rock and heavy rock, both styles are merged together to create an interesting and original approach. The entire first side is comprised of the classic title track, which paints a chilling picture of a future world where technology is in control (Peart's lyrics for the piece being influenced by Ayn Rand). Comprised of seven "sections," the track proved that the trio members were fast becoming rock's most accomplished instrumentalists."

SteveG wrote: Dude, why don't you just Start a Rush thread and take all of your musings there

ClosetothSupperBrick wrote: Haha I like how this thread descended into tribalism and madness well before me, and I just straight up answered the question in the title. That dude claiming Rush didn't influence bands or was taking things from older bands is a hoot, what an idiot. Sounds like someone's got a grudge against Rush, no? Dougmcau, you're totally right. Even though this is not the topic of this thread, Rush totally made their own style of music that had some influences (but what music doesn't?!), and that music is totally recognizable as unique and proggy 40+ years later. I hate people who show their personal dislike of a band in their analysis of music in general.

absolutely 

Sacro_Porgo wrote: uduwudu wrote: From the start Pink Floyd wanted to create an audio visual experience and progressed this to the logical conclusion (benefit of hindsight) of The Wall concert, film, album. Perhaps one of the reasons Floyd get this little query is the blues influences, particularly DG and his guitar. Prog rock usually eschews the blues. Why do I often read opinions like this one that seem to find the blues necessarily not progressive or less metal?  When Priest made Stained Class, it was filled with the blues! It just found some other great modes and moods to fit in as well so the music wasn't as purely derived from the blues as it had been on Sad Wings. There's also plenty of blues in ELP, who have lots of fun jazzy passages which rely heavily on the blues. The blues isn't something that hold music back from progression, it's just another element to use in your playing and writing. Pink Floyd are perhaps the greatest example of how versatile and progressive the blues can be, honestly.

I would say: sometimes, but mostly not so much :P

Who cares? Your choices are either yes, or "I'm a contrarian." Nobody is going to change anyone's mind on this topic.